Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Not sure if this belongs here. Sorry to rant but aiye I cant take it.

I have a friend, one of my best friends. His name is William. He says hes catholic but I dont think his actions reflect it. Now william has been messing with ESP and junk lately and thinks its fine. Hes been doing allot of stuff he shouldnt be. He doesnt believe the bible, he says he can praise God without it. He says that the bible is just a buncha hooey that a bunch of people made up. he also believes that the animals are just as valuable as a human being, I asked him this simple question, expecting him to have a clear answer.

"There is a baby in a cage and a tiger in a cage, and a bad guy with a gun in between. He says he has to kill one, which would you pick"

He has trouble deciding this! He believes everything is a sin, like killing animals for meat and even cutting down trees to print bibles! I dont know what to do about this guy, hes believing a load of crud and I dont know what to say. I dont think you can call yourself christian when you are so messed up in your thinking.

Ack sorry for dumping all that :P I doubt it even made much sense, Any comments of what I should do would be greatly appriciated.

Much love,
--Therese

Edited by Resey
missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Resey' post='958656' date='Apr 23 2006, 10:52 PM']
Not sure if this belongs here. Sorry to rant but aiye I cant take it.

I have a friend, on of my best friends. His name is William. Now william has been messing with ESP and junk lately and thinks its fine. Hes been doing allot of stuff he shouldnt be. He doesnt believe the bible, he says he can praise God without it. He says that the bible is just a buncha hooey that a bunch of people made up. he also believes that the animals are just as valuable as a human being, I asked him this simple question, expecting him to have a clear answer.

"There is a baby in a cage and a tiger in a cage, and a bad guy with a gun in between. He says he has to kill one, which would you pick"

He has trouble deciding this! He believes everything is a sin, like killing animals for meat and even cutting down trees to print bibles! I dont know what to do about this guy, hes believing a load of crud and I dont know what to say. I dont think you can call yourself christian when you are so messed up in your thinking.

Ack sorry for dumping all that :P I doubt it even made much sense, Any comments of what I should do would be greatly appriciated.

Much love,
--Therese
[/quote]

1) If the Bible is a bunch of hooey then there is no God, so it's not necessary to worship him anyway,

2)Jesus was an historical figure, we know that. Now Jesus was either what he said He was (God) or he was a most horrible liar and egoist or completely insane.
Jesus CANNOT, as some people would like to claim be just a really good person. It's impossible. The very fact that he claimed to GOD proves this.
Aperson who claims to be god is one of three things

1) God
2) An egoist and a liar
3) Insane

Jesus was NOT egoistic. He did nothing for Himself or by Himself, he did all thing through His Father, God. Giving one's life for hopeless sinners is not exactly the epitome of egoism. Jesus was NOt a liar either. One cannot be "just a really good person" and be a liar, as well.


Jesus was NOT insane. People do not follow the teachings of insane man. They commit an insane man.

Which leaves us with one conclusion- Jesus is GOD.

Now THAT brings us to.

Jesus is God. Jesus became a MAN to save MEN. That our GOD would become like us shows that animals are not as important to God as men.

Hope that helps

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='958671' date='Apr 23 2006, 10:14 PM']
1) If the Bible is a bunch of hooey then there is no God, so it's not necessary to worship him anyway,

2)Jesus was an historical figure, we know that. Now Jesus was either what he said He was (God) or he was a most horrible liar and egoist or completely insane.
Jesus CANNOT, as some people would like to claim be just a really good person. It's impossible. The very fact that he claimed to GOD proves this.
Aperson who claims to be god is one of three things

1) God
2) An egoist and a liar
3) Insane

Jesus was NOT egoistic. He did nothing for Himself or by Himself, he did all thing through His Father, God. Giving one's life for hopeless sinners is not exactly the epitome of egoism. Jesus was NOt a liar either. One cannot be "just a really good person" and be a liar, as well.
Jesus was NOT insane. People do follow the teachings of insane man. They commit an insane man.

Which leaves us with one conclusion- Jesus is GOD.

Now THAT brings us to.

Jesus is God. Jesus became a MAN to save MEN. That our GOD would become like us shows that animals are not as important to God as men.

Hope that helps
[/quote]



Thanks :) ill tell him all that. Its just so frustrating that he wont listen to what I tell him. I was like majorly shocked when he told me all this not believing the bible stuff. I was like *blinks* what did you just say?

Ack I dont know, I think the devil is workin through him to bother me. The devil has been on my back lately, its getting really annoying.

MichaelFilo
Posted

I think you ought to know, he is actually a very good Christian, you see. That is, in as much as a person can be a Christian while remaining outside of the Church. The real problem is that how does one tell someone like him that he ought to believe in the bible if he's Christian if his family, his friends, etc. probably reject key portions of the Bible anywho (the Eucharist, possibly; another favorite is keep the Sabbath holy). He's simply more of a skeptic then them, always realize that.

What you can actually do is pray for him. Another wonderful thing that a person like you could do is ask if he's ever read the Bible...

Then the next logical question is where he gets his beliefs, because if he simply makes them up, having no source or no foundation, then they are flimsy. And then you may proceed to read his mind to impress him and all your other friends, here is how:

Just kidding, but really, question the foundation upon which his beliefs are built on. Then ask him this funny question, if killing animals is a sin, did God make animals sinful, because dammit they kill animals all the time, and not because they get a rush out of it, but to survive, so it is part of their instinct.

At any rate, if he still blathers on with his semi-new age nonesense, be a good pal and light a candle in Church for him as you send up a prayer for his conversion because thicks skulls are hardest to peirce...

God bless,
Mikey

Posted

[quote name='MichaelFilo' post='958726' date='Apr 24 2006, 05:02 AM']
I think you ought to know, he is actually a very good Christian, you see. That is, in as much as a person can be a Christian while remaining outside of the Church. The real problem is that how does one tell someone like him that he ought to believe in the bible if he's Christian if his family, his friends, etc. probably reject key portions of the Bible anywho (the Eucharist, possibly; another favorite is keep the Sabbath holy). He's simply more of a skeptic then them, always realize that.

What you can actually do is pray for him. Another wonderful thing that a person like you could do is ask if he's ever read the Bible...

Then the next logical question is where he gets his beliefs, because if he simply makes them up, having no source or no foundation, then they are flimsy. And then you may proceed to read his mind to impress him and all your other friends, here is how:

Just kidding, but really, question the foundation upon which his beliefs are built on. Then ask him this funny question, if killing animals is a sin, did God make animals sinful, because dammit they kill animals all the time, and not because they get a rush out of it, but to survive, so it is part of their instinct.

At any rate, if he still blathers on with his semi-new age nonesense, be a good pal and light a candle in Church for him as you send up a prayer for his conversion because thicks skulls are hardest to peirce...

God bless,
Mikey
[/quote]

Hehe thanks so much! Im gonna tell him that :P. And by the way this guy is a practicing catholic. Its just so whacked out why he thinks all this when he goes to church and hangs out with priests.

Birgitta Noel
Posted

Wow! Good luck! That's right up there with a Catholic woman I know who said a few weeks back, "Well, He didn't die for MY sins!" :blink: I wante to ask her just what sort of Christology that was (she has an MA degree in Theo from a Cath Univ) :wacko:

Even my UCC friend did a double take. I just bit my tongue. How in the world do you respond to such nonsense. :pinch: :ohno:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Birgitta Noel' post='959317' date='Apr 24 2006, 02:22 PM']
How in the world do you respond to such nonsense. :pinch: :ohno:
[/quote]


Exactly :P. I had to leave before I spewed off a bunch of language that Jesus wouldnt use :cool:. Im talkin to this guy right now on IM...im hoping itll go good

Ok heres a chunk of the chat...

Resey says:
If the Bible is a bunch of hooey then there is no God, so it's not necessary to worship him anyway...
†William† Life is so cool! says:
now that = wrong for me
†William† Life is so cool! says:
what if a Bible never existed
†William† Life is so cool! says:
or a church
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and your faith had to be stronger than anything
†William† Life is so cool! says:
lets put it this way
†William† Life is so cool! says:
what about if the bible never existed
†William† Life is so cool! says:
does that mean I would be able to believe in God?
Resey says:
you wouldnt know about God now would you
Resey says:
you werent alive back in the day
Resey says:
so how would you know he exists
†William† Life is so cool! says:
exactly, called faith
Resey says:
but where do you get that faith from
Resey says:
faith is built off of something
†William† Life is so cool! says:
of a being that reigns over all
†William† Life is so cool! says:
who gave us life
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and who resides in our hearts
Resey says:
but where does that come from
Resey says:
how do you know this "Jesus"
†William† Life is so cool! says:
from the words Jesus let out of his blessed mouth
Resey says:
but you never heard those!
Resey says:
how do you know who jesus was
Resey says:
how he died
Resey says:
where he came from
Resey says:
THE BIBLE
†William† Life is so cool! says:
Jesus is not based on words, heh
†William† Life is so cool! says:
my priest told me this
†William† Life is so cool! says:
he is based on faith
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and if a bible would have never existed
†William† Life is so cool! says:
we would still have heard of him
†William† Life is so cool! says:
for he made a change
Resey says:
but how??
Resey says:
how do you know this is true?


Ack hes making excuses now. Any ideas of what to say??


heres more of the convo

†William† Life is so cool! says:
John 3:36
Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life, but whoever rejects the Son will not see life, for God's wrath remains on him.
Resey says:
THERE
Resey says:
YOURE QUOTING THE BIBLE
Resey says:
I thought you dont believe that
†William† Life is so cool! says:
heh
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I don't believe many of the things
†William† Life is so cool! says:
bu some are too strong to keep of your mind
Resey says:
you cant have selective things
Resey says:
jesus says
Resey says:
be hot or cold
Resey says:
because if youre luke warm
Resey says:
im ready to spit you out of my mouth
Resey says:
that means
Resey says:
you gotta be all for him
Resey says:
which includes the bible
†William† Life is so cool! says:
oh
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I am all for himb
†William† Life is so cool! says:
ut nit all for the bible
Resey says:
but he wrote the bible
†William† Life is so cool! says:
no
†William† Life is so cool! says:
men wrote the bible
†William† Life is so cool! says:
by words that came out of Jesus's mouth
†William† Life is so cool! says:
words said by God
Resey says:
but God wants us to read the bible
Resey says:
and believe it
Resey says:
its an instuction manual
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I liek this verse:
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I've always used it
†William† Life is so cool! says:
Mark 9:23
"'If you can'?" said Jesus. "Everything is possible for him who believes." (NIV)
Resey says:
and you think youre smart enough to go on your own eh??
†William† Life is so cool! says:
no
†William† Life is so cool! says:
because I know God is beside me
Resey says:
then why dont you listen to him?
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I do, but not to the bible
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I left my life to his arms a long time ago
Resey says:
im not trying to be judgemental
Resey says:
but seriously.
†William† Life is so cool! says:
how many times do I have to say this
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I believe what he says
†William† Life is so cool! says:
what he wants me o do
Resey says:
the bible is what he says
†William† Life is so cool! says:
when I close me eyes and see his image
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and hear his voice in my mind
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and the bible has the parts I believe and those I don't
Resey says:
so you believe the parts you like
Resey says:
and pretend you didnt hear the ones you dont like
†William† Life is so cool! says:
no
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I believe the parts which are reasonable enough to believe
Resey says:
like what?
†William† Life is so cool! says:
Ephesians 5:18
Do not get drunk on wine, which leads to debauchery. Instead, be filled with the Spirit. (NIV)
Resey says:
ok actually
Resey says:
tell me what you dont believe
†William† Life is so cool! says:
most of all these weird people
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and the 48 days rain
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and fire raining
Resey says:
what ever happened to faith
Resey says:
dont you believe in miracles?
†William† Life is so cool! says:
yep I do
†William† Life is so cool! says:
more than you think
†William† Life is so cool! says:
but if miracles mean getting myself killed then I do not think that came from God
†William† Life is so cool! says:
God loves us
†William† Life is so cool! says:
and according to chuch
†William† Life is so cool! says:
*church
†William† Life is so cool! says:
he would never hurt us
Resey says:
no
†William† Life is so cool! says:
I do believe in the plagues
Resey says:
he never said that
Resey says:
love hurts
Resey says:
and sometimes he does stuff for our own good
Resey says:
like a parent has to discipline their children
Resey says:
thats an example of tough love


Bah.

Edited by Resey
Posted

Ok this boy has problems. He's Catholic right? And he doesn't believe in the bible because it was written by men right? Does he believe in the Church, that it was founded by Christ and that the Pope speaks infallibly in matters of faith and morals and that the bishops of the Church are succesors to the apostles?

Posted

[quote name='LSW' post='959362' date='Apr 24 2006, 03:19 PM']
Ok this boy has problems. He's Catholic right? And he doesn't believe in the bible because it was written by men right? Does he believe in the Church, that it was founded by Christ and that the Pope speaks infallibly in matters of faith and morals and that the bishops of the Church are succesors to the apostles?
[/quote]


Yes hes catholic, and ill ask him that.

MichaelFilo
Posted

I'll be gibest Resey, we get our knowledge of Jesus both by word of mouth and through the Bible, so he does technically have a point.

What the real need of the Bible is, is actually summed up in the last chapter of John (or well, at least the need for the Gospel of Luke): "I have decided, after investigating everything accurately anew, to write it down in an orderly sequence for you, most excellent Theophilus, so that you may realize the certainty of the teachings you have recieved (Luke 1:3,4).

What we hear about Jesus can be false or true, and it is when checked against the Biblical accounts that we can truely know the falsehoods from the realities (of course, there is the Magestratum (sp?) but I think thats a bit over your head at the moment, although I could be wrong).

I think you stress the Bible too much, in all honesty. It is of most eminent importance, but alas, it is only a tool through which we can get to know the Word and His teachings. If it existed or if it didn't, we would still believe the same things, but with less surity.

Anywho, yes, his attitude, regardless, is unChristian. Then again, who am I to judge hearts?

God bless,
Mikey

missionseeker
Posted

I don't know if this'll help or not but maybe you should point out that men when left to themselves did not find faith in ONE, MERCIFUL, ALL-KNOWING, ALL-LOVING God. They devoloped religious systems with many, revengful, hypocritical, back-stabbing gods.

It wasn't until God reavealed Himself that men got the idea of our God.

Theologian in Training
Posted

You might also remind him that the reason we have a bible in the first place is so that we could remember what Jesus said and who Jesus was. If we did not have the bible, we would not have any idea a man named Jesus even walked the earth. Yes, we have faith, but what is it we have faith in, if we did not have a written account of what occurred? The oral tradition became the written tradition in an effort to record and remember Jesus.

Also, I would ask him how he knows what he is to do, if he does not believe in the bible. Granted, there is an innate sense, and a natural law, but that will not result in the same understanding that can be learned from the bible.

He seems to want to separate the bible from anything else, acting as though the bible is some written book, like the phone book, and yet he is using it to learn from. Little does he realize that his beliefs are being formed from what he reads in that bible. If that is not God being close to him, I don't know what is.

He seems a bit confused.

JesusITrustInYou
Posted

Resey, I don't have any great advice for you, but I promise I will be praying for William and for you!!! God bless!

Mary-Kathryn
Posted

I'm going to guess this person is close to you in age? I might be completely off-track but, he may be trying to express his independence from mom and dad by going his "own way"...although that might be only amongst friend and not within his family structure. Becoming an adult doesn't mean he/she has to discard what he/she has been taught....he'll pretty much need that in order to have a solid foundation to build on. To deny or water down his faith, is to deny himself. We don't "do" our faith on Sundays, we LIVE our faith. It is very much our identity.

Another thing to consider is that it seems as if he is being influenced by some extreme environmentalsit PETA type people or literature. They have a very lopsided view of animals and human beings. I remember many years ago, watching TV and seeing a protest by some animal rights people in New York. They were outside an upscale store that sold fur coats. A woman dressed in fur emerged from the store, and the protesters started in with a barrage of verbal abuse. The whole thing was loud and chaotic but I wasn't paying much attention. What caught my eye was what wasoff to the side of them: The homeless person laying on the heating grate to stay warm. An incredible picture of how we have lost sight of the value of each person.

You know, I wonder he would benefit from a mission-type activity over the summer? To be out there with the people, helping them and sharing the faith, is a powerful way to grow in faith and find your footing as someone growing into adulthood.


eh....I know I sound like exactly what I am...a mother. :P: Good luck with your friend. I hope he/she finds peace soon

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

Now this is an analogy I learned from a Jehovah's Witness who is trying to convert me... without success!

A businessman dictates a letter to his secretary. His secretary writes it. Who is the letter from? The boss. Thats the Bible.

Darn good analogy, I think.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...