Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Can anyone plz tell me what the ending of Lotr 3 means? When Frodo goes on a boat to a "better placE".

Posted

I believe he went with the Elves to live comfortably forever...

An immortal existence of sorts...

Posted

yeah... but what does that mean? does it mean he lives in heaven?

cantstopdancin9
Posted

no, it just means that he is going where all the other elves go. it's some place where they don't die cause of they're "powers". know what i mean? i don't think any of the three stories has anything to do with any kind of religion at all (even if the author was catholic).

Posted (edited)

but why would only Frodo go? Why would he go in the first place?

Edited by musturde
Posted

but why would only Frodo go? Why would he go in the first place?

Frodo had to go bc he carried the burned of the ring. Ya sam carried it for a good hours or what have u, but the ring changed Frodo. When he gets back to the Shire he even says that every one else's lives had returned to normal, but he felt out of place.

Posted

so from that he decides he'll live with elves? Why does Gandalf and Bilbo go? Btw I want to thank all of u who have answered my questions so far...

Mary's Knight, La
Posted

Read the Silmarillion not only is it an excellent work but it answers all those questions. in short the elves are going back to where they came from, because frodo saved middle earth from an evil that predated even the firstborn(elves) he merited a place with the elves in their return it's very garden of edenish in nature

Posted

cool, but why Gandalf and Bilbo?

Posted

The ending of the movie and the ending of the book are different, yet the same. The sailing into the undying lands can be interpreted two ways: Frodo went to heaven, or he went to live with the elves in the "undying lands". this doesn't necessarily means that he has died, but he's going where "no war, pain or despair" are. Frodo must go for a number of reasons. In the book, which are touched lightly in the movie, (but hopefully more in the exended versions) Frodo always feels pain and fear from his wounds even after the ring has been destroyed. The shire doesn't even recognize him as the "hero" but rather Sam and Merry and Pippin. They regard Frodo as, well the "groupie" that went with the other 3 hobbits. Anyways, in the book, Arwen gives up her seat (remember she stays with Aragorn) and she gives him her seat on the ship to the grey havens and also gives Frodo the Evenstar which will aid him when his hurts and fears trouble him. So basically, his hurts get worse and worse, his fears still come and he must go and pass into the West "until all the wounds and weariness has healed." Gandalf must go for his time was limited. (I'll look that up later for more details) He came back only to help as much as he was needed. Bilbo was a ring bearer also, so he is granted passage. Hope that helps some.

Anyways, I love the LOTR: ROTK! :cheer:

Posted

so Does he ever come back?

Posted

In the book he doesn't come back. After Rose, Sam's wife dies (old old age) Sam sails into the grey havens, the last of the ring bearers. :sadder:

This of course happens after a long filled life with many children etc.

The appendix tells what happens to ALL of the fellowship and thier decendents. ;)

Posted

thanks for asking this musturde...i was thinking the same thing but was too prideful to ask anyone!!!

Posted

this was made by Jrr or by another author?

Posted

same author, at the end of the book.

Posted

Hmm... interesting... .... ....

Posted

Go get your copy today! :P

Posted

this was made by Jrr or by another author?

Silmarillion was written by JRR Tolkien, actually before he wrote LOTR. It was more of a hobby for him- he was fascinated by the cultures of Middle Earth, so he started creating and writing down all the legends and history. He tried to submit it for publication, but the editors thought it was too complex. (They wanted another "story about hobbits" to follow up on the success of The Hobbit) So Tolkien set Silmarillion aside and wrote LOTR.

After Tolkien died, his son Christopher collected all of his father's unfinished works and published Silmarillion.

Sorry.. I just got done writing a term paper about Tolkien. :nerd: :book: :gradtalk:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...