Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

As Catholics, we believe that when the Pope is speaking on a matter of faith or morals, his teaching is infallible. I would understand this to mean that it is impossible for a Pope to change the official teaching of the Church on matters such as contraception and abortion (because Church teaching has already been clearly defined in these areas). Is this a safe assumption?

Furthermore, the recent Carlo Maria Martini interview would seem to suggest that there is debate within the Church on whether or not condoms should be acceptable in some circumstances. What if someone such as Cardinal Martini were to become Pope and change Church teaching on condoms? Could this happen? Wouldn't that be impossible? Does the Church teach that the Holy Spirit will protect the Church from such an occurrence?

Finally, would it be correct to assert that If a Pope were to reverse a prior teaching, it would logically follow that the prior teaching was incorrect, therefore shattering Papal infallibility and as an extension, the authority of the Church?

Thanks in advance for your reply.
God bless,
Jim

Posted (edited)

An essential feature of the Catholic faith is that the authority of Christ is mediated through the apostolic succession interpreting Scripture and Tradition throughout time. Such an understanding is rooted in a sacramental view of reality that sees the human realm as capable of mediatorship, of bearing truth and grace. The apostolic succession consists of human beings specially guided by the Holy Spirit, and when we turn to the Magisterium, we are turning to the apostolic succession living in our own time.1 However, not everything said by Popes and bishops throughout the centuries is an infallible interpretation of Scripture and Tradition, How can we tell what does and does not belong in the category of infallible teaching? In this regard, there are issues of particular interest today. First, are some matters relating to moral theology, especially some absolute moral norms, infallible?

Vatican II was careful to point out exactly when and where the voice of the Magisterium speaks infallibly. The varying "voices" of the Magisterium are spelled out in Lumen Gentium

A. The Extraordinary Papal Magisterium Here, the pope acts alone and speaks ex cathedra ("from the chair") in defining a dogma. According to a majority theological opinion, this has occurred two times: when the Immmaculate Conception was defined in 1854 by Pius IX (Ineffabilis Deus); and when the Assumption was defined in 1950 by Pius XII Munificentissimus Deus). Regarding our area of concern: No matter regarding morality has been defined in this manner.

B. The Extraordinary Episcopal Magisterium
Bishops gathered in ecumenical councils can define dogmas. At the twenty-one ecumenical councils held throughout Christian history, certain items have been infallibly defined. Consider Chalcedon's (451) definition of the two natures of Christ, or Trent's (1561) definition of the seven sacraments. One Marian dogma was defined in this manner: the Council of Ephesus, against the Nestorian position, defined Mary as Theotokos, Mother of God We owe an "assent of faith" to all matters infallibly defined.

The Ordinary Magisterium
A. The ordinary papal Magisterium consists in Popes teaching "authentically," usually in documents such as encyclicals or apostolic exhortations. These documents may contain truths that are taught infallibly, but the documents as a whole are not infallible. Rather, they require the "assent of mind and will" of the faithful, an assent which is distinct in nature from the "assent of faith" required of items infallibly taught. Humanae Vitae, for instance, is not an infallible document. It contains ideas which require respectful assent but which, while not being erroneous, may be incomplete or partially flawed. However, in article 12 the pope touches upon a matter that, it can be argued, is infallibly taught: the inseparability of the unitive and procreative dimensions of each conjugal act. Hence, the evil of contraception can be said to be taught infallibly. In sum, non-infallible documents can contain items that are infallibly taught or defined.

B. The Ordinary Episcopal Magisterium: Bishops teaching non-universally and universally.

1. Non-universally. Non-universal episcopal teaching occurs when bishops teach on items specific to their geographical location. They are not teaching on a matter which all bishops everywhere would necessarily recognize as true. This can occur either alone, such as when a single bishop appeals to a state official to not use the death penalty, or in episcopal conferences Again, they might refer to items that are infallibly taught or defined, but their teaching as a whole is not infallible.

2. Universally. This is the most delicate category . When the bishops gathered throughout the world have at some time agreed on a matter of divine revelation, dealing with faith or morals, to be held definitively, such agreement constitutes infallible teaching and is irreversible. Various contemporary issues, have given theologians an opportunity to further refine the exact meaning of this category.

In sum, there are a variety of levels on which the Magisterium speaks. Three of these, in the outline above, constitute infallible teaching

The Catechism of the Catholic Church provides a short summary of these key points of Lumen Gentium 25 in sections 890-91, and regarding moral matters in 2032-40. Interestingly, the infallibility of the ordinary universal episcopal Magisterium is not clearly delineated in these paragraphs, but rather is tacitly noted. 2034 states that "The ordinary and universal Magisterium of the Pope and the bishops in communion with him teach the faithful the truth to believe, the charity to practice, the beatitude to hope for." Then, 2035 notes that the charism of infallibility (no further distinctions) extends to the realm of morals (and in 2036 to the realm of the natural law). One may conclude that since moral matters are not taught infallibly by the extraordinary episcopal or papal magisteria, they must be taught infallibly by the ordinary universal episcopal Magisterium.

Matters that are defined infallibly usually were taught infallibly prior to the extraordinary definition. Often what causes a matter to be raised to the level of an infallible definition is some type of crisis requiring a more official definition. It is always a question of prudence as to whether or not to define a matter that is already infallibly taught by the ordinary universal episcopal Magisterium.

The recent Evangelium Vitae could have been the context within which the pope defined infallibly the Church's teaching on the sanctity of human life, on abortion, and on euthanasia. Instead, the pope (wisely in this author's opinion) used the encyclical to point out, in the midst of carefully reasoned argumentation, that [b]these matters are already taught infallibly by the ordinary universal episcopal Magisterium. [/b]

[b]If some bishops today have taught otherwise, they themselves stand in conflict with the tradition, and in a sense are standing outside the apostolic tradition at least on a particular issue. While we must not agree with them as regards their dissenting position, we still owe them our respect as members of the apostolic succession who guard the deposit of faith in many other (usually most other) respects. [/b]

Hence, we find a clear statement (a reminder) that these moral matters are taught (not defined) infallibly. Any other moral matters that have infallible status are taught, not defined, infallibly by the ordinary universal episcopal Magisterium. Other examples are those issues rooted in the Church's teaching on the nature of the conjugal act as unitive and procreative, such as homosexual acts, adultery and fornication, contraception and sterilization, autoeroticism, and certain new birth technologies.

I hope that may put your mind at rest regarding the lastest Media Blitz (mistaken at any rate). Maybe someone else may be clearer :D:

Edited by cappie

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...