she_who_is_not Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 I am still not a Catholic. I dropped out of RCIA the second week of Lent. I was so frustrated and upset about some things that were said, which now seem very silly to me and my sister had a miscarriage and I needed some spiritual support that I wasn't getting at that parish. So, I went back to my old Episcopalian parish. I had been going to evening prayer and Benediction of the Blessed Sacrament there pretty frequently, even though I was attending the Catholic mass so I guess I never really made a clean break. However, at Easter Vigil despite my happiness and the beauty of the service I realized that this was not right. I made the wrong decision. I have been drawn to Catholocism since I was twelve and read A Story of a Soul. My decision to enter the Church was painful and meant leaving a parish I loved, that is dedicated to glorifying God through worship. However, I felt and feel for very strong reasons that God wants me to be a part of the true Church. I put up with the craziness of RCIA classes, a faith formation director who is addicted to pain and anxiety medication to the point that she rarely makes sense, gives false information, and degrades the Bishop. I missed the trappings of my old parish, the incense, the beautiful choir, the vestments. But I recognized all this as "extras" This was important to God and I was willing to make the sacrifice. However, I was increasingly upset by more important issues, which are too painful for to even write about. Yet, I said to myself that these were flaws that could be overcome. The Church is made up of imperfect people and people with differing opinions. Far be it from me a little Protestant to question their theology. And, then, after all that the straw that broke my back is the silliest stupidest thing that you could ever imagine. At Ash Wedensday, I went up for a blessing during Communion and the Eucharistic mininster shook my hand and said "Welcome to the Club" Now I know she meant this in the nicest way possible but I was so appalled. I wanted to scream, " I am not joining a club, I am uniting myself more fully with the body of Christ." And for that matter the formal chapter meetings of my college sorority meetings were conducted with more reverance than you celebrate the mass. A week later my sister miscarried, after trying six years for a baby, and I needed spiritual counsel that I didn't feel comfortable seeking at the Catholic Church. Then I stopped going to Mass and RCIA. Now I know this is stupid and I am admitting my stupidity. I'm sure some of you think I am don't even deserve to be a part of the Church. However, now I stuck in limbo. Though, I love my old church I know that is not right and I've cut myself off from the Catholic Church. Someone suggested I talk to priest at another parish about some of my problems and concerns. But, I don't know if I can and I be faced with living my life outside of the sacraments. At least I am baptized. I don't know what to do. I am so angry at myself.
Noel's angel Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 Don't be angry at yourself!! It seems to me that you've had a pretty tough time with certain people and this isn't your fault!! Your continuing search for Truth is inspiring. Some people would have given up long ago, but you have persevered. Have you talked to a priest at the parish you were attending? He might not know the full extent of what is going on. Don't give up!! You have come this far! Keep persevering. It's tough to belong to a parish that doesn't fully respect and understand the faith, I can only imagine how much harder it must be to try and join a parish like the one you have described. Speak to the priest-it can do no harm. Tell him about your experience and ask him for advice. Alwasy remember PRIESTS ARE PEOPLE TOO! Never be too scared to speak to a priest, generally they are more than willing to help someone in need. I'm sure others will be able to offer better advice. All I can say is don't give up! You are in my prayers.
jasJis Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 I wouldn't call you stupid. A lot of what you posted is why I don't go to Church anymore, though I don't reject the theology of the Catholic Church, I just don't see it practiced in the Catholic Church. If this is God's 'Chosen Church', the source of All Truth, why don't people live it? Why do almost all Catholics fail at living the Faith with sincerety and welcome? When I have a spiritual problem, the least amount of help I ever get is from Catholics, whether it's friends, family, or clergy. It's always 'join the club', that's the way it's done, ignore the Bishop, the GIRM is the rule book, the GIRM is an outline, offer it up, we aren't perfect, here's a platitude, there's a platitude. I want to hear some advice from someone who knows what the Church really teaches, listen to my problem, and provide some advice with Christian Charity, not just let me know what rules I messed up or blow me off with 'offer it up'. The sad thing is, though I'd say my non-Catholic friends are usually better in acting like Christians, they lack a great deal of understanding that can be found in Catholicism. All I can say, is just keep trying to follow God's guidance. God's usually much more patient than us. We can get angry at the human part, but don't get angry at God. If we work to stay open to God's correction, things should work out, even if He's got to knock us off a horse and poke us in the eyes to get us going in the right direction.
MichaelFilo Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 Walk softly in the wake of the new church, for it is a dead faith that lingers in their hearts. I live next to one of these parishes... they tried to teach me that all men go to heaven, and have no choice... be careful, satan lingers in their hearts and minds (for who else would keep someone from the Truth of the Church?) Anywho, with the warning aside, I agree, some Catholic churches are complete peices of cardboard (and by that i mean flat and dry, as is the faith within them). I say, find a good Indult Mass Church (maybe I can help you find one near you) and go there, because all those things you love in an Episcopalean service can be found in the glorious gem of the Church, the Tridentine Mass. There too, and I put my honour on this, you will also find a faith filled Church, who will probably appreciate your conversion more than you can imagine. However, since the Churches are scarce it may not be the closest one to you, but alas, it maybe worth it considering your situation. And yes, the priests there are the creme of the crop. God bless, Mikey
Mary-Kathryn Posted April 28, 2006 Posted April 28, 2006 I am a convert. When I was in my 20's I started with RCIA...this was years ago with people who were still in the mode of the 60's and 70's. I had a female RCIA teacher/DRE who was quite scandalous. I think I made it through simply because I was so ignorant. You are hurt and angry and disappointed, and for that I am deeply sorry. This is what I would like you to try to do if you can. I want you to find a good and holy priest and make an appointment with him. Tell him of your struggles--be charitable in speech- and of the terrible pain of your sister's loss. Ask him if he would allow you to finish the RCIA lessons with him and if he would allow you to come into The Church outside of Easter. Also, Is there a Church that has Latin Mass in your area? Since you are mourning the absence of the beauty of vestments, incense and the beauty of music, a Latin Mass might fullfill your longings and ease your ache. I love the Latin Mass but it is an hour from my home. I am going to mail you off-line [if I can] and give you my email. If you need to vent or chat, I'm available. God is calling you to His Church, so answer the call! Mary-Kathryn
she_who_is_not Posted April 28, 2006 Author Posted April 28, 2006 Thanks to all for your loving and encouraging guidance. I am greatly encouraged and am praying that God will lead me to the right parish. Mikey, I had thought about finding a parish that had the Tridentine mass but the closest is about 2 hours away. However, I may be moving to Chicago ir Phoenix in the fall and I know that they have an abundance of churches to seek a home in. I really want to be a part of the Church and uniting with God's will I'm am confident that all shall be well in the end. However, I can't help kicking myself over my decision. I feel like I am going to have to wait forever to join the Church. Peace, Amanda
Mary-Kathryn Posted April 28, 2006 Posted April 28, 2006 [quote name='she_who_is_not' post='964104' date='Apr 28 2006, 11:44 AM'] Thanks to all for your loving and encouraging guidance. I am greatly encouraged and am praying that God will lead me to the right parish. Mikey, I had thought about finding a parish that had the Tridentine mass but the closest is about 2 hours away. However, I may be moving to Chicago ir Phoenix in the fall and I know that they have an abundance of churches to seek a home in. I really want to be a part of the Church and uniting with God's will I'm am confident that all shall be well in the end. However, I can't help kicking myself over my decision. I feel like I am going to have to wait forever to join the Church. Peace, Amanda [/quote] Phoenix has the new addition of the Poor Clares of Perpetual Adoration [from Mother Angelica's monastery] also, check this website out for the Latin Masses [url="http://www.diocesephoenix.org/LatinMassTimes.htm"]http://www.diocesephoenix.org/LatinMassTimes.htm[/url]
philothea Posted April 28, 2006 Posted April 28, 2006 Oh, Amanda, you poor thing! What a terrible thing that parish did, to carelessly discourage you like that. I don't think anyone here would scold you. We're all fallible. It's a big step. I lost at least a year of being Catholic just because I was too cowardly to contact a parish. You'll get there soon, I hope. It wouldn't hurt to look around at other parishes, and see if there are [i]any[/i] priests that might be understanding, and maybe help you join the Church sooner. Prayers and sympathy. [and PS to all... woot for the transmundane board. I totally overlooked this post when it was on open mic.]
Nathan Posted April 28, 2006 Posted April 28, 2006 The weeks and days leading up to Confirmation can be very stressful and frustrating. They were for me. I know that I, even though I wanted nothing more than to finally be received into the Church and to receive the Eucharist (I spend almost two years in RCIA), was ready to blow up at the drop of a hat in the final days. All it would have taken was for someone in the parish to say the wrong thing to me. For some reason, I felt very sensitive and out of my comfort zone. This may sound weird, but I believe that it was the Devil, trying to prevent me from going through with it.
Lil Red Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 prayers for you and prayers for your sister in law! your situation sounds very difficult and i pray that you will overcome it.
Guest Fr Hart Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 I read your message with a great deal of empathy and common understanding. I also have good news for you. It sounds to me that you are really missing the glorious worship of the more traditional worship of the Anglican church. The good news is that you can have both! There is an Anglican Rite in the Roman Church. For those of us that grew up traditional Anglicans (Episcopalians) the majesty and reverence of worship is something post Vatican II Roman Catholics can only dream of, but with the Pastoral Provision allowing the Anglican Rite you can still have it and the security of the Holy Church. Now, before I am violently attacked and taken to task with the indult Mass, I agree it is of great liturgical beauty and captures the reverential majesty of traditional Roman Catholic worship, it is difficult to find it dome properly anywhere and to worship in your own tongue has always been a sacred trust of Anglicans. Anyway, depending on where you are, you may be able to find one of the Anglican Rite churches. I hope this helps, Fr. Hartline
thessalonian Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 As for deserving to be a part of Christ's Church. You don't. But neither do I or anyone else who is in it. The grace of God is not deserved and earned, except when we allow ourselves to follow the will and grace of God. So follow it. He is leading you. Don't beat yourself up over all of this. The spirit was telling you loud and clear there was something very wrong in this parish. DO GO TO ANOTHER ONE. I can't guarantee it but the priest may work out something so you don't have to wait until next Easter to join the Church. I will add you to my prayer list. This is just a temporary setback and God knows your heart so hang in there and stay on the path to the fullness of the truth. No it's not a club. How completely absurd that EM was. Blessings
dUSt Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 Fr Hart has a point. I live a few blocks away from an Anglican Use Catholic church. Beautiful liturgy, and down with the pope. Can't beat that!
qfnol31 Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 [quote name='dUSt' post='965733' date='Apr 29 2006, 11:12 PM'] Fr Hart has a point. I live a few blocks away from an Anglican Use Catholic church. Beautiful liturgy, and down with the pope. Can't beat that! [/quote] My friends want me to go there some time...Maybe in a few weeks I shall.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 You didn't mess up dearie, you took a detour. Many of us have done that on our journey to the The Church is still waiting for you with open arms, pick a different parish and talk to the priest. Try the Anglican rite parish, and if you go, tell us about it. I haven't been lucky enough to visit one yet.
she_who_is_not Posted April 30, 2006 Author Posted April 30, 2006 The Anglican Use Rite is fascinating. I looked at a couple of parishes online. They all seem to be in Texas, though. One major issue I have faced is that I live in a small city in the South and we are not overflowing with Catholic Churches. I think there are three in the city proper, and the one I was attending is considered the most "traditional". There is a wonderful suburban parish, which I have been to twice when I was housesitting for my sister and I really liked it. They have a Gregorian chant choir and seem very devotional. Let's all pray that my car is fixed soon and I can commence a more regular attendance. I'm so glad everyone understands. I felt so childish for not sticking it out (refusing to bear the cross of it) but I know that in doing God's will there can be no failure and that in the words of Julian of Norwich, "All shall be well and all shall be well and all manner of things shall be well." I finding much consolation in prayer can feel God working throughout all of this. Thanks to all for your prayer and support. I really need the Phatmass community right now. It's keeping me catholic!! Peace, Amanda
cmotherofpirl Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 I love that quote! Phatmass keeps a lot of people catholic :
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now