Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Canon of Scripture


Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I'm posting this in the debate table because this is geared more towards Protestants than Catholics (as it wouldn't present a problem for Catholics, I don't think).

When discussing how the canon of the Bible came about, Protestants will inevitably cite something dealing with the authorship of the text-- or, more precisely, the Apostolic authorship.

However, with all the more recent scholarly biblical studies it has been determined that several texts formerly thought to be written by the hand of Apostles have been discovered to be allonymities (written by other people claiming to be someone else). Thus, the "apostolic" criteria fails in certain cases (i.e., 1 Timothy and Titus).

Shouldn't Protestants (et al.) be revising their Bibles in light of the serious scholarly evidence that has been found to be overwhelmingly certain? By keeping certain texts in their NT canon they are undermining their own criteria for determining the authentic canon of the Scripture.

Posted

Prots should be revising alot more than their Bibles!!!

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='dspen2005' post='963323' date='Apr 27 2006, 07:45 PM']
Prots should be revising alot more than their Bibles!!!
[/quote]
Well, yes, but this seems like a good stepping stone to the eventual embrace of authority outside of Scripture.

Posted

They won't do that. I think that many Protestants don't take these studies seriously and dismiss them because they consider these scholars to be athiests who only want to discredit the Word of God.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

New Advent advances the idea that since Scripture is declared inspired, and these texts claim Paul's authorship, they must have been written by Paul. Please share your thoughts.
More:
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14727b.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14727b.htm[/url]

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='963314' date='Apr 27 2006, 08:33 PM']
I'm posting this in the debate table because this is geared more towards Protestants than Catholics (as it wouldn't present a problem for Catholics, I don't think).

When discussing how the canon of the Bible came about, Protestants will inevitably cite something dealing with the authorship of the text-- or, more precisely, the Apostolic authorship.

However, with all the more recent scholarly biblical studies it has been determined that several texts formerly thought to be written by the hand of Apostles have been discovered to be allonymities (written by other people claiming to be someone else). Thus, the "apostolic" criteria fails in certain cases (i.e., 1 Timothy and Titus).

Shouldn't Protestants (et al.) be revising their Bibles in light of the serious scholarly evidence that has been found to be overwhelmingly certain? By keeping certain texts in their NT canon they are undermining their own criteria for determining the authentic canon of the Scripture.
[/quote]

I worry everytime I see something about overwhelming certianty based on what scholarship shows..." What method was used to determine this? Who are the people saying that this is true?

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='963389' date='Apr 27 2006, 05:38 PM']
I worry everytime I see something about overwhelming certianty based on what scholarship shows..." What method was used to determine this? Who are the people saying that this is true?
[/quote]
Ditto.

This is largely based on "historio-critical" "scholarship," which is seriously flawed, and is often based on modernistic assumptions concerning Scripture. It is not based in any serious scientific or archaelogical evidence, but often boils down to modernist bible scholars asserting their own opinions about the text. There is too much to go into right here.

These same scholars usually also deny the traditional authorship of the Gospels, claiming them to be later legends written much later by the "Christian communities," and that most of it (i.e. that containing the miraculous and references to Christ's divinity) does not actually record events in the life of Christ.

Look up "LittleLes" on these boards for examples and refutations of this nonsense.

Such "scholarship" attacks not just Protestant claims, but Catholic teachings as well.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='963373' date='Apr 27 2006, 08:28 PM']
New Advent advances the idea that since Scripture is declared inspired, and these texts claim Paul's authorship, they must have been written by Paul. Please share your thoughts.
More:
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14727b.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14727b.htm[/url]
[/quote]
I don't think inspiration and apostolic authorship are necessarily connected (though they aren't exclusive either).

Look at texts in the OT, especially Wisdom which is often attributed to King Solomon-- yet, Wisdom was written in Greek, and during Solomon's reign, Greek wasn't a language (it's only about 3500 years old... and Greek literature only dates back about 3000 years). And many of the Psalms contain historical references centuries removed from the time of David.

These texts are still inspired, for sure, but their inspiration isn't dependent upon being authored by an Apostle or OT "Great".

[quote name=''Brother Adam' date='Apr 27 2006' date=' 08:38PM'']I worry everytime I see something about overwhelming certianty based on what scholarship shows..." What method was used to determine this? Who are the people saying that this is true?[/quote]
Sometimes the best evidence is from the letters themselves...

1 Timothy and 2 Timothy give two different accounts of how Timothy came to the faith. 2 Timothy lines up with the account given in Acts 16.. so that leaves 1 Timothy (and by extension, Titus-- since Titus is basically an outline of 1 Timothy) in some question. Furthermore, 1 Timothy and Titus use key terms (i.e., faith, law, etc.) under very different contexts than do all the "undisputed" letters of Paul. The vocabulary and writing style is rather different.

All in all, I don't think authorship is the basis for determining Scriptural Canon... 1 Clement was written by a Pope, yet it's not included in the Canon of the NT. And I don't think it does any great damage to the Catholic faith to say that certain epistles in the NT were not authored by Apostles. I am sure that there were great Christian leaders in the early church who were not Apostles. If Apostolic authorship was/is the basis for determining Scripture-- why then would we have needed the Magisterium? But if this is an inproper assumption for me to make.. by all means... explain. I'm all ears.

[quote name='Socrates' post='963422' date='Apr 27 2006, 09:25 PM']
Ditto.

This is largely based on "historio-critical" "scholarship," which is seriously flawed, and is often based on modernistic assumptions concerning Scripture. It is not based in any serious scientific or archaelogical evidence, but often boils down to modernist bible scholars asserting their own opinions about the text. There is too much to go into right here.

These same scholars usually also deny the traditional authorship of the Gospels, claiming them to be later legends written much later by the "Christian communities," and that most of it (i.e. that containing the miraculous and references to Christ's divinity) does not actually record events in the life of Christ.

Look up "LittleLes" on these boards for examples and refutations of this nonsense.

Such "scholarship" attacks not just Protestant claims, but Catholic teachings as well.
[/quote]
Whoa, whoa... back up. I said nothing of the Gospels being "legends", etc. nor was I ever going in that direction...

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='963325' date='Apr 27 2006, 06:50 PM']
Well, yes, but this seems like a good stepping stone to the eventual embrace of authority outside of Scripture.
[/quote]

i'm not clear as to what u mean by "authority outside of Scripture"; isn't the authority rooted in Scripture?

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='963427' date='Apr 27 2006, 06:30 PM']
I don't think inspiration and apostolic authorship are necessarily connected (though they aren't exclusive either).

Look at texts in the OT, especially Wisdom which is often attributed to King Solomon-- yet, Wisdom was written in Greek, and during Solomon's reign, Greek wasn't a language (it's only about 3500 years old... and Greek literature only dates back about 3000 years). And many of the Psalms contain historical references centuries removed from the time of David.

These texts are still inspired, for sure, but their inspiration isn't dependent upon being authored by an Apostle or OT "Great".
Sometimes the best evidence is from the letters themselves...

1 Timothy and 2 Timothy give two different accounts of how Timothy came to the faith. 2 Timothy lines up with the account given in Acts 16.. so that leaves 1 Timothy (and by extension, Titus-- since Titus is basically an outline of 1 Timothy) in some question. Furthermore, 1 Timothy and Titus use key terms (i.e., faith, law, etc.) under very different contexts than do all the "undisputed" letters of Paul. The vocabulary and writing style is rather different.

All in all, I don't think authorship is the basis for determining Scriptural Canon... 1 Clement was written by a Pope, yet it's not included in the Canon of the NT. And I don't think it does any great damage to the Catholic faith to say that certain epistles in the NT were not authored by Apostles. I am sure that there were great Christian leaders in the early church who were not Apostles. If Apostolic authorship was/is the basis for determining Scripture-- why then would we have needed the Magisterium? But if this is an inproper assumption for me to make.. by all means... explain. I'm all ears.
Whoa, whoa... back up. I said nothing of the Gospels being "legends", etc. nor was I ever going in that direction...
[/quote]
Much of this concerning authorship is actually far from conclusive. And the Greek version of Wisdom is not neccessarily the original.

I never said whether a book was authored by a particular person determines whether it is inspired.

Nor did I claim you were stating that the Gospels were merely legends. However, that is the direction these "historio-critical scholars" usually DO take. They claim (on no solid historical basis, but their own anti-supernatural bias) that the Gospels were written long after living memory of Christ, and were based on a (non-existant) "Q source" of "sayings of Jesus."
Then they declare that the Gospels are unreliable as historical documents, and are mostly fictional fabrication.

Thus I'd say such "scholarship" is weak grounds for confronting Protestant claims. It is commonly used to discredit the Bible and the Church itself.
And bringing this stuff up would probably be a poor start to dialogue with a "Bible Christian."

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

So then would you say that we are obligated to say that Paul is the author of all the purported epistles (besides Peter, John, Revelation)? I mean, I say it usually for the sake of simplicity and to avoid confusion, but I don't demand that someone claim Paul is the author of 1 Timothy or Titus (or Hebrews, etc.).

Has the Church spoken on this matter? If she has, then by all means, I humbly submit myself to her authority. And if demonstrated, I would recant my position.

My hesitation is in "throwing the baby out with the bathwater"... we don't have to take ALL the conclusions that scholars who subscribe the historical-critical method take... but there are legitimate methods found within the method itself that can be prudently applied in the study of Scripture (read "The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church").. it has its limitations, for sure, but it does have its own value as well.

[quote name='dspen2005' post='963454' date='Apr 27 2006, 09:43 PM']
i'm not clear as to what u mean by "authority outside of Scripture"; isn't the authority rooted in Scripture?
[/quote]
Yes, but not solely in Sacred Scripture. We abide by Sacred Tradition which is extra-biblical (and includes the Scriptures) as well as the Scriptures themselves.

Brother Adam
Posted

Yeah, I had a feeling it was the so called "historical critical method". I'm glad you read that document. The method is useless for a spiritual reading, and the conclusions of scholars who read the Bible only through that method are guessing at best. Dr. Bergsma has shown the serious problems with the method even in itself almost to the point where I'm surprised he doesn't have a book on it.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Yes, it has it's problems (and I'm not promoting the method), but I don't think that we can completely disregard it entirely. It does have its merits when applied properly...

Nonetheless, this is getting a bit off topic.

Would you say then that we ought to/are obligated to say that Paul authored all the NT epistles originally attributed to him? Why is the identity of the human author so important? I won't deny that it does have some importance, but I would think that content outweighs human authorship...

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I think New Advent was saying that since Titus and both Timothy's both start out with the writer claiming to be Paul, it must be true since these texts are the word of God - not necesarily that they had to be written by Paul or some other respected person to be considered inspired.

I also have a problem with some of this modern "scholarship." It seems like if an achealogist can't find it, it didn't exist (ex: a Hebrew Gospel of Matthew).

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Alot of us know that the Early Church Fathers told us who wrote what book.......That's how we know who wrote the Gospel of Mathew and the letter of Hebrews.




Rome's official Bible Canon came from the Council of Trent.


Not the council of Hippo or the Council of Carthage......these were local/providential councils not ecumenical councils.


And even they were influenced by the compilation of books made by the Eastern Church in Constantinople.







INLOVE Jnorm

Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='963422' date='Apr 27 2006, 07:25 PM']
Ditto.

This is largely based on "historio-critical" "scholarship," which is seriously flawed, and is often based on modernistic assumptions concerning Scripture. It is not based in any serious scientific or archaelogical evidence, but often boils down to modernist bible scholars asserting their own opinions about the text. There is too much to go into right here.

These same scholars usually also deny the traditional authorship of the Gospels, claiming them to be later legends written much later by the "Christian communities," and that most of it (i.e. that containing the miraculous and references to Christ's divinity) does not actually record events in the life of Christ.

Look up "LittleLes" on these boards for examples and refutations of this nonsense.

Such "scholarship" attacks not just Protestant claims, but Catholic teachings as well.
[/quote]

I think the big problem with the historical-critical method is that people think it is just shedding light on the context of ancient texts, but in reality it is used to come to preposterous conclusions. Just do a Google search on "Jesus seminar" or "Dominic Crossan".

Another interesting note: author Steve Kellmeyer (he used to post here as skellmeyer) mentioned at a talk that the historical-critical method was nutured by protestant Prussia to undermine the legitimacy of the Catholic Church during the mid-1800s (at the same time protestant Prussia was reunifying Germany, including Catholic Bavaria).

[quote name='jnorm888' post='981772' date='May 15 2006, 04:44 PM']
Rome's official Bible Canon came from the Council of Trent.
Not the council of Hippo or the Council of Carthage......these were local/providential councils not ecumenical councils.
And even they were influenced by the compilation of books made by the Eastern Church in Constantinople.
[/quote]

Well, I 'd like to have one of the scholars/clergy on the phorum comment on this, as I've heard this before.

However, please keep in mind that the Vulgate included the books from the Council of Carthage that were later thrown out by the protestants.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Again, I never stated the historical-critical method was perfect... but I don't think it wise to completely disregard it either. It has it's limitations, yes, but if you stay within the bounds of those limitations it can be a fruitful method. If you think otherwise, you should be preparing a lengthy treatise to the Pontifical Biblical Commission.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='jnorm888' post='981772' date='May 15 2006, 04:44 PM']
Alot of us know that the Early Church Fathers told us who wrote what book.......That's how we know who wrote the Gospel of Mathew and the letter of Hebrews.
Rome's official Bible Canon came from the Council of Trent.
Not the council of Hippo or the Council of Carthage......these were local/providential councils not ecumenical councils.
And even they were influenced by the compilation of books made by the Eastern Church in Constantinople.
INLOVE Jnorm
[/quote]


Flourence was not a local council and Pope Damasus declared the canon toward the end of the 4th century is well. The Vulgate was based on his canon which was ratified by Hippo and Carthage. Pope Innocent I also enumerated the books identically to trent in 405 AD.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='thessalonian' post='984378' date='May 18 2006, 06:19 AM']
Flourence was not a local council and Pope Damasus declared the canon toward the end of the 4th century is well. The Vulgate was based on his canon which was ratified by Hippo and Carthage. Pope Innocent I also enumerated the books identically to trent in 405 AD.
[/quote]




Do you have any info I can read on this? I am asking because the normal Roman Catholic Arguement is that of the Council of hippo and how Rome gave the whole planet the Bible and how Protestants should come back to Rome because we use her books that she put together.


Such pridefull talk doesn't work and it causes more discord than unity.






INLOVE Jnorm

Edited by jnorm888
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Look up Pope Innocent I... usually any encyclopedia, etc. will tell you that he confirmed the canon of the Bible (that was confirmed at Trent) in the early 400s.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...