Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Guest Creepy
Posted

Okay, so I've been having a discussion with a Baptist friend of mine about the Bible, the Church, Saints, etc. and I have a few questions:

1) What are Saints? I told her that Saints are the people who have achieved full communion with God and the Saints canonized by God are ones that the Church knows are in heaven because of miracles and other investigatory processes, etc. But she said that she would doubt that just because a miracle happened from a Saint, she wouldn't necessarily believe that it was because that Saint is in heaven. Also, she said that all Christians are called to be Saints and that when they are saved they become Saints. And I said that I'm not a Saint and won't be until I am in heaven and am in full communion with God. So I just read that canonization is for the purpose of setting examples for us, not necessarily saying that this person is in heaven and we have proof. Am I wrong? Is there a better way?

2) I told her that God never lets us go but we can let go of Him. I said He holds people in the palm of His hands and if people want to jump out, they can, b/c God allows us to have free will and reject Him through our whole lives and she doesn't believe that once a person is saved that he/she can reject God, that we don't have the power to do so. She wanted an example of someone who rejected God and I said Judas b/c he killed himself and rejected God's power to forgive him. But she argues that Judas couldn't have believed in Christ in the first place if he rejected God. Can you help?

3) We talked about the whole "Church authority" thing and I said that Christ establishes Peter as Pope in the Gospel and sets up the Church that way and that the Church cannot officially teach something that is not of God because "the gates of hell will not prevail against the Church." But she reads that passage differently and argues that God doesn't actually establish the Catholic Church in that passage and that the Church is made of fallible humans and so you can't say that it won't teach the wrong thing. And so I used the example of the Church canonizing the Bible and saying this is a complete canon and she argues that when Paul says that you can't add or subtract to God's word that he's actually making a prophesy, if you will, or establishing that God promises to give us the Bible in its completeness, even if it wasn't complete at the time Paul wrote it, and that's how you can know that the Bible is complete, not because the Church has full authority. But she does say that the group that canonized the Bible, at the time, were given the authority by God to canonize that scripture and say what's what because of the promise that God gave to Paul that the Bible will be complete. How do I explain Church authority better?

Thanks!

Posted

JMJ
4/30 - Third Sunday of Easter

Complex questions, but I'll try to give short answers.

1.) The Church states that a saint is anyone who lives in the grace of God - so, in that sense, you and I are saints due to baptism. There are canonized saints, and these are ones whom God has shown are in union with Him in heaven. The Church has discerned over a couple thousand years that the way He shows this is through miracles - typically, two, but I think only one (or even none) for martyrs.

2.) Of course we can reject God. He loves us enough to let us reject Him. Anyone who says that people who reject God just never believed in the first place have clearly never worked in a parish. Satan does not waste time with non-believers. A good "for instance" would be the French priests who turned their back on God and the Church in the wake of the French Revolution - one would be hard-pressed to say that they never "really" believed in God in the first place. However, due to their own decisions in life, they led themselves to reject Him.

3.) I don't have time to answer this one (gotta drive back to school soon!), so I leave it to another scholar. I hope this helps!

Yours,
Pio Nono

Theoketos
Posted

[quote name='Creepy' post='963744' date='Apr 27 2006, 11:02 PM']
Okay, so I've been having a discussion with a Baptist friend of mine about the Bible, the Church, Saints, etc. and I have a few questions:


3) We talked about the whole "Church authority" thing and I said that Christ establishes Peter as Pope in the Gospel and sets up the Church that way and that the Church cannot officially teach something that is not of God because "the gates of hell will not prevail against the Church." But she reads that passage differently and argues that God doesn't actually establish the Catholic Church in that passage and that the Church is made of fallible humans and so you can't say that it won't teach the wrong thing. And so I used the example of the Church canonizing the Bible and saying this is a complete canon and she argues that when Paul says that you can't add or subtract to God's word that he's actually making a prophesy, if you will, or establishing that God promises to give us the Bible in its completeness, even if it wasn't complete at the time Paul wrote it, and that's how you can know that the Bible is complete, not because the Church has full authority. But she does say that the group that canonized the Bible, at the time, were given the authority by God to canonize that scripture and say what's what because of the promise that God gave to Paul that the Bible will be complete. How do I explain Church authority better?

Thanks!
[/quote]

Wow you did a great job! I do not think that there is much to add without learning Aramaic...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...