philothea Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 I know St. John of the Cross's "Dark Night" is discussed around here on occasion, and it's sometimes mistakenly used as a term for depression, or for having a long string of difficulties. I recently dug out one of my favorite books on prayer, Fr. Thomas Dubay's [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0898702631/ref=nosim/103-9385628-0733459?camp=2025&dev-t=D26XECQVNV6NDQ&l"]Fire Within[/url], and he has a great comparison between an emotional problem and the dark night. from the book (pp. 163-164): How do we know that we have entered upon the beginnings of infused prayer and are receiving the initial purification that will prepare us, if we persevere, for still deeper communion? Before we consider the signs that St. John of the Cross identifies, it may be well to lay to rest a spirtual direction blunder that is not rarely made, namely, the confusing of a mental problem with the dark night. Too often people use John's terminology without knowing what he actually has in mind. Clarifying the sharp differences between a mental/emotional problem and the purifying nights can prepare us to understand genuine signs better. We may arrange a few contrasting traits of each experience[...]: [i]Mental/emotional problem[/i]: Excessive introspection, self-concern, self-analysis. The person can scarcely get his mind off himself and his problem. Advice does little to remedy this trait, at least at first. [i]Dark, purifying night[/i]: Little or no introspection once the condition is adequately explained. Little awareness of the problem aside from prayer time. [i]Mental/emotional problem[/i]: Unrealism. The depressed person's situation is not as dismal and hopeless as he considers it (when the problem is depression). The moral case is not as the scrupulous person thinks, nor one's worth as the person with a weak self-image supposes. [i]Dark, purifying night[/i]: The pains of the dark night are objectively well founded: we are very imperfect, and we need exactly what is happening. The situation is as realistic as a laundry washing-machine operation and what it is doing for the soiled clothes. [i]Mental/emotional problem[/i]: Depression. The person with a mental problem often stuffers from clinical depression more or less severe. [i]Dark, purifying night[/i]: There is no depression at all. At work, play, meals, the person is as cheerful as any other period in the spirtual life. [i]Mental/emotional problem[/i]: Many mental problems are difficult to heal; years of therapy may be needed, and even then progress may be only partial. [i]Dark, purifying night[/i]: A competent explanation clears up the anxiety occasioned by the dark night. Therapy is not needed for either night, even if the second must run its course -- just as a washing machine must complete its cycles. [i]Mental/emotional problem[/i]: Chronic fatigue and/or insomnia often accompany the emotional disturbance. [i]Dark, purifying night[/i]: No problem at all. [i]Mental/emotional problem[/i]: Fixing attention on studying, reading or a lecture can be impossible. [i]Dark, purifying night[/i]: Attention at prayer can be difficult and at times impossible, but there is no attention problem in the rest of life. [i]Mental/emotional problem[/i]: Mental/emotional problems do not [i]of themselves[/i] promote virtue or increase depth of relationship with God. [i]Dark, purifying night[/i]: The two nights do [i]of themselves[/i] greatly increase love, humility, patience, and the like, and they decidedly prepare one for deeper prayer. It can happen that a person with some emotional problem may at the same time be going through contemplative purification, and it may be difficult in a given case to sort out one from the other. But all the same, the two phenomena are very different and disctinct both in their causes and in their effects. [i](If anyone wants, I can post more snippets of information, like the signs to look for. I highly recommend the book to anyone who is interested in contemplative prayer.)[/i]
Carolou Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 I've never heard of the dark night before. Can you tell more, please? What exactly is it..?
philothea Posted April 29, 2006 Author Posted April 29, 2006 [quote name='Carolou' post='964875' date='Apr 29 2006, 07:17 AM'] I've never heard of the dark night before. Can you tell more, please? What exactly is it..? [/quote] This is just my summary; quoting the book would take too long. Briefly, according to St. John of the Cross (actually, anyone who talks about prayer but the terminology is his), there comes a time in the prayer life of anyone who is serious about serving God, when God begins to interact more directly with the person praying. This is a transition between discursive meditation: primarily human-made prayer, and infused contemplation: the prayer that God gives directly. This is a wonderful thing, but for the person who experiences it, it feels like all of a sudden he can't pray anymore! This period of awkward, difficult adaptation is called "the first dark night" and it is often distressing to the recipient, who is always someone very serious about praying and doing good. The second dark night is like the first, but happens much later and is much more traumatic -- it's like purgatory on earth -- and it occurs right before someone becomes a saint. I'll post some excerpts from the book on definitive signs of entry to the first night later. Busy today... foo.
phatcatholic Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 [quote name='Carolou' post='964875' date='Apr 29 2006, 08:17 AM']I've never heard of the dark night before. Can you tell more, please? What exactly is it..?[/quote] you can read it online here: [url="http://www.ourladyswarriors.org/saints/darknite.htm"]http://www.ourladyswarriors.org/saints/darknite.htm[/url]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 Thank you, Thea. I see very much from Fr. Dubay's comments that my own difficulties really are psychological and not so spiritual (although, surely, I have problems there, too God, give me the grace to pass through these psychoses! :
Carolou Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 Philothea- thanks for posting all that. I never knew about it before. Very interesting. [quote name='phatcatholic' post='965005' date='Apr 29 2006, 09:52 AM'] you can read it online here: [url="http://www.ourladyswarriors.org/saints/darknite.htm"]http://www.ourladyswarriors.org/saints/darknite.htm[/url] [/quote] Thanks, phatcatholic. I'll have to check out that link. I saw you guys all at confession today, lol. :
phatcatholic Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 [quote name='Carolou' post='965575' date='Apr 29 2006, 07:45 PM'] Thanks, phatcatholic. I'll have to check out that link. I saw you guys all at confession today, lol. : [/quote] you should have said hi!
Carolou Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='965587' date='Apr 29 2006, 08:07 PM'] you should have said hi! [/quote] yeah but all your souls were clean and mine wasn't yet. I waved to Laura, though. hehe.
philothea Posted May 1, 2006 Author Posted May 1, 2006 More from Fr. Dubay (emphasis mine): St. John of the Cross offers[b] three main signs[/b] that one is in the first night of sense. We are not now discussing the transitional stage from discursive to infused prayer but rather the sitaution where one has quite completely left the former and is at least usually in the latter. The first sign is [b]an absence of "satisfaction or consolation" in either things of heaven or of earth.[/b] [. . .] At the same time, his [b]prayer is dry and unsatisfying: he finds little or no delight in it[/b]. While it may be indeed be bleak and painful, it is surely characterized by aridity and distraction. The second sign [b]is a concern for and a habitual turning to God, even though there may be little pleasurable taste for Him[/b]. We are dealing with a generous person who is considerably detached from earthly things and desires to give God everything. There is consequently a great difference between this apparent emptiness of mortification and the actual emptiness of mediocrity. [. . .] This dry contemplation is "secret and hidden from the very one who receives it [and] it imparts in the soul, together with the dryness and imptiness it produces in the senses, [b]an inclination to remaine alone and in quietude[/b]. [. . .] The third sign of the night of sense is [b]an inability to meditate discursively[/b]. We do not mean by this that the inability prevents discursive reasoning in spiritual reading or in other areas of daily life. [. . .] This person can force a reasoning process, but it runs counter to one's bent. *** If anyone has any other questions on this topic, I am sure I can find something in this nifty book (within the limits of fair use ) to help.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now