Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

MissScripture
Posted (edited)

I'm really confused. It may just be that our language is very ambiguous at times, but at one point it was explained to me that hatred and love are not opposites, because love is a choice and hatred is a feeling. Feeling hate is like feeling cold, you cannot change that fact. You do not, however, need to act on the feeling and that is where the problem comes in, it is the fruit of the feeling, not the feeling itself that is bad. So, you can feel hate for someone, but you must still treat them with kindness and respect. However, today, at Mass they talked about how one cannot hate his brother and say that he loves God. Was what I was told originally wrong, or is this an issue of language inhibiting understanding?

Edited by MissScripture
Posted

personally..I think people choose to hate also. We can choose to not hate. Maybe at times we can't stop the feeling of hate towards people, if we haven't forgiven them for something...that made us have the feelings of hate towards them. So, if you forgive them..I think the feeling of hate would go away on it's own.

God calls us to always forgive.

Love and Hate are feelings..but we have control over both of them, I believe. I don't think it's enough to act nice to someone or kind to them but then still hate them inside. Hate comes from different things...hurt, jealousy...I can't think of anything else right now. But, we aren't supposed to be jealous, we're supposed to love. And we may get hurt from someone but we're supposed to forgive. I think maybe the feeling of hate may seem like we don't have control over it...if you don't go deeper and ask why is it you hate them..then deal with what it is that caused the hate. So, then the hate can just go away and you can live with and out of love towards that person.

I'm not sure all that made sense, sorry if not all of it did. I think that maybe what you were originally taught was incorrect. Atleast I don't think I agree with it... those are just my thoughts on it. :)

Posted

It's just a problem with language. The terms love and hate are not precisely defined or consistently used, and even if one person (or group) define and use them in a particular way, that doesn't mean everyone else will understand and agree to that useage.

It gets even worse when you start trying to understand translations from other languages, like in scripture :ohno:.

IMO, the word "love" can describe both the feeling and the action, and also "hate" can describe both feeling and action. For example: a sociopath acts very hatefully, but they have no emotions over the matter.

As Christians, we're interested in the action part -- which we can control -- and less concerned with feelings, since we don't have as much influence over those. I think in the passage you're describing, both love and hate are actions. If you're doing hateful things to your brother, you are not loving God... regardless of what you feel or say.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

The greek is so much better for this. Love the feeling can be likened in greek to eros. Love the choice is more of an agape. But both words, very different, in english are still tranlated to love.

As for hate, yeah, its both a feeling and a choice. You may feel a hatred for someone, but its a choice to hate them. Same with love. You love a boyfriend, but then you must also choose to love them... cause the feeling doesnt last forever.

So yeah... you had some bad teaching. Listen to the guy in Mass.

Noel's angel
Posted

A feeling of anger towards another person is not wrong in itself-even Jesus got angry, but His was righteous anger. It is how we choose to deal with the feeling of anger that determins if it is wrong or not. Jesus felt that the best way to deal with the situation in the temple was to knock over the stalls etc. so it depends really on the situation and who the person is, because you have to react differently to different people. If you dismiss the feeling of anger, then you find you can't recognise it and you keep it within yourself, then it is only yourself that you are hurting.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

On anger in general, I once heard a sermon from a Presbytyrian minister. Basically, getting angry is not sinful, but harboring the anger and staying angry deliberately destroys your soul. We cant nurse anger. Thats hate.

Noel's angel
Posted

Yes, keeping anger locked in cause hurt within and it builds up into something worse. The feeling is not inherently bad, it is the decision on the action you wish to take that decides whether something is good or bad.

Posted

Apathy is the opposite vice of Charity of (Love).

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

thats something I never understood. care to explain for me Theo?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

As I christian I am ordered to love everyone. This does not mean I have to generate a "love" emotion toward them, but I do have to treat them as kindly and decently as I would treat myself. This is a choice we are called to make everyday.
We are also called not to hate other people. Even if we have terrible feelings about a person's actions, we cannot choose to return hatred in response. We are still required to treat them kindly and decently and forgive any trespasses against us. This forgiveness might take a lifetime to accomplish AND have to be down again and again, but its still required. Feelings come and go, but our actions in response to them is a choice.
Anger is not to be confused with hatred, its another emotion that comes and goes. Anger is a response to a specific situation and a challenge for us to choose a christian response.

Mary-Kathryn
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='966113' date='Apr 30 2006, 04:36 PM']
A feeling of anger towards another person is not wrong in itself-even Jesus got angry, but His was righteous anger. It is how we choose to deal with the feeling of anger that determins if it is wrong or not. Jesus felt that the best way to deal with the situation in the temple was to knock over the stalls etc. so it depends really on the situation and who the person is, because you have to react differently to different people. If you dismiss the feeling of anger, then you find you can't recognise it and you keep it within yourself, then it is only yourself that you are hurting.
[/quote]

I think your view of this [I didn't read everyone's post--just a couple] is one I agree with. There are situations that are forced upon victims [home invasion, assaults, rape and on and on] where hate is the natural feeling. They didn't choose to be victims, the choice belonged only to the criminal. Fury, hatred, andanger are a part of the healing process. And Noel you are right, if all these "negative" feelings are bottled up, then the person carrying them is the one who hurts the most.

Noel's angel
Posted

It didn't come from me, you can thank my priest for that one :)

It was strange really, we were just having a conversation about this very thing a few hours ago.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

[quote name='Mary-Kathryn' post='966130' date='Apr 30 2006, 03:05 PM']
I think your view of this [I didn't read everyone's post--just a couple] is one I agree with. There are situations that are forced upon victims [home invasion, assaults, rape and on and on] where hate is the natural feeling. They didn't choose to be victims, the choice belonged only to the criminal. Fury, hatred, andanger are a part of the healing process. And Noel you are right, if all these "negative" feelings are bottled up, then the person carrying them is the one who hurts the most.
[/quote]

I thought the process was denial, anger, depression, acceptance. Hate doesnt fall in that model of the healing process... it seems counterproductive from a theological/psychological perspective. Anger yes, hatred not so much.

Noel's angel
Posted

Hate is "a feeling of dislike so strong that it demands action", it is the action you choose which makes the difference.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Anger is a feeling, hatred is a choice.

Chica_Catolica
Posted

Going off what Theoketos said, apathy is the opposite of love. Love, hate, whatever else, they are all feelings, strong feelings of one way or the other. Apathy is the complete lack of feelings, none at all. If you love someone with all your heart, you have many feelings for him or her, right? If you hate someone with all your heart, you still have many feelings for them, right? Granted, the ways in which the feelings are channeled are different, but feelings do still exist. If you're apathetic towards someone, you have no feelings at all for them. Having strong feelings for someone (love) is the opposite of having no feelings at all (apathy). By this reasoning (as a little side note to ponder), is apathy the antithesis of hate as well? (Many apologies to Theoketos if my explanation is not at all related to what was meant by originally saying that apathy is the opposite of love! It's just my interpretation.)

Moving onto the original post, I have to disagree about love being a choice and hate being a feeling and that's why they're not opposites. I think that they are both feelings. Sometimes, you love someone, and you can't pinpoint making the conscious decision for this love. You make choices regarding these feelings for love and hate, usually in the form of affection and violence (maybe?), respectively. Actions, you choose; feelings, you do not.

Although I must say that I certainly think it is nobler to treat those you hate with kindness and compassion and that it is something we should aspire to do anyway, we should not hate. True, hate is a feeling that we often cannot control. We often find ourselves thinking horrible thoughts towards others when we know we should not. I do not think it is acceptable to just put on the facade of loving everyone and treating everyone kindly when we do not, and I think that makes us hypocritical to appear to feel one way when in fact we feel quite differently. While we cannot control how we feel (we can certainly control our actions), God can. To get over negative feelings such as hate, we can pray to God to remove and overcome such feelings. As Christians, that's what we should want to do. If we are happy with harboring hateful feelings (whether or not we act on them), then there is something wrong with us and our walk with God. We should all have the desire to overcome hate, and with the help of God, we can. With hatred, I think the aspects we choose are only the resulting actions of the hatred and the desire to do nothing about these feelings while the actual feelings themselves aren't necessarily a choice. To keep the feelings is, however, a choice. Who did Jesus hate? Are we not supposed to be like Him?

Cow of Shame
Posted

Except we are told that if we don't love God, we hate him. Even people who are apathetic towards God actually hate him.

Mary-Kathryn
Posted

[quote name='blovedwolfofgod' post='966141' date='Apr 30 2006, 05:22 PM']
I thought the process was denial, anger, depression, acceptance. Hate doesnt fall in that model of the healing process... it seems counterproductive from a theological/psychological perspective. Anger yes, hatred not so much.
[/quote]

I think trying to squeeze everyone into one model of healing can be damaging. Each person is unique and brings with them their own set of problems and ways of coping. I think it would only be counter-productive if others expect them not to feel and chastise them for it. Then they stuff it down, feel ashamed, and feel somewhat guilty. Working through the feelings with a counselor is a process. If you hate someone because they have a date with the guy you wanted to go out with...then yes, that feeling is very inappropriate. But to have that feeling of rage/hate towards someone who may have victimized you, then it is a part of the healing process.

~just my .02 ~

St.MGoretti
Posted

Love and hate are two emotions that we as humans have, and sadly love is the one that we are more timid to share. We all need to love and be loved but are afraid of sharing that emotion because we are afraid to get hurt. Hate is an emotion that occurs when we get hurt and we turn that anger into hate, but it is the action that we take towards that person or thing that allows the hate to grow. But we must try to not allow that anger to grow into hate, even though it is natural to do. It is nature that causes us to avoid the things that hurts us thus leading to avoiding the people or things that have hurt us in the past. Even though we avoid these pepole or things we still need to treat them how Christ would treat them. The more we give love the more love we get it in return.

You are right in saying that anger is an emotion and hate is a choice, it is the actions that we take on that emotion that turn it into hatred. I have had some issues with being hurt and it was a priest who had told me that you need to forgive but it may take longer to forget. This is due to the natural process of knowing that something or someone hurts you and trying to avoid such hurt. But again it is the action that we take that allows hate to grow and simply hurts us even more.

phatcatholic
Posted

[b]Hatred[/b]
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07149b.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07149b.htm[/url]

Hatred in general is a vehement aversion entertained by one person for another, or for something more or less identified with that other. Theologians commonly mention two distinct species of this passion.[list]
[*]One ([i]odium[/i] [i]abominationis[/i], or loathing) is that in which the intense dislike is concentrated primarily on the qualities or attributes of a person, and only secondarily, and as it were derivatively, upon the person himself.
[*]The second sort (odium inimicitiae, or hostility) aims directly at the person, indulges a propensity to see what is evil and unlovable in him, feels a fierce satisfaction at anything tending to his discredit, and is keenly desirous that his lot may be an unmixedly hard one, either in general or in this or that specified way.
[/list]This second kind of hatred, as involving a very direct and absolute violation of the precept of charity, is always sinful and may be grievously so. The first-named species of hatred, in so far as it implies the reprobation of what is actually evil, is not a sin and may even represent a virtuous temper of soul. In other words, not only may I, but I even ought to, hate what is contrary to the moral law. Furthermore one may without sin go so far in the detestation of wrongdoing as to wish that which for its perpetrator is a very well-defined evil, yet under another aspect is a much more signal good. For instance, it would be lawful to pray for the death of a perniciously active heresiarch with a view to putting a stop to his ravages among the Christian people. Of course, it is clear that this apparent zeal must not be an excuse for catering to personal spite or party rancour. Still, even when the motive of one's aversion is not impersonal, when, namely, it arises from the damage we may have sustained at the hands of others, we are not guilty of sin unless besides feeling indignation we yield to an aversion unwarranted by the by the hurt we have suffered. This aversion may be grievously or venially sinful in proportion to its excess over that which the injury would justify.

When by any conceivable stretch of human wickedness God Himself is the object of hatred the guilt is appallingly special. If it be that kind of enmity ([i]odium inimicitiae[/i]) which prompts the sinner to loathe God in Himself, to regret the Divine perfections precisely in so far as they belong to God, then the offence committed obtains the undisputed primacy in all the miserable hierarchy of sin. In fact, such an attitude of mind is fairly and adequately described as diabolical; the human will detaches itself immediately from God; in other sins it does so only mediately and by consequence, that is, because of its inordinate use of some creature it is averted from God. To be sure, according to the teaching of St. Thomas (II-II:24:12) and the theologians, any mortal sin carries with it the loss of the habit of supernatural charity, and implies so to speak a sort of virtual and interpretive hatred of God, which, however, is not a separate specific malice to be referred to in confession, but only a circumstance predicable of every grievous sin.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...