Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is it a sin to believe in magic?


Recommended Posts

MichaelFilo
Posted

So, I had a Satanic site in my history and visited it almost daily after going to Phatmass (because one ought to know, right?). Theres so much there, really, and while filling my ears with black metal (which indeed is Satanic, because, well, if they aren't talking about Satan, it is some pagan god(dess)) I came upon a very long list of spells and magicks (magick is the word used by the practitioners of the magic you speak of) thats are to be carried out and how they work within the context of the human body. Indeed, the idea of mana is not a foriegn one from the view of having "chakra" points but before I digress into the specifics (in fact, I'll avoid that, its of little importance) there was a statement made that ought to be clarified immedialty.

[quote]So, in Christianity, perhaps it can be said that the Consecration of the Host is a "magical" act. The priest performs the ritual and by Divine Grace we have the Consecration.[/quote]

The understanding of magick is that one has control over an element, which a priest NEVER does. In fact, a priest does not actual commit the change in the bread, nor does he do anything from his own "powers", but instead by dignity of his office, simply repeating the words of consecration causes the bread to change, but it is a change committed entirely by the Divine.

This is far removed from magick in which a person has some direct control of the force by invoking external forces. Consecration is a Divine action that (if my memory recalls) is claimed by some pagans as being a powerful magick committed by a congregation. It is neither done by priest nor congregation, and this ought to be pointed out, as this is hardly comparable to the evil nature of magic (which is, and always will be, evil because the angels only answer to God's commands, so the other source is the demons, which seek to fool thos who believe they have some dominance or power over them).

God bless,
Mikey

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='MichaelFilo' post='969072' date='May 2 2006, 09:09 PM']
there was a statement made that ought to be clarified immedialty.
The understanding of magick is that one has control over an element, which a priest NEVER does. In fact, a priest does not actual commit the change in the bread, nor does he do anything from his own "powers", but instead by dignity of his office, simply repeating the words of consecration causes the bread to change, but it is a change committed entirely by the Divine.

This is far removed from magick in which a person has some direct control of the force by invoking external forces. Consecration is a Divine action that (if my memory recalls) is claimed by some pagans as being a powerful magick committed by a congregation. It is neither done by priest nor congregation, and this ought to be pointed out, as this is hardly comparable to the evil nature of magic (which is, and always will be, evil because the angels only answer to God's commands, so the other source is the demons, which seek to fool thos who believe they have some dominance or power over them).

God bless,
Mikey
[/quote]
indeed, yes. :mellow: The definition of magic I provided was "an attempt to channel or control" that mana or Grace or whatever. The priest [i]channels[/i] it as the Divine performs the actual "magic". The Consecration could happen without the priest, if God so willed it.

It's a valid comparison and I thought it was clear.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...