Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Serious abuses today at Mass


Recommended Posts

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I will just say this from the start: I am just posting this to record my current experience at the Mass I attended today, and to ask for your opinion.

So, today was my cousin's first communion. What a blessed day! However, I knew before hand that there might be some disappointment in store in terms of the sacredness and solemnity of the day, because I knew that this certain parish wasnt exactly known for its faithfulness to the norms.

Here is the context: This parish is the only Catholic one in the small town of Holmen. Praise God, they have outgrown their building due to such a high membership. However, they seem quite 'protestant', if I may use that term, in their thinking about worship. They call the sanctuary the "worship area", where they have the altar on a slightly raised platform in the middle of the room. The whole place reminds me of a concert hall because they have rows of chairs surrounding the altar, and the altar is a square wooden table. The walls behind it simply have organ pipes, with no crucifix in sight. The tabernacle is in a small side chapel which is only connected to the sanctuary by a door, with no identification that it is a chapel. Even within the chapel, the tabernacle is off to the side.

The 'pews' (chairs) have no kneelers at all. In addition to the "worship space", they have a large gathering area directly in front of the sanctuary, only divided by glass doors. So, all in all, you get the feeling that you are in a community center of sorts, which also functions as a protestant-esque church.

Now, back to today. It started out when we arrived. I was expecting to go into the chapel and pray in quiet because I knew full well that they "worship area" would be very noisy, as it had been other times. However, when I went into the chapel, it was a complete zoo. The first communicants were in there with their parents, and they were running around like maniacs. Now, I understand that they need somewhere to go to prepare, however I would expect that they would altleast be quiet and respectful if they absolutely had to use the chapel.

We proceeded to just sit and wait for the Mass to begin in the 'worship space'. When it came time for the readings, during the responsorial psalm, they had some of the children do a liturgical dance to the response. They even personally thanked them as "children liturgical dancers" in the bulletin. Normally, I think that children doing little singing and dancing things is adorable, but during the Mass.. no way.

During the actual liturgy of the Eucharist, they used glass wine glasses instead of chalices, and wierd looking plates for the Hosts. I know for sure that glass anything is a no-no. I also witnessed a extraordinary Eucharistic minister take a measuring cup of what I am assuming was the precious blood into the back and do something with it. He went into the chapel. I didnt see him come out again. I really do not want to know what he did with it. It couldnt have been anything with receiving because no one was in the chapel.

Post communion, more children did dancing and singing. Then, Mass kind of half ended with announcements and clapping.

I, for one, really did not enjoy the experience. I did kneel during the proper times, and was the only one, even within my family. I also had to fight off the hands of the "hold hands our Father'ers". I really felt bad because I know that half of them are simply following what their Priest tells them, no matter how mistaken he is.

So, after that long winded testimony, I ask for your opinion. Do you think it would be more productive for me to try and talk with the pastors, whom I do not know at all, or to write a letter to the Bishop asking him to please check into the parish? Personally, I believe the letter would be more productive, because this parish is going to be building a new building soon, and if the bishop isnt keyed into things, I dont believe that the new building will be any better than the current. However, I am almost certain that the Bishop knows about these things. I mean, obviously he needs to be aware of any new Churches being built in the diocese. However, I do not think he knows much about the individual abuses going on, seeing as he is one man and is not capeable of seeing what goes on in each individual parish. He relies on the things he is told from people like us.

So, what do you think?

toledo_jesus
Posted

I believe the most productive thing for you to do in that situation is pray for perseverance. I don't think many priests would respond well to being corrected, and the bishop would never see your letter.

persevere!

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='966235' date='Apr 30 2006, 06:24 PM']
I believe the most productive thing for you to do in that situation is pray for perseverance. I don't think many priests would respond well to being corrected, and the bishop would never see your letter.

persevere!
[/quote]
I actually believe that the Bishop would see the letter. My Diocese, the diocese of La Crosse, isnt all that big. And I have personally met the Bishop on more than one occasion, and he is genuinely concerned with the spiritual life of his flock. And with his personality, I know that he reads the letters he receives. This is also evident from the Televised Mass on Sundays on a local channel. Most of the time, he personally celebrates the Mass which is televised. Afterwords, he appears and thanks everyone for their letters of support for the televised Mass and such.

Of course, I will continue to pray either way.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='966239' date='Apr 30 2006, 07:29 PM']
I actually believe that the Bishop would see the letter. My Diocese, the diocese of La Crosse, isnt all that big. And I have personally met the Bishop on more than one occasion, and he is genuinely concerned with the spiritual life of his flock. And with his personality, I know that he reads the letters he receives. This is also evident from the Televised Mass on Sundays on a local channel. Most of the time, he personally celebrates the Mass which is televised. Afterwords, he appears and thanks everyone for their letters of support for the televised Mass and such.

Of course, I will continue to pray either way.
[/quote]
well, if you think the letter will be read by the bishop and not his secretary, then go for it.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='966245' date='Apr 30 2006, 06:33 PM']
well, if you think the letter will be read by the bishop and not his secretary, then go for it.
[/quote]
Well, it's worth a try :)

Resurrexi
Posted

oh, heaven, that Mass sounded hellish.

Posted

reminds me of when I lived in Colorado for a year....all the Catholic churches were so protestant acting...I couldn't stand it.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

i agree. i had to deal with that kind of thing as well once at a confirmation. there was no cross, let alone the required crucifix, the tabernacle off to the side and made of wood, no kneelers...

yeah... no respect for the Eucharist is what I say.

JudgedByGod
Posted

It sounds exactly like the church that our college is affiliated with. I've been praying about what to do about it, but I've been trying to be a good witness. Unfortunately, our bishop knows about this church and even celebrates mass there once in awhile and nothing changes. Hopefully if you write a letter, it'll actually be read by your bishop.

Posted

Great.
So you went to your cousin's first communion with finding what will be wrong foremost in your mind. You weren't disappointed, were you?

And I guess you are a Certified Liturgical Expert as well.

I'm glad the child StThomasMore is able to correctly identify this experience as 'hellish'.

If you are so offended, write a letter to your Bishop. Maybe you should have taken picutures. Hopefully you can get the priest disciplined and maybe even de-frocked.

I'm sure the priest is an idiot and wouldn't learn anything if you deigned to meet with him to set him straight.

I hope you GLARED at the person trying to hold your hand during the Our Father. I'm sure that sends a better message than holding a hand. And you should give your family a good stern talking to about kneeling correctly.

Or maybe you could have looked for the positive of your Cousin recieving the Eucharist instead of scouting out detail for a good self-righteous scandal to share at phatmass. Did you have a chance to have a positive discussion with your cousin without running down his parish? Maybe you could have just sent the bulletin to the Bishop with a letter stating you don't understand and if someone could explain it to you.

thessalonian
Posted

Actually I've written many letters to our archibishop and all but perhaps one I have recieved responses from HIM. And not just thanks for the letter. One caused him to call a pastor and shut down general absolution services. I am in a fairly large diocese. Minneapolis/St Paul. I would highly encourage you to write the letter. I also wrote to a smaller diocese and got a resopnse back from that Bishop. I truly think they are concerned about such things. In that case the priest in one of those liberal parishes (this one would make your skin crawl) gave a sermon that made it quite clear he was encouraging women in the priesthood. I confronted him after mass and he was not receptive to my words so I wrote the Bishop and told him what I had experienced as a visitor to his diocese. The Bishop did not sound impressed.

As a matter of protocol and respect I do think you have the obligation to write a respectful letter or email to the pastor. That is the proper procedure and I don't think it is good if they just get blindsided by the Bishop. So write that letter first. Ask for a response (though, don't say if I don't here from you within x I am going to do Y). If you don't hear back in a resonsable amount of time from the pastor. 2-4 weeks I would say, write the Bishop and tell him what you experienced in his diocese and your feelings about it. Can't gaurantee he will be as resopnsive as what I have experienced. But he may. Prayers of course come first.

Blessings

By the way, while I don't like the hand holding at the our father, that to me is not worth bringing to a Bishop's attention. I can tell you he won't be concerned. In my study the canon and ruberics don't really deal with it. I most definitely would raise the thing about the wine as that needs to be answered for someone by someone. I do think there is something that they have where they can appropriately dispose of such things but generally it should be consumed.

Posted

The Mass is a drama in all its parts - in the introductory rite, the readings and prayers, the homily, the intercessions, the Creed, the presentation of the gifts, the Eucharistic Prayer, the Communion rite, and the dismissal. Precise, hallowed language is the thread that knits these sacred parts together. This means that priests and laity must enact with uniformity the canonically authorized texts and rites. Every part of Mass has an underlying message for any given day, and all parts must be conveyed to the people in as seamless a linguistic way as possible so that the message is perceived as having the stamp of God's Holy Catholic Church. To stamp the Mass with one's own personality, as celebrant or lector or extraordinary minister, is arrogance at best.

All deacons and priests must keep in mind that to transmit the clarity and purity of the Church's message throughout the Mass is a solemn duty. To mislead or falsely persuade any listener is a grave dereliction. Some priests and deacons, in their zeal to communicate their personal opinions on matters of gender, culture, or ecclesiology, produce misinterpretations of Scripture or cause false blessings to be administered to the people of God. To do this is to treat the congregation not as the people of God at their worship but as a captive audience for a private agenda.

The Catholic Faith, as expressed in the liturgy, requires that we adhere to canonically approved forms. Implicit is the recognition that as Catholics at worship we are not simply individuals expressing our various individual convictions. We are - both clergy and laity - a chorus of voices proclaiming liturgical and doctrinal harmony. Liturgy has a twofold quality, an outside and an inside; there is visible, sometimes tangible, action; and there is invisible, spiritual action. They are connected, and both are real, both are needed. And by the same token, our religious actions are social as well as personal. Our task at Mass is not to promote our own ideological eccentricities or project our own image but to soak up and then promulgate the Faith.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='jasJis' post='966307' date='Apr 30 2006, 07:52 PM']
Great.
So you went to your cousin's first communion with finding what will be wrong foremost in your mind. You weren't disappointed, were you?

And I guess you are a Certified Liturgical Expert as well.

I'm glad the child StThomasMore is able to correctly identify this experience as 'hellish'.

If you are so offended, write a letter to your Bishop. Maybe you should have taken picutures. Hopefully you can get the priest disciplined and maybe even de-frocked.

I'm sure the priest is an idiot and wouldn't learn anything if you deigned to meet with him to set him straight.

I hope you GLARED at the person trying to hold your hand during the Our Father. I'm sure that sends a better message than holding a hand. And you should give your family a good stern talking to about kneeling correctly.

Or maybe you could have looked for the positive of your Cousin recieving the Eucharist instead of scouting out detail for a good self-righteous scandal to share at phatmass. Did you have a chance to have a positive discussion with your cousin without running down his parish? Maybe you could have just sent the bulletin to the Bishop with a letter stating you don't understand and if someone could explain it to you.
[/quote]
I'll take that with a grain of salt, but also take it to heart. Perhaps I forgot to mention the fact that I am completely overjoyed that he finally received Jesus.

But the fact of the matter is, these things harm the integrity of the faith. When the Mass is reduced to a 'concert' and a happy gathering time, what purpose does the Mass even serve anymore? Certainly not to worship Christ, the Son of the Living God, in the flesh.

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='966400' date='Apr 30 2006, 08:31 PM']
I'll take that with a grain of salt, but also take it to heart. Perhaps I forgot to mention the fact that I am completely overjoyed that he finally received Jesus.

But the fact of the matter is, these things harm the integrity of the faith. When the Mass is reduced to a 'concert' and a happy gathering time, what purpose does the Mass even serve anymore? Certainly not to worship Christ, the Son of the Living God, in the flesh.
[/quote]Take it with salt.

What's the point of Mass if it ain't done right? We need copies of the GIRM in the pews too. I don't think I've ever been to a 'correct Mass'.

I'm stumped that all the Catholics at PhatMass know what's right but none of the priests or parishes I've attended can do it right. And a priest isn't supposed to say Mass if he's has an unconfessed Mortal Sin. Talk about Invalid and Illicit. We might as well go to a Protestant service where at least they don't have rubrics and you can assume it's sincere since all they're going to do is preach.

missionseeker
Posted

I think that some of it may be what I call Small Town Syndrome.

Basically the people in them become cliquish. They forget that there's more to the world than their little part. They forget that being Catholic isn't about them. They forget that there's a higher authority than them.
This is why a preist I know is ALWAYS telling our bishop "Send some good, solid preists to the rural areas and leave they wacko's in big cities where people have other churches to choose from" (Of course the fact that there are wacko's is kind of unsettling) At least that is part of what happened at my old parish.

The other thing is, well, ignorance. Maybe you could get some pamphlets by real good orthodox theologians and leave them there hehe.

Posted

jasJis,

a priest may say mass with an unconfessed mortal sin and receive communion. first, the validity of the mass does not depend on the personal holiness of the priest; and second, the Church out of the necessity of priests dispenses him from the necessity to abstain from holy communion while in mortal sin because it is necessary for a valid mass that the priest receive. it is not sacrilidge, or at least not culpable sacrilidge, for a priest to receive the Eucharist out of necessity. for the personal spiritual health of the priest, he ought to make the intention of going to confession as soon as possible when he says mass while conscious of a mortal sin.

also, there is widespread liturgical abuses in the Church today because of a widespread pride but also a widespread ignorance about the intentions of the liturgical reform. the fact that so many liturgies consist of so many illicit actions is sad, but it is no reason to dispair. it is clearly a temporal phenomenon that there be such widespread serious abuses in the liturgy. if you've never been to a liturgy done correctly, then may I suggest you go to a Latin Indult Mass? they generally do them correctly or at least do their best. but the widespread incorrectness of many liturgies is a result of (or a cause of depending on how you look at it) widespread misunderstandings about the faith. just because only a handful of the laity still look to Rome's guidance on liturgical matters doesn't mean it's not still important; not because we think holding hands at the our father is going to spread liberal-liturgist-cooties but because we want to help the majority of people reconnect with authentic understandings of the Faith that have been lost, not that they were never there in a widespread fashion because they certainly were, they have been lost in a ripple in time which will be to the history books about a paragraph at most in Church history.

Posted

I attended Mass at a parish I'd never been to on Saturday (I had to go to Confession, and I'd missed the opportunity at my home parish... I went to Confession around 4 and the parish was offering Mass at 5, so I stuck around). It turned out to be a First Communion Mass for a few children. When it came time for the old priest's homily, he came down from the pulpit and walked up and down the center aisle to engage the children -- no problem. He was basically talking to them about the Eucharist, how it isn't ordinary food, etc. Then he asked a little girl, maybe 6 or 7, in the audience, "But you don't eat the Body of Christ at home, do you?" She said, "No." To which he replied, "Well, at least not until you're ordained, right? Do you think that will happen?" She said rather forcefully, "No!" (Which I nearly applauded!) To which father smiled and replied, "Well..." and turned his attention to another child.

I was pretty disgusted with this. These are young children making their First Communion. Why did he have to go there? There was a young priest visiting from Africa (who heard my Confession) assisting in the Mass and he didn't look amused either.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote]And a priest isn't supposed to say Mass if he's has an unconfessed Mortal Sin. Talk about Invalid and Illicit. We might as well go to a Protestant service where at least they don't have rubrics and you can assume it's sincere since all they're going to do is preach.[/quote]

Unconfessed mortal sins of the priest do not make the Mass invalid. About the only thing I know of is changing the words of the consecration.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='966651' date='May 1 2006, 09:38 AM']
Unconfessed mortal sins of the priest do not make the Mass invalid. About the only thing I know of is changing the words of the consecration.
[/quote]

Correct. The ex opere operato causality of grace of the sacrament of the Eucharist means that the attitude, holiness, or state of grace that the priest may be in does not bare on the validity of a sacrament. The matter and form of the Eucharist are in this case what is most important - if the words were changed, if the priest used deritos and pop instead of bread and wine, etc.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote] the priest used deritos and pop instead of bread and wine, etc[/quote]

Ah, yes, that as well. Aditions such as honey and other things to the bread as well can invalidate.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...