Catholictothecore Posted May 1, 2006 Posted May 1, 2006 I think that this might be a good place to post this, but please treat this touchy subject with respect, those who don't believe it. Cause I think I do. Anybody here read any of the Marian Apparitions of Garabandal and/or Medjugorrie? I know precious little about them, but I fairly certian I believe them. I'm just looking for information on it from those who know more, not to convince anyone who doesn't believe them. Also, let me say up front that I understand it is not neccesary to believe in them, but I do. To me, they juest seem like something God would do. That's my opinion, and I'd like to know more.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 1, 2006 Posted May 1, 2006 I'm fine with the Apparitions approved by the Church. Having been to Medjugorje I am skeptical of it. I haven't heard much about Garabandal, so I can't say much there.
Catholictothecore Posted May 1, 2006 Author Posted May 1, 2006 Garabandal is similar to Mdju...however it's spelled. It teaches quite a few things, but four main points in particular. 1) At some point in the near future, the Church will have seemed to cease existing. It will not have, and the details are fuzzy, but at some point, the devil will have appeared to have won (which we all know he hasn't, isn't, and won't.) 2) at some after that, God will send the Warning. It will be as if all mankind living on earth will experience their personel judgement, seeing it in the sky. It will be terrible, yes, but one of the most dramatic shows of God's mercy, as we will all see the need for repentance, see what is true as we would have after death, but have the chance to repent. This DEFINITLY sounds to me like something God would do. It will not physically hurt anyone, except for those for whom the strain is too much. 3) Within a year of the Warning, a sign will appear at Garabandal that will bring millions of reluctant converts into the Church. It will be permenat, visible to the eye and camera, but not solid. God's reign upon earth will have begun. An outpouting of grace upon all. 4) if the world still does not repent, God's justice will come to those unrepentant. After that, the whole world will be Catholic, and a period of peace will come to all the world. I'm not sure this is an end-of-the-world thing. I believe it's more like Mary fulfilling her Rosary and Scapular promise about one day saving the world through them. And that promise is something the Church has recognized. To those who are wondering why I asked for info, it's because this post represents most of what I know about Garabandal. I know extraordinarily little of Mejugorie.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 1, 2006 Posted May 1, 2006 Medjugorje is tainted with a lot of disobedience issues, etc. I am somewhat skeptical of Garabandal... are you aware if the bishop has spoken regarding the apparition? (have they ceased?)
Catholictothecore Posted May 1, 2006 Author Posted May 1, 2006 [url="http://www.garabandal.com"]The site on Garabandal can be found here. [/url] I'm surprised I hadn't found this site before. Therea are some videa clips and stuff as well. I first heard of it through a the Garabandal Journal, a bimonthly magazine. I recommend it for more answers. I ma subscribe.
jasJis Posted May 1, 2006 Posted May 1, 2006 I feel safer saying this as a non-Catholic. But I never really got the whole Marian Appiration things. They all are frought with such controversy and divisiveness. I have no feelings about them one way or another. If they were proven true, I don't know if they would affect me any different than if they were proven false. They just don't matter to me at all.
Brother Adam Posted May 2, 2006 Posted May 2, 2006 [quote name='jasJis' post='967534' date='May 1 2006, 08:49 PM'] I feel safer saying this as a non-Catholic. But I never really got the whole Marian Appiration things. They all are frought with such controversy and divisiveness. I have no feelings about them one way or another. If they were proven true, I don't know if they would affect me any different than if they were proven false. They just don't matter to me at all. [/quote] I've basically said it as a Catholic.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted May 2, 2006 Posted May 2, 2006 For somebody so into the intellectual side of Catholicism, I actually dig Marian apparitions and mystics and hold them in high esteem. At this point, I do not really believe in the Medjegorje ones.
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted May 2, 2006 Posted May 2, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='967420' date='May 1 2006, 03:32 PM'] Medjugorje is tainted with a lot of disobedience issues, etc. I am somewhat skeptical of Garabandal... are you aware if the bishop has spoken regarding the apparition? (have they ceased?) [/quote] Garabandal has been dissapproved by the Church. The Local Bishop got the visionaries to sign documents stating that they did not experience the apparitions. Maybe they experienced something. But it is clear, that one of the girls involved never experienced anything and was playing along the whole time. I am extremely skeptical of Garabandal. Mejugorje is a very complicated issue. There is a lot of church politics involved. There is a long history of disagreement between the local diocese in the area, and the Franciscans. Basically, the local populace did not trust the diocese, and would only except Franciscans. In many cases the Franciscans were being accused of dividing the people against the Bishop. What is highly disconcerting was when these alleged apparitions took place. They were in a Franciscan parish. So, it was that the apparitions were once again assumed to be some ploy by the Franciscans. I don't mean to sound like i am taking sides. But it is clear that there is a long history of mistrust on both sides. Seeing as how some bishops are against it isnt adequate. Usually these Bishops have more qualm with the Franciscans. But also keep in mind, that Medjugorje has not been officially approved or disapproved by the Church. As for my opinion. I don't know much of the prophecies actually. I am convinced that Garabandal is a malignant mockery of Fatima. Before the children visionaries experienced an apparition of Our Lady, they encountered a beautiful angel. All previous apparitions consisted of Our Lady's immediate appearance. La Sallete, de Rue Bac, Lourdes, and Fatima. Once again, this is my opinion, but i do not believe that that angel was of God. As for Medjugorje i am becoming convinced because of the spiritual and psychological integrity of the visionaries themselves. SHALOM
Josie07 Posted May 2, 2006 Posted May 2, 2006 i'm a tad confused because i'm not excatly sure what is accept by the church and what isn't. I don't want to go and belive in something that isn't true.
phatcatholic Posted May 2, 2006 Posted May 2, 2006 here are two different lists of Church-approved apparitions: [url="http://www.apparitions.org/"]http://www.apparitions.org/[/url] [url="http://www.theotokos.org.uk/pages/approved/approved.html"]http://www.theotokos.org.uk/pages/approved/approved.html[/url]
Catholictothecore Posted May 5, 2006 Author Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' post='968343' date='May 2 2006, 10:16 AM'] Garabandal has been dissapproved by the Church. The Local Bishop got the visionaries to sign documents stating that they did not experience the apparitions. Maybe they experienced something. But it is clear, that one of the girls involved never experienced anything and was playing along the whole time. I am extremely skeptical of Garabandal. Mejugorje is a very complicated issue. There is a lot of church politics involved. There is a long history of disagreement between the local diocese in the area, and the Franciscans. Basically, the local populace did not trust the diocese, and would only except Franciscans. In many cases the Franciscans were being accused of dividing the people against the Bishop. What is highly disconcerting was when these alleged apparitions took place. They were in a Franciscan parish. So, it was that the apparitions were once again assumed to be some ploy by the Franciscans. I don't mean to sound like i am taking sides. But it is clear that there is a long history of mistrust on both sides. Seeing as how some bishops are against it isnt adequate. Usually these Bishops have more qualm with the Franciscans. But also keep in mind, that Medjugorje has not been officially approved or disapproved by the Church. As for my opinion. I don't know much of the prophecies actually. I am convinced that Garabandal is a malignant mockery of Fatima. Before the children visionaries experienced an apparition of Our Lady, they encountered a beautiful angel. All previous apparitions consisted of Our Lady's immediate appearance. La Sallete, de Rue Bac, Lourdes, and Fatima. Once again, this is my opinion, but i do not believe that that angel was of God. As for Medjugorje i am becoming convinced because of the spiritual and psychological integrity of the visionaries themselves. SHALOM [/quote] Does the fact that one of the visions said that they would later retract their claism mean anything? Not every bishop is a saint. What about what Pope St. Gregary the Great said about private revelations, that it is better and be wrong then not believe and be wrong. That's where I kinda came from. I could be wrong, but I'd rather believe then not. It helps me live the way I want to, believe it or not. I think I'm a better person for it, too.
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 The Garabandal Visionaries feel no obligation in obeying their local Bishop. That is dangerous to the faithful. How can we trust that their are not leading the faithful into error? SHALOM
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now