Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

So I played this awesome "review game" with my CCD kids (7th grade). We played it in the Fall and they did pretty well, so I was excited and really impressed.

Today, however, it was not the same story. They could hardly remember things we went over last week. :ohno: I was SO crushed. I kept trying to tell myself, at least they remembered some things (which is better than absolutely nothing)... but now I feel like this whole year was a waste. I had such high hopes that I would work super hard at reforming the parish, even if it was just through my one CCD class. But now that they don't really remember much of anything, I'm feeling a lot let down and just plain disappointed. I hoped that they would remember at least a little bit more. :sadder:

Does anyone have any ideas for next year? What can I do to help them remember more stuff?

My plan for our last class is to talk about Confirmation prep stuff and then I'm going to hand out a test/survey. The test portion to see what they've actually retained on their own (really basic simple questions) and then just to ask them about the class... what they liked, what they didn't like. What should I do next year? What should I leave out? etc. They'll be pretty honest I'm sure since we have a good trust relationship going and they'll be leaving anyway (and I won't make them put their names on it... they think that solves everything. :lol: )

But any other ideas?

Brother Adam
Posted (edited)

Buy "The Mystery We Proclaim" by Msgr Kelly. It is the foundation to the methods program at FUS and it works.

That's the best I can give you until I complete Flyfree Catholic Forums which will be dedicated to making Catholic Education (Catechesis) work well based on what I have learned here.

[url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/087973597X/sr=8-1/qid=1146535869/ref=sr_1_1/102-9701335-3846555?%5Fencoding=UTF8"]Link to Amazon.com[/url]

[img]http://images.amazon.com/images/P/087973597X.01._BO2,204,203,200_PIsitb-dp-500-arrow,TopRight,45,-64_AA240_SH20_SCLZZZZZZZ_.jpg[/img]

Edited by Brother Adam
Posted

prayers for u and ur ccd class

its not ur fault

its hard to get kids serious about God when theres so many voices telling them otherwise

Posted

I've said it before and I'll say it again:

Just because you can't remember what your mother fed you for lunch as a child, doesn't mean that the food didn't nourish you.

Don't worry about what they "remember" worry about the nourishment ;)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Did you get the parents to try to bring up the topics at home?

Don't despair...you said yourself that it was a parish in need of reform...the kids probably didn't feel much enthusiasm because they weren't having what they learned reinforced at home. It may take a few years to really change things.

In the meantime, I noticed you said, "I had such high hopes that I would work super hard at reforming the parish, even if it was just through my one CCD class." Maybe I'm looking too much into it, but if you are trying to put the onus on yourself, then you're approaching it all wrong. Remember that catechesis is about bringing people into intimate communion with Christ, not just teaching them lots of facts about the faith. You must show them that Christ is a Person and you must let Christ be the one who teaches through you or else it will fail. There are no exceptions to this rule. If this is what you did, then you have no reason to feel sorry for yourself, because you did what you were supposed to do and it just didn't work out...if that's the case, it's in God's hands...you just keep on going and keep trying to bring them into ever deeper communion. If you didn't do this, then start doing it. Pray for your students, pray with your students, let them see you pray, let them see you live the faith, not in a show-off way, but in a humble and honest way, as I know you're capable. Be like Christ for them. Finally, in the words of St. Padre Pio, "pray, hope, and don't worry."

Balthazor
Posted

Give them pretzels as rewards........

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I can't even get the parents to take their kids to Mass... one of them was supposed to be "homeschooled" for 3 months after he made the basketball team, and I printed off extra copies of my lesson plans for his mom and gave her all my contact information... and when he came back.. she hadn't ever done anything with him. I'm trying to see if I can get him held back.. he'll be mad. But I think his mother needs to know that 3 months is a lot of time he missed out, and it was her responsibility to keep up catechesis. But it's not going to happen because I'm the 21 year-old idealistic college kid.

I know that I can't make the kids all remember and learn, and take initiative. But I knew that of the catechesis in my parish, I had control over this one small aspect of it and wanted to put everything I could into it... and I'm just disappointed that it didn't turn out better.

I wasn't expecting them all to become mini-apologists, ready for confirmation, and preparing to join the convent/enter the seminary. I just wanted them all to take a little more responsibility and seriously consider their faith. I encouraged them to ask lots of questions, and to not be afraid to search for truth... and we got "off-topic" a lot discussing why women can't be priests, the da-vinci code, gay marriage and other contemporary issues.

Most of them are still viewing next year (their Confirmation) as "graduation" from learning about the faith, and going to Church. They just don't get it.

Whoever the next DRE is may possibly get a letter of some suggestions for the parish from me... lol. I'm so serious-- when I become a DRE Confirmation will not be the end of Catechesis (and I'll put the initiation Sacraments back in order... baptism, confirmation, eucharist), and kids definitely won't be without formal catechesis during high school (around here, 8th grade is confirmation and the end of formal catechesis). But all that is potentially a few years away.

HomeTeamFamily
Posted

if they left the party on their own, thats different than you kicking them out

they may remember stuff, just not necessairly in the format you set up to see if they did or not

im sure that some of the stuff stuck, dont get down on yourself

im sure anyone in youth education/ministry has felt the same, i know i have

Posted

honestly, you do'nt know how it turned out. They might remember a lot more than you think and just didn't want to embarass themselves in front of the other kids or something.

You are planting seeds as well. Nurtured by prayers they will grow and can change the lives of those students. Give God time to work.

If you did your best then leave it in his hands. God knows what he is doing. :)

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

My kids couldn't remember the 1st 3 kings of Israel... but they could remember things, which I was very happy with. Even though we did reveiw the 3 kings at least 10 times... lol

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='967749' date='May 1 2006, 08:56 PM']
I can't even get the parents to take their kids to Mass... one of them was supposed to be "homeschooled" for 3 months after he made the basketball team, and I printed off extra copies of my lesson plans for his mom and gave her all my contact information... and when he came back.. she hadn't ever done anything with him. I'm trying to see if I can get him held back.. he'll be mad. But I think his mother needs to know that 3 months is a lot of time he missed out, and it was her responsibility to keep up catechesis. But it's not going to happen because I'm the 21 year-old idealistic college kid.

I know that I can't make the kids all remember and learn, and take initiative. But I knew that of the catechesis in my parish, I had control over this one small aspect of it and wanted to put everything I could into it... and I'm just disappointed that it didn't turn out better.

I wasn't expecting them all to become mini-apologists, ready for confirmation, and preparing to join the convent/enter the seminary. I just wanted them all to take a little more responsibility and seriously consider their faith. I encouraged them to ask lots of questions, and to not be afraid to search for truth... and we got "off-topic" a lot discussing why women can't be priests, the da-vinci code, gay marriage and other contemporary issues.

Most of them are still viewing next year (their Confirmation) as "graduation" from learning about the faith, and going to Church. They just don't get it.

Whoever the next DRE is may possibly get a letter of some suggestions for the parish from me... lol. I'm so serious-- when I become a DRE Confirmation will not be the end of Catechesis (and I'll put the initiation Sacraments back in order... baptism, confirmation, eucharist), and kids definitely won't be without formal catechesis during high school (around here, 8th grade is confirmation and the end of formal catechesis). But all that is potentially a few years away.
[/quote]

You won't be putting much back in order if you think like that. It tends to take a good bishop (since he is the one that has to do it.)

I don't want to sound harsh, but rather to encourage you in another way. The greatest gift that you can give them is a hunger for the truth and the ability to find it. Learning isn't about facts, it is about understanding the basics so that you can go find the details.

Catechesis isn't about what we can do for others, but rather what God can teach them.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Sorry if someone said this already. I'm too tired to read the whole thread... Don't be discouraged. Much of teaching is providing "hooks" for them to build on. Yeah, they didn't remember when you played that game (and that's a drag-- That happens to me WAY more often with my kids than I care to admit), but you've given them hooks on which to hang more knowledge. When something comes up again, they will remember that they heard that somewhere.... And that will go on that hook. Eventually, it sinks in. If they don't go to church or never go to another CCD class, that's not your fault... just keep praying for them.

Posted

Take my advice for whith a grain of salt, considering who's it coming from...

I taught Confirmation class for 4 or 5 years. Think for a minute of what you're teaching, and what you've learned in school.

Let's look at math. How many of you know how to add, subtract, multiply, and divide? All of us probably do since we use it everyday. How many of us took calculus, have been out of school for more than 4 years, and still remember how to use sines, cosines, and tangents? Very few of us probably do, and those that do, are more likely to use that knowledge regularly. The huge majority of people only use relevant information, all else is filed away and eventually forgotten. Now apply that lesson to what and how you are teaching in your CCD class.

If the CCD program is directed toward teaching rules and stuff that can't be applied and utilized in everyday life, that information is filed away and forgotten as not relevant. What's the point of knowing which Sacraments are Healing Sacraments if the students don't know how to look in their lives and see when they need healing? What's the point of knowing when you're sick if you don't also know when your healthy? How healthy is being a freak about illness so that you are always examining yourself looking for disease?

CCD class probably does not apply to or is useful in Real Life. Faith is a living thing, or a journey. It's not a score card of how well we make it through the week with breaking the least amount of rules. Going to Mass or a Church Service isn't just about fulfilling your obligation, or just recieving your grace quota for the week. What do you do with it?

A good example is a glass of milk and Hershey's syrup. We're the milk, grace is the syrup. Christian religion teacher "A" put's in 5 squirts, we walk away, sip, and it still takes like plain milk. Christian religion teacher "B" put's in 1 squirt and stirs it up. For arguemnt's sake, let's say they only stir the top, and leave the bottom alone. YOu sip, like what you taste, and go back for more.

That's the example of Faith without Works or with Works. That's the example of talents invested, or buried to preserve them.

Kids will tell you what their questions are. Be an adult, stay in control, but let your class tell you what their religion questions and needs are. Then you can tell them how, when, and where the Church may supply the answers or fufill their needs. God's the answer, the Church is only part of the solution.

Mary-Kathryn
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='967683' date='May 1 2006, 09:01 PM']
So I played this awesome "review game" with my CCD kids (7th grade). We played it in the Fall and they did pretty well, so I was excited and really impressed.

Today, however, it was not the same story. They could hardly remember things we went over last week. :ohno: I was SO crushed. I kept trying to tell myself, at least they remembered some things (which is better than absolutely nothing)... but now I feel like this whole year was a waste. I had such high hopes that I would work super hard at reforming the parish, even if it was just through my one CCD class. But now that they don't really remember much of anything, I'm feeling a lot let down and just plain disappointed. I hoped that they would remember at least a little bit more. :sadder:

Does anyone have any ideas for next year? What can I do to help them remember more stuff?

My plan for our last class is to talk about Confirmation prep stuff and then I'm going to hand out a test/survey. The test portion to see what they've actually retained on their own (really basic simple questions) and then just to ask them about the class... what they liked, what they didn't like. What should I do next year? What should I leave out? etc. They'll be pretty honest I'm sure since we have a good trust relationship going and they'll be leaving anyway (and I won't make them put their names on it... they think that solves everything. :lol: )

But any other ideas?
[/quote]

Here's my take on CCD...When my children get to CCD classes [on a weeknight] they are already exhausted. This state has set very high standards for school children, so the kids are facing a mound of homework when they get home...more stress. This year, exams are being done for CCD which didn't exactly thrill the kids...more pressure and more studying....in between all the other homework they have.

Now, before anyone starts jumping up and down saying my children shouldn't view schoolwork and the faith/ CCD on the same level...remember they are *kids* Do they remember everything taught in CCD? No. Do they ask questions at home? Yes. Do they do their CCD homework? Yes...with alot of nudging from Mom. ^_^

My one complaint is that the exams tend to have a few questions way over their heads at times. I think all CCD teachers need to remember that CCD is not a college level course.

So don't despair that the kids don't remember it all. They are tired, it's nearing summer and they are burnt out, and like every other kids this time of year, they want to be done.

What I would urge CCD teachers to remember is this: It is good that you step up to volunteer, since teachers are always lacking. Just know that many families struggle just to get there weekly.

thessalonian
Posted

Even as adults we don't retain alot of what we learn. At least not in immediate memory. (see short article below). Yet I find that when I go back to things I have learned they are much easier the second time. Don't sweat it.

[url="http://uwacadweb.uwyo.edu/lrn/ForStudents/Success/memory.htm"]http://uwacadweb.uwyo.edu/lrn/ForStudents/Success/memory.htm[/url]

Developing Memory and Memory Skills

We forget what we learn very quickly. A day after a lesson if we have done nothing with the information we learned then and didn't think about it again, read it again, etc. we will have lost 50%-80% of what we learned. Seven days later, we remember even less, and by day 30, we retain about 2%-3% of the original! After each lesson we need to revise and practice new material so that we can remember it and so do projects, tests and exams easily with the knowledge we already have.

We remember things much better if we go over them very soon after we first learned them. On the same day we get the information, if we spend ten minutes reviewing, we will remember almost all we learnt. A week later, if we take 5 minutes to "reactivate" the same material, we can still retain almost 100%. By day 30, our brains will only need 2-4 minutes to give us the feedback, "Yup, I know that. Got it."
Take notes to increase your awareness of how you create meanings when you read and write. Jot down your thoughts in the margins while you're reading and writing. Express yourself freely, without trying for correct sentence structure, spelling, or punctuation. No one will see these notes but you.

Posted

Care to expound on what you mean by the educational philosophy of St. John Bosco?

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='967698' date='May 1 2006, 08:25 PM']
I've said it before and I'll say it again:

Just because you can't remember what your mother fed you for lunch as a child, doesn't mean that the food didn't nourish you.

Don't worry about what they "remember" worry about the nourishment ;)
[/quote]
what prose said...i totally concur

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Kristen' post='968144' date='May 2 2006, 08:54 AM']
Care to expound on what you mean by the educational philosophy of St. John Bosco?
[/quote]
Come to Franciscan University.

Brother Adam
Posted

Or read the book:

[url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0899440509/sr=8-1/qid=1146589175/ref=sr_1_1/103-5775889-3824654?%5Fencoding=UTF8"]http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/089944050...5Fencoding=UTF8[/url]

morostheos
Posted

I thought I'd share something from my morning meditation yesterday that gave me insight in a similar situation:

"No fighter is more divine than one who can achieve victory through defeat." - Hans urs von Balthasar

Take solace in the fact that Christ can achieve victory through any defeat, including our apostolic works that we consider to be failures. Just because you don't see them doesn't mean there aren't fruits! :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...