Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Does anyone else really want to pray, go to God, ask Him to help pray because we "do not know how to pray," and begin, say, a rosary, only to struggle the whole time even to keep your mind on God? What about when you say the Our Father or Hail Mary and repeat it again and again because every single time you say it, you didn't put any thought or your heart into it, and it's like when you read and read again the same line because even though you said the words, you don't know what was said? Does anyone know the spiritual cure for this? Sometimes, but rarely, I get great times of prayer where I go away knowing that I've been with God and that He's just given me blessings. Usually, though, I pray and feel nothing...and it's not that I'm going for feelings, but if God is interested in our spiritual growth (and I don't doubt that He is), then why doesn't He help us to grow when we approach asking Him to help us and we make an effort to be with Him...or are we simply not able to see what growth we make because God wants us to stay humble and keep trying to go deeper? What is it? We're all so horrible when it comes to prayer and God seems so distant, even when we ask Him to come and be with us.
jasJis Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Raph. YES. Often I don't percieve any sort of communication with God if I'm 'praying' some set prayer. Other times, it's great and I discern a 2 way conversation. Prayer is communication. Sometimes it's formal, sometimes not. Sometimes it's us talking, sometimes it us just listening. I HIGHLY recommend you getting 'Prayer: The Great Conversation' by Peter Kreeft (Ignatius Press). It's an interesting read as it's a conversation between Chris and Sal. (a play on Christ and Salvation) In Galileo's time, topics would be discussed in a book by writing a conversation (actually that's partly what got Galileo in trouble, but I digress). It also follows a development of questions kinda like the Summa. In fact, since it's about the 3rd time this book has come up in the last week, I think I'll read it again.
Brother Adam Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 How about this: Nick will post the links, I'll post the books. The Art of Praying by Romano Guardini, especially chapter 5 (Inward or Contemplative Prayer) and Chapter 8 (Prayer in Times of Incapacity) Then I would read: Spiritual Combat Revisited by Jonathan Robinson of the Oratory, especially chapters 7 (Prayer as a weapon), and 9 (The Practice of Prayer). I have both and would be happy to allow you to borrow them. If nothing else I would read Chapter 8 of Guardini's text. "When Satan cuts lines between you and home base, in this war like any war, you are in serious trouble."
jezic Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 to some extent it is normal to feel like this. The important thing is to realize that you are doing your best and place it in God's hands. He knows your heart and your desire. That is the important part. Besides prayer is only accomplished in part on our end, God controls everything else.
MichaelFilo Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 If your prayers are not a two way conversation than there is something blocking the signal; or it maybe "dry spells of prayer" which are often rewarded with a fulfilling spiritual life after one endures them. It's always important to realize, I believe, that when one talks to God, it ought not to be so much requests, but conversation, and while the Pater Noster and the Ave Maria are very awesome prayers, they are prayers of praise and request. While very approrpiate for all occasions, one must also enter into conversation during prayer, a give and take of sorts. Many of the saints seemed to talk with Jesus and felt as if they were responded to much like as if they were to talk with anyone else. So yes, as everyone has said, conversation. God bless, Mikey
Jaime Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Part of the problem is that we are getting waaaaaaaaaay to much information in our lives. We get more information bombarded at us all the time. Think about this question. How much time do you have (or can you afford to have being in college) where you are alone and not reading, on computer, on a cell phone, watching tv, listening to music, etc. For most of us its minutes a week. The problem with getting so much information is that we don't process it all, but our minds try to. So when we pray, (trans: not taking in information) our minds are still trying to process and decompress. That is why we get random thoughts that enter prayer. That's one of the reasons we get distracted. What can help is to take 10-15 minutes to not do anything prior to a rosary. Take some deep breaths slowly and allow yourself to decompress prior to prayer.
phatcatholic Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='968974' date='May 2 2006, 08:21 PM'] How about this: Nick will post the links, I'll post the books. [/quote] sounds like a plan [b]--[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP2SALVI.HTM"][i]Salvifici Doloris[/i] (On the Christian Meaning of Human Suffering)[/url] --[url="http://www.catholicdoors.com/courses/howtopray.htm"]How to Pray[/url] --[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/most/getchap.cfm?worknum=232&chapNum=23"]Mental Prayer[/url] --[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/Prayer/TRINITAR.HTM"]The Art of Trinitarian Prayer[/url] --[url="http://www.envoymagazine.com/backissues/article.asp?ID=152"]Trials and Temptations[/url] --[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/SPIRIT/MENTAL.TXT"]Progress Through Mental Prayer[/url][/b] i hope those help pax christi, phatcatholic
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 3, 2006 Author Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='969185' date='May 2 2006, 10:29 PM'] Part of the problem is that we are getting waaaaaaaaaay to much information in our lives. We get more information bombarded at us all the time. Think about this question. How much time do you have (or can you afford to have being in college) where you are alone and not reading, on computer, on a cell phone, watching tv, listening to music, etc. For most of us its minutes a week. The problem with getting so much information is that we don't process it all, but our minds try to. So when we pray, (trans: not taking in information) our minds are still trying to process and decompress. That is why we get random thoughts that enter prayer. That's one of the reasons we get distracted. What can help is to take 10-15 minutes to not do anything prior to a rosary. Take some deep breaths slowly and allow yourself to decompress prior to prayer. [/quote] Yes, distraction is probably the biggest problem. Adam, I have Spiritual Combat Revisited (or rather, Travis has it ) I think the problem largely has to do with the false understanding of consciousness (a Cartesian understanding) with which I've been raised...I feel that if I do not have every word consciously thought out with full consent of the will, or that I do not have the presence of God consciously on my mind, then it is not a prayer. Of course, I realize that this is a misguided thought. It is beyond human ability to pay attention to every word of a prayer, let alone to hold God in our minds. I recognize that this obsession (which I blame on my OCD) is a distraction from prayer, not an aid to it...and yet, I can't seem to get around it because it is so ingrained into my thought. I suppose the way to do it is to try to increase the practice of short, at the moment prayers, which come from the heart. Regardless, I continually feel so upset with myself because I say the Our Father and I feel like I wasn't even able to concentrate on the basic themes, much less the words. Yes, hot stuff, I think the main solution is to place myself in the presence of God for a while first so that I need not continually try to intellectually "convince" myself that He is there.
Old_Joe Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 dealing with my depression has made it much easier to pray. I still get distracted, but it feels like I'm more focused and get more done.
cappie Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Shakespeare writes the following for one of the characters in his plays: My words rise up, My thoughts remain below. Words without thoughts seldom to Heaven go. I start praying perhaps by meditating on a Mystery of the Rosary. I am thinking about the Presentation in the Temple while praying the Hail Mary when all of a sudden I am thinking about a cricket match (I'm Australian, ) what's for lunch or what I'm going to do the next day. Now if I did not mean to think these distracting thoughts then my prayer has not been in vain. Remember that prayer is not an intellectual exercise but a conversation or a desire for a relationship with God. Still, many people me included would like to have less distractions during prayer. The spiritual writers of old used to advise that one simply brushed distractions away as if they were annoying flies (there are lots of flies in Australia). This is a good analogy for the problem. I know that when I am talking to someone and a fly takes a great interest in me I am only momentarily distracted from the conversation. But let a bee instead of a fly landed on me and we have a totally different story. The conversation with the other person would be abruptly stopped while I tried to avoid being stung. My total concentration would be on the bee and not on the person I was talking to for some time. So treat distractions lightly and don't worry about them. Another technique to overcome annoying distractions is to make them part of one's prayer. If someone comes into your mind then pray for them, if it is a situation then include that. St. Therese of Avila, a Doctor of the Church called the Doctor of prayer, taught that most of the problem one has during prayer is related to what one does when one begins to pray. She really emphasizes the importance of beginning prayer by placing oneself in the Presence of God. Another term for this recollection. This fancy term means nothing more than collecting your thoughts. Give yourself time to settle down to prayer. Breathe deeply, find the best position, forget about what you were doing a few minutes before, etc. Don't begin your prayer already distracted. In whatever way is best for you, maybe a picture of Jesus, imagining Him before you or by another method place Him before you. Finally, consider praying out loud when distractions are really bad - if you are alone. This technique is especially helpful while doing what is called "conversational prayer," that is talking to God. By praying out loud at least if you get so distracted - and stop praying - you'll notice it!
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 3, 2006 Author Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='cappie' post='969358' date='May 3 2006, 12:15 AM'] Shakespeare writes the following for one of the characters in his plays: My words rise up, My thoughts remain below. Words without thoughts seldom to Heaven go. I start praying perhaps by meditating on a Mystery of the Rosary. I am thinking about the Presentation in the Temple while praying the Hail Mary when all of a sudden I am thinking about a cricket match (I'm Australian, ) what's for lunch or what I'm going to do the next day. Now if I did not mean to think these distracting thoughts then my prayer has not been in vain. Remember that prayer is not an intellectual exercise but a conversation or a desire for a relationship with God. Still, many people me included would like to have less distractions during prayer. The spiritual writers of old used to advise that one simply brushed distractions away as if they were annoying flies (there are lots of flies in Australia). This is a good analogy for the problem. I know that when I am talking to someone and a fly takes a great interest in me I am only momentarily distracted from the conversation. But let a bee instead of a fly landed on me and we have a totally different story. The conversation with the other person would be abruptly stopped while I tried to avoid being stung. My total concentration would be on the bee and not on the person I was talking to for some time. So treat distractions lightly and don't worry about them. Another technique to overcome annoying distractions is to make them part of one's prayer. If someone comes into your mind then pray for them, if it is a situation then include that. St. Therese of Avila, a Doctor of the Church called the Doctor of prayer, taught that most of the problem one has during prayer is related to what one does when one begins to pray. She really emphasizes the importance of beginning prayer by placing oneself in the Presence of God. Another term for this recollection. This fancy term means nothing more than collecting your thoughts. Give yourself time to settle down to prayer. Breathe deeply, find the best position, forget about what you were doing a few minutes before, etc. Don't begin your prayer already distracted. In whatever way is best for you, maybe a picture of Jesus, imagining Him before you or by another method place Him before you. Finally, consider praying out loud when distractions are really bad - if you are alone. This technique is especially helpful while doing what is called "conversational prayer," that is talking to God. By praying out loud at least if you get so distracted - and stop praying - you'll notice it! [/quote] Thank you, Father. I'd largely forgot about the importance of recollection from my year in the seminary. I know that it brought me great peace. I must bring it back into my prayer life. I will try these things. This particular issue comes and goes...but hopefully God will give me the grace to let it stop coming back this time.
Era Might Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Check out "Growth in Holiness" by Fr. Faber. Excellent insight into the "psychology" of spiritual growth. Also "The Soul of the Apostolate" by Jean-Baptiste Chautard.
LSW Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='969185' date='May 2 2006, 09:29 PM'] Part of the problem is that we are getting waaaaaaaaaay to much information in our lives. We get more information bombarded at us all the time. Think about this question. How much time do you have (or can you afford to have being in college) where you are alone and not reading, on computer, on a cell phone, watching tv, listening to music, etc. For most of us its minutes a week. The problem with getting so much information is that we don't process it all, but our minds try to. So when we pray, (trans: not taking in information) our minds are still trying to process and decompress. That is why we get random thoughts that enter prayer. That's one of the reasons we get distracted. What can help is to take 10-15 minutes to not do anything prior to a rosary. Take some deep breaths slowly and allow yourself to decompress prior to prayer. [/quote] I agree a 1000%. And thanks for the advice Cappie.
Theologian in Training Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='968890' date='May 2 2006, 07:20 PM'] Does anyone else really want to pray, go to God, ask Him to help pray because we "do not know how to pray," and begin, say, a rosary, only to struggle the whole time even to keep your mind on God? What about when you say the Our Father or Hail Mary and repeat it again and again because every single time you say it, you didn't put any thought or your heart into it, and it's like when you read and read again the same line because even though you said the words, you don't know what was said? Does anyone know the spiritual cure for this? Sometimes, but rarely, I get great times of prayer where I go away knowing that I've been with God and that He's just given me blessings. Usually, though, I pray and feel nothing...and it's not that I'm going for feelings, but if God is interested in our spiritual growth (and I don't doubt that He is), then why doesn't He help us to grow when we approach asking Him to help us and we make an effort to be with Him...or are we simply not able to see what growth we make because God wants us to stay humble and keep trying to go deeper? What is it? We're all so horrible when it comes to prayer and God seems so distant, even when we ask Him to come and be with us. [/quote] When you speak to someone do you always have your mind on them constantly? I know the ideal is to always have God before our minds, but the fact of the matter is, that is not always the case. Granted, the rosary is an excellent mediation for this, but sometimes our minds will wander, as they often do. Usually, in those situations, I let my mind wander, and just focus on the rythm of the prayer, letting the prayer bring me back in focus, and setting the interior silence that comes. I also find that, especially with regard to the rosary, it helps, to take a walk, at night usually, since it is quieter and cooler, and meditate that way. Also, with regard to the rosary, if you are meditating upon a mystery, and you find that you did not focus enough on the Hail Mary or Our Father, but let the scene unfold before you, then the rosary accomplished its purpose. You might try looking at those prayers not so much as something to meditate upon as much as "background music" that can help you visualize the mysteries set before you. Almost as though you are watching a movie and the Hail Mary and Our Fathers are the soundtrack to the movie. It can also be helpful to perhaps recite a part of Scripture that can be relevant to that mystery you are meditating upon. For example, if you were to pray the first Joyful mystery, you might begin it with "Be it done unto me according to Your word." It could then give you some focus on your meditation and help you really become draw into the mystery themselves. Sometimes it can help to think about other things that can draw your focus as well, think of a song, or a scene in a book or movie, or something else, and, if it is not Christian, Christianize it, and look at the mystery with those "eyes." It actually helps you see the presence of God in more than just the prayers you pray. Those are some of the things that I have done in the past to help me keep focused, I don't know if they may be helpful to you, but try them out and see what works. God Bless
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 5, 2006 Author Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='970739' date='May 4 2006, 10:23 AM'] When you speak to someone do you always have your mind on them constantly? I know the ideal is to always have God before our minds, but the fact of the matter is, that is not always the case. Granted, the rosary is an excellent mediation for this, but sometimes our minds will wander, as they often do. Usually, in those situations, I let my mind wander, and just focus on the rythm of the prayer, letting the prayer bring me back in focus, and setting the interior silence that comes. I also find that, especially with regard to the rosary, it helps, to take a walk, at night usually, since it is quieter and cooler, and meditate that way. Also, with regard to the rosary, if you are meditating upon a mystery, and you find that you did not focus enough on the Hail Mary or Our Father, but let the scene unfold before you, then the rosary accomplished its purpose. You might try looking at those prayers not so much as something to meditate upon as much as "background music" that can help you visualize the mysteries set before you. Almost as though you are watching a movie and the Hail Mary and Our Fathers are the soundtrack to the movie. It can also be helpful to perhaps recite a part of Scripture that can be relevant to that mystery you are meditating upon. For example, if you were to pray the first Joyful mystery, you might begin it with "Be it done unto me according to Your word." It could then give you some focus on your meditation and help you really become draw into the mystery themselves. Sometimes it can help to think about other things that can draw your focus as well, think of a song, or a scene in a book or movie, or something else, and, if it is not Christian, Christianize it, and look at the mystery with those "eyes." It actually helps you see the presence of God in more than just the prayers you pray. Those are some of the things that I have done in the past to help me keep focused, I don't know if they may be helpful to you, but try them out and see what works. God Bless [/quote] Thank you, Deacon. I really wish dUSt would finish 59beads...seeing images helps.
phatcatholic Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='972079' date='May 5 2006, 09:37 AM'] Thank you, Deacon. I really wish dUSt would finish 59beads...seeing images helps. [/quote] IDOLATOR!!!!! [size=1](haha, jk )[/size]
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 Everyone gets distractions. If you don't, you are allready in heaven. For the rest of us, the worst thing we can do is let ourselves get caught up in the distraction. The more we fight it with our thoughts, the larger and more powerful it becomes. Realize, it is perfectly normal, just irrelevent, and return gently. I mean, you don't want to be distracted by a distraction. SHALOM
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now