cappie Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Pell says Catholics should read the Koran Cardinal George Pell has said that it is vital to "read this sacred text of the Muslims, because the challenge of Islam will be with us for the remainder of our lives - at least". The message from a speech delivered in the US is reported in an article in today's Brisbane Courier-Mail. The speech, which was dated 7 February, appeared this week on the Sydney Archdiocesan website. Cardinal Pell said the totalitarian nature of Islamist ideology, and the brutality and rigidity of Islamist rule in Afghanistan under the Taliban would prove unsustainable, like Nazism and Communism, because of the enormous toll they exacted on human life and creativity. But on the pessimistic side, in reading the Koran Cardinal Pell began noting down the calls to violence. "There are so many of them, however, that I abandoned this exercise after 50 or 60 or 70 pages," he said. "It is easy for us to tell Muslims that they must look to themselves and find ways of reinterpreting their beliefs and remaking their societies. "Exactly the same thing can and needs to be said to us." [url="http://www.sydney.catholic.org.au/Archbishop/Addresses/200627_681.shtml"]SOURCE[/url]
dspen2005 Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 i must respectfully disagree... i think what should be mentioned is that those with strong understanding of the faith, etc are better equipped to read the koran. simply, reading the koran when you are weak in the Faith and aren't grounded in its realities can lead you to schism, heresy or apostasy (it could be an occasion of sin)
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 it doesn't hurt to have some familiarity with Islam, but I don't think reading the entire Koran is neccessary. Unless you're in a position where you must evangelize/dialogue with Muslims on a regular basis. But if I were to tell a Muslim what to read/study in order to have a grasp of what Catholicism is all about I think rather than telling them to read the Bible, it would be more productive to read a book that really summarizes Catholic theology, history and practice. Something such as Catholicism for Dummies. Similarly I think it would be more helpful for a lay person to read this sort of book about Islam rather than just reading the Koran. I'm sure there are plenty of good introductions to Islam out there. It might be interesting to read a Christian apologetic directed toward Islam such as Answering Islam.
dspen2005 Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 do u dispute the contention that one who is weak in his Faith ought not to read the koran, at all?
MissScripture Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='970332' date='May 3 2006, 08:42 PM'] We should get back to reading the Bible first [/quote] My thoughts exactly!
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 [quote name='dspen2005' post='970166' date='May 3 2006, 05:24 PM'] do u dispute the contention that one who is weak in his Faith ought not to read the koran, at all? [/quote] I guess someone who is poorly educated in Catholicism would be wasting time first learning Islam. But I don't think someone weak in their faith ought by default keep away from the Koran. Certain people with little faith might be swayed toward Islan, but in general I suppose one might experience the opposite effect.
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 I suppose any serious religious text will have a certain appeal, at least to some.. I can remember a friend of mine who after reading the Bhagavad Gita had their faith shaken for some reason. But when I was younger I used to read from the Mahabharata pretty much every day and never had any such issues. I just enjoy ancient literature and there is a lot of beautiful poetry and at times interesting philsophical notions in Hindu literature. But I never felt compelled to become Hindu anymore than reading Ovid compells me to start worshipping Juno or Diana. I suppose a lot of it has to do with why a person is reading a particular text. If someone finds Islam to be attractive and might be approaching the Koran with a mindset of giving Islam a chance, then sure, they might be swayed. But if a person is just critically reading the text in order to understand Islam in some way then I doubt one will feel the need to convert to Islam. I dunno.. And certainly if one truly has a living faith in Christ, reading something like the Koran, or the Bhagavad Gita ought not touch that in the least. I would hope not anyway, because there are texts out there which are more powerful than these and are designed to attack one's faith in Christ. I'd hate to see how such a person would respond to the cream of the crop anti-Christian stuff.
zwergel88 Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 This thread kind of applies to me. I just signed up for beginning Arabic classes (I really like the language and may want to work with translating it or something) and I'm sure that the only text book will pretty much be the Koran. Oh, well, I guess in this case you have to look at it more as a piece of Middle Eastern literature from the 8th century rather that the text of a particular faith.
Nathan Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='970160' date='May 3 2006, 05:21 PM']But if I were to tell a Muslim what to read/study in order to have a grasp of what Catholicism is all about I think rather than telling them to read the Bible, it would be more productive to read a book that really summarizes Catholic theology, history and practice. Something such as Catholicism for Dummies. Similarly I think it would be more helpful for a lay person to read this sort of book about Islam rather than just reading the Koran.[/quote] I agree.
jasJis Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 (edited) I wonder who Cardinal Pell was talking to in that speech so we can get a context of the 'Catholics' he was talking to? Was it a class of student theologions? Was it a group of religious? Was it a group of academic scholars? Or was it the 8th grade graduating class at St. Alphonso Elementary? Catholics cannot converse w/ Muslims grom a place of ignorance. The average Joe Cath does not debate religious ideology with a Muslim on a regular basis. From Cardinal Pell's statement: [quote]Obviously some of these questions about the future cannot be answered, but the issues should be discussed. Useful dialogue means that participants grapple with the truth and in this issue of Islam and the West the stakes are too high for fundamental misunderstandings. Both Muslims and Christians are helped by accurately identifying what are core and enduring doctrines, by identifying what issues can be discussed together usefully, by identifying those who are genuine friends, seekers after truth and cooperation and separating them from those who only appear to be friends. [/quote] Click on SOURCE in Fr. Cappie's post and read Cardinal Pell's entire statement. Edited May 4, 2006 by jasJis
DemonSlayer Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 Yeah, you should definitely be a strong Catholic first.
jasJis Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 Cardinal Pell was speaking at the Legatus Summit in Naples, FL. (Ave Maria Univ. is there). Please consider who he may have been tlaking too. I like this excerpt as well: [quote]Every great nation and religion has shadows and indeed crimes in their histories. This is certainly true of Catholicism and all Christian denominations. We should not airbrush these out of history, but confront them and then explain our present attitude to them.[/quote]Catholics need to be honest about their temporal Church failures as well in order to discuss serious issues with Muslims as peers, not as superiors.
dspen2005 Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='970357' date='May 3 2006, 10:19 PM'] I guess someone who is poorly educated in Catholicism would be wasting time first learning Islam. But I don't think someone weak in their faith ought by default keep away from the Koran. Certain people with little faith might be swayed toward Islan, but in general I suppose one might experience the opposite effect. [/quote] it does make sense to give someone whose Faith is weak, who is confused about what it is to believe, and who is in a state of simply wanting to grasp at anything that may remotely make sense or feed into his needs, the koran, or even some New Age text, to read.... that does make sense....
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 8, 2006 Posted May 8, 2006 [quote name='dspen2005' post='970664' date='May 4 2006, 07:38 AM'] it does make sense to give someone whose Faith is weak, who is confused about what it is to believe, and who is in a state of simply wanting to grasp at anything that may remotely make sense or feed into his needs, the koran, or even some New Age text, to read.... that does make sense.... [/quote] I guess you're being sarcastic. But your comment isn't fair because you added a bunch of other criteria. I would still say that just because a person has weak faith doesn't mean they should automatically be forbidden to read something like the Koran. I suppose if the person was also confused about what to believe and wanting to grasp at anything, etc.. then sure, they probably shouldn't read the Koran or new age texts. But the thing is, just because a person has a weak faith in Christ doesn't mean they're disposed toward Islam or the New Age. And quite frankly I see the literature of most religions to be in a similar category with Plato or Virgil. Now would you say that a person with weak faith automatically should avoid Cicero, or Homer? Better not give them anything by Marcus Aurelius, could push them over the edge? That's sort of where I'm coming from. And actually I've known people whose faith deepened after reading such things. I just think that acting as though these texts are so dangerous to Christian faith is really giving them too much credit. But sure, if a person is weak in their faith and in a state where such literature might make this worse, I agree, they shouldn't read it obviously. I just don't think that weak faith automatically means susceptibility to other religions, or that the books of other religions are necessarily an attack on Christian faith.
Myles Domini Posted May 8, 2006 Posted May 8, 2006 [quote name='jasJis' post='970576' date='May 4 2006, 12:47 PM'] I wonder who Cardinal Pell was talking to in that speech so we can get a context of the 'Catholics' he was talking to? Was it a class of student theologions? Was it a group of religious? Was it a group of academic scholars? Or was it the 8th grade graduating class at St. Alphonso Elementary? Catholics cannot converse w/ Muslims grom a place of ignorance. The average Joe Cath does not debate religious ideology with a Muslim on a regular basis. From Cardinal Pell's statement: Click on SOURCE in Fr. Cappie's post and read Cardinal Pell's entire statement. [/quote] Hey Jas please clarify what you meant by 'converse'. Thank you.
prose Posted May 8, 2006 Posted May 8, 2006 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='970332' date='May 3 2006, 07:42 PM'] We should get back to reading the Bible first [/quote] Yep. I was just thinking "read the Koran cover to cover?? Most people I know haven't even done that with the Bible!! OR the Catechism! Maybe we need to focus on our roots!!"
azaelia Posted May 8, 2006 Posted May 8, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='975157' date='May 8 2006, 10:45 AM'] Yep. I was just thinking "read the Koran cover to cover?? Most people I know haven't even done that with the Bible!! OR the Catechism! Maybe we need to focus on our roots!!" [/quote] Yeah, I have yet to even crack the Catechism
dspen2005 Posted May 8, 2006 Posted May 8, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='975055' date='May 8 2006, 05:28 AM'] I guess you're being sarcastic. But your comment isn't fair because you added a bunch of other criteria. I would still say that just because a person has weak faith doesn't mean they should automatically be forbidden to read something like the Koran. I suppose if the person was also confused about what to believe and wanting to grasp at anything, etc.. then sure, they probably shouldn't read the Koran or new age texts. But the thing is, just because a person has a weak faith in Christ doesn't mean they're disposed toward Islam or the New Age. And quite frankly I see the literature of most religions to be in a similar category with Plato or Virgil. Now would you say that a person with weak faith automatically should avoid Cicero, or Homer? Better not give them anything by Marcus Aurelius, could push them over the edge? That's sort of where I'm coming from. And actually I've known people whose faith deepened after reading such things. I just think that acting as though these texts are so dangerous to Christian faith is really giving them too much credit. But sure, if a person is weak in their faith and in a state where such literature might make this worse, I agree, they shouldn't read it obviously. I just don't think that weak faith automatically means susceptibility to other religions, or that the books of other religions are necessarily an attack on Christian faith. [/quote] 1. I don't think I used the term 'forbidden' 2. A weak faith can lead one into false religions and can cause one to renounce the Faith, which is a sin; thus, the reading of the Koran can be considered a near occasion of sin. 3. Cicero's works aren't of a religious content; neither is Homer's -- they are either commentaries or historical tales. 4. THe Church Herself also advises the Faithful to stay away from such works -- hence, it reviews the works of various theologians and decides whether or not they are in keeping w/ Catholic teaching; she reviews certain cinema works -- DaVinci Code, for example -- and advises the faithful that it isn't worth watching. 5. I never said that these books are inherently attacks on Christian Faith -- though, i would argue that point for the Koran. But they can be dangerous for those who are going through a period of weakness in their faith.
misereremi Posted May 8, 2006 Posted May 8, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='970160' date='May 4 2006, 12:21 AM'] it doesn't hurt to have some familiarity with Islam, but I don't think reading the entire Koran is neccessary. Unless you're in a position where you must evangelize/dialogue with Muslims on a regular basis. [/quote] I am pretty much in such a position and for me it is important to have some familiarity with Islam. I have read the Qur'an, some hadeeths and books on Islam and this helps me to have peaceful dialogues/debates with Muslims. When I was a lot weaker in my faith, I found reading the Qur' an (back to back) very aggravating and disheartening, and I am glad that I took the advice of my priest at that time to put those books away for now, use whatever time you have to pray, read the Holy Bible and the lives of the Saints esp. those who preached to the Moors.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now