Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The most effective argument against Catholicism


Recommended Posts

Myles Domini
Posted

[url="http://mliccione.blogspot.com/2006/05/most-effective-argument-against.html"]The most effective argument against Catholicism[/url]

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Good post (and point).

...O Lord, make us holy! :sign:

Brother Adam
Posted

Thanks.

Has Jas see this?

Posted

If that's the best argument they've got than I pity them and envy us.

If every Catholic in the world were a terrible sinner the Church would be no less Holy. If every Catholic in the world was a living saint the Church would be no more Holy.

The Church is Holy because Christ made it Holy. NOTHING can change that.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='974006' date='May 6 2006, 05:11 PM']
Thanks.

Has Jas see this?[/quote]Yeppers.
Disturbing, isn't it?
If it's a hospitial for sinners, where are the healed people?
Why am I told I'm too sick to come in?

Sorry OLAM, but if today's American Catholic Church is holy because Christ made it, WHO is the evidence?

Read more of this guy's blog. He tells a story of a prot to cath revert who couldn't decide between orthodox or roman. He chose orthodox because he felt roman wouldn't keep his kids catholic down the line. I feel his pain.

Posted

my response to that would be that Christ said the gates of Hell would never prevail against the Church but he never said that Satan wouldn't try.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

We cannot control others, but we can control ourselves. We have a responsibility to personal holiness.

And if we have a family, it's our job, first and foremost to keep our children Catholic. The family is the domestic church. We cannot rely on the Church to keep our children Catholic (as evidenced today...)-- is the Church an aid? Yes, of course, but the Church cannot assume the burden of totally raising everyone's children-- that's what families are for.

Personal holiness.... is the key. My former spiritual director, as I struggled with all the bad in the church, used repeat over and over that we are "loved sinners"... and that's the truth. We live in a fallen world where it becomes harder and harder everyday to follow Christ. But all these hardships should make us turn to Christ all the more, begging for His mercy, and for His return.

Era Might
Posted

[quote name='jasJis' post='974022' date='May 6 2006, 07:39 PM']
Sorry OLAM, but if today's American Catholic Church is holy because Christ made it, WHO is the evidence?

[/quote]

Mother Angelica. Avery Cardinal Dulles. Bishop Fabien Bruskewitz. Sean Cardinal O'Malley. Father Mitch Pacwa. Dustin Sieber. Etc.

[quote]And he said to his disciples, "Temptations to sin are sure to come; but woe to him by whom they come!

--Luke 17:1[/quote]

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='jasJis' post='974022' date='May 6 2006, 07:39 PM']
Sorry OLAM, but if today's American Catholic Church is holy because Christ made it, WHO is the evidence?[/quote]
[url="http://www.catholic-forum.com/saints/indexsnt.htm"][b]Evidence[/b][/url]

Responses [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/621"][b]One[/b][/url] and [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/622"][b]Two[/b][/url]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Yeah, I've meant tons of awesome and holy Catholics (if I may presume to judge). Both Catholic families and monks, nuns and priests.

There are religious communities out there where the people are ridiculously holy. And I've met Bishops who were totally in with the Holy Spirit if you know what I mean. It's just that bad stuff get noticed more..

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I think Benedict XVI giving his old job to an American is a sign that Rome wants to fix the Church in America.

Posted

jasJis,

While I agree that there are many WHOs, right here on Phatmass, my point was that even absent ANY WHOs the Church is the Church; one, holy, catholic and apostolic.

As bad as things seem today, we have gone through many rougher stretches. There have been times when even the pope wasn't worth a hill of beans when it came to personal holiness (unlike recent history). Regardless, the Church is the mystical body of Christ and above all of our unworthiness.

I find great comfort in this. I find even greater comfort in reading the gospels and finding that Jesus told us to expect this.

Thanks be to God for His mercy. We aren't worthy.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='974045' date='May 6 2006, 08:04 PM']
....It's just that bad stuff get noticed more..
[/quote]
this is an important point. i think that some people would rather think that the Church is just too far gone, so of course such people are only going to see the sinners within her. evil enjoys the spotlight. holiness would rather go about its way in relative anonymity

philothea
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='974056' date='May 6 2006, 07:17 PM']
this is an important point. i think that some people would rather think that the Church is just too far gone, so of course such people are only going to see the sinners within her. evil enjoys the spotlight. holiness would rather go about its way in relative anonymity
[/quote]
I think the only new "problem" is the quantity of information we can get. Until very recently, we would never have heard about abuses or scandals in any church except our own, or one nearby. Bad news gets attention, and the Church has a lot of enemies.

If the Church is what she claims, I'd expect her reputation to be [i]exactly[/i] what it presently is. We're fallible humans, and we're at war in a hostile world. Of course we're going to hear about every problem, as magnified as possible.

Personally, I know lots of awesome, holy Catholics. Sure, I observe some people I would consider mediocre, but I don't really know them. (Bad me, passing judgment!) All the bad stuff? Gossip and news stories. If I didn't hear it from other sources, I'd never know.

What amazes me is that the Church is doing as well as it is, considering how we're all a bunch of screw-ups. There's something to that.

I don't think the Church is especially worse (or better) than it has been at other times in history. We English speakers are certainly living in some of the worst cultures, though, so that's bound to affect everything, including the Church.

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

I tell people this all the time.

But they would rather sit around complaining than give it a try.

Too difficult i guess.

SHALOM

phatcatholic
Posted

tell them what? give what a try? (sorry)

Posted

This is an issue that came up often when I was debating whether to become Catholic or Orthodox. I always had my mind set on the Orthodox because of their beautiful liturgy, their chant, and their culture that has really remained preserved (at least that's what I thought) from modernism. However as has been mentioned before, there are two aspects to the Church, the pure and immaculate Body of Christ, and the human element which is always liable to corruption and sin. I remember watching the news when a report came up about the middle east. How Palestinian Christians were offering their land to the Orthodox church so the property can't be seized by the Israeli government. But there was this huge scandal because the bishop was covertly selling the land for years. They showed clips of lay people yelling at these Orthodox leaders, fully bearded, dawning their traditional vestments, totally being disparaged and humiliated. The point is there is no such thing as a perfect Church. There are as many sinners as their are saints and the Orthodox have their fare share. I know plenty of Greek orthos in my community that have no faith, and on the other hand I've met many a great Catholic who was full of passion and love for Jesus. You really have to look at the core issue, not the periphery. There is only one Church that truly bears all four marks: One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic and as much as any church may claim it, there is one Church that fully bears it. And that is the Catholic Church.

I foresee an eventual conversion to Catholicism by the orthodox. Eventually they will have to face up to all the problems and challenges of Modernism; challenges they are not prepared to handle. Let us not forget they have been unable to establish an ecumenical council since their split. Hopefully they will reunify with the Bishop of Rome.

phatcatholic
Posted

good points, mortify................welcome to phatmass!
:welcome:

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='974414' date='May 7 2006, 12:10 PM']
tell them what? give what a try? (sorry)
[/quote]

Personal holiness is the best witness to the effectivity of our faith. Hypocrisy is the worst weapon against.

Its like people complain all day about all the hypocrisy, but are too lazy to be set apart from the hypocrisy, and actually seek personal holiness.

SHALOM

phatcatholic
Posted

i see :cool:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...