Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is it a mortal sin to hang out with someone


Recommended Posts

Resurrexi
Posted

Is it a mortal sin to hang out with someone who might say something impure/blasphemous?

Posted

I wouldnt say its a mortal sin. If ur not strong in ur faith and they might be a threat to ur faith then it could deffinatly be a dangerous situation for you and u might wanna get outta there. If ur strong in ur faith then u can refute and correct them thus doing a spiritual work of mercy (instruct the ignorant or abomish the sinner) if u didnt mean to be with them then its deffinatly not a sin- ie if ur just sittin there and some dude starts bad mouthing the church. I would say it would be a good opportunity to practice some appologetics.

If u think its a threat to ur purity then be brave and flee (as Escriva puts it) but if u can defend the faith then do so- never comprimise, do battle for Christ and you very well might win over a new Apostle.

Hope that helps

God Bless and peace

Charms717RM1
Posted (edited)

Is it a mortal sin? That's probably a question for your confessor, your conscience, and your prayers.

But hanging out with someone like that may lead you into the oppurtunity of sin. So be careful and use prudence.

You may also want to closely examine your intent. Do you want to hang out with them because they might say impure/blasphemous things? If so, why? If your intent is to be around so that you may have an opputunity to charitably correct them and educate them in truth, then no, i would say hanging out with them is not a sin. But if your intent is to hear impure/blasphemous things just for the sake of hearing them...well like i said, that's a question for your confessor, your conscience, and your prayers.

God Bless!
Keith

Edited by Charms717RM1
Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='974126' date='May 7 2006, 12:03 AM']
Is it a mortal sin to hang out with someone who might say something impure/blasphemous?
[/quote]

Yes. Jesus usually mortally sinned hanging out with tax collectors and sinners.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='974159' date='May 6 2006, 09:52 PM']

Yes. Jesus usually mortally sinned hanging out with tax collectors and sinners. [/quote]

That's not very constructive, now.

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

I know in my own faith walk i cannot hang out with certain people who blaspheme, without being weakened in the faith.

However, standing up for respect, might change it.

Jesus can hang out with blasphemers and not sin, because he is still God. It is okay, to admit your own weeknesses, and leave a relationship that leaves you scarred spiritually, to pray for their soul.

SHALOM

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I think it can bring you down but sometimes you got to live through it. I have relatives that cuss all the time but I do not think it would be right to avoid them. Everybody messes up. There are times when I would not want to hang out with myself.

Era Might
Posted

I think it depends. You have to know yourself, and what you can tolerate. And also, it doesn't hurt to ask them to stop. You never know, they may just respect you for asking, at least when they're around you.

Posted

It's not a mortal sin. Like Brother Adam so sarcastically put it, even Christ kept company with huge sinners. A lot of times God can use your presence with them to touch their hearts--I know a lot of my friends "feel wrong" when they curse in front of me, and a few of my Catholic friends only remember to pray before meals and stuff when I'm around. The world needs a good Catholic presence to keep it in line :D However, if it does pose a temptation to you, then run like the wind.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Anyone of us [i]might[/i] do something wrong. Don't take chances-- become a hermit.

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='974126' date='May 7 2006, 01:03 PM']
Is it a mortal sin to hang out with someone who might say something impure/blasphemous?
[/quote]

Why would you want to :idontknow:

Posted

I don't think it's a mortal sin.

But, I know how you feel. This past week and weekend I was really thinking about is it okay to be around people if they're constantly being like that. I guess it really depends on how strong you are.

See, I just started cosmetology school last Monday. The ladies there constantly swear, talk bad about others and about sexual things. It's VERY draining on me having to be around it for so many hours every day of the week.

I started asking myself..is what I am there for worth being around them and chancing basically having all that rub off onto me.

I talked to my parents about it all. Basically, I got to keep going. I can't let how those people act and what they say keep me from doing what I feel is the path God wants me to be on right now.

I don't dislike the ladies or think they're bad people, it's just very hard for me to be around all that..especially for so much time. My dad reminded me, you know, hate the sin but not the sinner.

Also, if they're your friends that are acting this way..I would deffinitely talk to them. Not in a way that makes it seem like you're judging them but that you'd just really appreciate if they didn't say or act that way around you because you like them and want to hang out with them...but that it's hard for you because of what you believe of how God wants you to live. I don't know.

If the people continue and you feel like you're too weak in some areas to be able to keep haning around them without it rubbing off on you, I think maybe it'd be better to not hang out with them so much. Which can be extremely hard if they're like your best friend or something. But it's something you have to do if it's what needs to be done. Like, how far are you will to live your life Gods way and not your own?

Posted

curtins, you took the words out of my mouth on this situation

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='974159' date='May 6 2006, 09:52 PM']
Yes. Jesus usually mortally sinned hanging out with tax collectors and sinners.
[/quote]


<_< Christ never sinned. It was not a sin for Him to put Himself in danger of sin because He is perfect and never sinned. Christ was there for the sake of good. He would never offend His father.

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='974126' date='May 6 2006, 09:03 PM']
Is it a mortal sin to hang out with someone who might say something impure/blasphemous?
[/quote]

If you take that line of thinking to its logical conclusion, you'd wind up with hsmom's (tongue in cheek) solution:

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='974569' date='May 7 2006, 04:10 PM']
Anyone of us [i]might[/i] do something wrong. Don't take chances-- become a hermit.
[/quote]

It is a sort of defensive way of thinking. It's where you wind up entrapped by your own fears. It's something I've struggled with myself. The devil sometimes uses your desire for purity and holiness and twists it so that you become aloof/holier-than-thou. You have to be prudent, of course. If it leads to near occasion of sin or scandal, then avoid it like the plague. However, if you feel you can be a witness in some capacity, then it may be better to be there.



I really like Charms and Imagizun's posts.

[quote name='Charms717RM1' post='974138' date='May 6 2006, 09:10 PM']
But hanging out with someone like that may lead you into the oppurtunity of sin. [b]So be careful and use prudence.[/b]

You may also want to closely examine your intent. Do you want to hang out with them because they might say impure/blasphemous things? If so, why? If your intent is to be around so that you may have an opputunity to charitably correct them and educate them in truth, then no, i would say hanging out with them is not a sin. But if your intent is to hear impure/blasphemous things just for the sake of hearing them...well like i said, that's a question for your confessor, your conscience, and your prayers.

God Bless!
Keith
[/quote]


[quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' post='974171' date='May 6 2006, 10:05 PM']
I know in my own faith walk i cannot hang out with certain people who blaspheme, without being weakened in the faith.

[b]However, standing up for respect, might change it.[/b]

Jesus can hang out with blasphemers and not sin, because he is still God. It is okay, to admit your own weeknesses, and leave a relationship that leaves you scarred spiritually, to pray for their soul.

SHALOM
[/quote]

Posted

just you being around them could influence them for the better. :) i know from personal experience

brandelynmarie
Posted

also...whenever I hear someone swear or say somethng blasphemous....I will say interiorly..."Praise to You Lord Jesus Christ!" or some other phrase in reparation...or I may say a quiet prayer for the person or persons too...

I had to ask a former best friend of mine to not say a certain phrase around me...out of respect for me & my Faith...& that played a small part in us parting ways...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...