Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

So, I'm finishing up my Christian Initiation final (key word: finishing). We had to write a position paper on one of three topics: 1) the baptism of infants; 2) the order of the sacraments of initiation; 3) confirmation of the uncatechized. I chose #2.

So, anyone else have opinions/experience with the history of the development of the sacraments of initiation (baptism, eucharist, confirmation)? In light of your reading/experience/etc what are your views on the current order of the sacraments of initiation? Is the current theology for confirmation adequate?

Right now, I'm going to go off and write. Talk amongst yourselves.... :)

phatcatholic
Posted

i don't really have time now to give my opinion. i'm taking a break from finals b/c if i don't i get overwhelmed :blink: i can point you to some articles tho:
--[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/44"]Baptism[/url]
--[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/47"]Confirmation[/url]
--[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/46"]Eucharist[/url]

once you click on each link, the articles at the bottom (below the sub-entries) will probably be the most helpful, since they give comprehensive treatments on each sacrament, including their history and meaning.

peace,
phatty

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='975563' date='May 8 2006, 05:03 PM']
i don't really have time now to give my opinion. i'm taking a break from finals b/c if i don't i get overwhelmed :blink:
[/quote]
Phatty, I understand techniques to avoid nervous breakdowns during finals. Making this thread was my own distraction! :lol: Thanks for the links, guess I better get back to it!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I think Confirmation should be administered immediately after Baptism.

Posted

I agree. Would you care to elaborate? (no pressure :))

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='shortnun' post='975556' date='May 8 2006, 07:58 PM']
So, I'm finishing up my Christian Initiation final (key word: finishing). We had to write a position paper on one of three topics: 1) the baptism of infants; 2) the order of the sacraments of initiation; 3) confirmation of the uncatechized. I chose #2.

So, anyone else have opinions/experience with the history of the development of the sacraments of initiation (baptism, eucharist, confirmation)? In light of your reading/experience/etc what are your views on the current order of the sacraments of initiation? Is the current theology for confirmation adequate?

Right now, I'm going to go off and write. Talk amongst yourselves.... :)
[/quote]

There are good homilies by the fathers in "The Awe Inspiring Rites of Initation" if you have time to read them...

[quote name='shortnun' post='975720' date='May 8 2006, 11:16 PM']
I agree. Would you care to elaborate? (no pressure :))
[/quote]

Confirmation as it completes baptism and incorporates us into the economic Trinity (the mission of the Trinity towards the world), and is a sacrament of sending forth, of publically orienting us as missionaries, I favor the sacrament to be received later in life, and not in infancy.

journeyman
Posted

I'm not sure if this fits into your topic exactly . . . but it was a fascinating read:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=39130&hl="]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=39130&hl=[/url]

journeyman
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='975688' date='May 8 2006, 06:49 PM']
I think Confirmation should be administered immediately after Baptism.
[/quote]

I think that is the practice in the Eastern Rites

It makes sense to me for an adult convert . . . but for the child born into a Catholic family, what rite of initiation is available to make the statement "I accept" the faith . . . at infancy, the statement is made for the child by the parents . . . the child is "marked" at that time as a Catholic, but baptism alone can fill that role . . .

Acceptance at Eucharist could be such a ceremony, but the Church has historically welcomed the very young to the "source and summit" of the sacraments

Confirmation is, in some ways, similar to reconciliation: a sacrament looking for acceptance

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='shortnun' post='975720' date='May 8 2006, 09:16 PM']
I agree. Would you care to elaborate? (no pressure :))
[/quote]

Confirmation completes the initiation sacraments, and is not a graduation into adulthood as many view it today. Why should a child have to wait years to recieve the all the graces of the sacrament when growing up is such a hazardous time? If its a sacrament of initiation then lets treat it as such, and confirm soon after baptism.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='976107' date='May 9 2006, 10:23 AM']
Confirmation completes the initiation sacraments, and is not a graduation into adulthood as many view it today. Why should a child have to wait years to recieve the all the graces of the sacrament when growing up is such a hazardous time? If its a sacrament of initiation then lets treat it as such, and confirm soon after baptism.
[/quote]
I agree 100%. I think confirmation has lost it's "initiatory" status, and has become a rite of passage into adulthood. I don't have a problem with a liturgical celebration acknowledging further participation in the life of the Church, but we've been doing that since the moment of our baptism. It's almost condescending to the kids to say that they have to wait--and I think it puts a limit on how God's grace is dispensed!

Now, let's just say a quick prayer that I argued that point articulately in my paper, and that my prof gives me a good grade! ^_^

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

i see confirmation as just that. a confirmation in your own faith. at first, by no choice of your own, you were regenerated. why should all of your actions from then on be super-meritorious or super unmeritorious shortly after your birth when you dont even own your faith? i think it shouldnt be admininstered to fifth graders... no, i wont allow my child to be confirmed til at least 18 yrs of age. that way, they know exactly what they are doing, and if they are gonna leave the Church, then they leave it... of course, i def. think that the emphasis of these things should be drilled into kids. (but all this is opinion)

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='blovedwolfofgod' post='976479' date='May 9 2006, 04:56 PM']
i see confirmation as just that. a confirmation in your own faith. at first, by no choice of your own, you were regenerated. why should all of your actions from then on be super-meritorious or super unmeritorious shortly after your birth when you dont even own your faith? i think it shouldnt be admininstered to fifth graders... no, i wont allow my child to be confirmed til at least 18 yrs of age. that way, they know exactly what they are doing, and if they are gonna leave the Church, then they leave it... of course, i def. think that the emphasis of these things should be drilled into kids. (but all this is opinion)
[/quote]
Confirmation completes our initiation into the Church, there is no reason not to do it directly after Baptism. It is NOT a rite of passage into adulthood.

[quote name='shortnun' post='976446' date='May 9 2006, 04:39 PM']
I agree 100%. I think confirmation has lost it's "initiatory" status, and has become a rite of passage into adulthood. I don't have a problem with a liturgical celebration acknowledging further participation in the life of the Church, but we've been doing that since the moment of our baptism. It's almost condescending to the kids to say that they have to wait--and I think it puts a limit on how God's grace is dispensed!

Now, let's just say a quick prayer that I argued that point articulately in my paper, and that my prof gives me a good grade! ^_^
[/quote]
You can always post your paper when you get it back :)

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

I wasnt trying to say it was a rite of passage cmom. To me, its so much more than that. Thats precisely the reason I would want my child to wait, because it is more than a rite of passage. Its an imbueing with the Holy Spirit. Its the difference between culpability and super-culpability (well, not those words, but the equivalent if you know what Im saying).

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I know what you mean, but that is a exactly why the kids need those graces from the very start. Religious maturity and emotional/psychology maturity are not the same.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='975688' date='May 8 2006, 08:49 PM']
I think Confirmation should be administered immediately after Baptism.
[/quote]


In the Eastern and Orthodox churches confirmation is administered with baptism and they call confirmation by a different name. They call it Chrismation.


For a long time I have agreed with Beloved in that confirmation should not be until later because I think that it really should be a willing embrace of the faith that we have been given. I have thought that for a long time because it has bothered me for a long time that kids are doing it as a formality because this is what you do. And after they are confirmed some just disappear.

But really delaying it is seperating it from it's meaning as a sacrament of initiation. In principle the Eastern church has it right don't they? Confirmation is not about what our response or our ability to respond. It is about the gifts that God the Holy Spirit gives us.

My long held opinion might be changing. Thank you for making me step back and take a new look.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='976107' date='May 10 2006, 02:23 AM']
Confirmation completes the initiation sacraments, and is not a graduation into adulthood as many view it today. Why should a child have to wait years to recieve the all the graces of the sacrament when growing up is such a hazardous time? If its a sacrament of initiation then lets treat it as such, and confirm soon after baptism.
[/quote]

Theologically Eucharist completes iniation into the church. It was Pope Pius X who changed the order of the sacraments of iniation. Children could not receive their first Holy Communion until they were Confirmed. Pope Pius worried that children were not making their Communion sometimes until the age of 15, so he lowered the age to 7

Posted

[quote name='blovedwolfofgod' post='977031' date='May 9 2006, 09:49 PM']
I wasnt trying to say it was a rite of passage cmom. To me, its so much more than that. Thats precisely the reason I would want my child to wait, because it is more than a rite of passage. Its an imbueing with the Holy Spirit. Its the difference between culpability and super-culpability (well, not those words, but the equivalent if you know what Im saying).
[/quote]
[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='977033' date='May 9 2006, 09:54 PM']
I know what you mean, but that is a exactly why the kids need those graces from the very start. Religious maturity and emotional/psychology maturity are not the same.
[/quote]
The beauty (and mystery) of the sacraments--particularly those of initation--is that the graces come to us regardless of if we've "proved" ourselves or not. We are brought forth by our parents and the church. They make a committment to be attentive to the Spirit and to raise us in the faith. WE don't have to DO anything. We're being brought into the Church. God's love and mercy is so abundant that he takes us as complete persons, and helps us become the fullest persons we can.

[quote name='Mercy me' post='978023' date='May 10 2006, 11:18 PM']
For a long time I have agreed with Beloved in that confirmation should not be until later because I think that it really should be a willing embrace of the faith that we have been given. I have thought that for a long time because it has bothered me for a long time that kids are doing it as a formality because this is what you do. And after they are confirmed some just disappear.

But really delaying it is seperating it from it's meaning as a sacrament of initiation. In principle the Eastern church has it right don't they? Confirmation is not about what our response or our ability to respond. It is about the gifts that God the Holy Spirit gives us.
[/quote]
Mercy me, there are some articles I am trying to find to link for you.... if you're interested, that is, in hearing current arguements for catechetical confirmation vs. initiatory confirmation (not that confirmation isn't just one or the other, but the first group argues for a later age, while the second argues for an earlier age). So often confirmation is seen as a formality; it's something we *have* to do. And many people--rightly so--worry about what will happen to young Catholics if they're complete with "mandatory" sacraments by age 7. It's a challenge for us to respond to the spiritual and personal needs of all ages in our Church so they feel welcome and sustained.

You hit the nail on the head for me: It's not about our ability to respond. It's about the particular gifts of the Holy Spirit which God has prepared in our hearts since the time we first received the Spirit at baptism.

[quote name='cappie' post='978045' date='May 10 2006, 11:39 PM']
Theologically Eucharist completes iniation into the church. It was Pope Pius X who changed the order of the sacraments of iniation. Children could not receive their first Holy Communion until they were Confirmed. Pope Pius worried that children were not making their Communion sometimes until the age of 15, so he lowered the age to 7
[/quote]
Pope Pius X and I have a long history together. I've worked at three different Pius X schools or parishes, in three states, over the past 6 years. ^_^

Cappie brings up a great point.... that if Eucharist completes initiation into the Church, are we (for lack of a better term) demeaning it's signficance if it is no longer the last sacrament of initation? How can we, as a Eucharistic Church, (re)teach the significance of this central sacrament if it just something we receive after baptism and before confirmation?.................. slightly rhetorical questions, but slightly serious at the same time.........

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...