phatcatholic Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 i'm having trouble distinguishing these different Greek words in my mind: [i]homoousios [/i] -- [i]ousia [/i] -- [i]hypostasis [/i] -- [i]prosopon[/i] someone help me out thanks, nick
Brother Adam Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 Off the top of my head: Homoousios. Of the same nature. the one nature shared by the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. ousia. Being or substance Hypostasis. The essential person of Jesus in which his human and divine natures are united prosopon. extrinsic, natures. In Christ - One hypostasis, two prosopon (human and divine.
Apotheoun Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='975807' date='May 8 2006, 07:30 PM'] i'm having trouble distinguishing these different Greek words in my mind: [i]homoousios [/i] -- [i]ousia [/i] -- [i]hypostasis [/i] -- [i]prosopon[/i] someone help me out thanks, nick [/quote] To be [i]homoousios[/i] means to possess the "same essence" (i.e., to be "one in essence"), and refers to the Son's and the Spirit's derived origin from the Father, who is the sole font of divinity. [i]Ousia[/i] means "essence." [i]Hypostasis[/i] means "subsistence," and so, it is used to designate a concrete existing thing. [i]Prosopon[/i] means "mask" or "face," and is normally translated into English by the word "person." Now it is important to note that the word [i]hypostasis[/i] has also -- in the past -- been translated into English by the word "person," although most scholars today avoid this translation, because it can lead to confusion both in Triadological and Christological theology. That being said, it is more common now to simply transliterate this word, rather than attempt to translate it. With these definitions in mind, it is possible to understand the Triadological teaching of the Greek Fathers, who held that there are three [i]hypostaseis[/i] in God (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit), and that these three distinct subsistences are one in [i]ousia[/i], i.e., one in essence. Finally, the Christological teaching of the Fathers explained the incarnation by saying that Christ is one divine [i]hypostasis[/i] in two natures ([i]physeis[/i]). Thus, as the Chalcedonian [i]Horos[/i] proclaimed: "We confess that one and the same Christ, Lord, and only-begotten Son, is to be acknowledged in two natures without confusion, change, division or separation. The distinction between the natures was never abolished by their union, but rather the character proper to each of the two natures was preserved as they came together in one person ([i]prosopon[/i]) and one subsistence ([i]hypostasis[/i])."
qfnol31 Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 Prosopon versus persona caused a little trouble at one point, didn't it.
phatcatholic Posted May 9, 2006 Author Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='975858' date='May 8 2006, 11:15 PM'] Now it is important to note that the word [i]hypostasis[/i] has also -- in the past -- been translated into English by the word "person," although most scholars today avoid this translation, because it can lead to confusion both in Triadological and Christological theology. That being said, it is more common now to simply transliterate this word, rather than attempt to translate it.[/quote] yea, that's where i was getting confused. i couldn't tell the difference between [i]hypostasis[/i] and [i]prosopon[/i].
Myles Domini Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='975882' date='May 9 2006, 04:52 AM'] Prosopon versus persona caused a little trouble at one point, didn't it. [/quote] And with good reason after all etymologically they are equivalents yet their usage proved oft asymetrical. In "the Bazaar of Heracleides", for instance, Nestorius clearly does not mean to make prosopon a subsistence. Nestorius makes prosopon the manifestation of a nature and accordingly the Bazaar presents Christ as having two natures and two prosopa which may or may not blend into one. Its not exactly clear what Nestorius' is trying to convey but certainly his use of prosopa does not seem to share ground with Pope St Leo the Great's. In Pope St Leo its quite clear that person is meant to act as an equivalent hypostasis. So whereas in Pope St Leo its incoceivable that after the union Christ can be said to have two prosopa by Nestorian logic it cannot consistently be thought to be otherwise. Indeed, as an aside, one can say Nestorius' use of prosopon was outdated by his time the Cappodacian fathers having eliminated the abstract usage of the term prosopon and attached it to work hypostasis in their revolutionary reclarification of the terms ousia and hypostasis.
Apotheoun Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 As I understand Nestorius' teaching, he held that after the incarnation Christ is two [i]hypostaseis[/i], but only one [i]prosopon[/i]. In other words, for Nestorius Christ has two different acts of existence (i.e., subsistence), while He possesses only one countenance or outward aspect. Thus, his teaching involves positing only one "person" but two beings (i.e., acts of existence) in Christ, along with two natures ([i]physeis[/i]). The Church of course rejected Nestorius' position, and declared it heretical at the Council of Ephesus (A.D. 431). In opposition to Nestorius the Church taught that Christ is in fact one [i]hypostasis[/i] and one [i]prosopon[/i] in two natures ([i]physeis[/i]). That being said, there is no human subsistence (i.e., act of existence) in Christ; and as a consequence, Christ's human nature is actuated by the divine [i]hypostasis[/i] of the eternal Logos. Shortly after the Nestorian heresy was condemned, a monk named Eutyches promoted another heresy, and in this heresy he put forward the idea that the two natures ([i]physeis[/i]) in Christ coalesced in order to form one nature after the incarnation. This heresy is commonly called Monophysitism, and it was specifically condemned at the Council of Chalcedon (A.D. 451).
phatcatholic Posted May 9, 2006 Author Posted May 9, 2006 can you explain this line for me: [quote name='Apotheoun' post='976172' date='May 9 2006, 12:08 PM']That being said, there is no human subsistence (i.e., act of existence) in Christ; and as a consequence, Christ's human nature is actuated by the divine [i]hypostasis[/i] of the eternal Logos.[/quote] it seems incorrect, but i'm probably just misunderstanding it. the rest was very helpful, thank you
Apotheoun Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='976174' date='May 9 2006, 09:15 AM'] can you explain this line for me: it seems incorrect, but i'm probably just misunderstanding it. the rest was very helpful, thank you [/quote] If Christ has a human act of existence (i.e., subsistence; in Greek [i]hypostasis[/i]), He would be a human person, but the teaching of the Church is clear on this, Christ is not a human person, nor is He a human being; instead, He is a divine person ([i]prosopon[/i]) and a divine being ([i]hypostasis[/i] / subsistence) who has assumed a full and complete human nature ([i]physis[/i]). To put it another way: Christ's human nature subsists in the eternal [i]hypostasis[/i] / [i]prosopon[/i] of the divine Logos.
phatcatholic Posted May 9, 2006 Author Posted May 9, 2006 its difficult to fully comprehend, but i see what you're saying. please excuse my ignorance. thank you for your help
Myles Domini Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='976177' date='May 9 2006, 05:19 PM'] If Christ has a human act of existence (i.e., subsistence; in Greek [i]hypostasis[/i]), He would be a human person, but the teaching of the Church is clear on this, Christ is not a human person, nor is He a human being; instead, He is a divine person ([i]prosopon[/i]) and a divine being ([i]hypostasis[/i] / subsistence) who has assumed a full and complete human nature ([i]physis[/i]). To put it another way: Christ's human nature subsists in the eternal [i]hypostasis[/i] / [i]prosopon[/i] of the divine Logos. [/quote] St Cyril would be smiling...
Apotheoun Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 Perhaps the following information will help: The Cappadocian Fathers took the word [i]prosopon[/i], which was used by the Sabellian heretics because it allowed for a modalistic interpretation of the Trinity, and used it in conjunction with the more concrete word [i]hypostasis[/i] in order to rule out the idea that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit were simply "masks" or "modes" of being assumed by God in a transitory fashion. The Cappadocians held that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, are true and distinct subsistences ([i]hypostaseis[/i]); and as a consequence, God is tri-[i]hypostatic[/i] and tri-existent, and is not merely a monad who assumes different faces at different times. Now, when this Cappadocian Triadological terminology is applied to the incarnation of the eternal Logos, it follows that the Son of God made man is one divine [i]hypostasis[/i] and one divine [i]prosopon[/i] in two natures, and the union of God and man in Christ is properly called a [i]hypostatic union[/i]. The use of the term [i]hypostasis[/i] affirms the concrete existence of the incarnate Logos, while the word [i]prosopon[/i] affirms that He has only one visible countenance both before and after the incarnation. Thus, Christ's human nature exists in the uncreated and eternal [i]hypostasis[/i] of the Logos, and so He is not a human [i]hypostasis[/i] or [i]prosopon[/i]. [quote name='phatcatholic' post='976180' date='May 9 2006, 09:23 AM'] its difficult to fully comprehend [. . .] [/quote] Here is a simple formula for understanding the dogma of the incarnation: Christ is only one divine [i]hypostasis[/i], and one divine [i]prosopon[/i], in two natures ([i]physeis[/i]), divine and human.
Brother Adam Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 Hey! It's my Christology exam on phatmass! This is all the same stuff lol.
phatcatholic Posted May 9, 2006 Author Posted May 9, 2006 yea, i'm tryin to make sure i have all this straight for my gad Historical Foundations class...................i think i'm about to fail the final
Apotheoun Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='976194' date='May 9 2006, 09:41 AM'] Hey! It's my Christology exam on phatmass! This is all the same stuff lol. [/quote] Dr. Hildebrand and I used to have great conversations about Christology. If you have time ask him, I'm sure he'll remember me. I'm the infamous Palamite that always brought up Eastern theological ideas in his classes.
Myles Domini Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='976197' date='May 9 2006, 05:43 PM'] yea, i'm tryin to make sure i have all this straight for my gad Historical Foundations class...................i think i'm about to fail the final [/quote] Fail? No way! How comes..?
Apotheoun Posted May 9, 2006 Posted May 9, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='976197' date='May 9 2006, 09:43 AM'] yea, i'm tryin to make sure i have all this straight for my gad Historical Foundations class...................i think i'm about to fail the final [/quote] Do you have Dr. Hildebrand for that class? This is just a suggestion, but you might try to memorize the portion of the Chalcedonian Decree that I quoted in post number three in this thread.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now