Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

In the Anne Rice book she makes a claim to philo teaching christ as a child. I have heard that 3 of the major gnostic gospels treat this like fact. Any idea about this?

Posted

So what if he did? My favorite explanation for the Gospel silence about Christ's youth is that he wanted to know obscurity, like most other poor people of the world. It is fitting with his humility. However, it may be assumed that he had many teachers growing up; Mary, Joseph, and school teachers, too. Why not?

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

I think Anne Rice's purpose behind the book (unless she is being overlly deceptive and maniacal), is to use her gifts as a writer to glorify God.

I doubt that she is trying to make historical claims as a writer, she wants to write an original and compelling novel about Jesus.

This, however unlike a certain un-learned misinformed author who doesnt do any research whatsoever when he writes about Jesus, is faithful to the Divinity and Humanity of Jesus.

SHALOM

Posted

If Philo did teach Christ so what? I highly doubt the Historicity of any Gnostic source, espcially since most of them come around the time of St Irenaeus of Lyon. If I were to speculate why these gnostic sources included Philo in the life of Christ, I would say that it was done so not to reflect history, but insert a neo-platonic agenda into their "Christian" System.

I actually have suffered through two Gnostic Tenured Professors, does this mean I hold to their system, certainly not. Infact the word Gnostic, these days gives me a head ache.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='978092' date='May 11 2006, 03:06 AM']
In the Anne Rice book she makes a claim to philo teaching christ as a child. I have heard that 3 of the major gnostic gospels treat this like fact. Any idea about this?
[/quote]

She isn't making a claim, she is writing an original story. She has in fact, rejoined the Catholic Church.
She is not doing a Dan Brown.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

well, without some evidence (which I doubt there is any) it just sounds like a goofy claim. The Holy Family did go to Egypt, but we don't know that it was Alexandria.. And I'm not sure what Philo would be doing tutoring a carpenter's son. And I'm not seeing the connection in Christ's teachings. And its not like Christ grew up in Egypt, they were there for a short time, so I guess maybe Philo was teaching Christ his ABC's when he was in kindergarten or something? :idontknow:

anyway, it sounds like something for a fictional novel more than a credible historical claim.

Posted

I know that I am going to pay LD after he finishes his PHD to teach my Daughter to count to 35. Does a reasonable salary sound like something around 200 k?

/sarcasm

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='978401' date='May 11 2006, 11:12 AM']
anyway, it sounds like something for a fictional novel more than a credible historical claim.
[/quote]

And i believe that was Anne Rice's original intention.

any research she did was merely for ideas for her novel, not her absurd historical claims a la Brown.

SHALOM

phatcatholic
Posted

in the New Advent article [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08375a.htm"]Early Historical Documents on Jesus Christ[/url] we read:[list]Philo, who dies after A.D. 40, is mainly important for the light he throws on certain modes of thought and phraseology found again in some of the Apostles. Eusebius (Hist. Eccl., II, iv) indeed preserves a legend that Philo had met St. Peter in Rome during his mission to the Emperor Caius; moreover, that in his work on the contemplative life he describes the life of the Christian Church in Alexandria founded by St. Mark, rather than that of the Essenes and Therapeutae. But it is hardly probable that Philo had heard enough of Christ and His followers to give an historical foundation to the foregoing legends.
[/list]i think that answers your question :thumbsup:

peace,
phatcatholic

toledo_jesus
Posted

I read Anne Rice's forward to the book and her long explanation of how it came about. I detected no maliciousness.

Posted

I'm actually in the middle of reading this book, and am enjoying it. So far, she has stayed true to Mary's perpetual virginity and immaculate conception by creating a story with Jesus having step-brothers from Joseph, but not blood brothers from Mary. In the novel, Philo had taken a particular interest in teaching Jesus because of how Jesus clearly stood out and excelled above the rest of the students.

It's neat to read a fictitious account of what Jesus' childhood might have been like, and the interior struggles he must have had while he gradually figured out who he was. I mean, it's something I've thought about on my own, so all I'm doing now is reading a story by a great other and how she imagines it might have been.

I hope she continues to write more books in this genre. In a weird way, it has made me contemplate on the life of Christ more deeply, even if it is just in wonderment about the parts of his life that we don't know much about. I must admit, before reading this book, when I looked at a crucifix, I saw a 33 year old Jesus and what he did in the last few years of His life--but now, I see a man who was once a child, His entire life lived for the moment He was to finally hang on that cross.

Yeah, I'm weird.

journeyman
Posted

I read a batch of those "other" gospels a couple of years back ... I do remember several dealing with the time period when the Holy Family was in Egypt, but I don't remember them mentioning what sort of education he was receiving or a teacher's name . . . If only I'd known someone would ask!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...