khouse Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 On a college message board I post on we are debating the Bible and its place in a Catholic University (keep in mind we are debating this at the most liberal "catholic" college in the US). The people against the Bible being used to be against homosexual marriage or the pro-life cause is the fact that the Bible seems to condone slavery and violence towards slaves in Exodus 21. I really do not know how to defend Exodus 21...Can I get some help from you guys here? How can we literally translate certain parts and ignore parts like that?
thessalonian Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 [quote name='khouse' post='979090' date='May 12 2006, 04:59 AM'] On a college message board I post on we are debating the Bible and its place in a Catholic University (keep in mind we are debating this at the most liberal "catholic" college in the US). The people against the Bible being used to be against homosexual marriage or the pro-life cause is the fact that the Bible seems to condone slavery and violence towards slaves in Exodus 21. I really do not know how to defend Exodus 21...Can I get some help from you guys here? How can we literally translate certain parts and ignore parts like that? [/quote] Well, I think the problem with the rendering of that passage as you and your friends have done is a lack of understanding of slavery and it's history. When we think of slavery we think of the black man captured in africa, brought accross the ocean and forced in to hard labor at a plantation, many times ripped from his or her family. There are actually several forms of slavery, in fact it is kind of a continum. Racial slavery, the kind we generally think of is what I have spoken of. There is also slavery due to wars as well as slavery that is due to criminal behavior causing incarceration. There is also what is more properly called indentured servitude which is a slavery chosen by the individual in order to pay off a dedt or to feed his family. An example of this is the story of Jacob in Gensis 29 who indentured himself to Laban for 7 years to marry his daughter, Rachael but got Leah and then indentured himself to Laban for another 7 years to finally get Rachael. She must have been some women. All this might start a thread on polygamy but let's keep it to slavery. Indentured servitude was actually a major part of economic systems even up to the second millenium (1000 AD). In this system the slave master (it is not really an owner/owned relationship in this form) agreed to provide for the slave and his family and in return the slave would provide his complete labor. It was more of a contract in lu of our present system in which money is exchanged for work. There were hardly mints around in those days and so agreements such as this were economically prudent. The system was eventually replaced by share cropping and the serf system which in many ways was not a whole lot better. The slavery that we normally think of, chattel slavery, was actually very rare until the 15th century when the spanish and portugese started going in to africa and capturing slaves. The Church has allowed forms of slavery that were either volantary, such as indentured servitude, as well as forms of slavery from a just war or due to incarceration. It has always condemned chattel slavery (slavery due to race in which the slave is "owned"). This is actually consistent with scripture and the Church has in fact been very consistent in it's position if it is examined in the light of a proper understanding of slavery. A good book on all of this is Fr. Panzer's "The Popes and Slavery". I hope that this helps. Blessings
khouse Posted May 12, 2006 Author Posted May 12, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='979095' date='May 12 2006, 05:46 AM'] Well, I think the problem with the rendering of that passage as you and your friends have done is a lack of understanding of slavery and it's history. When we think of slavery we think of the black man captured in africa, brought accross the ocean and forced in to hard labor at a plantation, many times ripped from his or her family. There are actually several forms of slavery, in fact it is kind of a continum. Racial slavery, the kind we generally think of is what I have spoken of. There is also slavery due to wars as well as slavery that is due to criminal behavior causing incarceration. There is also what is more properly called indentured servitude which is a slavery chosen by the individual in order to pay off a dedt or to feed his family. An example of this is the story of Jacob in Gensis 29 who indentured himself to Laban for 7 years to marry his daughter, Rachael but got Leah and then indentured himself to Laban for another 7 years to finally get Rachael. She must have been some women. All this might start a thread on polygamy but let's keep it to slavery. Indentured servitude was actually a major part of economic systems even up to the second millenium (1000 AD). In this system the slave master (it is not really an owner/owned relationship in this form) agreed to provide for the slave and his family and in return the slave would provide his complete labor. It was more of a contract in lu of our present system in which money is exchanged for work. There were hardly mints around in those days and so agreements such as this were economically prudent. The system was eventually replaced by share cropping and the serf system which in many ways was not a whole lot better. The slavery that we normally think of, chattel slavery, was actually very rare until the 15th century when the spanish and portugese started going in to africa and capturing slaves. The Church has allowed forms of slavery that were either volantary, such as indentured servitude, as well as forms of slavery from a just war or due to incarceration. It has always condemned chattel slavery (slavery due to race in which the slave is "owned"). This is actually consistent with scripture and the Church has in fact been very consistent in it's position if it is examined in the light of a proper understanding of slavery. A good book on all of this is Fr. Panzer's "The Popes and Slavery". I hope that this helps. Blessings [/quote] Thanks for the help. I basically posted what you wrote and this was the response I got: [quote] So, you are taking an interpretive view of the bible, re-analyzing it for the contemporary period. that means it can be re-interpreted in other sections too. however, if u are taking a literal position, u are essentially arguing that capitalism is based upon (wage) slavery according to the bible. so does that make u an anti-capitalist? on the other hand, it sounds like it would make u in favor of arranged marriage, whereby the daughter is the property of the father to give over to a suitor. now, i havta tell ya, as a commie im well schooled in the history of slavery, and ive nearly never read anywhere where terms like indentured servitude and slavery were used interchangably. slaves are property, it is an owned/owner system by definition. of course the slavery of BCE is different from more modern racist chattel slavery, but it is still one human being the property of another. now, i would debate with you about the church's position on chattel slavery, when the history of spanish and portuegese churches was to condone chattel slavery thru the cain and abel story to explain racialism, but that would be going waaaay off topic even for this thread. but slavery is slavery, and the bible condones the beating of slaves (which you do not address), the normalcy of slavery, the sometimes not-as-poor treatment of slaves, and on and on and on. slaves in rome, greece, egypt, or anywhere else were not happy with their situations, would have been free given the choice, and revolted in class war when they had the chance. if u take the bible literally, u have to condone slavery, and so the real question is whether. and we do not get to pick and choose what out of the bible we read literally. everything must be either taken literally or set against contemporary times in order to decide where it belongs. [/quote] What would be the best way to refute all his claims?
jasJis Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 REsponse would be to address their lack of logic and reason. It's not an either/or situation of either taking everything literally or not. Address the core fundamentals of the principles. Slaves in the old testament were not treated as the same as African slaves who were considered as not human or sub-human. The principle of being human has been steady. Different economic times and cultural issues can and do change. The issue of homosexuality is at it's core, the direction of sexual love. When rightly understood as unitive and procreative everything falls into place. What's wrong with adultery or pre-marital sex, whether homo or hetero? What have a commandment against it? Is the commandment only to protect marriage, or is a core moral principal at play? Homosexual sex is mutual masturbation, just as premarital sex, promiscuous sex, contraceptive sex, etc. The mistake is the hatred people show toward same sex attractions, as if that is more disordered than infidelity. Infidelity is truthfully graver than homosexuality, though that doesn't make either act any less wrong.
thessalonian Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 My response on first glance is cast your pearls elsewhere. This guy is a know it all who knows nothing. He has no grasp of historical slavery. My only source is not fr. panzer. I spent 6 months studying this issue. Protestant and Catholics scholars. He simply does not know what he is talking about. The Bible itself proves him wrong. "You shall not oppress the foriegner". Race based slavery was not allowed in the Hebrew scriptures. Was it ever done? I don't know. But there is no question that much of the slavery talked about in scripture is indentured servitude. It is simple historical fact that this was a significant part of the hebrew economy. Chattel slavery was not. Race based slavery was not common mid 2 millenium. Of course we have to consider culture and language in the historical context. Language changes and so does culture. Let's take the word tribulation. It meant the thressing of grain before John the Apostle used it as a word to describe trials that men would face in their lives. Where in scripture does it say that the master owned the slave? It simply doesn't! Where is his historical background to back up his statements. He has presented none but handwaving. He can claim the same and I will try to give you some info directly out of Fr. Panzer's book. He clearly has not studied the writings of the Popes and councils. Yes, some Catholics did participate in chattel slavery in spain and portugaul. But this was not the will of the magesterium who consistently condemned with the penalty of excommunication anyone who wrongfully held in bondage someone who was not of his own free will an indentured servant or a just war prisoner or a criminal. Simple fact. The Popes also freed many slaves. Was the Church big on other forms of slavery? No and eventually they played a key role in ridding the world of slavery. Cain and abel story? No, I think it was ham that some used. no popes and no councils however in any official statement used such things to justify race based slavery. He simply doesn't know what he is talking about. That some Catholic or a group in some part of the world didn't go along with the teaching of the Church does not make a doctrine in the Catholic Church. Your friend is not really worth debating unless you feel there are others watching who will benefit from the continued discussion. You are a better judge of that than I. If you need more let me know. Blessings
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now