N/A Gone Posted May 13, 2006 Posted May 13, 2006 Just to be annoying to a recently graduated friend of mine that enjoys apologetics I told him that the sacrifice of Christ on the cross did not matter because He knew that He was going to be ressurected. Thus he did not truly sacrifice himself. It isnt suicide jumping from the bridge if you have a bungy on your back. How would you argue someone on this issue? A common phrase is "jesus died for your sins" but what is death if you knew you were coming back? In love we respect love because the risk it takes, God took a risk by creating and loving us. Not a risk to himself, but a risk of rejection and in that we have perfect love. But how is the sacrifice of Christ valid if there was nothing risked?
Era Might Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 That's a pretty nihilistic view of things. Hope does not negate sacrifice; it gives it its full meaning. Sacrifice isn't just the giving up of something good for the sake of giving up something good, but for the hope of a greater good. In Christ's case, it is the hope of the resurrection.
N/A Gone Posted May 14, 2006 Author Posted May 14, 2006 what exactly did he sacrifice? because he knew he would be coming back..
Era Might Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 He sacrificed his life, and he got it back again. Sacrifice is fleeting. All Christians know that we will get back our sacrifices tenfold. That is the eternal hope of sacrifice.
uruviel Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='980559' date='May 13 2006, 05:47 PM'] Just to be annoying to a recently graduated friend of mine that enjoys apologetics I told him that the sacrifice of Christ on the cross did not matter because He knew that He was going to be ressurected. Thus he did not truly sacrifice himself. It isnt suicide jumping from the bridge if you have a bungy on your back. How would you argue someone on this issue? A common phrase is "jesus died for your sins" but what is death if you knew you were coming back? In love we respect love because the risk it takes, God took a risk by creating and loving us. Not a risk to himself, but a risk of rejection and in that we have perfect love. But how is the sacrifice of Christ valid if there was nothing risked? [/quote] ok ok. Tell me something. If you knew you were gonna die the way Christ did and yet you knew you would rise would you feel good? NO you wouldn't. Christ called for comfort from God and He gave Him none. Christ's sacrifice HAD to be done if you wanted to make to Heaven. That bridge comparison is totally off. btw. lol. I don't get what your saying. The hope of rising again did NOT AT ALL ease His pain. He was in the midst of sin. He felt dirty, He felt like he had commited a magaillion sins. Not only did he feel physical pain, but it was torture being in the midst and the direct middle of sin for Him because he is so perfect. And what most people don't realize is that EVERY day he's suffering. Everyday that we reject Him, everyday that we forget Him, everyday that we tear another hole in His heart is more pain for Him to bear. And yet His love and mercy keeps on coming. So don't try to tell me that what was the point of His sacrifice if He knew He would rise. And even if your just asking how to defend Christ, there it is. It's not hard. Christ died for us. For us to not go to hell someone would have to bear the pain. And He did. That's it. [quote name='Revprodeji' post='980625' date='May 13 2006, 07:42 PM'] what exactly did he sacrifice? because he knew he would be coming back.. [/quote] What do you mean what did He sacrifice!? He had his flesh ripped from his body, He experienced physical pain no man on earth can begin to imagine!!! Excuse me if I come across as rude but Christ suffered. What He suffered we may never experience, but we do know that He sacrificed His body. His torn and beaten body and sacrifices for being the midst of sin were what saved us. Please stop questioning Christ's sacrifice.
CatholicCid Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 I'd approach that question the same way uruviel just did... You skip the means and look to the end... He not only died for us, but suffered... As he knew he would give his own life and take it, he knew he would greatly suffer... I'd also say the bungee jump/suicide analogy is off base... Christ did not "almost die" or save himself from death... He took it and the pain that went with it... So it is somewhat too different for use... I can't really think of any comparable analogy.
N/A Gone Posted May 14, 2006 Author Posted May 14, 2006 [quote name='uruviel' post='980699' date='May 13 2006, 09:17 PM'] Please stop questioning Christ's sacrifice. [/quote] friend, I am simply presenting an argument that is something someone could and has brought up in the past to us.
uruviel Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 I know I"m really sorry I did get really heated up in that post. I just got frusterated when you asked a question about His suffering. He suffered. Thats it. And He suffered more than you know. It just got me heated. lol. It's ok though. As you can see, everyone agree's with the same thing.
N/A Gone Posted May 14, 2006 Author Posted May 14, 2006 But alot of people suffer... The fact that the sacrifice had a bunge cord is the issue
Fidei Defensor Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='981122' date='May 14 2006, 05:35 PM'] But alot of people suffer... The fact that the sacrifice had a bunge cord is the issue [/quote] But remember that even Christ had doubts about what was to come. He prayed that the cup would pass from him. His divine nature knew that his death and resurrection would redeem us all, but the suffering and doubt he experienced as human is what redeemed us. Just because he knew he would rise from the dead does not necesarily mean that he had a bunge cord. He still had to suffer, he still had to die. And like I mentioned, his human nature still doubted the divine plan.
rkwright Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 aside from all the physical sufferings... I'm sure the actual atonement for our sins had to be some great burden, something beyond comprehension...
uruviel Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='981122' date='May 14 2006, 05:35 PM'] But alot of people suffer... The fact that the sacrifice had a bunge cord is the issue [/quote] Your bungee cord idea is annoying me. I'm sorry. Jesus did NOT have a bungee cord! He fell on the rocks!! And THEN he was risen!! He suffereed the pain with the doubt of the plan!! [quote name='fidei defensor' post='981147' date='May 14 2006, 06:46 PM'] But remember that even Christ had doubts about what was to come. He prayed that the cup would pass from him. His divine nature knew that his death and resurrection would redeem us all, but the suffering and doubt he experienced as human is what redeemed us. Just because he knew he would rise from the dead does not necesarily mean that he had a bunge cord. He still had to suffer, he still had to die. And like I mentioned, his human nature still doubted the divine plan. [/quote] You got it. [quote name='rkwright' post='981321' date='May 15 2006, 12:36 AM'] aside from all the physical sufferings... I'm sure the actual atonement for our sins had to be some great burden, something beyond comprehension... [/quote] oh wow I can't even imagine. As I was saying in my last post, He was in the center of sin. Can you imagine the feeling of every single sin ever commited in the world on YOUR soul at 1 time? No. His perfect and beautiful soul was consumed by evil. It was more than the word of description "torture" can cover.
CatholicCid Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote]Your bungee cord idea is annoying me. I'm sorry. Jesus did NOT have a bungee cord! He fell on the rocks!! And THEN he [b]rose[/b]!! He suffereed the pain with the doubt of the plan!! [/quote] Sorry... Trivial matter, it was just bugging me Makes it more obvious that he rose through his own power just Once again, sorry... little thing just eating at my brain
uruviel Posted May 16, 2006 Posted May 16, 2006 I still don't get what the fuss is about. DID HE OR DID HE NOT SUFFER THE PAIN? DID HE FEEL THE PHSICAL PAIN? DID HE FEEL THE DOUBT? DID HE HAVE MENTAL AND SPIRITUAL AND EMOTIONAL PAIN!? the answer to that is YES so why do you question it?!?!?!?!? Just because someone gets up after a very hard fall doesn't mean they didn't feel the pain from the fall. And they could have thought that when they fell, they could have never gotten back up because it was clouded by fear! Maybe God felt that too!! Why do you doubt Him!??!
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted May 16, 2006 Posted May 16, 2006 (edited) Thats kind of like saying that those who fight in wars are doing a useless thing, because they are fighting that there might be peace? You can still go into fighting a war you know you are gonna win? Knowing there will be peace in the end? SHALOM Edited May 16, 2006 by MC IMaGiNaZUN
uruviel Posted May 19, 2006 Posted May 19, 2006 that's an ok anaolgy. Good job. But the fact of the matter is, God felt it. Why? For you. If He didn't land on the rocks you wouldn't have been saved. If the bungee cord caught him you would NOT have been saved! To save you SOMEONE has to feel the pain and Christ did! why doubt that? It tears me up to think WHY would you ever doubt the pain He went through???? Who are you to question it?? [quote name='Revprodeji' post='981122' date='May 14 2006, 05:35 PM'] But alot of people suffer... [/quote] yeah do you know why ppl suffer? Its because God gave US a chance to share in it with Him! i'm so glad he gave me that oportunity! Because of the guilt I felt for His suffering, my guilt is relieved when I can suffer with Him! Don't you see? And when we suffer, we help him save souls!!
jswranch Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 Jumping infront of a bullet for a buddy is not suicide. That is what Jesus did.
kateri05 Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 the root of your question is the hypostatic union unless you're a Docesitist, Arian, Apollinarian or Adoptionist (who can tell i'm taking a Christology course at this exact moment? , ie. if you are a Christian!, then you believe that Jesus was fully human AND fully divine, thus you have to apply the reality of the Incarnation to the sacrifice of Jesus on the Cross. Sure, in His divinity, He knew God'sl plan, etc etc. However, factor in His human nature and then you will really understand how Jesus suffers. if Jesus is fully human, then He has taken upon Himself all that it means to be human. This includes a weak human nature (thus making Him susceptible to temptation by the Devil, although He does not give in) and a genuine understanding and comprehension of the true dignity and value of the gift of earthly human life and thus the fear of losing it, no matter what is known to be over the horizon. so, even tho He knows of God's plan for the resurrection, as a fully human man, He still has the fear and dread of losing His earthly life. then, as Luther discusses quite well pre-heresy, Christ took upon Himself the sins of all mankind even tho He Himself was truly innocent. COnsequently, He suffered in a unique, horrible way the effects of that sinfulness upon His conscience. because the alienation and damnation that is the due of all sin was NOT due to Him who was Sinless and Full of Grace above all others, taking upon Himself the reality of that sinfulness made Him suffer even MORE than those who had sinned because it was not His own sinfulness to bear in the first place. So the Agony in the Garden as well as the "my God, My God" cry upon the cross give evidence to His mental and spiritual anguish that He suffered because of our sins perhaps even over and above the historically documentable physical tortures that He suffered. so yes, Jesus suffered really and truly. and to say otherwise is not only to deny in someway Jesus' humanity (that somehow, like the Nestorians, it is impossible for God to truly suffer "in the flesh") but also to negate in some way our actual sanctification. for only the perfect sacrifice can overcome our punishment due to sin, that of the Suffering Servant prohphesyied by Isaiah, and if the Servant did not suffer, He did not accomplish our salvation and Christianity is worthless. whew. Christology hurts my head
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now