betinabean Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 Does the church teach that Jesus was nailed to the cross through the hands or the wrists? I heard that it's impossible for someone to hang from their hands but
Pio Nono Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 JMJ 5/14 - Fifth Sunday of Easter (St. Mathias) betinabean, The Church has no official teaching on this matter. The Bible does say that Jesus was nailed through His hands, but let's remember that there is no Hebrew word for "wrist" - in fact, their word for hand encompasses what we would call the wrist. Modern research has shown that it's not very likely that someone would have been crucified through what we call the hands, but rather the wrists. I hope this helps. Yours, Pio Nono
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 As a side note, I've always heard the wrists thing too (that hands isn't possible), but I recall hearing something more recently where someone studied the issue scientifically and concluded that crucifiction through the hands is perfectly possible.. I wish I had a link.. This could be false but I wanted to throw it out there. I'll see if I can find something about that. [quote]For the sake of expediency, the victim was probably affixed to the cross by ropes, nails, or some combination of the two. In popular depictions of crucifixion (possibly derived from a literal reading of the translated description in the Gospel of John, of Jesus' wounds being "in the hands"), the Victim is shown supported only by nails driven straight through the feet and the palms of the hands, which is possible, if there was a foot-rest to relieve the weight; on their own, the hands could not support the full body weight. Another possibility, that does not require tying, is that the nails were inserted just above the wrist, between the two bones of the forearm (the radius and the ulna). The nails could also be driven through the wrist, in a space between four carpal bones (which is the location shown in the Shroud of Turin). As some historians have suggested, the Gospel word χειρ (cheir) that is translated as "hand" may have in fact included everything below the mid-forearm. Indeed, Acts 12:7 uses this word to report chains falling off from Peter's "hands", although the chains would be around what we would call "wrists". This shows that the semantic range of χειρ is wider than the English "hand", and can incorporate nails through the wrist. Another possibility, suggested by Frederick Zugibe, is that the nails may have been driven in on an angle, entering in the palm in the crease that delineates the bulky region at the base of the thumb, and exiting in the wrist, passing through the carpal tunnel. A sedile, or a foot-rest, was often attached to the cross, for the purpose of taking the man's weight off the wrists. This was most likely a simple peg or slab of wood, upon which the man would rest the feet. A new study and a documentory on the Geographic channel "Quest for Truth: The Crucifixion," as well as a brief news article on the experiment and the documentory, have shown that a person can be suspended by the wrists. As the ankles are nailed to the side of the cross producing little strain on the wrists. They also say [b]the palms are a likely place for the nails as it would cause the maximum amount of pain and trauma[/b].[/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now