Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Tell me this Catholic Church doesn't look like...


Recommended Posts

Posted

Okay, I don't think the Church is [i]that[/i] bad. I mean, I wouldn't have designed it, but man, people here are really tearing it apart.

I like the baptismal font.

toledo_jesus
Posted

I think the corpus is a bit stupid looking without the cross. I'm not exactly sure what point they were trying to make.

Posted

I think they were trying to allude to the cross with the lighting on the ceiling.

Posted

I think that when you walk into a church, you should KNOW you are walking into one. If there wasn't a sign saying this was a Catholic Church...or any type of church for that matter, I would think it was some place to have small concerts or something. There aren't any other statues besides the dangling Corpus? Yikes! :blink: But this is just MHO.... :wacko:

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='981134' date='May 14 2006, 06:09 PM']At long as there is a tabernacle with Jesus, its a Catholic Church.[/quote];) you got it!


[quote name='Theoketos' post='981161' date='May 14 2006, 07:19 PM']The Corpus is a little wierd, but no it does not look like a lodge.[/quote]agreed :yes:

Posted

I don't necessarily think that churches [b]must[/b] all look like traditional Cathedrals to be beautiful (although, I personally think they are the most beautiful), as I can appreciate well-done modern architecture as well... but, having a crucifix is very important. Other than the "hanging" corpus, this church ain't that bad, for the architectural style it's going for. Art/architecture evolves, and as long as it remains holy and reverant, and exceeds and represents a well-done and superior form in comparison to secular buildings, to glorify God, then it's a matter of taste.

Posted

all the walls are plain white! no stain glass windows, nothing, where are the statues of saints? That makes me very sad. There is something very wrong with such architecture, for catholic churches. It looks more like a meeting hall. Sad thing is, many of these parishes before they were built, they tore down beautiful traditional church, only to replace them with modern horrors such as that.

Posted

[quote name='MC Just' post='981469' date='May 15 2006, 11:15 AM']
all the walls are plain white! no stain glass windows, nothing, where are the statues of saints? That makes me very sad. There is something very wrong with such architecture, for catholic churches. It looks more like a meeting hall. Sad thing is, many of these parishes before they were built, they tore down beautiful traditional church, only to replace them with modern horrors such as that.
[/quote]
Well, we only have this one picture. We don't know whether or not they are representing saints in other parts of the building, on the walls we can't see, etc. I agree that most modern churches do a poor job of doing this, but we can't just blanket [b]all[/b] modern architecture as being bad. There are some very well-done modern churches which have obviously made it a point to create a building that is unique, beatiful, and superior.

It is true that too many modern churches simply are content with being bland and "average". I too think this is wrong, as our churches should all glorify God, and for this reason should stand out and be better than any buildings surrounding it.

I think artsy for the sake of being artsy is bad too. Our art and architecture should be created with the intention of increasing holiness and glorifying God, not to glorify the artist or architect who created it.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='dUSt' post='981476' date='May 15 2006, 12:23 PM']
Well, we only have this one picture. We don't know whether or not they are representing saints in other parts of the building, on the walls we can't see, etc. I agree that most modern churches do a poor job of doing this, but we can't just blanket [b]all[/b] modern architecture as being bad. There are some very well-done modern churches which have obviously made it a point to create a building that is unique, beatiful, and superior.

It is true that too many modern churches simply are content with being bland and "average". I too think this is wrong, as our churches should all glorify God, and for this reason should stand out and be better than any buildings surrounding it.

I think artsy for the sake of being artsy is bad too. Our art and architecture should be created with the intention of increasing holiness and glorifying God, not to glorify the artist or architect who created it.
[/quote]


true..I looked at the site with all the other pics, the other parts of the church as just as bad...

[img]http://www.pano4you.com/stmaryoftheangels/images/0624.jpg[/img]

Here's saint mary of the angels, or is it fredrica kreuger?

[img]http://www.pano4you.com/stmaryoftheangels/images/0618.jpg[/img]

is this a church or a school? Exterior.

here's the site

[url="http://www.pano4you.com/stmaryoftheangels/#"]http://www.pano4you.com/stmaryoftheangels/#[/url]

[img]http://www.pano4you.com/stmaryoftheangels/flat/0655wide.jpg[/img]

Edited by MC Just
Noel's angel
Posted

It looks like a lecture theatre and not a very nice one at that. I do agree with dUSt though, not all new Churches are ugly. My parish Church was rebuilt in 1993 and it doesn't look like a theatre or a meeting hall

[img]http://file003.bebo.com/large/2006/05/15/19/17968277a827811436b28152456l.jpg[/img]

(side altar)

Posted

I agree with dust too. Not all new churches look like this one.

This one still isn't very easy on the eyes though!!! :P:

missionarybelle
Posted

^ditto

Posted

The reason some church's appear the way they do is before 2002 liturgical consultants before building a new church was not mandated, now all dioceses need to have liturgical consultants before the building of a new church.

Posted

Also, keep in mind that this church is in Singapore, which is a totally different culture, where this style of architecture may be more condusive to a feeling of holiness.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Yeah, I guess we didn't get that little fact previously.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='981720' date='May 15 2006, 02:57 PM']
Yeah, I guess we didn't get that little fact previously.
[/quote]
Probably not because of any type of agenda. :yawn:

homeschoolmom
Posted

I'm sure it was an innocent mistake.

PadreSantiago
Posted

what the heck! Jesus looks like a mummy or an alien...that's creepy. I want my lord and savior to have blonde hair and blue eyes, with fair white skin.

DemonSlayer
Posted

Interesting looking church, nothing like I've seen before.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

The Masonic Lodge looks more like no wait alot like the Oval Office, or white house press room you know where ever the Presindent speaks than it does a church. Dont yah think?!

Edited by KnightofChrist

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...