Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

So I attended one of the final meetings of my RCIA group last evening -- though we are no longer candidates/catechumens, we are still meeting weekly with the sponsors for "transitional" value. Anyway, toward the end the group got into a discussion about the Eucharist and how (courtesy of me) it is a grave sin for non-Catholics to receive. One of the sponsors -- an older women whom I like very, very much -- pipes up and says, "You know, that's one of the things I have a lot of trouble with. Why can't they receive Jesus? It doesn't make sense to me." The RCIA instructor echoed this! Then she went on to say that, when she is travelling and can't find a Catholic parish, she often attends Protestant services and receives communion. "Jesus is Jesus," she said. Alarmed but trying to remain diplomatic, I said, "I guess the question is, is it really the Body of Christ at a non-Catholic service?" To which she replied, "Well, I don't really look at it that way. It's a symbolic thing -- if I approach it as the Body of Christ, then it is for me." Umm... OK. I tried to explain to her and the group the official Catholic teaching on such matters, to which she replied, "So what?" I could see where the conversation was going -- bad feelings -- so I dropped it.

This kind of thing, which has occured more than once over the year-long RCIA session, really troubles me. It troubles me because there are clearly new Catholics in the group who do not know what the Church teaches on many matters, do not study theology at all, and are easily influenced by dissenting voices because they don't know any better. I love my RCIA instructors and the sponsors, but there has just been too much wishy-washy teaching going on. Again, I may not have been affected by it, but I'm sure my less-educated brothers and sisters in the group have been.

End of rant.

Noel's angel
Posted

That is horrid. I'm sorry that this is the sort of thing that happens. We don't have programmes like that over here-our priests do it themselves. It's why I worry a lot about the delegation of such tasks to lay people. I know thee are lay people who are well-quailfied to undertake such tasks, however it seems like a vast majority of these 'liturgical directors', 'music directors' and RCIA instructors really don't know, or care about what they are doing and teaching.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)
:rolleyes: :maddest:

Incredible. She is a protestant!

Actually this is a matter to bring to the priests attention and if he will not act, it needs to be raised to the Bishop who has ultimate responsibility for all catechesis in the Diocese. These people need to be removed from instucting anyone! Please write the priest first and if you get no response go up the chain. Out of love for new Catholics do this. In love for these people we must admit they are heretics and for the good of their souls as well (1 Cor 5) they must be dealt with. That is love. Edited by thessalonian
blovedwolfofgod
Posted

For reasons such as this I will be a volunteer instructor of RCIA. Sad that someone like me is gonna have to step in to protect our layity from the instructors. I would encourage anyone else who know two cents about anything to do this as well. We are in need of good, orthodox catechists, not heretics with a master catechist certification.

Posted

It's a travesty when those responsible for RCIA don't teach the faith. People who knowingly do it will probably be fitted for a millstone at some point...

Posted

Yes, indeed write the priest of the parish. He should be notified of such goings on. I have a friend in another state that went through this and I was so worried that she wouldn't be taught the truth. Which I'm not sure if she was or not. Very sad. Pray very hard that the right people get into these teaching positions and not wishy-washy instructors that many of the RCIA programs have. This is exactly why my brother-in-laws had private instruction instead. :ohno:

toledo_jesus
Posted

you definitely want her corrected. she's got a lot of responsibility, and she should be held to a high standard.

Posted

I can't believe she said that! It appears she is enforcing her views/opinions without regard to church teachings--very dangerous! I was truly blessed when I did RCIA because our Pastor did ALL instruction. At my current church, the Deacon presides over the group and is there to make sure everything is properly explained and understood.

Posted

[quote name='Nathan' post='983607' date='May 18 2006, 12:37 AM']
So I attended one of the final meetings of my RCIA group last evening -- though we are no longer candidates/catechumens, we are still meeting weekly with the sponsors for "transitional" value. Anyway, toward the end the group got into a discussion about the Eucharist and how (courtesy of me) it is a grave sin for non-Catholics to receive. One of the sponsors -- an older women whom I like very, very much -- pipes up and says, "You know, that's one of the things I have a lot of trouble with. Why can't they receive Jesus? It doesn't make sense to me." The RCIA instructor echoed this! Then she went on to say that, when she is travelling and can't find a Catholic parish, she often attends Protestant services and receives communion. "Jesus is Jesus," she said. Alarmed but trying to remain diplomatic, I said, "I guess the question is, is it really the Body of Christ at a non-Catholic service?" To which she replied, "Well, I don't really look at it that way. It's a symbolic thing -- if I approach it as the Body of Christ, then it is for me." Umm... OK. I tried to explain to her and the group the official Catholic teaching on such matters, to which she replied, "So what?" I could see where the conversation was going -- bad feelings -- so I dropped it.

This kind of thing, which has occured more than once over the year-long RCIA session, really troubles me. It troubles me because there are clearly new Catholics in the group who do not know what the Church teaches on many matters, do not study theology at all, and are easily influenced by dissenting voices because they don't know any better. I love my RCIA instructors and the sponsors, but there has just been too much wishy-washy teaching going on. Again, I may not have been affected by it, but I'm sure my less-educated brothers and sisters in the group have been.

End of rant.
[/quote]


And people worry about the Da Vinci Code :idontknow: when people such as this run the RCIA...
That's why I do it myself (with a little help from others,.... but I take responsibility)

thessalonian
Posted

Noone has a right to insert their own views in to what is Church teaching in such a setting!

Posted

RCIA is so hit and miss ... depending on the parish, you can get heterodox or orthodox instruction.

In my case, we had people who a week before Easter didn't know that Jesus is God. They were confirmed/baptised at the Vigil service same as I was.

It seems to me that all to often following the form is more important than ensuring that the heart of the rite is intact, that people actually appreciate the gravity of the things they assent to -- teachers as well as people entering the church.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...