Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Greetings! I’m new to this board, as you can see. I’m Roman Catholic, coming through the RCIA around two or three years ago. (Please, if this is in the wrong forum, forgive me.)

This is my question: clearly, magic in this world is evil, but what about in games or books? Is Tolkien magic evil? What about Harry Potter?

This is a question I have greatly debated with family and friends, and would like your opinions, if you would be so kind. Used to be, role-playing was a great fun of mine, and I’m a big Tolkien fan, but for a while now I’ve been wondering exactly what defines fantasy magic as ‘evil’ or ‘alright.’ Personally, while I find Ouija boards and such quite dangerous, but I wonder about other games and books.

Edited by Augustine
aalpha1989
Posted

Other people here will give you much better explanations than mine...I just thought I would start it :). In Tolkien, the magic comes from a higher power. Gandalf is not the source of his own power. He subjects himself to the higher power (God) and does not use the magic to control destinies, lives. Gandalf uses his magic (not really 'his' magic...) for God's will. Notice in Tolkien, whoever does use their power controllingly, for their own benefit, IS evil.
I don't know if Harry Potter is evil, I have heard a lot of arguments either way...I suppose that it is fiction, and so the magic in it can not be judged either way, because in Rowling's pretend world God doesn't exist anyway. If there WAS a school of 'magic' in the real world, it would be evil (at least if it was like Rowling's). Anyway, that was kindof a half explanation, I'll let the smarter people do the rest...

toledo_jesus
Posted

if you try to take fictional magic and make it real, then that's not right. But enjoying tales of the fantastic is no sin.


IDLENESS, HOWEVER, IS! Reading for pleasure is therefore sinful.

aalpha1989
Posted

reading for pleasure is sinful? Are you serious or were you kidding? Idleness is sinful....but since when is pleasure idleness? Playing basketball for fun isn't sinful, neither is reading.

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='984037' date='May 17 2006, 07:24 PM']
if you try to take fictional magic and make it real, then that's not right. But enjoying tales of the fantastic is no sin.

IDLENESS, HOWEVER, IS! Reading for pleasure is therefore sinful.
[/quote]
:getaclue:

[quote name='aalpha1989' post='984074' date='May 17 2006, 07:53 PM']
reading for pleasure is sinful? Are you serious or were you kidding? Idleness is sinful....but since when is pleasure idleness? Playing basketball for fun isn't sinful, neither is reading.
[/quote]
He's kidding. :rolleyes:

Every book needs to be judged on its own, and perhaps really impressionable young people should be supervised in what they read (fantasy -- or anything else!) but there's nothing inherently wrong with fantasy fiction. Especially, as it's called "2nd word" fantasy -- stories that do not take place on everyday Earth. There's no way to imagine spells in a fanatsy setting like that having any resemblance to the pagan/wicca/magic stuff that people attempt for real.

Posted

If you're evaluating the magic system of a given fantasy universe in a game, it ultimately requires a prudential judgement. I'd take much greater caution in a pen-and-paper RPG than in a video game.

In terms of books, I'd say the magic in it really depends on both how it "works" and how the book, narrator, theme, etc. react to it. For example, if magic were sourced from the bodies of sacrificed children in a given universe, but the story showed how evil such a thing is, then I wouldn't be worried. However, if it were some hidden power that were naturally inside of people that magicians learned to unlock, and basically the theme stratified people into suckers and magicians... that wouldn't be good.

Tolkien was Catholic, and the magic in his stuff seems to have a different character than most of the DND-type stuff. The magic in it is much more mysterious and less like "from my spellbook, I cast magic missile at the kobold."

Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='984398' date='May 18 2006, 08:09 AM']
In terms of books, I'd say the magic in it really depends on both how it "works" and how the book, narrator, theme, etc. react to it. For example, if magic were sourced from the bodies of sacrificed children in a given universe, but the story showed how evil such a thing is, then I wouldn't be worried. [/quote]
:ninja:







:whistle:

Posted

As long as you know fact from fiction, and don't have issues confusing the two, I don't have a problem with fictional magic, be it in novel or RPG format.

Posted

Ah, while MMORPGs were really what I played, I did some pen and paper RPGs also. I see you are familiar with Dungeons and Dragons scardella, which has been one of the games principally on my mind. I am familiar with the game, having read the rulebook, and I understand its concepts. Personally, I’m strongly against ‘clerical’ magic, or any kind of ‘powers’ derived from gods (lest it be from the true God, but should that really be imitated in [i]fantasy games?[/i]), but I’m unsure about ‘arcane’ magic. My friend (who is also Catholic) and I have discussed it, and I believe we came to the conclusion that [i]if[/i] it was an innate magic within the character (like Tolkien’s elves) and not really a sort of ‘hidden power’ without recourse to demons or false gods, but a natural part of the imagined world, then it would be acceptable.

Even then, however, I wonder if we not just should avoid it altogether, as an unnecessary temptation. Or should we just avoid games in which magic is from ‘gods’? I have a feeling this debate falls upon the nature of magic in itself, and why it is evil.

Any more thoughts? (Thank you for your responses already).

Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='984435' date='May 18 2006, 09:22 AM']
As long as you know fact from fiction, and don't have issues confusing the two, I don't have a problem with fictional magic, be it in novel or RPG format.
[/quote]

I still think that it can be damaging to someone even if you are able to separate fact from fiction, especially if you're vulnerable for some reason.

[quote name='Augustine' post='984522' date='May 18 2006, 11:24 AM']
Ah, while MMORPGs were really what I played, I did some pen and paper RPGs also. I see you are familiar with Dungeons and Dragons scardella, which has been one of the games principally on my mind. I am familiar with the game, having read the rulebook, and I understand its concepts. Personally, I’m strongly against ‘clerical’ magic, or any kind of ‘powers’ derived from gods (lest it be from the true God, but should that really be imitated in [i]fantasy games?[/i]), but I’m unsure about ‘arcane’ magic. My friend (who is also Catholic) and I have discussed it, and I believe we came to the conclusion that [i]if[/i] it was an innate magic within the character (like Tolkien’s elves) and not really a sort of ‘hidden power’ without recourse to demons or false gods, but a natural part of the imagined world, then it would be acceptable.

Even then, however, I wonder if we not just should avoid it altogether, as an unnecessary temptation. Or should we just avoid games in which magic is from ‘gods’? I have a feeling this debate falls upon the nature of magic in itself, and why it is evil.

Any more thoughts? (Thank you for your responses already).
[/quote]

I can see how MMORPG's would fall somewhere in between traditional pen-and-paper RPG's and regular video game RPG's. When I had my initial conversion, I needed to avoid fantasy stuff like the plague. Right now, I'd probably be ok w/ playing RPG's as long as I knew that they were at least practicing Christians.

In PnP RPG's, a lot of the susceptibility to error comes from how much you wind up identifying with your character and the freeform nature of it. If the cosmos/mechanics of the game implicitly/explicitly wound up being anti-Christian/anti-Catholic, then you should backslash the game mechanics. It's entirely possible to have a gameworld where magic exists but the manner in which it exists manages to reflect a Christian worldview.

Posted

[quote name='Augustine' post='984522' date='May 18 2006, 11:24 AM']
[...] we came to the conclusion that [i]if[/i] it was an innate magic within the character (like Tolkien’s elves) and not really a sort of ‘hidden power’ without recourse to demons or false gods, but a natural part of the imagined world, then it would be acceptable.

Even then, however, I wonder if we not just should avoid it altogether, as an unnecessary temptation. Or should we just avoid games in which magic is from ‘gods’? I have a feeling this debate falls upon the nature of magic in itself, and why it is evil.

Any more thoughts? (Thank you for your responses already).
[/quote]
My question is: is reading about fantasy magic actually a serious temptation to anyone? I can think of a whole lot more dangerous everyday temptations than fantasy novels!

I write fantasy (and science fiction). There are many valid reasons for chosing that genre: allegory, symbolism, amplification of themes, and best of all -- disassociation of sensitive subjects. I can deal with serious religious and moral issues in a fantasy setting, and the setting and mythological trappings let me slip in under the reader's radar. In real-world/mainstream settings it is very hard to make any kind of religious statement without people immediately thinking you're preaching at them. There are many well-known Christian fantasy writers, who could not tell the stories they do without the tropes inherent in the genre.

If it tempts [i]you[/i] to go try witchcraft, then yeah, don't read the stuff, but there is nothing inherently wrong with fantasy itself.

Posted

I think people tend to have some really strange ideas about what constitutes magic in fiction. I have never, for example, considered Tolkein's elves "magical". Here are several definitions of magic:

[i] 1. any art that invokes supernatural powers

2.magic trick: an illusory feat; considered magical by naive observers

3.charming: possessing or using or characteristic of or appropriate to supernatural powers; "charming incantations"; "magic signs that protect against adverse influence"; "a magical spell"; "'tis now the very witching time of night"- Shakespeare; "wizard wands"; "wizardly powers" [/i]

Now I don't think the "magic" of the elves corresponds at all to these definitions. As far as they (and many other fantasy of mythical creatures) are concerned, theses "magical" abilities are simply natural characteristics that humans don't possess and are thus rather mystified by.

Posted

this is a sticky subject. Magic shouldn't be mingled with. Tolkien magic, is... well I would say it's fine. Harry Potter magic is not because it is witchcraft and wizardry, and what allot of ppl don't know about HP is that the incantations used in the book are REAL incantations ppl use to worship the demons and satan. Soooo I wouldn't get itno HP if your not already. I personally can't stand that series. And I adore LOTR. But that's just my preference. Tolkien's analogy's are taken from the book of Revalations and as you can easily tell are related to the bible. The descision is yours but the facts are here. I didn't lay them down right here sorry

[quote name='philothea' post='984541' date='May 18 2006, 12:18 PM']
My question is: is reading about fantasy magic actually a serious temptation to anyone? I can think of a whole lot more dangerous everyday temptations than fantasy novels!

I write fantasy (and science fiction). There are many valid reasons for chosing that genre: allegory, symbolism, amplification of themes, and best of all -- disassociation of sensitive subjects. I can deal with serious religious and moral issues in a fantasy setting, and the setting and mythological trappings let me slip in under the reader's radar. In real-world/mainstream settings it is very hard to make any kind of religious statement without people immediately thinking you're preaching at them. There are many well-known Christian fantasy writers, who could not tell the stories they do without the tropes inherent in the genre.

If it tempts [i]you[/i] to go try witchcraft, then yeah, don't read the stuff, but there is nothing inherently wrong with fantasy itself.
[/quote]

yay, I love writting fiction! :yahoo: anyways, a temptation is a temptation, try to ignore ALL of them.

I guess you could say there is nothing wrong with the HP magic itself, oh except for the real incantation demon worship part! LOL sorry.

toledo_jesus
Posted

RM: Why are you casting magic missile? There's nothing to attack here.
BM: um, uh, I attack the darkness.

journeyman
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='984416' date='May 18 2006, 07:46 AM']
:ninja:
:whistle:
[/quote]


hmmmm . . . where have I seen that concept recently . . .

[quote name='philothea' post='984120' date='May 17 2006, 07:29 PM']
:getaclue:

He's kidding. :rolleyes:

[/quote]

Thanks for the pinch hit

journeyman
Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='985296' date='May 19 2006, 11:10 AM']
I think people tend to have some really strange ideas about what constitutes magic in fiction. I have never, for example, considered Tolkein's elves "magical". Here are several definitions of magic:

[i] 1. any art that invokes supernatural powers

2.magic trick: an illusory feat; considered magical by naive observers

3.charming: possessing or using or characteristic of or appropriate to supernatural powers; "charming incantations"; "magic signs that protect against adverse influence"; "a magical spell"; "'tis now the very witching time of night"- Shakespeare; "wizard wands"; "wizardly powers" [/i]

Now I don't think the "magic" of the elves corresponds at all to these definitions. As far as they (and many other fantasy of mythical creatures) are concerned, theses "magical" abilities are simply natural characteristics that humans don't possess and are thus rather mystified by.
[/quote]


Especially as technology outraced people's imaginations, anything that isn't understood becomes "magic."
In the D&D environment, is "healing" any different than miracles performed by Jesus and the apostles? Is "defending" any different than the scene from Isiah (or was it Elijah) where the servants eyes were opened to see all the angels on the ramparts? (by the way, I've heard stories about (non-Catholic) missionaries who (a) were defended by angels or (b) were slaughtered by the people they were trying to convert, but those people were converted on the next round of missionaries because they had seen the angels) Teleport or bilocation?

Not that I've played that many, but I've skimmed several of the rule books and I really can't remember a D&D game world where a real "Christian" rule for "magic" was laid down. I think that would have to be developed by the game leader and participants.

The Harry Potter texts are more "incantational" magic. The basic theme of the books is that there is an inherent ability (distinguishing them from the 'muggles") and each individual has strengths and weaknesses that are revealed by their spells, but they are all (except maybe (mostly) for the potions - which are still a large part chemistry?) incantational . . . which suggests an exterior, rather than an interior, source.

Boy, that was a real run on sentence . . . did everyone understand? Did I?

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='986370' date='May 21 2006, 10:37 AM']
RM: Why are you casting magic missile? There's nothing to attack here.
BM: um, uh, I attack the darkness.
[/quote]

WHERE'RE THE CHEETOS?!?!?!

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='Crispy' post='989481' date='May 24 2006, 11:45 AM']
WHERE'RE THE CHEETOS?!?!?!
[/quote]
CAN I HAVE A MOUNTAIN DEW?

Posted

Regarding MMORPG's specifically, I think that because it's always available and easy to get on and you cannot pause it and its open ended nature, it is much more a temptation to be grow out of whack in terms of time spent on it. W/ pen and paper ones, you have to get together a specific group of people in order to do something with it. W/ regular video game rpg's, it has a specific storyline and ends. You can also stop it at will and come back to it without dire consequences.

Posted

I think what we should do is look at the definition of magic given by the catechism:

"All practices of magic or sorcery, by which one attempts to tame occult powers, so as to place them at one's service and have a supernatural power over others -- even if this were for the sake of restoring their health -- are gravely contrary to the virtue of religion." CCC 2117

Now I don't entirely understand what the definition of occult is but I've always seen it as involving demons or false gods after all magic comes from a word for pagan priests but I know there must be a little more too it because of other ways the catechism uses the term magic. Nonetheless because of this I think that if the power comes from inside of the person as described above when talking about elves it cannot be considered magic as the church defines it because it is simply part of a creatures natural abilities thus not supernatural. So for example in Harry Potter I see the "magic" simply being special powers that they have naturally and are therefore it is not really magic at all. Just like Superman’s ability to fly. Or Spiderman’s Spidy senses. So any of that kind of "magic" cannot be sinful and therefore even if this fiction cause temptation it cannot be sinful. That said there is defiantly fantasy where they are talking about magic and meaning magic but I think that they definitely aren't wrong if the Christian God doesn't exist in the world of the story and you aren’t tempted. But honestly what Christian is tempted to worship a pagan god or call upon ones power. That said in these types of games I usually put myself on the side of the religion that you can tell was molded after Christianity but I don’t see anything wrong with not doing so. It is kind of like fighting on the side of the Communists in Command and Conquer it doesn’t mean you actually want to advance their cause. In fact the only things I’d be cautious about are books/games/movies/etc. that promote the occult in a Christian world.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...