N/A Gone Posted May 18, 2006 Posted May 18, 2006 This message is in response to the dialogue that I have been having with my class. Yes, the class as a whole because Im the token catholic kid. If you want to read up just find the other link I started called "women priests" Here is the recent approach. The teacher pretty much called me out on it and I need to pick up the bat and hit a homer. [quote]First, I don't necessarily think there is a contradiction between male - only priesthood and the Christian principle of gender equality. What it makes is so difficult is that priests not only administer the sacraments, but also run the church! As a result, as you point out, women are thereby excluded from decision making--which means that their gifts are also excluded. In my opinion, the RC Church really needs to confront this. However they intend for the doctrine to work, it has the effect of subordinating women. In so far as the church won't acknowledge this problem, I believe they are denying a key component of the gospel. Which means that, at the very least, the doctrine needs to be restated. Part of the problem for Catholics is that, much like the Evangelicals, many of the voices pushing for gender equality are doing so from a liberal - feminist perspective, not from a "gospel" perspective. It would help if there were some faithful, orthodox Catholics pushing for this stuff on the basis of Scripture and Tradition. Beyond all that, I've actually thought of a way that women could be priests without denying the doctrine. Here's how a woman could be a priest without violating the male priest dogma. I'm not going to footnote any of this, but I believe such footnoting could be done. In the early church, it was fairly common to say that a woman who had attained a level of sanctity had "become a man." This was especially true for, say, martyrs who had crossed over to their transformed bodies while still in their old body. But it also shows up in ascetical and apocalyptic literature--the Acts of Paul and Thecla being a notable example. I see the problems with this way of thinking. As Christians, we don't want to say that "maleness" represents the ideal human. However, there is a way in which it could be useful. Catholicism teaches that in the Eucharist, a direct connection with the eternal realm is opened. Our prayers mingle with the prayers of the angels and saints in heaven. Because we know that our transformed bodies will be essentially genderless, couldn't we then argue that a woman priest "becomes male" in the act of opening the link between the two realms? (We could even say that accidents of femaleness don't change, but the underlying substance does!) If we are truly participating in the heavenly liturgy, then it seems to me we have to acknowledge the (temporary!) change/transformation in our own bodies, one in which gender no longer plays a formal role. I think the idea needs some refining, obviously. The why genders matter thing can be handled--I think--by the fact that gender does belong to the created order, as does sexuality. So while we cannot use gender to create hierarchies we can, and must, acknowledge that genders matter within the context of our particular expression of the divine nature. . . . [/quote] Help???
thessalonian Posted May 18, 2006 Posted May 18, 2006 Help is right. This guy doesn't know what he is talking about. It is always dangerous when protestants start talking as if they do. Catholicism does not say there is no gender in heaven. Before the fall adam and eve were created before the fall, "male and female he created them". This is their natural state. Gen 1 27: So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them. All it says about heaven is that we neither marry nor are given in marriage. But this does not mean we are not male and female. This idea that women become men in heaven is from the gnostic gospels. I believe the Gospel of Thomas. There is no validity to it.
Oik Posted May 18, 2006 Posted May 18, 2006 Put very simply your prof has missed on really vital point... we don't receive the eucharist in Heaven. That being said the argument that since women had reached a level of sanctity from theosis(East) or redemptive suffering(West) and now have a 'heavenly' body falls short as a requiste for being a priest. Secondly, the glorified body is not given until Heaven, so even then, this idea that some woman has reached a certain level of sanctity falls short. Finally, the classic and ancient undersatnding of the Sacrament involves the realization that the validity of the Sacrament does not depend on the holines of the minister. IN a way, this has ramifications for this argument, for a woman, no matter how holy or blessed cannot confect the Sacrament. The Church cannot validly ordain a woman. Even if the intent is present, the Church does not have the authority to do this (the last two senctences are just follow up, i know you know all this and so does your prof).
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 19, 2006 Posted May 19, 2006 Women do not become more holy by becoming "more male" (or having more "maleness"... what BS!!!) Such an idea is not a Catholic idea, nor even a Christian one, but a gnostic one, as has been mentioned above. Just plain ridiculous. Women need to embrace their WOMANHOOD!!! to be real, true women, not act like men! All those women who preach that women have to act like men to be "equal" are only aggrivating the cause, not helping it. They are a disgrace to what it means to be a woman. I refuse to reject that which makes me a woman as demeaning or devaluing me. I am who I am, and my feminity does not hold me back. The only women who have problems are those who struggle with their womanhood and want to reject that which makes them a woman.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now