Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey all~

What do you say to someone you don't know well, but you know they were (raised) Catholic, gets "remarried"? Invites you to a shower? Expects a "congratulations!" when they tell you the happy news?

In particular what would you say if it was someone in authority over you (like an employer)?

Thanks much for any feedback; hope everyone's doing good.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I'd wish them good luck. Unless you know the actual circumstances {recieved annulment, death of spouses partner etc etc] you really can't have an informed opinion.

The shower is up to you. You could give them some nice catholic books :D:

Posted

How do you know they weren't annulled? Then it would be just as good as a first wedding, because the other "wedding" was invalid.

I would say congratulations! what time would you like me to be there? Where are you registered?

Really, unless you know the circumstances, or are willing to ask, it is best to assume the best from people.

My sister is divorced and engaged. She had an annullment the same time she was divorced. So you just never know.

Posted (edited)

Hey~

Well that's just it, knowing vs not knowing the circumstances.

I already knew this was a fallen away Catholic...and from things said to me would be shocked if an annulement was involved...which my warped and scattered brain didn't think to mention till now. It would be improper for me to ask outright that question anyway...

But I appreciate the feedback for situations where I don't know the circumstances.

What would anyone say when expected to give congrats in the situation described above?

t/y

PS: the spouse is still alive.

Edited by Donna
Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

I'm with Cmom - wish them good luck. Pray for them. If you are uncomfortable giving a shower gift or even attending the ceremony (assuming you are invited), then don't. There's no law saying you have to or even should. Be cordial, be kind, but be true to your beliefs.

My last boss was a fallen away Catholic. She was a very kind, God-fearing woman who loved her husband very much. He was just uncomfortable with the Church, so she compromised and attended a Methodist church with him. It made me sad to know that she had been a good Catholic and rather than try to bring him in she compromised. But I was glad to know she was very active in the church she was attending. I prayed for her and her husband. She knew I am very Catholic and I think she appreciated that I did not try to "correct" her about her situation. It wasn't my place and I suspect that deep down she wasn't completely comfortable with it.

Regardless, wish them luck. Keep them in your prayers.

Posted

Don't be so judgemental. It is absolutely NONE of your business and you have no right to criticize anyone. In your life you will have to deal with many different types of people, in all kinds of circumstances. I have to work with people who are atheists, practice unusual relgions, have been in trouble with the law, and sometimes are the lower end of society. I have to treat them with as much respect as I would treat a bishop.
You say good luck to them, get them a nice gift and stay out of it.
Only my opinion

Posted

[quote name='alicemary' post='985790' date='May 20 2006, 09:30 AM']
Don't be so judgemental. It is absolutely NONE of your business and you have no right to criticize anyone. In your life you will have to deal with many different types of people, in all kinds of circumstances. I have to work with people who are atheists, practice unusual relgions, have been in trouble with the law, and sometimes are the lower end of society. I have to treat them with as much respect as I would treat a bishop.
You say good luck to them, get them a nice gift and stay out of it.
Only my opinion
[/quote]


Gee...bite her head off.

Posted

Is she marrying a nonCatholic? if she is, this a grave and serious matter. You can not support her in any way. This is not the same as 2 prots getting married or her marrying another fallen away Catholic. If you dont know, figure it out first.

Posted

Didn't mean to bite her head off, sorry bluntness is me. I only mean you can't judge someone else. I just don't get hyper about what religion a person marries into. And with a divorce rate at 50% or greater these days, I don't see what difference it really makes.
Donna forgive me if I have offended you, not my intention

Posted

I thought you said exactly what I had said... :hehe:

Posted

Kilroy...good to see you. I appreciate the example of not correcting, I'm sure she already knew the correction (can't do it right now for whatever reason) and that she knew you didn't approve, yet really cared about her soul.

Thanks for answering - everyone.

Tarcisius, who knows? I appreciate the zeal for souls, but it'd be detrimental for me to try to find everything out.

However it is true that I do wish them good luck - and if there's the irregularity it sure sounds like, to be converted and live out chastely, or however God would resolve the situation.

AliceMary it's your second answer which grieves me, it matters a great deal to marry into the true religion, esp. if the Catholic marries a non-baptized person, then they have not even the grace of the sacrament.

Well, I'm still pondering the way God wants me to handle it.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Hi Donna,
The root issue is the fact that she is lapsed. If she was returning to the Church or still practicing, then she probably would be more open and have a greater understanding about the question of marriage within the Church, and annulment. It's hard for someone to be interested in getting their marriage in line with the Church when they don't have an interest in the Church in the first place.

I liked cmom's idea of giving a nice gift of religious significance. :) Good luck and all God's blessings for you and your friend.

Posted

Thanks Ash.

son_of_angels
Posted

Tell her you hope her decision is right, explain a good Catholic perspective on marriage and family, if you have the opportunity, and don't go to the shower or "wedding." I would suggest this if you have any doubt at all as to its validity.

Then again, I would also advise caution in attending any non-Catholic marriage ceremony. It is important that when you say "Amen" or even "Praise you, Lord Jesus" you understand that, while you're praising the same Lord, you are not really participating with them, because the Lord is something different to you than to them. Hence, you ought to use caution in how much you support the actions of another religion or the heretical/schismatic churches.

Posted

[quote name='alicemary' post='985790' date='May 20 2006, 07:30 AM']
Don't be so judgemental. It is absolutely NONE of your business and you have no right to criticize anyone. In your life you will have to deal with many different types of people, in all kinds of circumstances. I have to work with people who are atheists, practice unusual relgions, have been in trouble with the law, and sometimes are the lower end of society. I have to treat them with as much respect as I would treat a bishop.
You say good luck to them, get them a nice gift and stay out of it.
Only my opinion
[/quote]

I agree completely. This is especially true if you do not know the person well. If she invites you, you should congratulate her and buy her a gift. A religious gift would be nice (do not get her one blatently on the Catholic Church's view on divorce lol.).

Posted

That's a tough one. I don't agree that it's always wrong to criticize anyone. Adominishing the sinner is a spiritual work of mercy. If you don't know her very good, I think it would be ok to respect a certain prudence and wish her well without inquiring into her private life. Attending the wedding is another matter, IMO, and I think you would be justified in asking if she was marrying validly within the Church. Otherwise, your attendance could be scandalous. St. Paul tells us, "Do not hold him as an enemy, but warn him as a brother." You don't have to give a fire-and-brimstone speech. Just explain why you cannot attend, and leave it at that. Hopefully, she'll respect your conscience, and she may even reconsider.

Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='986538' date='May 21 2006, 02:58 PM']
That's a tough one. I don't agree that it's always wrong to criticize anyone. Adominishing the sinner is a spiritual work of mercy. If you don't know her very good, I think it would be ok to respect a certain prudence and wish her well without inquiring into her private life. Attending the wedding is another matter, IMO, and I think you would be justified in asking if she was marrying validly within the Church. Otherwise, your attendance could be scandalous. St. Paul tells us, "Do not hold him as an enemy, but warn him as a brother." You don't have to give a fire-and-brimstone speech. Just explain why you cannot attend, and leave it at that. Hopefully, she'll respect your conscience, and she may even reconsider.
[/quote]

I agree.

Of course, you could always arrange to be out of town on the days of the shower and the wedding.

Guest phatdaddy
Posted

[quote name='Donna' post='985555' date='May 19 2006, 09:14 PM']
Hey all~

What do you say to someone you don't know well, but you know they were (raised) Catholic, gets "remarried"? Invites you to a shower? Expects a "congratulations!" when they tell you the happy news?

In particular what would you say if it was someone in authority over you (like an employer)?

Thanks much for any feedback; hope everyone's doing good.
[/quote]

To answer your question what you don't need is opinions. What you need is the truth, what the church teaches. There will be as many opinions as there are people. May I suggest: determine for yourself what does the church teach on this subject. Start with just a few of the principals:

A valid, sacramental and consummated marriage is indissolvable.
A marriage must be assumed to be valid unless proven otherise by a church tribunal.
If a married person divorces and re-marries without a declaration of nullity of the first marriage commits adultry.
In the above case the second marriage is invalid.
To give scandal is to sin
To revel in another's sin is a sin.

What does the church teach about this? Start with the Code of Canon law 1075, 1085, 1086, 1102. Also The Catechism, 1644. Anyway, this is at least a place to start. Speak to a priest that you trust will speak the truth to you. You don't need the opinion of a priest either. What does the church teach.

Certainly you will have to know the circumstances in order to make a judgement. You do have a moral obligation to make a judgement because personal sin is involve. It is sinful for a Catholic who knows, to participate in a invalid marriage because of the scandal they would cause.

I just went through this ordeal and understand the ramifications for being Catholic. God bless you.
Mr. Ray

Posted

Thanks, Mr. Ray. I've gone through it before as well...but those other times I had all the info needed without one doubt. Here, I'm only 95% certain.

And too, knowing the teaching doesn't always answer "what do I say" or "how do I say it?" I posted to get support (which I have :) and really, because I'm bewildered as to what "to say!" , as I've not yet seen the person in question since they have sent news around of the wedding.

It is for the moment we are face to face, them knowing that I know the news: what do I say? Because I've not handled this before in the best way, I am eager to do better, if that be possible. I'm sure Our Lady has helped in garnering this thread/possible replies to ponder.

Attendance wouldn't be right for me to do...that I already know. It helps to have y'all go through it with me just the same. And, I do know what to say about not attending (fortunately!)

Posted

But a hefty PS, cause it's now bugging me, as it keeps being added to replies to not be so judgemental: it IS my business, when one of the flock - one who is my sibling in grace, has partaken of the Blessed Sacrament - ditches all that, and expects me to rejoice with them.

God kill me first, is that OK with ppl?

It's my business to defend Our Lord, and at least not to ditch Him out of Human Respect. If I have to lose a friend or employment over this, so be it. It's incredible to be seen as judgemental for being part of the Church Militant. I get enough of that **** from the world.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...