Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is putting songs on xangas filesharing?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Is putting songs on xangas, myspaces, etc. considered filesharing? Is it immoral? Would it be considered stealing from the artist?

Posted

i'll answer the first question.

technically yes it is file sharing.

you put it on the web

letting people listen to it

therefore technically you're sharing it.

Posted

no listening to the artists' music is not stealing.

Posted

Well, stores play music for customers to listen to, and customers don't have to pay for listening to the music. If you paid for the music and put it on your site, I don't think it's wrong. I mean, as long as you don't offer it as a download for others to download illegally. I'm not an expert, though. :idontknow:

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I know restuarants need a special paid license to play music. The same may apply to stores. I just don't know.

Posted

When I worked for a not-for-profit agency, we had to pay yearly dues to ... someone, I don't remember who, to do things like show movies, play music, etc. I don't know the specifics of intellectual property law as it would apply to myspace ... but honestly, I wouldn't do it unless I knew I had a right to do it. Ignorance of the law is not a defense.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

Although the fact that myspace is now such a public entity, I would think if it was illegal, somebody would have publicly pointed that out by now (and myspace would remove the feature). People have been putting background music on websites for quite a while. I still would not do it without permission.

Posted

I think that it is not such a good idea.

Posted

[quote name='Colleen' post='990459' date='May 25 2006, 01:30 PM'] Well, stores play music for customers to listen to, and customers don't have to pay for listening to the music. If you paid for the music and put it on your site, I don't think it's wrong. I mean, as long as you don't offer it as a download for others to download illegally. I'm not an expert, though. :idontknow: [/quote]

We have to pay to use it at Barnes and Noble I believe. We are only allowed to play certain CDs (we have 12 that we cycle through each month) and I think it's for that reason.

Twelve CDs are not enough not to give you a headache after 31 days. :P:

[quote name='Theoketos' post='991092' date='May 26 2006, 01:26 PM'] I think that it is not such a good idea. [/quote]

Do you say that because you think it's immoral, illegal, or because it makes sites way too difficult to open up? :P:

I'm actually asking in seriousness too.

Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='990896' date='May 26 2006, 09:12 AM']
Although the fact that myspace is now such a public entity, I would think if it was illegal, somebody would have publicly pointed that out by now (and myspace would remove the feature). People have been putting background music on websites for quite a while. I still would not do it without permission.
[/quote]

This is because myspace partialy exists so that bands can get a website. If bands own the copy right to their music then they can do what they want with it. But if you put someone elses music on your xanga/myspace you are stealing from them. Just like if you put someone elses picture on your xanga. or copy and past an entire article on your xanga you are stealing from them. To put the music on your xanga you would have to pay royalties but the way I understand it because xanga allows people to choose which song they want to listen to the royalties would be far to expensive for xanga to pay let alone the person using their site.

Posted

[quote name='Colleen' post='990459' date='May 25 2006, 02:30 PM']
Well, stores play music for customers to listen to, and customers don't have to pay for listening to the music. If you paid for the music and put it on your site, I don't think it's wrong. I mean, as long as you don't offer it as a download for others to download illegally. I'm not an expert, though. :idontknow:
[/quote]
The company has to pay to play it though. (I think there may be an exception for music stores but I could be wrong)

To the OP it isn't filesharing perse rather it infringes upon the copyright holders nonexclusive right to perfrom their music publicaly. It is more like playing things on a radio station without paying royalites than buring a CD for someone.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='JJMG2001' post='991379' date='May 27 2006, 05:42 AM']
This is because myspace partialy exists so that bands can get a website. If bands own the copy right to their music then they can do what they want with it. But if you put someone elses music on your xanga/myspace you are stealing from them. Just like if you put someone elses picture on your xanga. or copy and past an entire article on your xanga you are stealing from them. To put the music on your xanga you would have to pay royalties but the way I understand it because xanga allows people to choose which song they want to listen to the royalties would be far to expensive for xanga to pay let alone the person using their site.
[/quote]
Good point.

Posted

"This is because myspace partialy exists so that bands can get a website. If bands own the copy right to their music then they can do what they want with it. But if you put someone elses music on your xanga/myspace you are stealing from them. Just like if you put someone elses picture on your xanga. or copy and past an entire article on your xanga you are stealing from them. To put the music on your xanga you would have to pay royalties but the way I understand it because xanga allows people to choose which song they want to listen to the royalties would be far to expensive for xanga to pay let alone the person using their site."

are you telling me its immoral to copy someones pic or article and put it on your site?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='991733' date='May 28 2006, 01:19 AM']
"This is because myspace partialy exists so that bands can get a website. If bands own the copy right to their music then they can do what they want with it. But if you put someone elses music on your xanga/myspace you are stealing from them. Just like if you put someone elses picture on your xanga. or copy and past an entire article on your xanga you are stealing from them. To put the music on your xanga you would have to pay royalties but the way I understand it because xanga allows people to choose which song they want to listen to the royalties would be far to expensive for xanga to pay let alone the person using their site."

are you telling me its immoral to copy someones pic or article and put it on your site?
[/quote]Yes just as immoral as burning a CD. The same laws that protect songs protect images and forms of writing. Sometimes things fall under fair use but not this. I know my dad as a part time photographer wouldn't appreciate someone publishing his photos without getting any money for it. This would include things posted on this phorum.

Edited by JJMG2001
Posted

but the things on this forum arent copyrighted and your dad's fotos are.

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='991805' date='May 28 2006, 10:04 AM']
but the things on this forum arent copyrighted and your dad's fotos are.
[/quote]
No I meant putting copyrighted things on this phorum. However everything on this phorum which is unique enough to get a copyright is already copyrighted by virtue of being fixed in a tangible medium. That said posts in forums and emails are understood to be open of replying, archiving, and forwarding. So unless someone specifically asks you not to you can do that.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...