Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Cardinal Arinze on Liturgical Translations


Recommended Posts

phatcatholic
Posted

[b]Letter from Cardinal Arinze to Bishop Skylstad about Liturgical Translations[/b]
[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?RecNum=6954"]http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?RecNum=6954[/url]

2 May 2006

The Most Reverend William Skylstad
Bishop of Spokane
President, United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
Prot. n. 499/06/L

Your Excellency,

With reference to the conversation between yourself, the Vice President and General Secretary of the Conference of Bishops of which you are President, together with me and other Superiors and Officials when you kindly visited our Congregation on 27 April 2006, I wish to recall the following:

The Instruction [i][url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDWLITAU.HTM"][b]Liturgiam Authenticam[/b][/url][/i] is the latest document of the Holy See which guides translations from the original-language liturgical texts into the various modern languages in the Latin Church. Both this Congregation and the Bishops’ Conferences are bound to follow its directives. This Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments is therefore not competent to grant the [i]recognitio[/i] for translations that do not conform to the directives of [i]Liturgiam authenticam[/i]. If, however, there are difficulties regarding the translation of a particular part of a text, then this Congregation is always open to dialogue in view of some mutually agreeable solution, still keeping in mind, however, that [i]Liturgiam authenticam[/i] remains the guiding norm.

The attention of your Bishops’ Conference was also recalled to the fact that Liturgiam Authenticam was issued at the directive of the Holy Father at the time, Pope John Paul II, to guide new translations as well as the revision of all translations done in the last forty years, to bring them into greater fidelity to the original-language official liturgical texts. For this reason it is not acceptable to maintain that people have become accustomed to a certain translation for the past thirty or forty years, and therefore that it is pastorally advisable to make no changes. Where there are good and strong reasons for a change, as has been determined by this Dicastery in regard to the entire translation of the [i]Missale Romanum[/i] as well as other important texts, then the revised text should make the needed changes. The attitudes of Bishops and Priests will certainly influence the acceptance of the texts by the lay faithful as well.

Requesting Your Excellency to share these reflections with the Bishops of your Conference I assure you of the continued collaboration of this Congregation and express my religious esteem,

Devotedly yours in Christ,

+Francis Card. Arinze

Prefect, Sacred Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments

Posted

ooooh ooooh ooooh ooooh :yahoo:












wait. :mellow: what does it mean? :idontknow:

phatcatholic
Posted

well, i could be wrong, but i'm pretty sure the bishops are currently undertaking a revision of the missal--what we say at mass--to make it more in accordance with the original Latin. some bishops are opposed to this b/c the laity are used to saying their parts of the mass a particular way, even tho they are technically reciting a mistranslation. for example, when the priest says, "Dominus vobiscum" ("The Lord be with you"), the response is, "Et cum spiritu tuo," which actually means "and with your Spirit"...........yet, we've been saying, "and also with you" all these years :blink:

anyway, for pastoral reasons, some bishops would rather keep things as they are. it appears that bishop skylstad discussed this w/ cardinal arinze, and the wise cardinal informed him that the bishops should follow the guidelines set forth in [i]Liturgiam Authenticam[/i], and that "but we've been doin it this one way for years now" is not a good enough reason to avoid revising the translation.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

ps: it will be interesting to see how well this is received in [i]your[/i] diocese......

Posted
:lol_pound: i love how you use the word "received." by this do you mean "ignored"?

because, the trend is, following the Cardinal's article anaylzing the liturgical abuses outlined in redemptoris sacramentum (sp?), we just chuck everything out the window that we don't like (he put an article in the diocese newspaper explaining how lots of things in JPII's encylical didn't apply to us, like using glass/crystal, like pouring after the consecration, etc etc etc.) :rolleyes: :madrant:
phatcatholic
Posted

no purgatory for kateri, that's for sure!! :D:

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I hope this is addressed speedily among the bishops in the USCCB. It took FOREVER with the General Instruction, and then even longer before most dioceses began implementing it (i.e., mine began in Fall '04)

Myles Domini
Posted

I dont see the need for all this discussion nonsense. Why doesn't Rome just order immediate implementation? If the Holy See is unhappy with the current situation why dont they just take charge and change it. What is the need for further review?

Posted

The role of the individual Bishops in their own Dioceses?

Posted

We have to pray for our Bishops
The Church is in 'flux'. The new translation will be out shortly (hopefully). Get catechized (sp)and get involved in a parish. What else can one do?

Cardinal Arinze is awesome. This letter seems to indicate that some supposed things in the new translation will not be accepted. That's what I get.

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='991443' date='May 27 2006, 09:05 AM']
no purgatory for kateri, that's for sure!! :D:
[/quote]

awww :blush:

well i don't know about THAT! :rolleyes: :P:

Posted

[quote name='Myles Domini' post='991468' date='May 27 2006, 11:49 AM']
I dont see the need for all this discussion nonsense. Why doesn't Rome just order immediate implementation? If the Holy See is unhappy with the current situation why dont they just take charge and change it. What is the need for further review?
[/quote]
Then why have bishops at all? Why not just have the laity and Rome? (Pardon me for being hyperbolic.)

The episcopacy exists so the Holy See can understand current situations in dioceses worldwide. And both sides, at least in my humble opinion, have valid arguements--ie, we have been saying this for years, and change can be difficult, and we should think about ways to better articulate the original texts. I pray for the USCCB, that they may find themselves open to the Spirit, and find a solution that will best support the Catholic faith and the teachings of the Church.

  • 2 weeks later...
phatcatholic
Posted

[b]Welcoming a New Translation, This Time[/b]
[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/highlights/highlights.cfm?id=111"]http://www.catholicculture.org/highlights/...ghts.cfm?id=111[/url]
[size=1]by Dr. Jeff Mirus, special to CatholicCulture.org
June 7, 2006[/size]

There has been a good deal of coverage of the new translation of the Roman Missal which the bishops must consider at their mid-June meeting. This is the first part of a retranslation of the texts of the Mass using the principles set forth by the Vatican in its 2001 instruction Liturgiam authenticam. A complete translation is still two years away, but the bishops may (or may not) authorize the use of the parts that have been completed in the meantime. Why should we welcome a new translation?

[b]The Trouble with Translations[/b]

As I’ve said before in this space, the trouble with constant retranslating of texts is that this tinkering undermines the transcendence of the liturgy and the perceived permanence of the mysteries of salvation (see [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/highlights/highlights.cfm?id=54"][b]The Trouble with Translations[/b][/url], March 2005). The many changes in the English liturgical and Scriptural texts since the 1970’s attest to this problem. The principle of translation generally used over the last generation was one of accommodating the text to the culture (or, inevitably, the translator’s view of the culture). On this principle, the very frequency of change was an advantage, because by undermining sacral language and promoting constant innovation, the liturgy more accurately reflected our materialist and consumerist culture.

Indeed, this is the argument that has been employed by the chairman of the USCCB Committee on the Liturgy, Bishop Donald Trautman of Erie, PA in his prolonged resistance to the new guidelines for translation issued by the Vatican five years ago. Trautman has criticized the Vatican repeatedly for its “failure” to understand that we must use the language of a culture to communicate effectively with that culture. This, of course, is a strong argument for translating the official Latin in the first place, but it is a very bad argument for altering the meaning of the texts to suit cultural preferences.

[b]Lex Orandi, Lex Credendi[/b]

A very old Catholic proverb says “the law of praying is the law of believing”—that is, what the faithful express in regular prayer is what they will come to believe. In this way, liturgy plays an enormous role in shaping our faith. The question naturally arises: who is playing the major role in shaping our liturgy? Is it translators who attempt to adapt the liturgy to what they believe the prevailing culture will find acceptable? If so, the very texts of our prayers will tend to erode what we believe. Or is it the Church herself, pointing us always toward realties beyond our culture? If so, then the texts will strengthen our faith.

The plain fact is that the translations we’ve been using for the last 35 years have deviated substantially in style, emphasis and meaning from the normative Latin text. This can only mean that the translators have been manipulating our Faith rather than the Church reinforcing and teaching it. This is evident both in the prosaic, conversational, familiar style of the English liturgy, which obscures the transcendent majesty of God, and in the countless adaptations of the Roman Missal for American use, which make it difficult to distinguish between approved liturgical formulae and personal ad libbing on the part of the celebrant. Did you know, for example, that the acclamation “Christ has died, Christ is Risen, Christ will come again” is an adaptation invented by the translators, which was put first among the legitimate options even though it does not appear in the Latin at all?

[b]Little Things[/b]

Admittedly, the proclamation of the mystery of faith is one of my pet peeves. When the Roman Missal, after the consecration of the bread and wine, says simply “Mysterium Fidei”, it means to affirm what has just occurred, that the transubstantiation of the bread and wine into the body, blood, soul and divinity of Jesus Christ is “the mystery of faith”. In English, however, we tend to slip past the consecration and then announce, “Let us proclaim the mystery of faith”, followed by one acclamation or another which, linguistically, appears to be the mystery of faith which we are proclaiming. No doubt these acclamations do represent various mysteries of the faith but, as far as the liturgy goes, they are not preeminently the mystery of faith, the Eucharist.

A similar erosion of meaning is evident in many other faulty translations. When the priest says, “The Lord be with you”, the Latin response is “Et cum spiritu tuo” (and with your spirit), not “and also with you.” It was argued at the time (by the translators) that this was more in keeping with both contemporary culture and the Hebrew conception of man as a unity (as opposed to the Greek distinction between body and soul). But the Church is bound neither to the Greek nor the Hebrew nor the current culture but to Christ, and if Catholic tradition and Church authority wish in this response to place a special emphasis on our “spirit” or soul, which is the part of us that is immortal and in which the Holy Trinity dwells, then it is hard to see why the translators should resist.

Or consider the Confiteor. Using the current translation, I confess that I have sinned “through my own fault”, but the official Latin wishes me to emphasize “through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault”. Do we really need to concentrate so much on our personal guilt? Well, if the Church wants us to, yes. And the list goes on. We say “Holy, Holy, Holy, Lord God of Power and Might”. The Latin says “Holy, Holy, Holy is the Lord God of hosts.” We say, “Lord I am not worthy to receive you” but the Latin says, “Lord, I am not worthy that you should enter under my roof.” The originals in both cases come right out of Scripture and so preserve a vital connection with Revelation. Again, the current English text of the Creed begins “We believe”, emphasizing the community, but the Latin says “Credo” — I believe — which stresses that Faith is a personal commitment.

[b]This Time, Yes[/b]

The new translation corrects the vast majority of the errors of the current English text, restores most of the emphases of the original Latin, and begins the difficult task of sacralizing the language again, making it less common, more formal and courteous, more like it is specially reserved for our relationship with God. For these reasons, when it is finally implemented, whether in parts or only after the entire project is completed, we should welcome this new translation as we would welcome release from prison. Doing so will affirm the most important principle of authentic liturgical translation: Our right to be formed not by the translators, but by the Church.

Posted

I agree with others here. What is all the debating about. I don't really think there are "licit" arguments to the reduction of Sacred Language in the Liturgy. They might have reasons why they were done, but the point should have never been about conforming to the people. Why would this even be something to argue about. It should be, i obey (in the case of the bishops to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith) not i debate.

Posted

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=53298"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=53298[/url]

  • 2 weeks later...
phatcatholic
Posted

articles on the new translation of the mass that the USCCB just passed:

[b]--[url="http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=6969"]US Bishops Approve Changes to the Mass[/url]
--[url="http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=6970"]Changes to Mass to Reflect Latin Translation and Biblical Origins[/url]
--[url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=44821"]US Bishops Approve New Translation for Mass[/url]
--[url="http://acatholiclife.blogspot.com/2006/06/its-done-usccb-approves-changes.html"]USCCB Approves Changes[/url]
--[url="http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/13350553/"]US Catholic Leaders Approve Changes in Prayer[/url][/b] (from a non-Catholic source)

Posted

Thanks phat.

phatcatholic
Posted
:thumbsup:
phatcatholic
Posted

two more articles:
[b]--[url="http://www.ncregister.com/articulo4.php?artkod=NTc2"]How Will the Mass Change?[/url]
--[url="http://www.guardian.co.uk/worldlatest/story/0,,-5890000,00.html"]US Bishops Approve New Mass Translation[/url][/b]

Posted

i :love: catholicculture.org

note to self: when have more $$, should donate to them ;)

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1008632' date='Jun 19 2006, 08:15 PM']
i :love: catholicculture.org

note to self: when have more $$, should donate to them ;)
[/quote]
:yes: i encourage EVERYONE to do this!! they certainly need AND deserve the money. Catholic Culture has been a great help to me in building the directory and they were very patient with me when they reviewed the directory, giving me the time to add some disclaimers to a few links so they could give me the green light.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...