Ziggamafu Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 Evil is not a thing, but the absence of a thing: Good Hate is not a thing, but the absence of a thing: Love God [i]is[/i] Goodness. God [i]is[/i] Love. God is also infinite and eternal. Therefore, Goodness and Love are infinite and eternal. But if Goodness and Love are infinite and eternal, how can the absence goodness and love ever exist? *** This is a much more compelling theological challenge than the normal "why is there suffering" shpeel because a simple "God gives us free will and we create suffering by not loving and not being good" answer isn't going to stand up to logic. We as Catholics believe that our faith is reasonable - not contradictory or logically impossible. So how is this logically resolved, here? To clarify, this challenge is not asking how / why an omni-benevolent God could / would allow suffering - it's asking how the existence of hate and sin are logically possible, given the definitions of God.
Myles Domini Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 Of course nothing can be lacking in God, God suffers no privations but in the world thats not true at all. Only in God is all potentiality in act, which is absolutely unprecedented in the cosmos of created essence. Your query would make sense if we were pantheists, that is, if we believed God's essence was identical to the universe so that what is present in God must also be present in the world. However, what is present in God is actually so far different than what is present in the world that it makes any similarity seem nullified. Its just a byproduct of being created that privations can exist.
goldenchild17 Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 mmm, good question... Maybe the same reason stupidity exists in the world, and yet God is all-knowing? Ima gonna think on this one .
Ziggamafu Posted May 28, 2006 Author Posted May 28, 2006 the pantheism vs monotheism answer is best, i think...but it still seems kinda cop-out-ish...
jswranch Posted May 28, 2006 Posted May 28, 2006 How? God decided to allow for the possibility of of hate, sin and evil. Sin and evil could not exist without His permission Why? The possibility for such hate and sin is necessary for the creation of beings that have the freedom to love him back.
jswranch Posted May 28, 2006 Posted May 28, 2006 (edited) Let me again answer your question by quoting Dr. Peter Kreeft in "Faith and Reason:The Philosophy of Religion" where he uses the socratic model to test the different truth claims of the world's major religions (8). He first tests atheism. The question you have asked is "the strongest argument for atheism (in fact, the only one that claims to prove with certainty that God cannot possibly exist)." He spends an entire chapter on this argument for atheism alone. This is my favorite response of many: [quote][size=4][font="Times New Roman"]God-We have been arguing about God's goodness and power, but we forget a third attribute, his wisdom. It might be that he sees what we do not see: how apparent evil really works out for our greater good and our greater happiness in the end. That answer is not satisfying to our natural curiosity because it doesn't explain evil. Instead, it explains why we can't explain it. But although it's not very satisfying, it is logically consistent[/font][/size][/quote] I got this book (on tape) from the local library, so maybe so can you to hear all 45min of his response. Edited May 28, 2006 by jswranch
Myles Domini Posted May 28, 2006 Posted May 28, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='991647' date='May 28 2006, 02:14 AM'] the pantheism vs monotheism answer is best, i think...but it still seems kinda cop-out-ish... [/quote] Explain. How can there be no privations in the world at all? If all potency was actuality in the world then the world would be God. Having a created essence demands that there be some lack of actuality in a thing and that allows for there to be a greater privation.
phatcatholic Posted May 29, 2006 Posted May 29, 2006 some helpful articles: --[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/248"]The Problem of Evil, and Other Causes of Unbelief[/url]
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted May 29, 2006 Posted May 29, 2006 [quote name='Myles Domini' post='991390' date='May 27 2006, 07:39 AM'] Of course nothing can be lacking in God, God suffers no privations but in the world thats not true at all. Only in God is all potentiality in act, which is absolutely unprecedented in the cosmos of created essence. Your query would make sense if we were pantheists, that is, if we believed God's essence was identical to the universe so that what is present in God must also be present in the world. However, what is present in God is actually so far different than what is present in the world that it makes any similarity seem nullified. Its just a byproduct of being created that privations can exist. [/quote] I agree. I don't see how the challenge applies to Christianity.
magnificat Posted May 30, 2006 Posted May 30, 2006 (edited) Free will. Yes, God is infinite and eternal, but by free will we are able to reject God. When we reject God, we reject goodness and love as well being that they are intimately connected. Not specifically your question, but perhaps it's also possible for the partial absence of goodnes & love since as humans, our sin prevents us from perfect union with God. Thus, though we try and strive to do God's will, our failings keep perfect goodness & love from being perpetually present. Edited May 30, 2006 by magnificat
Aloysius Posted May 30, 2006 Posted May 30, 2006 Infinity does not mean that it must encompass all things. A finite thing can exist completely seperate from an infinite thing. That is where the logic fails here, just because something is infinite, it does not necessarily fill up every finite thing. the absence of goodness can exist in something finite. that is not the END of the infinite goodness, it is just a place where infinite goodness is not present. infinite goodness needn't be present there to remain infinite. mathematics can help out this logic: you can have any number of different types of infinities. you can have an infinity counting by 1's, by 2's, by 3's, et cetera. None of them will ever have an end. But if you make an infinity which counts by two's the numbers 1, 3, 5 and all odd numbers will not be included in that infinity. The infinity is still infinite, we do not say that it has an end at 3.
Ziggamafu Posted May 30, 2006 Author Posted May 30, 2006 ooh...that was the best and perfect response! thanks, aloysius, that will do just fine!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now