Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

does anyone know anything about Kazimierz Dabrowski's theory of positive disintegration? If so, what exactly do you think of it?

Thanks

phatcatholic
Posted
:idontknow:

(show off :thumbsup:)
phatcatholic
Posted

anyone else?

Noel's angel
Posted

It's full of big words.....My head is frazzled already with 19th Century Irish nationalism

Posted

Ummm... so I still kinda want to know what it is.....


:mellow:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

It's a psychological theory of personality development. I was just wondering because you don't often see or hear anything about it and yet I think it has some interesting aspects.

Wikipedia has a decent article which explains the gist of it: [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_Disintegration"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_Disintegration[/url]


[quote]The theory is based on numerous key ideas:

- That our lower animal instincts (first factor) must be inhibited and transformed into "higher" forces for us to be Human (this ability to transform our instincts is what separates us from animals).
- That the common initial personality integration, based upon socialization (second factor), does not reflect true personality.
- At the initial level of integration, there is little internal conflict as when one “goes along with the group,” there is little sense of individual wrong doing. External conflicts often relate to the blockage of social goals – career frustrations for example. The social mores and values prevail with little question or conscious examination.
- True personality must be based upon a system of values that are consciously and volitionally chosen by the person to reflect their own individual sense of "how life ought to be" and their "personality ideal" — the ideal person they feel they "ought to be."
- The lower animal instincts and the forces of peer groups and socialization are inferior to the autonomous self (personality) constructed by the conscious person.
- To break down the initial integration, crises and disintegrations are needed, usually provided by life experience.
- These disintegrations are positive if the person can achieve positive and developmental solutions to the situation.
- "Unilevel crises" are not developmental as the person can only choose between equal alternatives (go left or go right?).
- A new type of perception involves "multilevelness," a vertical view of life that compares lower versus higher alternatives and now allows the individual to choose a higher resolution to a crisis over other available, but lower, alternatives — the developmental solution.
- "Positive disintegration" is a vital developmental process.
- Dabrowski developed the idea of "developmental potential" to describe the forces needed to achieve autonomous personality development.
- Developmental potential includes several factors including innate abilities and talents, "overexcitability" and the "third factor."
- Overexcitability is a measure of an individual’s level of nervous response. Dabrowski found that the exemplars he studied all displayed an overly sensitive nervous system, also making them prone to angst, depression and anxiety - psychoneuroses in Dabrowski's terms, a very positive and developmental feature.
- The third factor is a measure of an individual's drive toward autonomy.
- Dabrowski's approach is very interesting philosophically as it is Platonic, reflecting the bias of Plato toward essence — an individual's essence is a critical determinant of his or her developmental course in life. However, Dabrowski also added a major existential aspect as well, what one depends upon the anxieties felt and on how one resolves the day to day challenges one faces. Essence must be realized through an existential and experiential process of development. The characterization advanced by Kierkegaard of "Knights of faith" may be compared to Dabrowski’s autonomous individual.
- Reviewed the role of logic and reasoning in development and concludes that intellect alone does not fully help us know what to do in life. Incorporates Jean Piaget's views of development into a broader scheme guided by emotion. Emotion (how one feels about something) is the more accurate guide to life's major decisions.
- When multilevel and autonomous development is achieved, a secondary integration is seen reflecting the mature personality state. The individual has no inner conflict; they are in internal harmony as their actions reflect their deeply felt hierarchy of values.
- Rejected Maslow's description of self-actualization (Dabrowski was a personal friend and correspondent of Maslow's). Actualization of an undifferentiated human self is not a developmental outcome in Dabrowski's terms. Dabrowski applied a multilevel (vertical) approach to self and saw the need to become aware of and to inhibit and reject the lower instinctual aspects of the intrinsic human self (aspects that Maslow would have us "embrace without guilt") and to actively choose and assemble higher elements into a new unique self - this process is what differentiates Man from the Animals. Dabrowski would have us differentiate the initial self into higher and lower aspects, as we define them, and to reject the lower and actualize the higher in creating our unique personality. [/quote]

Many of the ideas strike me as compatible with Catholicism that's all.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I'll have to read over it some more.

But I don't find it all that appealing upon first glance, but it could just be wikepedia's terminology/phraseology.

Any articles on it?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1001568' date='Jun 9 2006, 05:13 PM']
I'll have to read over it some more.

But I don't find it all that appealing upon first glance, but it could just be wikepedia's terminology/phraseology.

Any articles on it?
[/quote]
There are lots of articles on it.. Here's one site:

[url="http://members.shaw.ca/positivedisintegration/"]http://members.shaw.ca/positivedisintegration/[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...