Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

In a discussion among some non-Catholic friends, a Lutheran friend of mine responded that claiming salvation by grace is too ambiguous... and then proceeded to argue that we are saved by baptism. And while I didn't disagree with the baptism comment, I was puzzled by his stance towards grace. I asked if baptism wasn't a great grace and he affirmed that it was, but still insisted that saying one is saved by grace is too ambiguous, and then added that faith "in" is a necessary component--to which I also readily agreed and then said again, "but isn't faith itself a grace?" and he again affirmed that it was.

Now, this is where it got confusing. He then stated that not all of God's gracious gifts impart salvation (I'm not sure I agree with that). He also stated that the Lord's Supper alone does not save, but it is a component of salvation (though he renigged, because he originally used this as an example of something that imparts grace without salvation-- until I started pulling out John 6). We did distinguish between different senses of grace (i.e., the Catechism talks about sanctifying, habitual, and actual grace), but I do not see how one could say that certain types/senses of grace do not impart salvation? It is my understanding that the Sacraments are necessary because they impart grace... without grace, baptism is only a bathing of the skin, and without grace the Eucharist is only bread and wine, etc. etc. etc.


The conversation continued a bit, but by the end I was doing this: :wacko: I thought I understood the concept of grace relatively well, but now I'm not so sure as I didn't have a decent response by the end except to note that I disagreed. Am I wrong somewhere? Have I slipped into some sort of heresy regarding grace?

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Back to fundamentals.

We have been saved. Baptism.


We are being saved. Eucharist feeds us spiritually and Holy Spirit leads us to do the work of God as he works in us. Eph 3:20-20. Actually baptism might be understood to have a present part as well because without it the current santifying graces would not be effective. One would take the Eucharist and could still be damned.

[20]
Now to him who by the power at work within us is able to do far more abundantly than all that we ask or think,
[21] to him be glory in the church and in Christ Jesus to all generations, for ever and ever. Amen.

We will be saved - grace of perseverence will be given. On this we place our trust.

Actually as well one cannot say that baptism is the first grace. Nature itself is grace in that it cries out to the glory of God. Baptism cannot comprise all of salvation because salvation is not a one time event. God saved the Jews when he led them out of egypt, as they crossed the red sea and as he destoried the chariots and the chariteers, when he fed them and guided them in the desert and when they crossed the jordan in to the promised land. God even saved the jews prior to the actual event by intervening in the life of Moses. Looking back in my life I can see how God was saving me before I was born in the life of my mother. ALL is grace. Baptism saves us by putting us in to a saving relationship but that relationship must be maintained. Grace alone is the only phrase that captures the awesome ways that God is providing for and bringing about our salvation of which baptism, though a significant part, is just one part. Grace cannot be said to be too general because God saves us in so many ways, but the underlying and basic component of our salvation is grace. To say it is too general is like saying that water is too general as something that sustains life. All life must have water and grace is like the water of life.

Does that help?

Edited by thessalonian
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Yes, very much so Thessalonian... I knew there was something that I should've been remembering but I couldn't think of it.

phatcatholic
Posted

it also depends on what your opponent (for lack of a better word) means by the word "salvation." there are many senses of the word, and it is itself ambiguous.............as in, you can't always assume that a person uses the word the same way you do. once you know what he means by "salvation" then u should be able to understand his view of grace.

when some people speak of "salvation" they have in mind "eternal security" or "an assurance of heaven." when protestants say, "we are 'saved' by faith alone" they usually mean: "once i make a profession of faith, i have secured a place in heaven that i cannot lose." however, when catholics speak of "salvation" (or being "saved") in this life, they usually mean "sanctification" (or being "sanctified"). so, we are "saved" by baptism in the sense that, through baptism, we are sanctified and justified. however, there is no assurance of heaven upon baptism b/c there is still that opportunity to turn from God after being sanctified/justified.

receiving the Eucharist "saves":

1. in a practical sense, in that it grants us graces which forgive venial sin and which strengthen us to resist sin; and
2. in an ultimate sense, in that the habitual reception of the Eucharist allows us to persevere in grace and die in right relationship with the Lord.

in a way, i guess one could say that grace is "ambiguous" b/c, as you pointed out, there are different types of grace, and they don't all have the same effect in the life of man.

i hope that helps

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Posted

NICE!

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Phat,

Good comments. I agree.

Except my friend claimed that because it was too ambiguous it would not be proper to say that one is saved by grace, though he said he would not go so far as to say it "necessarily incorrect". He kept citing an example of an atheist who prospers in this life--must be getting grace from God, therefore, "not all grace saves". Can that truly be the case? Can we say that a certain type of grace is not salvific? I think this is where my true problem lies.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='992755' date='May 30 2006, 06:25 AM']....we are saved by baptism.[/quote]

Was the good thief at the crucifiction baptized? No. We have no reason to say yes.


Did he go to heaven? Yes.


Then he must have been saved by some other means than baptism. Therefore, some other means to salvation must exist strictly baptism.

Posted

there are things called baptism by desire.

some desire to be baptized but aren't baptized.

and that itself can "save" someone

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='993460' date='May 31 2006, 08:23 AM']
Phat,

Good comments. I agree.

Except my friend claimed that because it was too ambiguous it would not be proper to say that one is saved by grace, though he said he would not go so far as to say it "necessarily incorrect". He kept citing an example of an atheist who prospers in this life--must be getting grace from God, therefore, "not all grace saves". Can that truly be the case? Can we say that a certain type of grace is not salvific? I think this is where my true problem lies.
[/quote]

The theif really is an invalid arguement because he died before the resurrection. The baptism of John was practiced at that time but it did not confer the Holy Spirit.

The theif on the cross was a special instance and a good case for the statement "God is not limited by his sacraments". Sacrements call us to obedience. They do not give us a reason for condemning the part of the world that does not know of them. Most certainly had the theif on the cross had the opportunity he would have recieved baptism and so he is not overyly problematic.

Blessings

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I looked up some more about grace and Catholicism and found that the Church distinguishes between two types of grace not found in the Catechism: efficacious graces and sufficient graces.

The definition of the latter (sufficient) grace says that this grace is "not effective through some fault of the person"... but how then is it the fault of grace not being efficacious when in reality, it is the rejection (the fault) of the person that destroys the efficacy? This is under the section of Ott's book that claims as a matter de fide "There is a grace which is truly sufficient and yet remains inefficacious"-- This does not make sense to me in speaking about grace. :idontknow:

Any one know anything more in depth about this?

(BTW, lutheran friend is claiming that atheists accept grace (the grace of their "daily bread") and are not saved, therefore not all grace saves.. but I am having a hard time admitting that an atheist would accept grace in any sense... so any light there would be helpful)

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='994461' date='Jun 1 2006, 08:04 AM']
I looked up some more about grace and Catholicism and found that the Church distinguishes between two types of grace not found in the Catechism: efficacious graces and sufficient graces.

The definition of the latter (sufficient) grace says that this grace is "not effective through some fault of the person"... but how then is it the fault of grace not being efficacious when in reality, it is the rejection (the fault) of the person that destroys the efficacy? This is under the section of Ott's book that claims as a matter de fide "There is a grace which is truly sufficient and yet remains inefficacious"-- This does not make sense to me in speaking about grace. :idontknow:

Any one know anything more in depth about this?

(BTW, lutheran friend is claiming that atheists accept grace (the grace of their "daily bread") and are not saved, therefore not all grace saves.. but I am having a hard time admitting that an atheist would accept grace in any sense... so any light there would be helpful)
[/quote]

I have not heard that terminology but I think your looking at it from the wrong direction. I would say it is not a fault of the grace. It of course cannot be. But I think the term sufficient derives from the church teaching that God gives all men grace SUFFICIENT for thier salvation. It is adequate to bring about their salvatoin but grace can be rejected. Therefore, though sufficient to overcome the fault in the person, it is not efficacious because they reject it. In some sense each Eucharist, which is infinitely sufficeint because it is Jesus Christ, to overcome all of our faults falls short only because our wills are not completely conformed to him. Our will is still choosing sin. That would be my take on it all.

There is another grace in the Catholic Encyclopedia that I don't think is in the Catechism. It is called gratuitous grace. It is defined as grace for the purpose of somone else. For instance, in Acts 10,11 the tongue speaking of Cornelius and his people was for the purpose of convincing Peter that the gentiles were to recieve the Gospel
as well.

Your Lutheran friend is right. Not all grace saves. All creation cries out to the glory of God! This is natural grace and the scriptures tell us that when it is rejected "there is no excuse". Some do not come to the conclusion that there is a God, as the grace is intended and is sufficient to bring about, though it is there for all except the blind and mentally deficient. I.e. it is sufficient to bring them to a knowledge of God but not effective because they reject it. Hope that helps.

Edited by thessalonian
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

How does that become the fault of grace, and not the person? If I reject it-- I'm rejecting it's efficacy-- but were I to embrace it, it would be efficacious.

Or, is there grace that a person can accept and it still isn't efficacious?

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='994991' date='Jun 1 2006, 06:27 PM']
How does that become the fault of grace, and not the person? If I reject it-- I'm rejecting it's efficacy-- but were I to embrace it, it would be efficacious.

Or, is there grace that a person can accept and it still isn't efficacious?
[/quote]


It cannot be the fault of grace. That's my point. Grace is given but it is not efficasious because it freewill does not allow it to be efficasious. It is suffient to be however if the will would allow it.

Here is the new advent article. Perhaps it will help.
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06710a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06710a.htm[/url]

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

But then I don't think it appropriate to say that "not all grace saves". Grace does save, but it requires cooperation (i.e., acceptance).

thessalonian
Posted

As a statement without laying fault, I think the statement "not all grace saves" is fine. Not all food keeps men alive. Do you agree? That which does not get eaten does not. It is not the fault of the food. I think it is a matter of perspective. I think both ways of looking at it are okay. In the case of grace one might even take it in, i.e. come to a conclusion there is a God, but it still might not save because he may not change his life accordingly. Once again, not the fault of the grace.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...