Resurrexi Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 (edited) Was the Assumption the last dogma defined or has there been a more recently defined dogma? By the way, I am NOT looking for a debate! Edited May 31, 2006 by StThomasMore
jswranch Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_letters/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_22051994_ordinatio-sacerdotalis_en.html"]Ban on women priestesses.[/url] JPII. 1994.
phatcatholic Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='993338' date='May 30 2006, 11:34 PM'] [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_letters/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_22051994_ordinatio-sacerdotalis_en.html"]Ban on women priestesses.[/url] JPII. 1994. [/quote] as i understand it, that was not a definition of dogma, which usually has the effect of giving the last word on something that has been up for debate. instead, it was an affirmation of what has always been the common teaching of the Church. of course, it still requires our utmost assent.
Apotheoun Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 The fact that women cannot be ordained to the presbyterate has been infallibly taught by the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium as a truth of Catholic doctrine; as a consequence, the teaching contained in [u]Ordinatio Sacerdotalis[/u] is an official confirmation of a doctrine that must be held definitively (i.e., irrevocably) by all the members of the Church.
cappie Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 Just a note on "defined dogma" from the Catholic Encyclopedia: It has been sometimes said that it is impossible to know whether or not a theological definition has been issued; but very few words are needed to show that the assertion is without foundation. At times, doubt will remain about the definitive nature of a decree, but as a rule no possibility of doubt is consistent with the terminology of a definitive decree. Thus in the doctrinal teaching of a general council, anathema attached to condemned errors is a certain sign of an infallible definition. Words also like those in which Pius IX solemnly defined the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin give irrefutable proof of the definitive nature of the decree: "By the authority of Our Lord Jesus Christ and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul, and by Our own authority, We declare, pronounce and define the doctrine . . . to be revealed by God and as such to be firmly and immutably held by all the faithful." No set form of words is necessary; any form which clearly indicates that the four requisite conditions are present suffices to show that the decree is a definition in the strict sense. It should be noted that not everything contained in a definition is infallibly defined. Thus, arguments from Scripture, tradition, or theological reason, do not come under the exercise of definitive authority. Incidental statements, called obiter dicta, are also examples of non-definitive utterances. Only the doctrine itself, to which those arguments lead and which these obiter dicta illustrate, is to be considered as infallibly defined. The Assumption was the last dogma defined in a solemn way
JJMG2001 Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 [quote name='ORDINATIO SACERDOTALIS']I declare that the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church's faithful."[/quote] That is an infallible statement. One could argue it is a doctrine not a dogma but it is still infallible.
Apotheoun Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 [quote name='JJMG2001' post='993406' date='May 31 2006, 02:09 AM'] That is an infallible statement. One could argue it is a doctrine not a dogma but it is still infallible. [/quote] The Pope's [i]declaration of confirmation[/i] in the Apostolic Letter [u]Ordinatio Sacerdotalis[/u] taken by itself is not an infallible definition; instead, it is an official confirmation of an already existing infallible doctrine taught through a non-defining act of the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium. Certainly, John Paul II's [i]declaration of confirmation[/i] is infallible when it is seen as the final link in the entire chain of teaching of the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium on this issue, but it is not infallible [i]per se[/i], because it must always be read in connection with the teaching of the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium understood diachronically. Click the link below to read a paper that I wrote on the power of the Pope to confirm a teaching of the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium as [i]definitive tenenda[/i]: [url="http://www.geocities.com/apotheoun/paper13b"][u]The Debate Occasioned by Lumen Gentium 25 regarding the Authority of the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium[/u][/url]
jswranch Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 So the dogmatic weight of a sentence in 'Ordinatio Sacerdotalis' is in debate at some level. How about other recent dogmas: The council at Vatican II was infact an ecumenical council. JPII and BXVI were elected pope.
journeyman Posted May 31, 2006 Posted May 31, 2006 How do the elections of JP II or B XVI pertain to teachings of the Savior or the Apostles, or to faith and morals? [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05089a.htm"]Dogma - defined - Catholic Encyclopedia[/url] The word dogma (Gr. dogma from dokein) signifies, in the writings of the ancient classical authors, sometimes, an opinion or that which seems true to a person; sometimes, the philosophical doctrines or tenets, and especially the distinctive philosophical doctrines, of a particular school of philosophers (cf. Cic. Ac., ii, 9), and sometimes, a public decree or ordinance, as dogma poieisthai. In Sacred Scripture it is used, at one time, in the sense of a decree or edict of the civil authority, as in Luke, ii, 1: "And it came to pass, that in those days there went out a decree [edictum, dogma] from Caesar Augustus" (cf. Acts 17:7; Esther 3:3); at another time, in the sense of an ordinance of the Mosaic Law as in Eph., ii 15: "Making void the law of commandments contained in decrees" (dogmasin), and again, it is applied to the ordinances or decrees of the first Apostolic Council in Jerusalem: "And as they passed through the cities, they delivered unto them the decrees [dogmata] for to keep, that were decreed by the apostles and ancients who were at Jerusalem" (Acts 16:4). Among the early Fathers the usage was prevalent of designating as dogmas the doctrines and moral precepts taught or promulgated by the Saviour or by the Apostles; and a distinction was sometimes made between Divine, Apostolical, and ecclesiastical dogmas, according as a doctrine was conceived as having been taught by Christ, by the Apostles, or as having been delivered to the faithful by the Church. But according to a long-standing usage a dogma is now understood to be a truth appertaining to faith or morals, revealed by God, transmitted from the Apostles in the Scriptures or by tradition, and proposed by the Church for the acceptance of the faithful. It might be described briefly as a revealed truth defined by the Church -- but private revelations do not constitute dogmas, and some theologians confine the word defined to doctrines solemnly defined by the pope or by a general council, while a revealed truth becomes a dogma even when proposed by the Church through her ordinary magisterium or teaching office. A dogma therefore implies a twofold relation: to Divine revelation and to the authoritative teaching of the Church.
qfnol31 Posted June 1, 2006 Posted June 1, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='993635' date='May 31 2006, 02:35 PM'] So the dogmatic weight of a sentence in 'Ordinatio Sacerdotalis' is in debate at some level. How about other recent dogmas: The council at Vatican II was infact an ecumenical council. JPII and BXVI were elected pope. [/quote] Cardinal Ratzinger said Ordinatio Sacerdotalis is infallible. A difference between this and the two ex-Cathedra statements is the fact that those were defined, this was not. It's infallible either way, but one cuts off a lot of discussion (defintions).
cappie Posted June 1, 2006 Posted June 1, 2006 The doctrine of the Assumption was legitimately declared under papal authority with the words "by our own authority, we pronounce, declare, and define" The use of the majestic plural is more than poetry. The Pope used this language to establish that the truth being proclaimed has been held explicitly or implicitly by prior Popes, and is to be held explicitly by future Popes. Likewise, the active sense of the word "define" is intentional. Though the Pope appeals to other types of infallible revelation, he is clearly affirming the truth by his own papal authority in an act of full papal infallibility. On the other hand, Pope John Paul II declared his position through an apostolic letter addressed to the bishops, rather than a papal bull, addressed to all the faithful. He is implying from the start that this letter is of lesser authority than Munificentissimus Deus. Furthermore, John Paul II stated that the position that the Church is not authorized to ordain women, is to be held as though it were infallible ("is to be definitively held"). There is a different use of the word "define" such that the Pope is not actively defining a doctrine, so much as holding up a judgment to be definitively held by all. In the Latin, this was the exact same usage we saw in the Vatican II definition of the infallibility of the ordinary universal Magisterium. Furthermore, in John Paul's letter, he used the words "I declare", implying this position is his opinion from the perspective of his ordinary papal Magisterial authority, such as the authority of Humanae Vitae, rather than the opinion of the infallible and ex cathedra authority of the papacy per say that the majestic plural would convey. Thus, it appears that John Paul II is not claiming ex cathedra papal authority. This does not seem to be a statement of full papal infallibility. Rather, the Holy Father made this statement based on the second type of infallibility outlined above, that of the ordinary universal Magisterium, or the consensus of the college of bishops. This was confirmed by the CDF in its Responsum Ad Dubium on October 28, 1995, when they responded to a Bishop's inquiry with the following: This teaching requires definitive assent, since, founded on the written Word of God, and from the beginning constantly preserved and applied in the Tradition of the Church, it has been set forth infallibly by the ordinary and universal Magisterium (cf. Second Vatican Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church Lumen Gentium 25. 2). Thus, in the present circumstances, the Roman Pontiff, exercising his proper office of confirming the brethren (cf. Lk 22:32), has handed on this same teaching by a formal declaration, explicitly stating what is to be held always, everywhere, and by all, as belonging to the deposit of the faith. This will sound to the layperson or to the conservative like mere semantics. However, the Prefect for the CDF, Joseph Cardinal Ratziner, in his commentary on the October 28, 1995 statement confirmed the difficulty with the following statements: In fact, as the Reply explains, the definitive nature of this assent derives from the truth of the doctrine itself, since, founded on the written Word of God, and constantly held and applied in the Tradition of the Church, it has been set forth infallibly by the ordinary universal Magisterium (cf. Lumen Gentium, 25). Thus, the Reply specifies that this doctrine belongs to the deposit of the faith of the Church. It should be emphasized that the definitive and infallible nature of this teaching of the Church did not arise with the publication of the Letter Ordinatio Sacerdotalis. In the Letter, as the Reply of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith also explains, the Roman Pontiff, having taken account of present circumstances, has confirmed the same teaching by a formal declaration, giving expression once again to quod semper, quod ubique et quod ab omnibus tenendum est, utpote ad fidei depositum pertinens. In this case, an act of the ordinary Papal Magisterium, in itself not infallible, witnesses to the infallibility of the teaching of a doctrine already possessed by the Church.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now