Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

It isn't playing in my area, but I'm really looking forward to checking it out. I'm not looking for opinions of Al Gore, just the movie.

Posted

Never heard of it. Politics are akin to blasphemy, though, so I don't really care about it, either. And then there's the fact that I absolutely [b]hate[/b] movies. So...no >_>

Posted

I would give it a chance, although coming from Al Gore, I don't know how objective and reliable it would be.

heavenseeker
Posted

Al Gore is funny. Dont ask how he just is.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I have heard that both Al Gore and Bob Dole have a pretty good senses of humor which often is overshadowed by their political careers. (Though the time Gore went on that irate rant scared me.)

[img]http://www.kegz.net/archives/images/gore_angry.jpg[/img]

Anyway -- about the film -- I've heard that Gore isn't trying to be partisan about the film, and I am interested in seeing it. I hope that the film isn't a big ad for the Democratic Party. The environment need not be a partisan issue since it affects everyone.

TheOliverOrder88
Posted

I think he's pulling for the Oval office...

Guest T-Bone
Posted

Here's the logic behind global warming:

They start off with two facts:

Increased CO2 [i]may[/i] cause a global temperature increase.

-and-

There is an increase in global levels of CO2.

Given this, they have constructed mathmatical models of global climate change.

Global warming policy is based on these mathmatical models. NOT ACTUAL SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE.

There is no proof that global temperatures are significantly on the rise.
There is no proof that human activity is effecting the global climate.
There is no proof that a changed climate is necessaraly a negative thing.

This, my friends, is "An Inconvenient Truth."

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone' post='995357' date='Jun 2 2006, 03:49 AM']
Here's the logic behind global warming:

They start off with two facts:

Increased CO2 [i]may[/i] cause a global temperature increase.

-and-

There is an increase in global levels of CO2.

Given this, they have constructed mathmatical models of global climate change.

Global warming policy is based on these mathmatical models. NOT ACTUAL SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE.

There is no proof that global temperatures are significantly on the rise.
There is no proof that human activity is effecting the global climate.
There is no proof that a changed climate is necessaraly a negative thing.

This, my friends, is "An Inconvenient Truth."
[/quote]

There is no [i]may[/i] about CO2 and global warming. There is tons of irrefutable scientific proof. Again I haven't seen the movie, but when I worked as a hotel A/V technician, I sat in a meeting for the EPA. During the meeting, a scientist gave a talk that was corroborated by an international team of arctic scientists who drill ice cores at the poles. They can measure average global temperatures over hundreds of thousands of years with certain types of oxygen molecules trapped in the snow layers. They also measure CO2 levels in the atmosphere. When he compared CO2 levels with global temperatures on a chart, the lines matched identically with a slight delay in the temperature line. Over the past 50 years the CO2 levels went clear off the chart. The levels are many times higher now than have been observed in over 600,000 years. The temperatures haven't caught up yet, but they will. This meeting was a huge eye-opener for me.
T-Bone, the polar ice caps are melting. You can go there and observe it with your own two eyes. At the current rate, many coastal cities will be under water in a hundred years. Is that necesarrily a negative thing? And, that's only the tip of the iceberg (pun intended). Watch the storms and rainfall over the next 10 years. Its going to get a lot stronger from warmer oceans. I'm not a fan of algore, but I'm looking forward to hearing what he has to say.
I live in Steubenville, so the issue is near and dear to my heart. Every day I watch dozens of coal barges and trains and trucks go by my window (If you listen closely to some of the CD's we've recorded at Innovation, I'm sure you can hear some of them too). And then I have to breathe the air here, and my son has asthma, and it smells of elderberries. We should all be concerned about this because these are major problems our kids will have to deal with.

Guest T-Bone
Posted

[quote name='mofca' post='995431' date='Jun 2 2006, 07:25 AM']
There is no [i]may[/i] about CO2 and global warming. There is tons of irrefutable scientific proof. Again I haven't seen the movie, but when I worked as a hotel A/V technician, I sat in a meeting for the EPA. During the meeting, a scientist gave a talk that was corroborated by an international team of arctic scientists who drill ice cores at the poles. They can measure average global temperatures over hundreds of thousands of years with certain types of oxygen molecules trapped in the snow layers. They also measure CO2 levels in the atmosphere. When he compared CO2 levels with global temperatures on a chart, the lines matched identically with a slight delay in the temperature line. Over the past 50 years the CO2 levels went clear off the chart. The levels are many times higher now than have been observed in over 600,000 years. The temperatures haven't caught up yet, but they will. This meeting was a huge eye-opener for me.
[/quote]

This is not irrefutable scientific proof. Global warming is dogma, and is "proven" only by theoretical mathmatical models. Even the intellectally honest scientists that beleive in human-caused global warming admit that their opinions are based on these mathmatical models.

Al Gore is no scientist, and he has a clear agenda.


[quote]
I live in Steubenville, so the issue is near and dear to my heart. Every day I watch dozens of coal barges and trains and trucks go by my window (If you listen closely to some of the CD's we've recorded at Innovation, I'm sure you can hear some of them too). And then I have to breathe the air here, and my son has asthma, and it smells of elderberries. We should all be concerned about this because these are major problems our kids will have to deal with.
[/quote]

I'm not saying that air pollution isn't bad, or that we shouldn't reduce emissions. But films such as this remind me of Micheal Moore and his shinaningans.

Posted

Two hours of Al Gore lecturing us on global warming!
Wow! Get me my advance tickets! <_<

Posted

[quote]This is not irrefutable scientific proof. Global warming is dogma, and is "proven" only by theoretical mathmatical models. Even the intellectally honest scientists that beleive in human-caused global warming admit that their opinions are based on these mathmatical models.
[/quote]
The mathmatical models are based on imperical evidence. By the time the mathematical models becomes as you say "irrefutable scientific proof", it will be too late. There really is no debate among scientists about this. One of the most surprising facts from the film: of the 900-odd peer-reviewed scientific papers on the subject, the number that said this wasn't man-made is zero. Again, global warming is a fact.

[quote]Al Gore is no scientist, and he has a clear agenda.[/quote]
I've heard others say this, and I don't understand what his agenda is, other than to educate people about a topic that he is passionate about. He is out of the political game. He's announced that he will not run for office again.

Here is what Robert Ebert said in his review of the film:
[quote]In 39 years, I have never written these words in a movie review, but here they are: You owe it to yourself to see this film. If you do not, and you have grandchildren, you should explain to them why you decided not to.[/quote]
But then again, he's liberal, so he's probably blowing smoke just like algore.

Guest T-Bone
Posted

[quote name='mofca' post='997912' date='Jun 5 2006, 06:20 PM']
One of the most surprising facts from the film: of the 900-odd peer-reviewed scientific papers on the subject, the number that said this wasn't man-made is zero. Again, global warming is a fact.
[/quote]

I have oft heard this touted by many an environmentalist, but not one person could prove it.

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone' post='998226' date='Jun 6 2006, 05:23 AM']
I have oft heard this touted by many an environmentalist, but not one person could prove it.
[/quote]
So, is it likely that the movie lies about this? I doubt it.

Here's another way to look at it. If you want to visualize the rate of global oil consumption, picture an olympic size pool filled with oil. Now picture it draining in 15 seconds.
The next time you fly, look out the window and you'll notice a layer of yellow-brown haze just below the clouds. I remember flying as a kid 25 years ago and you would only see that haze around major cities. Now its everywhere.
Try starting a car in your living room. You would be dead in an hour. How can there be 600 million cars on the road and there not be dire consequences? I think its irresponsable for the human race to blow this stuff off like its BS, and this movie might be a step in the right direction.

Guest T-Bone
Posted

[quote name='mofca' post='998347' date='Jun 6 2006, 07:56 AM']
So, is it likely that the movie lies about this? I doubt it.
[/quote]

If a lie is quoted enough, it becomes the "truth." I'm not saying that Al Gore is lying, I'm just saying I do not at all believe the little tid-bit about the research papers.

(Then again, Al Gore is not above misleading people. After all, he did clain to "take the inititive in the creation of the internet.")

[quote]
Here's another way to look at it. If you want to visualize the rate of global oil consumption, picture an olympic size pool filled with oil. Now picture it draining in 15 seconds.
[/quote]

Good job of confusing the issue. The subject is global warming, not oil consumption.

[quote]
The next time you fly, look out the window and you'll notice a layer of yellow-brown haze just below the clouds. I remember flying as a kid 25 years ago and you would only see that haze around major cities. Now its everywhere.
[/quote]

I've gone on several plane trips in the last ten years. I have not noticed this at all. Try again.

[quote]
Try starting a car in your living room. You would be dead in an hour. How can there be 600 million cars on the road and there not be dire consequences?
[/quote]

Finally, some meat to your argument. But I'm sorry, I want actually data before I significantly change my lifestyle. Just the way I am.

[quote]
I think its irresponsable for the human race to blow this stuff off like its BS, and this movie might be a step in the right direction.
[/quote]

I think it is irresponsible for the human race to panic everytime people cry "The world is ending!" and not actually think critically about the claims of scientists. A propoganda movie that is filled with speculation and half truths is not a step in the right direction.

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone' post='998226' date='Jun 6 2006, 06:23 AM']
I have oft heard this touted by many an environmentalist, but not one person could prove it.
[/quote]
Just curious: what evidence would you require to consider something like global warming "proven" and is the acquisition of such evidence possible?

(Almost nothing in science is [i]proven[/i] -- only mathematics has that kind of rigor.)

Guest T-Bone
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='998821' date='Jun 6 2006, 02:47 PM']
Just curious: what evidence would you require to consider something like global warming "proven" and is the acquisition of such evidence possible?

(Almost nothing in science is [i]proven[/i] -- only mathematics has that kind of rigor.)
[/quote]

An actualy [i]significant[/i] increase in world wide temperatures, as compared to actually measured temperatures from the past--not estimates. Proof, not mathmatical models.

Posted (edited)

[quote]Good job of confusing the issue. The subject is global warming, not oil consumption. [/quote]

The movie is about global warming, to which greenhouse gases contribute. Burning fossil fuels releases CO2 into the atmosphere, which is a a greenhouse gas. This doesn't seem confusing to me.

[quote]I have oft heard this touted by many an environmentalist, but not one person could prove it.[/quote]
Here is an article from CNN.com. I simply did a search for global warming.
[url="http://www.cnn.com/2005/TECH/science/04/08/earth.science/index.html"]http://www.cnn.com/2005/TECH/science/04/08...ence/index.html[/url]

Here is a direct quote from the first paragraph of the article:
[quote]Is global warming really a threat?

Absolutely, respond most scientists, but they have only recently been able to approach a basic agreement about our changing climate.[/quote]

I guess CNN is spreading lies too.

Edited by mofca
Guest T-Bone
Posted

[quote name='mofca' post='998920' date='Jun 6 2006, 06:41 PM']
The movie is about global warming, to which greenhouse gases contribute. Burning fossil fuels releases CO2 into the atmosphere, which is a a greenhouse gas. This doesn't seem confusing to me.
[/quote]

I never said I was confused.
I said you were confusing the issue. Maybe I should have been more clear: DWINDILING FUEL SUPPLIES ARE A DIFFERENT ISSUE THAN GLOBAL WARMING.

[quote]
[quote]
I have ft heard this touted by many an environmentalist, but not one person could prove it.
( One of the most surprising facts from the film: of the 900-odd peer-reviewed scientific papers on the subject, the number that said this wasn't man-made is zero. Again, global warming is a fact.)
[/quote]
Here is an article from CNN.com. I simply did a search for global warming


[url="http://www.cnn.com/2005/TECH/science/04/08/earth.science/index.html"]http://www.cnn.com/2005/TECH/science/04/08...ence/index.html[/url]

Here is a direct quote from the first paragraph of the article:
I guess CNN is spreading lies too.
[/quote]

Hmmm...no mention of the 900 peer-reviewed scientific papers...
Try again.


[quote] Is global warming really a threat?

Absolutely, respond [b]most [/b]scientists, but they have only recently been able to approach a basic agreement about our changing climate.[/quote]

This kinda refutes your assertion that it is a fact, does it not?

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone' post='998860' date='Jun 6 2006, 05:54 PM']
An actualy [i]significant[/i] increase in world wide temperatures, as compared to actually measured temperatures from the past--not estimates. Proof, not mathmatical models.
[/quote]
What do you consider significant (and why)? And how many years of data do you require? Obviously worldwide temperature monitoring is a fairly recent development.

FWIW, the most prominent studies of global temperature change show data like this:
[img]http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/info/warming/gat2005-600x283.gif[/img]
[i]from the Climatic Research Unit, UEA Norwich[/i]

I assume this is not good enough for you? Some of the data for the oldest dates was collected from things known to be directly caused by ambient temperature, like coral growth.

Guest T-Bone
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='999012' date='Jun 6 2006, 07:27 PM']
What do you consider significant (and why)? And how many years of data do you require? Obviously worldwide temperature monitoring is a fairly recent development.

FWIW, the most prominent studies of global temperature change show data like this:
[img]http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/info/warming/gat2005-600x283.gif[/img]
[i]from the Climatic Research Unit, UEA Norwich[/i]

I assume this is not good enough for you? Some of the data for the oldest dates was collected from things known to be directly caused by ambient temperature, like coral growth.
[/quote]

Thank you for the graphic.

I cannot trust the temperatures from before 1940 at all, and I would not call a change of less than one degree over 60 years significant. I understand the cause for concern, but frankly there is not enough evidence that the global temperature changes are man-caused, significant, or harmful.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...