MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted June 1, 2006 Posted June 1, 2006 NOTE: This is not a debate about Nietzsche. I am just under the impression that the people who are likely to help me with refutations to his systems are likely to be found in here. Well, i am taking a summer upper division philosophy class. And well, its the only one offered, and is required. However, the teacher is a little off her rocker. Stereotypical washed up old hippy, who is late for class every day, and goes over time. She is more obsessed with her agenda. In fact, she wasnt even there on the first day of summer school. But anyways, our only actually philosophical work we are reading is Nietzsche. It seems to be her worldview. But rather, i think she may have a candycoated perception of Nietzche that is more in line with her sixties progressive agenda than Nietzsche himself. So i do need any links or references you may have that challenge Nietzsche. Thanks. SHALOM
Franimus Posted June 1, 2006 Posted June 1, 2006 Could you refresh me on some of the ideas regarding Nietzsche? I can get my philosophy notes off of my old laptop... Plus I have my philosophy books from last semester still. Most of the stuff I have regards specific ideas; we didn't focus on just one person, just ideas and who said what.
ChrisZewe Posted June 1, 2006 Posted June 1, 2006 You can't challenge Herr Nietzsche. It doesn't work.
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted June 1, 2006 Author Posted June 1, 2006 [quote name='ChrisZewe' post='994879' date='Jun 1 2006, 04:43 PM'] You can't challenge Herr Nietzsche. It doesn't work. [/quote] Why not? Nietzsche's major thing is master and slave morality. We are covering him in an ethics class, so it would mostly be about Nietzsche's positions there. SHALOM
AngelofJesus Posted June 1, 2006 Posted June 1, 2006 [quote name='ChrisZewe' post='994879' date='Jun 1 2006, 02:43 PM'] You can't challenge Herr Nietzsche. It doesn't work. [/quote] You must not have read G.E. Gorfus' writings.
ChrisZewe Posted June 1, 2006 Posted June 1, 2006 [quote name='AngelofJesus' post='994923' date='Jun 1 2006, 06:23 PM'] You must not have read G.E. Gorfus' writings. [/quote] By "doesn't work" I didn't mean that challenging him is impossible. I just meant that it's impossible if you don't want to make a fool of yourself.
raptor13 Posted June 2, 2006 Posted June 2, 2006 "Herr" is German for "Mister." And Chris is right, Nietzche is hard to attack because he specifically attacks Christianity and anyone who attacks him will just be considered one of the "Jesus-brainswashed slaves trying to rebel against the aristocrats" This is all supposing, of course, that God doesn't exist. Which will probably be the default viewpoint.
qfnol31 Posted June 2, 2006 Posted June 2, 2006 [quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' post='994909' date='Jun 1 2006, 05:07 PM']Why not? Nietzsche's major thing is master and slave morality. We are covering him in an ethics class, so it would mostly be about Nietzsche's positions there. SHALOM[/quote] I know a lot, I think..., about Nietzsche's master-slave morality. It's based on the idea that men are always in a relationship of master to slave. Men are either supposed to rule or be ruled. His idea of how man came to have reason was just so that he could survive. Reason allows us to put things together, like a rock and stick to make a spear. Another big thing in Nietzsche is the Eternal Return, which is the eternal recurrence of the world exactly the same each time. Somehow he thought that it was also empirically verifiable. I just took an entire semester on Nietzsche plus a little extra, so I know some on him.
Guest T-Bone Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='ChrisZewe' post='994938' date='Jun 1 2006, 03:38 PM'] By "doesn't work" I didn't mean that challenging him is impossible. I just meant that it's impossible if you don't want to make a fool of yourself. [/quote] So you're saying that Nietsche is the end-all, be-all of philosophers? Hmm...haven't read much by him, but his arguements seem to be just as refutable as any other philosopher.
Socrates Posted June 4, 2006 Posted June 4, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='995424' date='Jun 2 2006, 08:01 AM'] I know a lot, I think..., about Nietzsche's master-slave morality. It's based on the idea that men are always in a relationship of master to slave. Men are either supposed to rule or be ruled. [/quote] Personally, I have trouble seeing how Nietzsche would appeal to the "peace'n'luv" hippy mentality.
jezic Posted June 4, 2006 Posted June 4, 2006 isn't he the philosopher that said "God is dead" ? (i am thinking so with LD's comment, but i am not entirely sure. I haven't studied a lot of philosophy yet.)
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted June 4, 2006 Author Posted June 4, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='996289' date='Jun 3 2006, 07:48 PM'] Personally, I have trouble seeing how Nietzsche would appeal to the "peace'n'luv" hippy mentality. [/quote] I do too. But i think thats why my teacher candy coats him. At least for her, i think Nietzsche is just her way of taking out her vengence on Christianity. And yes, i am a fool. I would hope to reserve such research not for class discussion, as much as for personal discussion. The teacher has a monopoly on discussion of course. SHALOM
dspen2005 Posted June 4, 2006 Posted June 4, 2006 Nietzsche's enterprise was to counter what he considered to be a dualistic structure in traditional metaphysics. According to him, metaphysicians had always focused on being, neglecting it's opposite, 'non-being' or nothing. (now, some can argue that there is a distinction b/w these two concepts of 'non-being' and 'nothing'). For Nietzsche, 'nothing' was a real metaphysical category and a means by which we confront our anxiety and freedom. only by placing ourselves out into the 'nothing' can we experience freedom.....
Justified Saint Posted June 5, 2006 Posted June 5, 2006 [quote name='dspen2005' post='996454' date='Jun 4 2006, 02:28 AM'] Nietzsche's enterprise was to counter what he considered to be a dualistic structure in traditional metaphysics. According to him, metaphysicians had always focused on being, neglecting it's opposite, 'non-being' or nothing. (now, some can argue that there is a distinction b/w these two concepts of 'non-being' and 'nothing'). For Nietzsche, 'nothing' was a real metaphysical category and a means by which we confront our anxiety and freedom. only by placing ourselves out into the 'nothing' can we experience freedom..... [/quote] I have only read one book by Nietzsche, but that seems a little odd since one of his biggest gripes against Christianity is, in his terms, its "will to nothingness." Of course I have seen hard-core Nietzscheans admit that he is about as contradictory as they come. Many are of the opinion that theology is only possible after Nietzsche's "death of God" insights. Whatever one thinks of him, he is clearly an important thinker to those who wish to take seriously their (Christian) faith.
Guest T-Bone Posted June 5, 2006 Posted June 5, 2006 [quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' post='996432' date='Jun 3 2006, 11:04 PM'] I do too. But i think thats why my teacher candy coats him. At least for her, i think Nietzsche is just her way of taking out her vengence on Christianity. And yes, i am a fool. I would hope to reserve such research not for class discussion, as much as for personal discussion. The teacher has a monopoly on discussion of course. SHALOM [/quote] Point out how he was an anti-semite and a racist, and how his philosophy influenced the Nazi party.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted June 5, 2006 Posted June 5, 2006 [quote name='T-Bone' post='997180' date='Jun 5 2006, 12:43 AM'] Point out how he was an anti-semite and a racist, and how his philosophy influenced the Nazi party. [/quote] Don't do that. All of the above are [i]ad hominem[/i] attacks and argumentative fallacies. If you really want to counter Nietzsche, then you need to take at his thought, if not his person, seriously. Do some research of your own, read his writings and the critiques of other philosophers. As a starter, I would point out that, while Nietzsche certainly had some brilliant insights, he painted his philosophical landscapes with broad strokes, and this resulted in his providing characatures of many philosophical systems rather than accurate accounts. His analysis of Christianity was pointedly biased and no serious scholar will disagree, and his depiction of much of Greek thought failed to acknowledge its more subtle points and turns. This resulted in many of his arguments contra alternative systems of thought to be little more than straw-men, however, they must be taken on a case-by-case basis, and an adequate knowledge of the history of philosophy will be necessary in order to point out exactly where Nietzsche philosophical paint brush was simply too broad to provide accurate depictions. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now