Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Are you a Roman or Eastern Catholic?


Are you a Roman or Eastern Catholic?  

97 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think that doing both, although it is allowed, it isn't encouraged. I spoke to an Easter Rite priest about this. He said that they prefer to have to priests unmarried.

Janana8706
Posted

it won't let me vote, but I'm a Roman

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

Traditional Latin Catholic

Posted

I'm a Byzantine (Ruthenian) Christian.

Posted

Roman Catholic.

Posted

I'm a Latin...I consider myself by Church, not by Rite. :P:

Posted

StThomasMore, why do you have a Quebec flag as your avatar?

Posted

because, I love Quebec for it is the land of my French-Canadian ancestors. I also went on vacation there recently and enjoyed myself grately.

Posted

I also love Quebec, because:
it is my home,
it is the land of a bunch of my ancestors,
it is the cradle of faith in Canada (and we therefore have just about all the Saints and Blesseds),
it's a beautiful land,
the particular island I live on was founded as Ville Marie,
there's no place quite like it (when I visited my uncle in BC, I really missed the French, even though sometimes I can't remember whether something was said in English or French, and even though I have trouble understanding Joual),
it's home.

And I can't imagine only knowing people who have the same mother tongue. Or always going to mass in the same language. Parts of the mass hit you in a special way when you hear them in a different language.

Norseman82
Posted

Latin Rite here.

[quote name='Franimus' post='996029' date='Jun 3 2006, 06:41 AM']
one thing i like about eastern rites - their priests can marry... i've lightly considered switching so i can do both. [/quote]

I was told years ago - by a Ukrainian Catholic priest, I think - that one is not allowed to switch rites just to be a married priest.

Posted

[quote]Parts of the mass hit you in a special way when you hear them in a different language.[/quote]

Most definetly. Especially when that language is dead!

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='996349' date='Jun 3 2006, 10:31 PM']
I was told years ago - by a Ukrainian Catholic priest, I think - that one is not allowed to switch rites just to be a married priest.
[/quote]
True. However, I think Eddie Doherty somehow changed rites, because he was ordained after being married to Catherine Doherty. They did give up marital relations, but I'm still pretty sure he switched rites

Someone else said that eastern rites prefer non-married priests. I've heard that in the West that is the case out of respect for the pope and the latin discipline.
Of course, only non-married priests can become bishops.

One of our seminarians once told us about a fellow seminarian of an eastern rite who went off to get married the weekend before he was ordained deacon. The seminarians felt it was kind of weird to have a fellow seminarian showing off pictures of his fiancé.

Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Maria' post='996366' date='Jun 3 2006, 09:54 PM']
Someone else said that eastern rites prefer non-married priests. I've heard that in the West that is the case out of respect for the pope and the latin discipline.
[/quote]

Apotheun could probably speak better about this, but I did do a research paper in college about celibacy in the Eastern Rites, and what happened in the USA was that in the late 1800s people in Minnesota who were unfamiliar with the Eastern Rites encountered some married priests, felt scandalized, complained to the bishop, and that got back to Rome, so Rome issued a prohibition on Eastern Rite dioceses in the USA ordaining married men. What ended up happening was that if a married man inthe USA wanted to be ordained for an Eastern Rite, he would have to be ordained for a diocese in Ukraine (or wherever). I believe this prohibition may have been lifted recently.

Anyway, I think everyone should pay attention to the reunification efforts between the Roman Catholic Church and the Polish National Catholic Church:

[url="http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/mchenry/chi-0606020196jun02,1,194272.story?ctrack=1&cset=true"]http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/m...ack=1&cset=true[/url]

This is important because the Polish National Catholic Church allows bishops and priests to marry:

[url="http://www.pncc.org/who_beliefs.htm"]http://www.pncc.org/who_beliefs.htm[/url]

This especially came into play about ten or so years ago when i was reading about a Polish National Catholic priest who "came home to Rome". I don't remember if he was married or not, and I didn't save the article, so I'm relying on memory here, but he did not have to be ordained again in the Roman Catholic Church because his original ordination in the Polish National Catholic Church was recognized as valid...

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='995962' date='Jun 3 2006, 12:06 AM']
I'm Roman Catholic, in the Roman Rite. Although I really enjoyed being a part of a Roman Catholic Church, of the Eastern Rite, when I lived in Texas. The Marionites are cool :).
[/quote]
hehe yes they are :).
I'm eastern rite but go mostly to latin-rite mass. If I go to any eastern Church, it's the Maronite Church (even though I'm Melkite, my moms Maronite).

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='995590' date='Jun 2 2006, 03:38 PM']
Roman, but my family also attends the local Marionite rite church occasionally. It's really beautiful, and is said partially in (I think) Syrian.
[/quote]

It's said partially in Syriac. Actually a lot of it is in Syriac, the language of Jesus. The Maronite Church is Lebanese (although there are some Maronites in Syria). The one in my area has like a soundproof feeling when you walk in, it's soo cool.

[quote name='Franimus' post='996029' date='Jun 3 2006, 06:41 AM']
one thing i like about eastern rites - their priests can marry... i've lightly considered switching so i can do both. My friend is Byzantine and he plans on marrying and being a priest (you have to marry first).
[/quote]

Yes, we get more rights hahaha.

Posted

A couple points of clarification:

First, it is important to note that there is no such thing as a Roman Catholic of the Eastern Rite.

The Eastern Catholic Churches are true particular Churches, and so they should not be referred to as [i]rites[/i]. In fact, Eastern Catholics find it offensive when a person refers to their Churches as [i]rites[/i], because a rite is simply a liturgical tradition (i.e., it is a particular way of worshipping almighty God), but the Eastern Catholic Churches (e.g., the Ukrainian Catholic Church, the Ruthenian Catholic Church, the Melkite Catholic Church, etc.) are true apostolic Churches that are in communion with the Roman Church. It is also inappropriate to refer to Eastern Catholics as [i]Roman Catholics[/i], because the Eastern Catholic Churches have different spiritual, liturgical, and doctrinal traditions than the Roman Catholic Church; and moreover, this way of referring to Eastern Catholics has been used by Eastern Orthodox Christians in order to deny the true Eastern nature of the Eastern Catholic Churches, while simultaneously implying that Eastern Catholics are traitors to the Greek Patristical tradition (i.e., that they are in fact Latins pretending to be Eastern).

Second, as far as the issue of married clergy is concerned, a man who is ordained cannot get married after his ordination, and this tradition is common to both the Catholic and Orthodox Churches.

That being said, the Eastern Churches will ordain married men to the diaconate and the presbyterate, while in the modern Roman Church married men can only be ordained to the diaconate. As far as the episcopate is concerned, it is the universal tradition of both the Eastern and Western Churches that only celibate men can be consecrated as bishops.

Posted

[quote]The Eastern Catholic Churches (e.g., the Ukrainian Catholic Church, the Ruthenian Catholic Church, [b]the Melkite Catholic Church[/b], etc.) are true apostolic Churches that are in communion with the Roman Church.[/quote]

:blush:
:)

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I belong to the Latin Rite of the Roman Catholic Church. :)

Mateo el Feo
Posted

I'm a Romanized Maronite.

ilovechrist
Posted

Roman Roman Roman.

is what i am.

but i am telling you... the Eastern Rite's Churches + Masses are basically the most gorgeous creations on earth.

Posted

The Phorum -- based upon the poll results so far -- appears to be very homogeneous.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...