prose Posted June 2, 2006 Posted June 2, 2006 And I can understand the whole doctrine about that, but we do with a different type of prayer thing. I know someone here had an excellent explanation of different prayers to people (it was in regards to Mary). something about different translations. Now, for example, when we ask St.Anthony for help, we don't say "Saint Anthony, please pray to the Lord to help us", we say "St.Anthony help us.... (fill in rest here)" Is Saint Anthony helping us with God's help? Or is God helping us in response to St. Anthony's prayer? Just wanted to clarify this.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 2, 2006 Posted June 2, 2006 Yes, we actually pray TO Saints. Some conservative Catholics are afraid to say this, mistakenly thinking that "to pray" means "to worship as God or a god" (or are afraid that Protestants think that). All they need is a dictionary to find that "to pray" means "to ask." Now, pray tell, was that so hard to figure out?
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 In addition, good 'ol St. Thomas Aquinas developed a great term (err, set of terms) for the distinction of worship: dulia and latria. We adore God (and God alone) in latria, and we venerate the Saints in dulia. Our worship of the Saints does not terminate in them, but reaches through to God, because they are His-- He is their Creator. In honoring the "masterpieces" of His creation, we are giving honor and glory to the Creator. (and Mary, as the pinnacle of creation, receives hyper-dulia (above all other dulias))
franciscanheart Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 I use St. Thomas Aquinas's terms when talking about prayer because it seems to be the easiest way. Trying to argue dictionary definitions gets complicated and down-right frustrating!
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='hugheyforlife' post='995682' date='Jun 2 2006, 09:18 PM'] I use St. Thomas Aquinas's terms when talking about prayer because it seems to be the easiest way. Trying to argue dictionary definitions gets complicated and down-right frustrating! [/quote] agreed! I should've also mentioned/defined: latria=worship of one who is uncreated (i.e. the Trinity) dulia=worship of one who is created the distinction is critical... because we, as Catholics do recognize that the Saints are nothing without God, just as a painting is nothing without the Painter.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 Don't forget Hyperdulia! [quote] We actually do "worship Mary" -- but not with the sort of worship that is due to God alone (latria) which has become the modern Protestant sense of the word (this is why many Catholics, using this modern definition, insist we don't "worship Mary"; we most definitely don't believe she is God! We do not "worship Mary" in any sense that Protestants accuse us of, i.e., we don't "worship Mary" in the modern, Protestant sense of the word!). "To worship" does not necessarily mean treating someone or something as God. The British call their magistrates and mayors "Your Worship," and I don't think any of them mistakenly consider Mayor So-and-So to be the Father Almighty. The point for Protestants reading this is this: if you come across a traditional Catholic text referring to "Mary worship" in a good light, don't freak out.[/quote] Hyperdulia is the special veneration due to the Blessed Virgin Mary.
salveregina Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 Oh man...this thread made me think of a conversation I had yesterday at work (I work at a Catholic bookstore). A woman and I are talking (she's obviously not Catholic), and she says, "Yes, well, for Christians, Jesus is most important. And for Catholics, Mary is. Right?" Ummmm... Don't worry, I *kind of* straightened her out. She really wasn't interested in finding out the truth, though. Very interesting, and sad.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='salveregina' post='995694' date='Jun 2 2006, 09:06 PM'] Oh man...this thread made me think of a conversation I had yesterday at work (I work at a Catholic bookstore). A woman and I are talking (she's obviously not Catholic), and she says, "Yes, well, for Christians, Jesus is most important. And for Catholics, Mary is. Right?" Ummmm... Don't worry, I *kind of* straightened her out. She really wasn't interested in finding out the truth, though. Very interesting, and sad. [/quote] that's never fun
Old_Joe Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 I just gave a presentation on the Nicene Creed for my Comparative Religions Class. one of the girls in the front row asked, "What are Saints?" I was like . I tried to explain the best I could, but I was still taken aback at the thought that someone had never even heard of them.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 these 2 girls i know tried to convince me that their was no such word as "heretic" lol
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 I thought the saints help intercede. I think we pray for the intercession of the saints, like we pray for the intercession of Mary to her Beloved Son.
OLAM Dad Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 This confusion is just due to a limitation in the English language. Unfortunately, we only have one word for both Latria, and Dulia. I like this analogy. The Eskimo language has over 30 words for snow. We pretty much have only one...snow. Because of this eskimos can describe the type of snow by using just a single word whereas in English we would need to add adjectives. They have words for: Wet snow dry snow soft, newly fallen snow the crust on top of snow I think you get my point. In English we only have pray. It's understandable that there is confusion, it's our job to clarify.
franciscanheart Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='OLAM Dad' post='996025' date='Jun 3 2006, 06:23 AM'] This confusion is just due to a limitation in the English language. Unfortunately, we only have one word for both Latria, and Dulia. I like this analogy. The Eskimo language has over 30 words for snow. We pretty much have only one...snow. Because of this eskimos can describe the type of snow by using just a single word whereas in English we would need to add adjectives. They have words for: Wet snow dry snow soft, newly fallen snow the crust on top of snow I think you get my point. In English we only have pray. It's understandable that there is confusion, it's our job to clarify. [/quote]
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='995691' date='Jun 2 2006, 10:00 PM'] Don't forget Hyperdulia! Hyperdulia is the special veneration due to the Blessed Virgin Mary. [/quote] 'twas in my first post in this thread! I couldn't forget the Blessed Mother!
prose Posted June 3, 2006 Author Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='Proud2BCatholic139' post='996008' date='Jun 3 2006, 04:43 AM'] I thought the saints help intercede. I think we pray for the intercession of the saints, like we pray for the intercession of Mary to her Beloved Son. [/quote] Okay, so is this the answer to the second half of my post? Do the saints answer what we ask them with God's help, or does God answer b/c the saints have asked?
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='996048' date='Jun 3 2006, 10:10 AM'] Okay, so is this the answer to the second half of my post? Do the saints answer what we ask them with God's help, or does God answer b/c the saints have asked? [/quote] I think it's a bit of both simultaneously...
ReinnieR Posted June 3, 2006 Posted June 3, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='995619' date='Jun 2 2006, 04:55 PM'] And I can understand the whole doctrine about that, but we do with a different type of prayer thing. I know someone here had an excellent explanation of different prayers to people (it was in regards to Mary). something about different translations. Now, for example, when we ask St.Anthony for help, we don't say "Saint Anthony, please pray to the Lord to help us", we say "St.Anthony help us.... (fill in rest here)" Is Saint Anthony helping us with God's help? Or is God helping us in response to St. Anthony's prayer? Just wanted to clarify this. [/quote] i agree we pray to the saints but we don't pray to them.
Old_Joe Posted June 4, 2006 Posted June 4, 2006 I've found this verse helpful for defending why we pray to Mary: "When Solomon was seated on the throne of his father David, with his sovereignty firmly established, Adonijah, son of Haggith, went to Bathsheba, the mother of Solomon. "Do you come as a friend?" she asked. "Yes," he answered, and added, "I have something to say to you." She replied, "Say it." So he said: "You know that the kingdom was mine, and all Israel expected me to be king. But the kingdom escaped me and became my brother's, for the LORD gave it to him. But now there is one favor I would ask of you. Do not refuse me." And she said, "Speak on." He said, "Please ask King Solomon, who will not refuse you, to give me Abishag the Shunamite for my wife." "Very well," replied Bathsheba, "I will speak to the king for you." Then Bathsheba went to King Solomon to speak to him for Adonijah, and the king stood up to meet her and paid her homage. Then he sat down upon his throne, and a throne was provided for the king's mother, who sat at his right. "There is one small favor I would ask of you," she said. "Do not refuse me." "Ask it, my mother," the king said to her, "for I will not refuse you." So she said, "Let Abishag the Shunamite be given to your brother Adonijah for his wife." "And why do you ask Abishag the Shunamite for Adonijah?" King Solomon answered his mother. "Ask the kingdom for him as well, for he is my elder brother and has with him Abiathar the priest and Joab, son of Zeruiah." And King Solomon swore by the LORD: "May God do thus and so to me, and more besides, if Adonijah has not proposed this at the cost of his life."" -1 Kings 2:12-23
Maria Posted June 4, 2006 Posted June 4, 2006 I don't know if this will help, but as a result of a conversation with a friend who won't pray to saints because he doesn't want to end up doing something that is abhorent to God (communicating with the dead), I have realized that the crucial difference is that we do it 'through Christ our Lord'. Or communication is based on both of us being members of Christs body, united in Him. Our interaction depends on Him. So I don't really know how to answer your original question. I guess I'd go more with the first option, but it's all done as members of Christ's body. I mean, how does God tend to help people? He prefers to do it through other people. He likes to get others involved. So of course it's God helping us, but He's doing it through St. Anthony. And St. Anthony is doing it through Him. Okay, whatever. Sorry I'm not making much sense.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted June 5, 2006 Posted June 5, 2006 Well, yes, it can be both in a way. Patron saints strived for God's Will in their lives, put forth on a mission. Of course, everything is in God's Will. However, God wants us to ask. So, for special intentions, we pray to the saints for the intercession of God's help, even though it is in God's divine will.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now