Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted

Today there was a radio show on a Protestant station and the guy was actually quite positive about Catholicism. One caller who was Catholic called in and made a case for the priest hood, authority and succession. It was "refuted" with the priesthood of believers verse in Peter. I called in and debunked that with an explanation of how Peter was just applying ex 19 which states the very same thing. Te guy generally basically said he was okay and just didn't thing we should be dividing. That all Christian religions are equal and that we are human so we make mistakes. I have some ideas of the email I want to write him. Just wanted some input from you very intelligent folks on this relativistic sort of idea that says one Christian religion is as good as the other.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='996168' date='Jun 3 2006, 02:54 PM']Te guy generally basically said he was okay and just didn't thing we should be dividing. That all Christian religions are equal and that we are human so we make mistakes.[/quote]

That's what Protestants say when they've been trumped by a Catholic. ;)

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

Tell him the Body of Christ should not be divided. Multiple, contradictory theologies cannot be true at the same time. Sola Fide and Catholic soteriology are not equal, etc.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Nathan' post='996176' date='Jun 3 2006, 04:24 PM']
That's what Protestants say when they've been trumped by a Catholic. ;)
[/quote]

Yes. seemed to me to be what he was doing.

[quote name='thedude' post='996338' date='Jun 3 2006, 09:17 PM']
Tell him the Body of Christ should not be divided. Multiple, contradictory theologies cannot be true at the same time. Sola Fide and Catholic soteriology are not equal, etc.
[/quote]

Actually this is helpful because early in the program he spoke of how there was only one Church. Then Catholics and Orthdox. Then all hell broke loose. Well he didn't say that. But why is he following the divisions if he is against division?

phatcatholic
Posted

u also need to point out that Catholics believe in the priesthood of believers as well, and show how that priesthood is not contradictory to the ministerial priesthood.

articles on this:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/614"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/614[/url]

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='997961' date='Jun 5 2006, 09:33 PM']
u also need to point out that Catholics believe in the priesthood of believers as well, and show how that priesthood is not contradictory to the ministerial priesthood.

articles on this:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/614"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/614[/url]
[/quote]

I did all that when I called in on the radio, siting the passage in Exodus and the Catechism on priesthood of believers. I said that there was nothing in the NT that indicated there would be no hierarchical structure or priesthood like there was in the OT. :D: He agreed that there was nothing in the NT that said there would be no priesthood. He basically took the position that it is okay for you to believe that as long as you don't tell me I have to. He said we are heading down a dangerous road when we say that our own Church is the only true Church. (not exactly what Catholicism says).

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

I hate it when people avoid the question like that! I think someone already mentioned this, but you just really need to bring up the question of whether he thinks there can be multiple truths, whether God would really have left us without any final authority on matters of religion, etc. Also bring up the quotation in which Jesus says that the gates of hell will not prevail against the Church.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='998267' date='Jun 6 2006, 07:41 AM']
I hate it when people avoid the question like that! I think someone already mentioned this, but you just really need to bring up the question of whether he thinks there can be multiple truths, whether God would really have left us without any final authority on matters of religion, etc. Also bring up the quotation in which Jesus says that the gates of hell will not prevail against the Church.
[/quote]

He doesn't believe there are multiple truths. That is why I say it is not quite relativism. He simply believes that we cannot be pure in our truth. That the whole truth cannot be known by any individual. We are all humans, make mistakes, and therefore we cannot know all the truth. But the scriptures say "you shall know the truth and the truth shall set you free" and "those who worship God must worship in spirit and in truth". Seems there is a problem there to me.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

But when he comes, the Spirit of truth, he will guide you to all truth.
- John 16:13

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='998307' date='Jun 6 2006, 09:43 AM']
He doesn't believe there are multiple truths. That is why I say it is not quite relativism. He simply believes that we cannot be pure in our truth. That the whole truth cannot be known by any individual. We are all humans, make mistakes, and therefore we cannot know all the truth. But the scriptures say "you shall know the truth and the truth shall set you free" and "those who worship God must worship in spirit and in truth". Seems there is a problem there to me.
[/quote]

Ok, I see. That is a little less easy to refute. :think:

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='998346' date='Jun 6 2006, 10:54 AM']
But when he comes, the Spirit of truth, he will guide you to all truth.
- John 16:13
[/quote]
emphasis on [b][i]all[/i][/b] truth

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='998346' date='Jun 6 2006, 09:54 AM']
But when he comes, the Spirit of truth, he will guide you to all truth.
- John 16:13
[/quote]

Good verse for my reply. Thanks.

thessalonian
Posted

Having a very good email conversation with the other guy, the pastor who was on the show, right now. I have gotten him to back down from saying that the Catholic Church discourages Bible reading. Still trying to get him to see that the God that the Jews understood was not a false God, though the didn't understand him as a trinity. The old round red rubber ball vs. radius and volume, color on the color spectrum, elastic constant, chemical composition arguement. He's not grasping it.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='998702' date='Jun 6 2006, 04:44 PM']
The old round red rubber ball vs. radius and volume, color on the color spectrum, elastic constant, chemical composition arguement. He's not grasping it.
[/quote]
i don't think i'm familar w/ that argument

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='998839' date='Jun 6 2006, 05:16 PM']
i don't think i'm familar w/ that argument
[/quote]

It's more an arguement for development of doctrine but it seems to fit here as well. I think I read it from Aquinas or Nueman, can't recall which.

It shows that an understanding may not be contradictory. Just at a higher level. 1000 years ago one might have known a ball as round and red and rubber. Today we can describe it by it's volume, moleculer composition, elastic constant and color on the color spectrum. The understandings are not contradictory.

In the case of the Jews of the Old Testament, the believed there was one God. They had not had trinitarian theology revealed to them, though there were hints of it. Trinitarian theology is a deeper but not contradictory understanding of the God of the Bible to what the OT Jews understood.

The point of all of this is that he (the pastor) said on air that the Jews believed in a false God because they did not believe in the trinity. Their belief does not become false until they reject the Son of God, Jesus Christ, and the Trinity is my point.

blessings

Edited by thessalonian
thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Here is my email.

Dear Mr. Dahlen,

I've been having a conversation with Pastor Carr over the last few days and requested your email. I hope it is okay that I contact you. I was one of your last callers (I called in about EX 19 and the priesthood of believers). Pastor Carr and I have been discussing his statement with regard to the Catholic Church prohitions on Bible reading. I think he is almost ready to make at least a partial retraction as I have provided him with quotes from the Magesterium that encourage it (even pre-vatican II). I am currently doing a little poll for him, asking priests about Bible reading. So far it is not going in the direction he thought it would but we'll see. I sent emails to about 25 priests and not heard back from a little over half of them yet. I understand that he, and you have had instances where Catholics have told you that their priest discouraged them from reading the Bible. That is sad, because the Church most definitely does not. I can share the quotes I sent him if you like. Pre-Vatican II Jerusalem Bibles even had a statement from Pope Pius XII regarding blessings for 15 minutes of Bible reading daily right inside the cover.

There are a couple of comments I had for you. First of all on a minor note you said on the program that if someone is pro-homosexual you first refuse them communion. Great. Then you said that you told them they would have to find somewhere else to go. This is a minor nit but is that the proper response? I mean I think properly we should cast people out of church but not in any sense encourage them to go to a heretical Church that will just feed their error. Anyway, a minor nit. By the way don't take this email as negative because I did agree with much of what you had to say on the show.

I do find your stand that we should not be devisive to the extent that you took it to be quite problematic both scripturally and practically. On a practical level, it for me brings Christianity down to a least common denominator level where we come up with some list of 20 or 10 or some have 1, doctrine that is what we think everyone should go to the mat for. Lists vary from Christian to Christ and on your show you seemed to base what you would allow for an answer regarding what the Church was based on what you felt that list of go to the mat doctrines are. I think if you think about it you will agree. Pastor Brock likely has a different list and I know that other programs on KKMS have a much different list. We Catholics hold that the Bible teaches Apostlic succession and the Papacy. We have a different view of judging salvation and so it is not as problematic as you find it to be. We don't say if someone doesn't believe our doctrine on the papacy that they go to hell. But this email will get much to long if I explain why. The basic scripture I would site is "to whom much has been given, much will be expected". I think it's in Luke 12. The term that applies is called invincible ignorance. A term most non-Catholics do not find very pleasant and cannot be judged by man. I am culpable for what I have been given. I cannot judge a man who may not have been given what I have and we are not all given equally.

One doctrine that I find your position to be very problematic on I discussed on air with pastor Brock before. He believes and I suspect you do as well that Christ is really present in some form (not our transubstantiation, but I think you call it consubstantiation) in the Lord's Supper. Yet Baptists and many non-denominationals, including those on KKMS, believe that it is only symbolic. Christ is not present and it is simply a memorial. The scriptures of course tell us in John 6, "Unless you eat the flesh of the son of man and drink his blood you shall not have life within you". "My flesh is true food, my blood is true drink". Now how can this not be a doctrine to go to the mat over? To this day I do not understand Pastor Brocks response when I asked the question. I feel much more comfortable going to the mat over it but leaving the judgement of those who do not believe in the hands of God, knowing that he gives the grace to help them recieve his word.

That's the practical aspect. From the scriptural side of things it seems to me that we are told

Eph.6
[17] And take the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God.
You and I have a bit different definition of the WOG. I include Sacred Oral Tradition as spoken in 2 Thes 2:15. I find it problematic that scripture alone is the WOG, first because scripture never equates the two and secondly because if one has a particular passage but a wrong understanding of it it can actually be detrimental to his salvation. If you like I will provide an example but in the interest of time I will leave the statement for your reflection. But that aside, what you are saying it seems to me is that the Word of God contains all that is neccessary for salvation. Yet some of it is unneccessary for salvation. I don't know how to reconcile that. I can't say some part of God's word is unimportant in the salvation of souls.

Secondly I find your position problematic scripturally because we are told in several places we can know the truth.

John.8
[32] and you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free."
1John.2
[21] I write to you, not because you do not know the truth, but because you know it, and know that no lie is of the truth.

[24] Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I complete what is lacking in Christ's afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church,
[25] of which I became a minister according to the divine office which was given to me for you, to make the word of God fully known,
[26] the mystery hidden for ages and generations but now made manifest to his saints.


John.4
[23] But the hour is coming, and now is, when the true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and truth, for such the Father seeks to worship him.
[24] God is spirit, and those who worship him MUST worship in spirit and truth."

And not just a part of the truth is knowable but all truth.

John 16
[13] When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into ALL THE TRUTH; for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come.

That this truth was recieved by the Church and passed on in a manner that it is not lost is a must. This can only happen by the Holy Spirit.

As individuals of course we will not understand things perfectly. But nevertheless I cannot reconcile your somewhat relativistic view that all Christian Chruches are equal. I have to say that I know that the Catholic Church is the fullness of the truth. I do not say this boastfully or to put protestants down as I rejoice in the truth that you have and it is of value in your salvation. But I cannot say that matt 16:18 and what it teaches for instance or what is taught in John 6, understood in a correct light is not neccessary for your salvation. Nor can I say that not understanding it in a correct light is not detrimental to your salvation.

Feel free to comment.

God bless

Peace in Christ.

Gerald

Edited by thessalonian
thessalonian
Posted (edited)

I am currently stuck by the irony of something. On the program basically they were saying that anyone who does not believe in the trinity goes to hell. Non-trinitarians are apart from Christ so cannot go to heaven. Yet the trinity doctrine is difficult for men to come to. It requires the grace of God and a good explanation. It is not something that more than 1 out of 10 (if that) people would come up with if you just handed them a bible.

Yet somehow doctrines such as baptismal regeneration (which these lutherans believe) and the real prescence of Christ in the Lord's Supper, that are in my view more easily seen especially when someon is a Christian and should have the grace to see, are not significant in the salvation realm for them. Men are not culpable for them and we must not divide over them or emphasize belief in them. This seems odd to me. :idontknow: Anyone else?

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

thess, try to find a copy of George Weigel's [u]Letters to a Young Catholic[/u]. in chapter 5, he addresses liberalism (and relativism) in Christianity. i think it would help your arguments.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1000368' date='Jun 8 2006, 08:08 AM']
thess, try to find a copy of George Weigel's [u]Letters to a Young Catholic[/u]. in chapter 5, he addresses liberalism (and relativism) in Christianity. i think it would help your arguments.
[/quote]
[i]Excellent[/i] book...and, I agree, it would probably help. Good call. :)

thessalonian
Posted

Thx for the suggestion. I'll put it high on my reading list.

Does what I have written make any sense?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...