Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Birgitta Noel' post='996514' date='Jun 4 2006, 11:55 AM']
Precisely! ^_^ (Much less a CAT 4 or 5! :blink: )
[/quote]

Yeah, another Andrew or Katrina would be bad for lots of windows. It'd probably be cooler w/out the windows too. That said, am I the only one who thinks it might look better all glass?

Posted

I am happy because even if the design is that great, the stone is awhole lot better than glass.

journeyman
Posted

I'm not an architect, but it looked like the same frame, with a different exterior . . . if that was the only choice, the first choice might be more aesthetically pleasing

While vaguely reminiscent of the gothic style, it didn't seem to fit with the surrounding buildings . . . it certainly will be what catches they eye . . . but will it catch the heart?

The comments about Florida and big storms are certainly worth considering

Posted

[quote name='MichaelF' post='996513' date='Jun 4 2006, 12:30 PM']
Big windows, in that part of the State, won't be very nice when a Cat 3 comes ashore.

Florida is it's own environment, with all the engineering problems that entails.
[/quote]

I appreciate the weather concerns due to the location being in Florida. However, as a resident of Florida I can assure you that the vast majority of our buildings do indeed have windows. We do not live our lives in fear of the next hurricane. It wouldn't kill anyone to let in a little Florida sunshine.

I don't mean to be too harsh. God knows that we have a lot of ugly churches around. I am sorry for failing to hide my disppointment. I guess I just hoped that this one would be different from what it is.

Birgitta Noel
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='997011' date='Jun 4 2006, 11:19 PM']
I appreciate the weather concerns due to the location being in Florida. However, as a resident of Florida I can assure you that the vast majority of our buildings do indeed have windows. We do not live our lives in fear of the next hurricane. It wouldn't kill anyone to let in a little Florida sunshine.
[/quote]

Yes, I know, our house in Florida is full of windows and there are many Churches in FL with lots of windows. It does seem likely though that the fewer windows the less repairs post hurricane will be and the lower the a/c bill!

Posted

[img]http://www.naples.avemaria.edu/media/Files/7_21_05/oratory_model_interior_Small.jpg[/img]

I've said it before, and I'll say it again. It's a chapel for ants!

For anybody saying it's ugly: it's a wood model! The inside could end up being quite gorgeous, then it wouldn't matter as much what the outside is. At least it doesn't look like a spaceship or a can of tuna like at Steubenville.

Posted

I wouldn't build a church like this if money was no object but it's Tom's money, not mine. I'll wait until it's complete to solidify whether I like it or not. If the interior ends up looking like the photo above then it's going to be real hard to like.

Guest ROTS
Posted

*points to the picture in jgirls' post*

I've talked to some people at AMU, and I'd just like to point out that the oratory (not a parish because they don't have permission to have marriages or baptisms) will have altar railings a much larger than life crucifix, and the largest organ installation in any Catholic Church in a long while (unless it [i]is[/i] the largest). Fr. Joseph Fessio, among many others wants this oratory to be the center of gregorian chant revival in the Church.

Oh and by the way, even though Tom Monaghan is the primary donator of funds, his donation alone will [i]not[/i] pay for the entire bill of the the first phase of AMU.

The main reason they aren't building the glass version of the oratory, is that four hurricanes hit Florida and price tag for the entire project doubled or tripled. It was originally going to seat 3,000 souls. Now it will seat only one third of that. And I'm a former AMU student making my first post. ^_^

Posted

Actually the priest that i was talking to said that it was never going to be glass. That was the public's interpretation of the steel frame when they released it.

He also noted that the model is very large and very detailed. I would venture to guess that we are not seeing the true depth of it yet.

Why would you not like it though?

Posted

Welcome to Phatmass ROTS. A current student I talked to last month said that most of the students don't like it but that it was 'Tom's money and Tom's decision'. I don't have a problem with this, even though I don't think I'll like the Oratory architecture.

I'm happy to hear what you've said about the Gregorian Chant focus, that will be exciting indeed.

Posted

Dude, the first one looked really tight. It wouldnt have worked tho if it was all glass. The second one... well I think its a good frame but i don't personally like it. Inside it may look a lot better.

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='997011' date='Jun 4 2006, 11:19 PM']
I appreciate the weather concerns due to the location being in Florida. However, as a resident of Florida I can assure you that the vast majority of our buildings do indeed have windows. We do not live our lives in fear of the next hurricane. It wouldn't kill anyone to let in a little Florida sunshine.

[/quote]

Yes, but 40-foot windows?

My old Parish, on Pensacola Beach, had a huge wall-cum-window. Ivan trashed it, even before the storm-surge hit.

Posted

I think it's awesome.

I think the whole town is awesome.

I think that town should be re-named Awesome Town.

  • 1 year later...
Posted

I have seen the town...it looks like it is pretty close to being finished soon...you should see it! The church building is huge!

Posted

I know I'm the naysayer here, but I have been extraordinarily put off by the way Monaghan conducted himself with regard to the situation with the Ave Maria law school ... it leaves me highly skeptical of any of his other endeavors.

Posted

ya...you could say alot of negative things...but I would suggest not...everyone has faults and it is time for everyone to forgive and forget...

Posted

[quote name='Gandalf' post='1296610' date='Jun 16 2007, 10:43 AM']ya...you could say alot of negative things...but I would suggest not...everyone has faults and it is time for everyone to forgive and forget...[/quote]
Well, he didn't harm me personally so there's not much to forgive on my part.

However, I think it's unwise to forget how the man has conducted himself in similar ventures in the past, as it may well be an indicator of future performance.

Posted

I think it looks really modern and ugly...my friend who goes to Ave and I are always joking around about whose school is better, and the chapels were used as a point of comparison at one point--and I said, FUS's chapel does look like a can of tuna or a birthday cake, but it was built in the 70s--what's their excuse? heh.

I agree about Tom Monaghan...the whole business of firing Fr Fessio really put me off, and then just the stuff with the Michigan campus versus moving down to Florida and everything...I don't know, it really does feel like Tom's project and Tom's money, not just the church but the entire school, and I don't know if it's normal for someone to have such a heavy hand in the fate of a school, for an entire school to even pack up and move at someone's whim like that.

Posted

[quote name='jiyoung' post='1296780' date='Jun 16 2007, 01:18 PM']I think it looks really modern and ugly...my friend who goes to Ave and I are always joking around about whose school is better, and the chapels were used as a point of comparison at one point--and I said, FUS's chapel does look like a can of tuna or a birthday cake, but it was built in the 70s--what's their excuse? heh.

I agree about Tom Monaghan...the whole business of firing Fr Fessio really put me off, and then just the stuff with the Michigan campus versus moving down to Florida and everything...I don't know, it really does feel like Tom's project and Tom's money, not just the church but the entire school, and I don't know if it's normal for someone to have such a heavy hand in the fate of a school, for an entire school to even pack up and move at someone's whim like that.[/quote]
Those are my concerns as well.

And let's not that the school (the law school at least) did not WANT to move. They'd worked hard to build up connections in the community they started in, and then all funding was pulled unless they agreed to move to Fla. In addition, board members and others who opposed the move were kicked out. This has severely damaged AM's street cred, and I'm sure will affect their ability to recruit students. I know when I was looking at law schools I briefly considered them but the whole mess totally took them out of consideration for me. And, from talking to people who transferred from there to UST, I am VERY glad I made the decision I did.

Posted

[quote name='indescribable' post='996413' date='Jun 4 2006, 01:08 AM']i read an article that attendence at Ave Maria has dwindled to 3 students.[/quote]


There are bad rumors circulating about the university which are not true. They are receiving 140 new students this year, in addition to the ones they already have. :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...