jswranch Posted June 5, 2006 Posted June 5, 2006 Perpetual Virginity of Mary: Protoevangelium of James 120AD Writtings of Origen 244AD Do we have nothing earlier? Do we have nothing between these two accounts that affirm the PV? I have scanned the directory.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 Hmm.. To my knowledge the subject of Mary's perpetual virginity was not really a hot topic until later heretics started denying it. The subject of emphasis in the early writings was the virgin birth. And I can't think of any early documents which specifically and explicitly address Mary's perpetual virginity. There are apocryphal works (the Protoevangelium of James being the most well known) which affirm it, although it is possible to argue that the intent of such works is to emphasize the virgin birth, and that applying these texts to Mary's perpetual virginity is a matter of inference. There is also a statement of St. Ignatius of Antioch (~100AD) which might fit the bill for what you seek, but I suspect the same sort of argument could be made there. The typical understanding is that it was not a hot topic prior to Helvidius and thus you don't find people feeling to need to defend it or strongly assert it. But the earlier fathers who do speak of it (Hilary of Poitiers, Athanasius, Jerome, etc.) were clearly defending and expounding upon what they considered to be the Apostolic Faith which had been handed down. So by inference I think it is safe to say that this truth was sort of taken for granted until it was disputed, and only then did it become a subject that was emphasized enough to have a presence in writings which have survived to our day. But even here one could attempt to throw a wrench in this perspective by pointing out that there is a quite early statement which denies Mary's perpetual virginity, namely the view of Tertullian who held that Mary had other children after the birth of Christ. But certainly one could then point out the difference between this and the other evidence. Namely that Tertullian's view is an assumption, or inference, based on bad exegesis, not something he put forth as a statement of faith or an affirmation of the true fatih as is the view of the other fathers. In other words, he puts it forth as his opinion, whereas the fathers who defend this doctrine insist that it is the true faith period. The understanding of Mary as ever-virgin is doctrine, and the opinion of one father (a heretical father at that) does not really undermine this fact. One possibility for you might be the History of Joseph the Carpenter. It is often assigned a somewhat late date (~400AD), but in light of more recent scholarship I am of the view that this document actually dates to somewhere around 200AD. This would complicate your situation though since you would have to substantiate the dating of this document which can be a dubious task. And there is not a great deal of scholarship in English which will be of help to such an endeavor.
Theoketos Posted June 17, 2006 Posted June 17, 2006 St. Ignatius of Antioch states Mary's Virginity antepartum and Post Partum, he wrote around the 100. If you have access to Ebsco Host, there is an article on this topic by Plumpe, Joseph C. “Some little know Early Witnesses to Mary’s Virginitas in Partu” TS 9 (1948) 567-77 I wrote a paper about this topic, and would post it, but the format is screwy.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now