Guest Scotty Posted June 7, 2006 Posted June 7, 2006 Hello my fellow brothers and sisters. I have made a list of a bunch of topics where the Roman Catholic Church seem to defy what the word of God actually says. I am really sorry if i offend anyone, but i just wanted to let you know what Jesus said about a number of doctrine, here is what the Bible says about: [b] Calling priests ‘Father’ (or pope in Greek or Latin) and all of its implications:[/b] [i]Mat 23:9 [/i] [b]Praying in repetition, such as from the Rosary [/b] [i]Mat 6:7[/i] [b] About The Virgin Mary[/b] Did she stay a virgin? [i] Mat 13:55-56 [/i] Did Joseph begin normal sexual relations with his wife after Jesus was born? [i]Mat 1:24-25 [/i] About adoration of the Virgin Mary [i]Luk 11:27-28 [/i] There is only one mediator between man and God (the same goes for saints) is this mediator the Virgin Mary or a ‘Saint’? [i]1tim 2:5 [/i] [b]Communion[/b] Did Christ and Paul command that ALL Christians drink of the communion cup, not just the Priests? [i]Mat 26:26-28, 1Cor 11:23-28[/i] [b]Transubstantiation[/b] After Jesus had said, "this is my blood" and prayed, he still referred to the contents as, "fruit of the vine". If transubstantiation of the juice into blood had occurred at this time, then Jesus would never have referred to it as "fruit of the vine' but rather "blood". [i]Mat 26:29[/i] Paul calls the loaf, "bread" after both the "change" was supposed to take place. Thus, making Paul a liar by calling the loaf "bread" rather than what Catholic false doctrine claims it was: Literal Flesh. [i]1Cor 11:26-27[/i] Paul instructs us to "drink the cup" instead of "drink the blood". The Holy Spirit would not use such a figure of speech as "synecdoche" (referring to a part for the whole) if such a literal transubstantiation was actually taking place. To use a symbol when such a literal change is taking place is unthinkable. [i]1Cor 11:25-28[/i] Jesus instituted Lord’s Supper before his blood was shed and body broken! He spoke of His blood being shed, which was still yet future. This proves it was a symbol. The Earliest historical hint of transubstantiation becoming doctrine was not until the fourth century AD And Jesus’ words, "this is my body" should be taken symbolically because it falls within a long list of symbolic statements Christ said: "I am the bread," John 6:41, "I am the vine," John 15:5, "I am the door," John 10:7,9, "I am the good shepherd," John 10:11,12, "You are the world the salt, Matthew 5:13, "You are the light of the world Matthew 5:14 [b] The Doctrine of Purgatory[/b] The problems with this doctrine are: 1. It is not explicitly found in the Bible 2. It implies that the righteousness of Christ does not cleanse us of all sin 3. It implies that justification is not by faith alone 4. It implies that there is something we must do in order to be cleansed of sin. See [i]Rom 8:1[/i] [i]1Pet 2:24[/i] [i]John 19:30[/i]- The term ‘it is finished’ derived from the Greek term tetelestai which was a legal term used to state the a debt had been paid in full [i]Rom 5:1[/i] [i]Rom 3:28 [/i][b] All Christians are saints, and they don’t have to be dead[/b] Was every living Christian in the church in Corinth called a saint? [i]1Cor 1:2[/i] Did Paul write the book of Ephesians to dead saints? [i]Eph 1:1[/i] Was the average Christian in the church of Philippi called a saint? [i]Phi 1:1 [/i] All Christians are meant to be priests [i]1Pet 2:5, 9 Rev 1:6 Rev 1:10 [/i] [b]What does it say about Clerical Dress?[/b] [i]Mat 23:5[/i] [b]Peter was not the Rock, the revelation that Jesus is Christ is the rock, in fact, Christ himself is the rock of the Christian Church [/b] Jesus is the head of his church [i]1Cor 3:10-11 Eph 5:23 [/i] Jesus Christ is the Chief Cornerstone, and living stone [i]Mat 21:42 Eph 2:20 1Pet 2:6-8 Psa 18 1Cor 10:4 [/i] In Mat 16:13-18 it may appear that Jesus was referring to Peter as "the rock", but we have to keep in mind that the New Testament was written in Greek, not English. This is one instance where the original wording reveals the true meaning of what is being said. The Greek word for Peter is petros, which means "a pebble" or a small stone. On the other hand, the Greek word that Jesus used for rock is petra, meaning "a massive rock" or bedrock. Now we can see that there is an obvious difference! Peter was correct when he stated that Jesus was "the Christ" and it was this profession of truth that the church would be founded upon: Jesus Christ. And Peter was to become many of the smaller rocks that rest on the chief cornerstone that has previously been mentioned. Even Augustine, who was sainted by the Roman Catholic Church, admitted that Jesus was the rock. As I’m sure you are well aware, this Greek translation gaffe could be argued on the grounds that petra and petros are actually interchangeable terms, and petros had to be used because it is the masculine term, however all of the previous verses in this section, alongside what is found in Mat 23:9 is surely enough evidence to deny papal succession. [b]The second commandment[/b] [i]Exo 20:4 [/i] [b]Baptism [/b] Was Jesus and the early church members baptised by sprinkling? Or were they fully immersed? [i]Mat 3:16 Acts 8:38-39[/i] The Catholic Church also baptised by immersion up until 1311 AD Can babies be baptised, since they have not yet repented? [i]Acts 2:37-38[/i] [b] Every Christian can read and understand the bible, not just Catholic Priests[/b] [i]Eph 3:4[/i] [b]Did Jesus give the OK for man to change the Word of God for man made Catholic Doctrine?[/b] [i]Mark 7:7-9[/i] I am sorry that was so big, but the Lord has just placed on my heart that alot of followers of the Catholic faith put the tradition of man before their love and relationship with Jesus Christ. Please keep God above men, he loves you so much more than any man could. Getting into heaven is not enough, we have to do as much as we can for the one we are meant to love more than anything else. God Bless You all
TheresaMF Posted June 7, 2006 Posted June 7, 2006 Hi Scotty, I think all your questions are answered at [url="http://www.catholic.com"]Catholic Answers[/url]. I would recommend you check that out, in case the Lord laid this on your heart in order to draw you closer to His Church. God bless you! Theresa
Akalyte Posted June 7, 2006 Posted June 7, 2006 Where did the bible come from? The Roman Catholic Church, between 300-400 A.D. Catholic Bishops united under the Pope put the canon of the new testament together. The Catholic councils of Hippo and Carthage. Martin Luther, from which your church came from, admitted it was the Catholic Church who gave the world the bible. "We are compelled to concede to the Papists that they have the Word of God, that we received it from them, and that without them we should have no knowledge of it at all." ~ Martin Luther So did Henry G Graham. The Bible Centenary and the Catholic Church Amid the general jubilation over the three hundredth anniversary of the appearance of King James’s version of the Bible, I think it would be a pity if we did not make mention of that great Church to which, under God, we owe our possession of the sacred Scriptures – I mean of course, the Roman Catholic Church. Without striking one single jarring note, I hope, in the universal chorus, yet I feel it would be rather ungenerous, and indeed historically unjust, did we not turn our eyes at least in passing to that venerable figure standing in the background surveying our celebrations, and, as it were, saying, ‘Rejoice over it, but remember it was from me you got it.’ As a Scotsman, who cannot forget that it is the Bible that has made Scotland largely what she is today, I yield to no one in veneration of the inspired Scriptures and in admiration of the incomparably beautiful Authorized Version. Still, honor to whom honor. We shall only be awarding a just meed of praise and gratitude if we frankly and thankfully recognize that it is to a council (or councils) of the R.C. Church that we owe the collections of the separate books into our present Canon of the New Testament, and that to the loving care and devoted labor o the monks and scholars of that Church all through the ages we are indebted, not only for the multiplication and distribution of the sacred volume among the faithful when as yet no printing press existed, but even for the preservation of the Book from corruption an destruction. It is, then, undoubtedly true to say that, in the present order of Providence, it is owing to the Roman Catholic Church that we have a Bible at all. And no one will be a bit the worse Christian and Bible-lover if he remembers this notable year that it is to the Mother Church of Christendom he must look if he would behold the real preserver, defender, and transmitter of the ‘Word that endureth forever.’ – Henry Grey Graham.
Mateo el Feo Posted June 7, 2006 Posted June 7, 2006 Hello Scotty, Thank you for stopping by. These are fairly common questions about the Catholic Faith. It seems that most of your questions are presented at the "www.bible.ca" website. That's what Google brought me to, anyway! As Theresa mentioned, the internet has some excellent online resources like Catholic.com which have comprehensive responses to these questions. Phatmass has created a useful directory of resources that present the teachings of the Catholic Faith. Please see the following link to browse or search the directory: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/[/url] I also found the following sites helpful in answering questions about the Catholic faith:[list] [*]Text of the Catechism of the Catholic Church ([url="http://www.usccb.org/catechism/text/"]link[/url]) [*]The Catholic Encyclopedia ([url="http://www.newadvent.org/"]link[/url]) [/list] After reading these sites, please feel free to let us know if you still have any unanswered questions. May God bless you and aid you in your search for answers.
Akalyte Posted June 7, 2006 Posted June 7, 2006 ok here is my response to your questions. Sorry its long.. [[b]Questions will be in bold[/b], followed by "[color="#FF0000"]Response[/color]" in red] [b]Calling priests ‘Father’ (or pope in Greek or Latin) and all of its implications:[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] For I became your father in Christ Jesus through the gospel" (1 Cor. 4:14–15). [b]Praying in repetition, such as from the Rosary[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] Matt. 6:7 - Jesus teaches, "do not heap up empty phrases" in prayer. Protestants use this verse to criticize various Catholic forms of prayer which repeat phrases, such as litanies and the Rosary. But Jesus' focus in this instruction is on the "vain," and not on the "repetition." Matt. 26:44 - for example, Jesus prayed a third time in the garden of Gethsemane, saying the exact same words again. It is not the repetition that is the issue. It's the vanity. God looks into our heart, not solely at our words. Luke 18:13 - the tax collector kept beating his breast and praying "God be merciful to me, a sinner." This repetitive prayer was pleasing to God because it was offered with a sincere and repentant heart. Acts 10:2,4 - Cornelius prayed constantly to the Lord and his prayers ascended as a memorial before God. Rom. 1:9 - Paul says that he always mentions the Romans in his prayers without ceasing. Rom. 12:12 - Paul commands us to be constant in prayer. God looks at what is in our heart, not necessarily how we choose our words. 1 Thess. 5:17 - Paul commands us to pray constantly. Good repetition is different than vain repetition. Rev. 4:8 - the angels pray day and night without cessation the same words "Holy, Holy, Holy is the Lord God Almighty." This is repetitious prayer that is pleasing to God. Psalm 136 - in this Psalm, the phrase "For His steadfast love endures forever" is more repetitious than any Catholic prayer, and it is God's divine Word. Dan. 3:35-66 - the phrase "Bless the Lord" is similarly offered repeatedly, and mirrors Catholic litanies. [b]About The Virgin Mary[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] Very Numerous topic, go here: [url="http://www.scripturecatholic.com/blessed_virgin_mary.html"]http://www.scripturecatholic.com/blessed_virgin_mary.html[/url] Christ is the one and only mediator between God and man. The saints and the Virgin Mary go to him, they point to him. [b]Communion[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] 1 Cor 10:16-17 I speak as to wise men: judge ye yourselves what I say. The chalice of benediction, which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ? And the bread, which we break, is it not the partaking of the body of the Lord? For we, being many, are one bread, one body, all that partake of one bread. [b]Transubstantiation[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] They Recognized Him In the Breaking of the Bread Luke 24:30-31 And it happened that, while he was with them at table, he took bread, said the blessing, broke it, and gave it to them. With that their eyes were opened and they recognized him, but he vanished from their sight. [b]The Doctrine of Purgatory[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] According to Jewish sages, this is a period of spiritual punishment and/or purification for a period of up to 12 months after death called Gehinnom (in Yiddish it's Gehenna). However, Jesus clearly states there is not a "set" limit for all, but we set our own limits. Yet, if Calvary cleansed us of our sins, what is there left to pay (Protestant argument)? We believe the full text of Matthew helps clarify this as we read when Jesus is condemning when we judge our brother: "You have heard that it was said to men of old, 'You shall not kill; and whoever kills shall be liable to judgment.' But I say to you that every one who is angry with his brother shall be liable to judgment; whoever insults his brother shall be liable to the council, and whoever says, 'you fool!' shall be liable to Gehenna. So if you are offering your gift at the altar, and there remember that your brother has something against you, leave your gift there before the altar and go; first be reconciled to your brother, then come and offer your gift. Make friends quickly with your accuser, while you are going with him to court, lest your accuser hand you over to the judge, and the judge to the guard, and you be put into prison; truly, I say to you, you will never get out till you have paid the last penny." Matt.5.21-26 [b]What does it say about Clerical Dress?[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] There’s nothing wrong with clerical dress. [b]Peter was not the Rock, the revelation that Jesus is Christ is the rock, in fact, Christ himself is the rock of the Christian Church[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] two quotations from different works [i]Donald A. Carson III, Baptist and Professor of New Testament at Trinity Evangelical Seminary[/i] Although it is true that petros and petra can mean “stone” and “rock” respectively in earlier Greek, the distinction is largely confined to poetry. Moreover the underlying Aramaic is in this case unquestionable; and most probably kepha was used in both clauses (“you are kepha” and “on this kepha”), since the word was used both for a name and for a “rock”. The Peshitta (written in Syriac, a language cognate with Aramaic) makes no distinction between the words in the two clauses. The Greek makes the distinction between petros and petra simply because it is trying to preserve the pun, and in Greek the feminine petra could not very well serve as a masculine name. [i]John Peter Lange, German Protestant scholar[/i] The Saviour, no doubt, used in both clauses the Aramaic word kepha (hence the Greek Kephas applied to Simon, John i.42; comp. 1 Cor. i.12; iii.22; ix.5; Gal. ii.9), which means rock and is used both as a proper and a common noun.... The proper translation then would be: “Thou art Rock, and upon this rock”, etc. [b]The second commandment[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] Deut. 4:15 - from this verse, Protestants say that since we saw "no form" of the Lord, we should not make graven images of Him. Deut. 4:16 - of course, in early history Israel was forbidden to make images of God because God didn't yet reveal himself visibly "in the form of any figure." Deut. 4:17-19 - hence, had the Israelites depicted God not yet revealed, they might be tempted to worship Him in the form of a beast, bird, reptile or fish, which was a common error of the times. Exodus 3:2-3; Dan 7:9; Matt. 3:16; Mark 1:10; Luke 3:22; John 1:32; Acts 2:3- later on, however, we see that God did reveal himself in visible form (as a dove, fire, etc). Deut. 5:8 - God's commandment "thou shall not make a graven image" is entirely connected to the worship of false gods. God does not prohibit images to be used in worship, but He prohibits the images themselves to be worshiped. Exodus 25:18-22; 26:1,31 - for example, God commands the making of the image of a golden cherubim. This heavenly image, of course, is not worshiped by the Israelites. Instead, the image disposes their minds to the supernatural and draws them to God. Num. 21:8-9 - God also commands the making of the bronze serpent. The image of the bronze serpent is not an idol to be worshiped, but an article that lifts the mind to the supernatural. I Kings 6:23-36; 7:27-39; 8:6-67 - Solomon's temple contains statues of cherubim and images of cherubim, oxen and lions. God did not condemn these images that were used in worship. 2 Kings 18:4 - it was only when the people began to worship the statue did they incur God's wrath, and the king destroyed it. The command prohibiting the use of graven images deals exclusively with the false worship of those images. 1 Chron. 28:18-19 - David gives Solomon the plan for the altar made of refined gold with a golden cherubim images. These images were used in the Jews' most solemn place of worship. 2 Chron. 3:7-14 - the house was lined with gold with elaborate cherubim carved in wood and overlaid with gold. Ezek. 41:15 - Ezekiel describes graven images in the temple consisting of carved likenesses of cherubim. These are similar to the images of the angels and saints in many Catholic churches. Col. 1:15 - the only image of God that Catholics worship is Jesus Christ, who is the "image" (Greek "eikon") of the invisible God. [b]Baptism[/b] [is it by sprinkling or immersion? can babies be baptized?] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] Ezek. 36:25 - Ezekiel prophesies that God "will 'sprinkle' clean water on you and you shall be clean." The word for "sprinkle" is "rhaino" which means what it says, sprinkle (not immersion). (“Kai rhaino eph hymas hydor katharon.”) 2 Kings 5:14 - Namaan went down and dipped himself in the Jordan. The Greek word for "dipped" is "baptizo." Here, baptizo means immersion. But many Protestant churches argue that "baptizo" and related tenses of the Greek word always mean immersion, and therefore the Catholic baptisms of pouring or sprinkling water over the head are invalid. The Scriptures disprove their claim. Num. 19:18 – here, the verbs for dipping (“baptisantes”) and sprinkled (“bapsei”) refers to affusion (pouring) and sprinkling (aspersion), not immersion. Matt. 3:11; Mark 1:8; Luke 3:16 -John the Baptist prophesied that Jesus will baptize ("baptisei") with the Holy Spirit and fire. In this case, "baptisei" refers to a "pouring" out over the head. This is confirmed by Matt. 3:16 where the Holy Spirit descends upon Jesus' head like a dove and Acts 2:3-4 where the Holy Spirit descended upon Mary and the apostles' heads in the form of tongues of fire. In each case, in fulfilling John the Baptist's prophecy, the Lord baptized ("baptizo") in the form of pouring out His Spirit upon the head, not immersing the person. Matt. 20:22-23; Mark 10:38-39; Luke 12:50 - Jesus also talks about His baptism (from "baptizo") of blood, which was shed and sprinkled in His passion. But this baptism does not (and cannot) mean immersion. Mark 7:3 - the Pharisees do not eat unless they wash ("baptizo" ) their hands. This demonstrates that "baptizo" does not always mean immersion. It can mean pouring water over something (in this case, over their hands). Mark 7:4 - we see that the Jews washed ("bapto" from baptizo) cups, pitchers and vessels, but this does not mean that they actually immersed these items. Also, some manuscripts say the Jews also washed (bapto) couches, yet they did not immerse the couches, they only sprinkled them. Luke 11:38 - Jesus had not washed ("ebaptisthe") His hands before dinner. Here, the derivative of "baptizo" just means washing up, not immersing. Acts 2:41 - at Peter's first sermon, 3,000 were baptized. There is archeological proof that immersion would have been impossible in this area. Instead, these 3,000 people had to be sprinkled in water baptism. Acts 8:38 - because the verse says they "went down into the water," many Protestants say this is proof that baptism must be done by immersion. But the verb to describe Phillip and the eunuch going down into the water is the same verb ("katabaino") used in Acts 8:26 to describe the angel's instruction to Phillip to stop his chariot and go down to Gaza. The word has nothing to do with immersing oneself in water. Acts 8:39 - because the verse says "they came up out of the water," many Protestants also use this verse to prove that baptism must be done by immersion. However, the Greek word for "coming up out of the water" is "anebesan" which is plural. The verse is describing that both Phillip and the eunuch ascended out of the water, but does not prove that they were both immersed in the water. In fact, Phillip could not have baptized the eunuch if Phillip was also immersed. Finally, even if this was a baptism by immersion, the verse does not say that baptism by immersion is the only way to baptize. Acts 9:18; 22:16 - Paul is baptized while standing up in the house of Judas. There is no hot tub or swimming pool for immersion. This demonstrates that Paul was sprinkled. Acts 10:47-48 - Peter baptized in the house of Cornelius, even though hot tubs and swimming pools were not part of homes. Those in the house had to be sprinkled. Acts 16:33 - the baptism of the jailer and his household appears to be in the house, so immersion is not possible. Acts 2:17,18,33 - the pouring of water is like the "pouring" out of the Holy Spirit. Pouring is also called "infusion" (of grace). 1 Cor. 10:2 - Paul says that the Israelites were baptized ("baptizo") in the cloud and in the sea. But they could not have been immersed because Exodus 14:22 and 15:9 say that they went dry shod. Thus, "baptizo" does not mean immersed in these verses. Eph. 4:5 - there is only one baptism, just as there is only one Lord and one faith. Once a person is validly baptized by water and the Spirit in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit with the intention of the Church (whether by pouring or immersion), there is no longer a need to rebaptize the person. Titus 3:6 – the “washing of regeneration” (baptism) is “poured out” upon us. This “pouring out” generally refers to the pouring of baptismal waters over the head of the newly baptized. Heb. 6:2 – on the doctrine of baptisms (the word used is “baptismos”) which generally referred to pouring and not immersion. Heb. 10:22 – the author writes, “with our hearts sprinkled clean from an evil conscience.” This “sprinkling” of baptism refers to aspersion, not immersion. The text also parallels 1 Peter 3:21, which expressly mentions baptism and its ability to, like Heb. 10:22, purify the conscience (the interior disposition of a person). Isaiah 44:3 - the Lord "pours" water on the thirsty land and "pours" His Spirit upon our descendants. The Lord is “pouring,” not “immersing.” 2 Thess. 2:15 - hold fast to the tradition of the Church, whether oral or written. Since the time of Christ, baptisms have been done by pouring or sprinkling. [b]Every Christian can read and understand the bible, not just Catholic Priests[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] Read below [b]Did Jesus give the OK for man to change the Word of God for man made Catholic Doctrine?[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Response:[/color][/b] The Catholic Church never changed the word of God. The Apostles weren’t instructed to even write anything down. Besides, The protestants are the ones who change the word of God. Martin Luther decided to remove the greek Septuagint, the 7 books Christ and the apostles used. The Protestants sided with a Jewish sect who rejected those books, rather than side with Christ and his true church. Peace and God Bless, any other questions? Anything I missed im sure one of my other brothers or sisters will answer it..
phatcatholic Posted June 7, 2006 Posted June 7, 2006 akalyte, if u don't mind, i have formatted your response to make it easier to read.
Ziggamafu Posted June 7, 2006 Posted June 7, 2006 I'm so glad I became Catholic. What an amazing, everlasting, powerful ark I'm in. Thank you Jesus!
Akalyte Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='999704' date='Jun 7 2006, 01:05 PM'] akalyte, if u don't mind, i have formatted your response to make it easier to read. [/quote] thanks...yeah that was pretty messy. lol
Chica_Catolica Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 To play devil's advocate here, doesn't Gehenna refer to Hell? I'm actually debating Purgatory with a friend, and I know he will respond with a question similar to that, especially because of those verses only a few lines down from the ones Akalyte quoted, where it mentions how it's better to do than to have your whole body thrown into Gehenna.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 Rev. 21:27 tells us that nothing unclean will enter Heaven. Thus, we must be "cleaned" (aka purified) before we enter Heaven if we are stained with any impurities/attatchments to sin, temptation, worldly ideals, etc.
MissScripture Posted June 10, 2006 Posted June 10, 2006 [quote name='Chica_Catolica' post='1000287' date='Jun 8 2006, 08:12 AM'] To play devil's advocate here, doesn't Gehenna refer to Hell? I'm actually debating Purgatory with a friend, and I know he will respond with a question similar to that, especially because of those verses only a few lines down from the ones Akalyte quoted, where it mentions how it's better to do than to have your whole body thrown into Gehenna. [/quote] Sort of, yes. Gehenna was a place that was not very nice. Lots of fighting and such and so they referenced it like we would hell. It was sort of a "real-life application," if you will.
fundy_mental Posted June 14, 2006 Posted June 14, 2006 on the query about the body and blood of Christ try Jn 6:52-59 this helped me answer some of the questions i had.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now