curtins Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 Lets hypothetically say John and Jane like each other. They told each other they like each other and they're not really dating but they just wanna take things slow and see how the relationship goes. Thing is word gets out many a rumors get started and thing start to look and seem like they're going alot quicker than planned. So they decide to slow things down, take a step back. Thing is rumors are still going around and John's freinds have a problem with him. See John and Jane have some different divisions in who they hang out with and consider their freinds. Nothing major but lets say some of John's freinds arn't exactly best freinds with Jane. Theres peace and things are cool but they're arnt really freinds. John's freinds see John and Jane hanging out more (and the whole thing kinda comes outtta the blue) and they think they're being rejected or dumped by John. He tells them this isnt the case and he didn't mean to do so. They tell him this: Basically you have to pick between us and Jane. If you pick Jane then you can't hang out with out her and sicne we're not so close to her we're not gonna invite her to our get togethers etc thus you wont be able to come either. If one of John's freinds whos a girl happens to have a party and shes not particularly fond of Jane and doesn't invite her then John can't go cause it would look bad if John were to go to a girl's party without his girlfreind. John likes Jane but he doesn't want to lose his freinds. He could try and pick Jane and explain it to his freinds and work something out where John and Jane are cool if they don't always hang out or if they hang out seperatly on certain occasions. So basically for John its the girl or his friends? What does John do? Thank you.
heavenseeker Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 John takes the Jane and gets new friends because true friends would not make him choose between them or her.
Socrates Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 [quote name='curtins' post='999991' date='Jun 7 2006, 07:27 PM'] Lets hypothetically say John and Jane like each other. They told each other they like each other and they're not really dating but they just wanna take things slow and see how the relationship goes. Thing is word gets out many a rumors get started and thing start to look and seem like they're going alot quicker than planned. So they decide to slow things down, take a step back. Thing is rumors are still going around and John's freinds have a problem with him. See John and Jane have some different divisions in who they hang out with and consider their freinds. Nothing major but lets say some of John's freinds arn't exactly best freinds with Jane. Theres peace and things are cool but they're arnt really freinds. John's freinds see John and Jane hanging out more (and the whole thing kinda comes outtta the blue) and they think they're being rejected or dumped by John. He tells them this isnt the case and he didn't mean to do so. They tell him this: Basically you have to pick between us and Jane. If you pick Jane then you can't hang out with out her and sicne we're not so close to her we're not gonna invite her to our get togethers etc thus you wont be able to come either. If one of John's freinds whos a girl happens to have a party and shes not particularly fond of Jane and doesn't invite her then John can't go cause it would look bad if John were to go to a girl's party without his girlfreind. John likes Jane but he doesn't want to lose his freinds. He could try and pick Jane and explain it to his freinds and work something out where John and Jane are cool if they don't always hang out or if they hang out seperatly on certain occasions. So basically for John its the girl or his friends? What does John do? Thank you. [/quote] Well, at that point, this hypothetical John character cracks and goes psycho, and goes on a murderous rampage, brutally murdering Jane and then all their nasty little hypothetical friends, before shooting himself. And thus all ends in dark tragedy in our hypothetical little work of fiction. Why should we be so concerned about these hypothetical little people and their excruciatingly detailed and petty and tedious, though hypothetical, world?
heavenseeker Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 i dont think it is truely hypothetical. something tells me real people are involved and John and Jane are just names that were used to keep us honest. I could be wrong though.
curtins Posted June 8, 2006 Author Posted June 8, 2006 Socrates- someone's been playing too much GTA lol
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 John Grows up and figures out things for himself, instead of posting about them.
Aloysius Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 [quote]If you pick Jane then you can't hang out with out her[/quote] so wait, let me get this straight: if John starts dating Jane he can't hang out anywhere without her? that is an unhealthy relationship right there, two people feeding off of a co-dependent addiction for each other. if that's the way John and Jane view dating (I understand it's also the way most teenagers and even adults in our society do as well) then John and Jane should not date each other or anyone else.
Janana8706 Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 I say try to work things out w/ all of them, and make a special night or sumthing for just John's friends and a special night for jane. The other 5 nights of the week can be played by ear and john and jane can do w/e they want as far as beign together or not. If that doesn't work, i say get new friends
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 John becomes a novice in the Jesuit Order and Jane takes perpetual vows as a poor clare.
curtins Posted June 8, 2006 Author Posted June 8, 2006 [quote] [/quote] so wait, let me get this straight: if John starts dating Jane he can't hang out anywhere without her? that is an unhealthy relationship right there, two people feeding off of a co-dependent addiction for each other. if that's the way John and Jane view dating (I understand it's also the way most teenagers and even adults in our society do as well) then John and Jane should not date each other or anyone else.[quote] Not really. John and Jane are perfectly fine if they hang out seperatly (ie with their own freinds)/ hang out without always being in each other's company. Example- If John were invited to a party and Jane were not- John and Jane are both fine that John were to go without Jane. The problem lies in John's freinds. Lets say the party was thrown by one of John's freinds whos a girl. She would not want John to come because she thinks it would "look wrong" if John were to go to her party without Jane but she won't invite Jane because shes not freinds with her. Basically John and Jane don't care but John's freinds have a problem that it would look bad and make rumors or something.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 John's friends seem bad. John should get rid of them.
heavenseeker Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1000620' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:16 PM'] John's friends seem bad. John should get rid of them. [/quote] thats what i said
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 [quote name='heavenseeker' post='1000624' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:20 PM'] thats what i said [/quote] It's the first thing we ever agreed on. i saw your posts about how God "was calling someone away from Catholicism"
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 i saw all of them. i was enraged. Why would God tell people not to be Catholic? does that make any sense to you? If God is Truth would he decieve someone by calling them away from Catholicism (the True Church)?
curtins Posted June 8, 2006 Author Posted June 8, 2006 I think we would all agree it would be hard for someone to get up and leave their freinds like that. i.e. its easier said than done.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 yeah it is just explain to them how you feel, and tell them not to be rude brats.
heavenseeker Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1000634' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:29 PM'] i saw all of them. i was enraged. Why would God tell people not to be Catholic? does that make any sense to you? If God is Truth would he decieve someone by calling them away from Catholicism (the True Church)? [/quote] obviously you didnt read them all because i stated that i wanted her to stay with the church. that first one or so were just saying that some people have to check out diferent branches of christianity before they fully understand and appreciate what the catholic church offers. i dont see how you have the right of saying stuff like that when you have the i don't rep the church icon
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 [quote name='heavenseeker' post='1000674' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:48 PM'] obviously you didnt read them all because i stated that i wanted her to stay with the church. that first one or so were just saying that some people have to check out diferent branches of christianity before they fully understand and appreciate what the catholic church offers. i dont see how you have the right of saying stuff like that when you have the i don't rep the church icon [/quote] the reason i have this icon is because im not a liberal like you. [quote]um ok then bye bye[/quote] you said that. then you said you were not going to try and stop someone from leaving the faith. that is typical liberal catholic. what if this person would have died and gone to hell? you would have been responsible. then you said: [quote]if God is calling them down a different path then i really cant do much to stop them. [/quote] see God doesn't lead people from the truth.
CatholicCid Posted June 8, 2006 Posted June 8, 2006 Tell the friends to get over it and drop the drama
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now