Era Might Posted June 9, 2006 Posted June 9, 2006 (edited) [quote name='OLAM Dad' post='1001386' date='Jun 9 2006, 03:57 PM'] He has clearly placed his position on this manner as one outside the Church. He needs to publically recant his statement and do penance. [/quote] I am willing to give Cardinal McCarrick, who has been a consistent defender of Church teaching, the benefit of the doubt. It's true that what was said does not appear to be consistent with Church teaching (if it is an accurate transcript), but that does not mean Cardinal McCarrick is necessarily setting himself against the Church. Again, let's wait and see what comes of it. There is a difference between doctrinal error and theological error. Perhaps Cardinal McCarrick is making fine distinctions which ultimately will not square with the established teaching of the Church; but that would constitute theological error rather than disobedience. It's evident that he was not coming out and supporting homosexuality or homosexual relationships, but personal benefits (such as visiting someone in the hospital). This itself is an important nuance. Again, that doesn't mean his considerations would ultimately justify civil unions, but even the holiest of Saints have gotten their theology muddled. [quote]Among the prelates, indeed, one or other there may be affording scope to criticism either in regard to personal conduct or in reference to opinions by him entertained about points of doctrine; but no private person may arrogate to himself the office of judge which Christ our Lord has bestowed on that one alone whom He placed in charge of His lambs and of His sheep. Let every one bear in mind that most wise teaching of Gregory the Great: "Subjects should be admonished not rashly to judge their prelates, even if they chance to see them acting in a blameworthy manner, lest, justly reproving what is wrong, they be led by pride into greater wrong." --Pope Leo XIII, Encyclical Letter "Sapientiae Christianae"[/quote] Edited June 9, 2006 by Era Might
cmotherofpirl Posted June 9, 2006 Posted June 9, 2006 Lets give the good man the benefit of the doubt. He wasn't giving a speech, he was having a conversation. How many of us have tried to make a point and it just doesn't come out quite the way we meant?
OLAM Dad Posted June 10, 2006 Author Posted June 10, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1001456' date='Jun 9 2006, 04:34 PM'] Lets give the good man the benefit of the doubt. He wasn't giving a speech, he was having a conversation. How many of us have tried to make a point and it just doesn't come out quite the way we meant? [/quote] I agree, he should be given the benefit of the doubt. He made his statement 4 days ago. I'm waiting on some sort of official correction. In the past he has sided with John Kerry regarding the issue of whether pro-abort polititions should be welcomed at the communion rail. Below is a mostly even handed column written by Robert Novak (a convert to the faith) regarding his meeting with Kerry during the 2004 presidential campaign. [quote]WASHINGTON -- Readers of the Catholic Standard, official publication of the Archdiocese of Washington, D.C., raised their eyebrows two weeks ago. They learned of a 45-minute meeting April 15 of Sen. John Kerry with the Archbishop of Washington, Cardinal Theodore McCarrick. Why did Sen. Kerry seek a meeting with a prelate who was not his bishop and whom he never had met? The answer was grounded in high-level political intrigue. McCarrick heads the task force on Catholic participation in public life established by the U.S. bishops. Its most publicized task is to inquire whether politicians who defy Catholic teaching should receive the sacraments. About to become the first Catholic since John F. Kennedy to be nominated for president, Kerry was lobbying McCarrick against being denied Holy Communion as an unwavering pro-choice abortion advocate. Whether his lobbying helped, Kerry could not have been more pleased by his interview published in last Thursday's Catholic Standard. While asserting abortion "may be primary," he added that "people who are with us on one issue" may be "against us on many other issues." McCarrick concluded: "All these things will have to be weighed very carefully." Intentionally or not, he was following the lead of liberal, pro-choice Democrats and providing cover for Kerry with traditional Catholics. Cardinal McCarrick is so respected and well-liked that not only priests but also prominent laymen do not want to criticize him. Without mentioning McCarrick by name, publisher Deal Hudson of the conservative Catholic magazine Crisis told me: "Anytime our leaders allow the life issue to be made one of many issues provides cover for Kerry's effort to attract Catholic votes." McCarrick's interview is far more important than Cardinal Francis Arinze's recent Vatican declaration that priests must deny Communion to pro-choice politicians. The decision is not in the hands of Rome but of local bishops. I asked one highly placed source to measure Arinze's impact on leaders of 195 American dioceses. "Little or none," he said. "The weak will ignore it. The brave and courageous will be encouraged, but they already know they are right." Even before last week's interview, McCarrick had opposed withholding Communion as a "sanction" against offending Catholics. He fortified that position last week by asserting that abortion is only one issue even if it's the most important one. That fits the claim made by Catholic Democrats in recent days that Cardinal Arinze's position raises questions about sanctions for advocating capital punishment or even war in Iraq. Actually, the Catholic Catechism asserts that "the Church has acknowledged as well-founded the right and duty of legitimate public authority to punish malefactors by means of penalties commensurate with the gravity of the crime, not excluding, in cases of extreme gravity, the death penalty." As far as war in Iraq is concerned, it apparently meets the Catechism's definition of "just war." In contrast, Vatican Council II declared abortion to be an "unspeakable crime." Pope John Paul II's Evangelium Vitae (Gospel of Life) encyclical in 1995 asserted that responsibility for this crime "falls on the legislators who have promoted and approved abortion laws." This encyclical, uncompromising on abortion, defends the death penalty "in cases of absolute necessity." Indeed, abortion is not only a "primary" issue as described by McCarrick, but there is no other issue described in Catholic doctrine as threatening a loss of sacraments. The problem may be the Cardinal's statement April 11 on Fox News Sunday a few days before Kerry came to visit him: "I'm happy that I have friends on both sides of the aisle." He obviously meant not an abortion aisle but the political aisle, a concept that imposes on a prince of the Church the burden of exercising even-handed judiciousness between Republican and Democrats. The pro-choice politicians seem to be winning the first round, but one priest familiar with how the Church operates told me that more and more American bishops, influenced by John Paul II, will deny communions and "finally 'out' liberal Catholics for what they are at heart, Protestants." This priest sees the day when "pro-abortion politicians will stop calling themselves Catholic or repent of their sins." That surely will not happen before the 2004 election.[/quote]
OLAM Dad Posted June 12, 2006 Author Posted June 12, 2006 5 days. Still no clarification that I've seen.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 ... Let us double our prayer for priests and bishops, that they remain faithful and obedient to the Church and her teachings at all times.
KatS Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 [quote]He thinks it is his swan song. He is saying it and can say it because he is retiring.[/quote] Seems so. I just figured that this kind of talk is something that can get a Church leader excommunicated.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 (edited) [quote]“I’m afraid that I misspoke last Wednesday when I was being interviewed on CNN. “We were talking about the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment and the protection of marriage between a man and a woman. Here is what I said: ‘We really have to continue to define marriage as we have defined marriage for thousands of years as a union between a man and a woman.’ “After that, I spoke of the legislation as it had been proposed and that it would not eliminate the possibility of civil unions. I said, ‘If this is what the legislation would provide for, I think we can live with that.’ “My point was that the wording of the proposed legislation to protect marriage, which did not eliminate civil unions, might be necessary in order to have the votes needed to pass it. I added, ‘to say that you can take the concept of marriage and use it in ways that it has never been used before, as far as I know, in the history of the world, I think makes no sense.’ “When probed further on the question of civil unions, which came up because the wording of the constitutional amendment did not seem to eliminate them, I returned to the ideal – that everybody should be ‘able to enter a union with a man and a woman and that would bring children into the world and have the wonderful relationship of man and wife that is so mutually supportive and is really so much part of our society and what keeps society together.’ “I added, ‘If you fool around with the whole nature of marriage, then you are doing something which affects the whole culture and denigrates what is so important for us. Marriage is the basic foundation of our family structure and if we lose that, then I think we become a society that is in real trouble.’ “In trying to reply to a question, I mentioned people who may need the right to take care of each other when they are grievously ill and hospitalized, but it was always in the context of the proposed legislation and in no way in favor of a lifestyle that is contrary to the teaching of the Church and Scripture. I realized that my words could have given the wrong impression to someone who did not take my remarks in context. “I regret any confusion my words may have caused because I did not make myself sufficiently clear.” [/quote] [url="http://www.adw.org/news/News.asp?ID=378&Year=2006"]http://www.adw.org/news/News.asp?ID=378&Year=2006[/url] Edited June 12, 2006 by Fides_et_Ratio
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 Cool. Isn't it funny how reported statements can be so grossly misunderstood?
Lil Red Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1003400' date='Jun 11 2006, 09:25 PM'] ... Let us double our prayer for priests and bishops, that they remain faithful and obedient to the Church and her teachings at all times. [/quote] amen! prayer and sacrifice for our priests and bishops are very much needed!
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 Don't forget to notice post #31 [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=53473&st=25#"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...ic=53473&st=25#[/url]
OLAM Dad Posted June 12, 2006 Author Posted June 12, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1003776' date='Jun 12 2006, 10:38 AM'] told you it wasn't so... [/quote] It 'was so', he admitted he misspoke. And now it is 'no longer so' because he corrected himself. I think that the good bishop has been around politicians too long, he talks like one. Even his apology is confusing. He starts by saying that he misspoke and ends by saying that his words were taken out of context. Regardless, I'm glad that he apologized even though I don't think that nearly as many people will be shown his correction as have been shown his initial words. Oh well...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now