Crusader_4 Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 Just curious to know if anyone here has any knowledge on why origien and Tertullian are not considered saints of the Early church, but are yet Early church fathers. I am under the understanding that origien fell into heresy as he grew older hence the originism heresy, but what about tertullian? Also someone once suggested to me that it was either tertullian or origien that had castrated themselves has anyone heard this also thanks?
Guest GAIB Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 Origen was the one that castrated himself. Which is in itself problematic because it demonstrates a very faulty understanding of sexuality and how to combat sexual sins, in addition to which it might be interpreted as a lack of faith in the power of grace to redeem us (that is, "I don't believe God can redeem my fallen nature nor can He give me the strength to resist when temptation comes so I'm going to remove the source of temptation myself"). But there were other problems with Origen's theology that are far less speculative than that. As to Tertullian, later in life he fell into the heresy of Montanism and left the Church (thus when reading his writings one should be careful and check whether they were written in his pre-Montanist or post-Montanist period). Generally leaving the Church makes it difficult to become a saint.
thessalonian Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 Origen's writings have problems as well as he leans toward universalism.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 Origen is the founder of Origenism - the heresy of universal salvation.
jswranch Posted June 12, 2006 Posted June 12, 2006 both started heresies both supported heresies neither is to be considered church fathers, but church historians both had followers who continued heresies after their deaths Imagine if George Weigel started a heresy (not that it would ever happen).
Crusader_4 Posted June 13, 2006 Author Posted June 13, 2006 Im framilliar with the specifics of originism could someone explain in more depth the heresy that Tertullian was involved in and its specifics as far as belief? thanks in advance. -Will
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted June 13, 2006 Posted June 13, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1003659' date='Jun 12 2006, 07:34 AM'] Origen's writings have problems as well as he leans toward universalism. [/quote] This was the heresy that got Origen condemned as a heretic. Basically taken to full, Origen taught that even Satan would recieve salvation. Tertullian, and Monatism... Monatism was a group of radical fringe christians which asserted to have the authentic power of the holy spirit, and not the church hierarchy. They were a wacky bunch, but i cannot think of any beliefs outside of that. But Tertullian died in a heretical sect, not the true church. Both are brilliant men who helped greatly the early church. However it just goes to show you how we all need forgiveness, because we may yet fall into heresy. SHALOM
jswranch Posted June 13, 2006 Posted June 13, 2006 I think a group started up after Tertulian died, actually called the Tertulians (like the Lutherans). They were finally reconciled to the church years later by Augustine. ?Something I read?
phatcatholic Posted June 13, 2006 Posted June 13, 2006 these New Advent entries should be helpful: --[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11306b.htm"]Origen and Origenism[/url] --[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14520c.htm"]Tertullian[/url]
N/A Gone Posted January 19, 2007 Posted January 19, 2007 Interesting, my patristics class is promoting Origen big time. Saying he basically was the augustine to the east. really promoting him. Someone wanna give me a quicky on his universalism?
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted January 19, 2007 Posted January 19, 2007 [quote name='thedude' post='1003732' date='Jun 12 2006, 10:44 AM'] Origen is the founder of Origenism - the heresy of universal salvation. [/quote] Correction: Origenism was started later on. Not sure exactly how Origen himself fits into the picture. I believe there were problems with his theology but he also had a lot of good stuff from what I know.
Pennypacker11 Posted January 20, 2007 Posted January 20, 2007 [quote name='thedude' post='1170718' date='Jan 19 2007, 07:08 PM'] Correction: Origenism was started later on. Not sure exactly how Origen himself fits into the picture. I believe there were problems with his theology but he also had a lot of good stuff from what I know. [/quote] Origen and Origenism should really be seen as separate. Origenism is certainly a logical development out of Origen's throughts, but it takes certain elements of his theology, develops them further than he did and without some other parts of his theology which restricted them. Most modern historians (whether or not they judge Origen to be orthodox or not) recognize that the condemnations by Justinian in 553 do not accurately describe Origen's beliefs but instead the Origenists in the 6th century. As for Origen being the Augustine of the East, this is certainly true in terms of his [i]influence[/i]. Athanasius, Gregory of Nyssa, Gregory Nazianzen, Denys, Maximus the Confessor and many others were strongly influenced by Origen's writings (as well as many in the West through Rufinus' translation). Further, he is probably the greatest exegetical minds of the early Church (unless, like most modern exegetes, you dislike spiritual exegesis and then he may be one of the worst ). Is Origen orthodox? Well, this certainly isn't all or nothing. If we judge by later standards, certain statements are obviously heterodox but oftentimes these were also not going against any statement of orthodoxy at the time (I'm not sure if anyone could stand up to this standard). Origen himself recognizes at times (i.e. His discussion of the Holy Spirit in [i]On First Principles[/i] that he is speculating into matters which have not been definitively spoken upon and that his opinions should be judged accordingly). Othertimes (such as with the pre-existence of souls) his opinions are simply heterodox; IMO, most of these cases come from his letting his neo-platonic philosophy dictate his Christianity and not vice versa. Even if certain ideas in Origen are judged to be off the mark and even dangerous, if one wants to understand the theology of the Eastern Fathers (and particularly their biblical exegesis), Origen is probably the most important person to study.
Starets Posted January 20, 2007 Posted January 20, 2007 The problem with Origen's thought appears to be more how Evagrius Ponticus developed some of those ideas. Origen himself apparently wrote that if someone could show him from scripture or tradition that he was wrong, he would gladly recant his ideas. There's a good chapter on origen in Andrew Louth's [b]The Origins of the Christian Mystical Tradition: from Plato to Denys[/b].
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now