Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

GIRM question about musical instruments


Recommended Posts

missionseeker
Posted

I know it says organs and no pianos but what if you have a piano keyboard that sounds like an organ?

[url="http://music.yamaha.com/products/category.html;jsessionid=ADFABE0A4711D26688DDDEDB74C40423?groupId=18"]Clavinova[/url]


Is it the sound of the piano that we don't want (since it's a percusion instrument) or is the piano itself?

Would they be acceptable? It seems like they would be more acceptable than a piano.

Just wondering.

phatcatholic
Posted

where does it say "no piano" in the GIRM?

missionseeker
Posted

Sorry not the GIRM. :doh:

The Sacro Sanctum Consilium ( I think )

I'm still on lots of meds.

phatcatholic
Posted

SC does say that the organ should have pride of place, but it doesn't say anything about "no pianos" :unsure: maybe you should rest and come back when you have a clear head :thumbsup: :P:

franciscanheart
Posted
:lol: I was about to say ... !
missionseeker
Posted

whoa, you're both on here at once. That never happens anymore.

:bye:

Posted

If you find one of Cam's postings on instruments (check debate - especially when guitars are the subject), he'll provide chapter and verse re the guidelines.

The key phrase in the GIRM appears to be # 393

While the organ is to be accorded pride of place, other wind, stringed, or percussion instruments may be used in liturgical services in the dioceses of the United States of America, according to longstanding local usage, provided they are truly apt for sacred use or can be rendered apt.

Given prior condemnation of the piano, and the declared aptness of the organ, the argument would be the piano (or the guitar or other instrument) cannot be made apt.

One of the more logical arguments against the guitar is that without amplification (which I think is another prohibition), it is not well suited to congregational singing (especially large congregations) as it gets drowned out.

Posted

[quote name='Sacrosanctum Concilium #120']In the Latin Church the pipe organ is to be held in high esteem, for it is the traditional musical instrument which adds a wonderful splendor to the Church’s ceremonies and powerfully lifts up man’s mind to God and to higher things.[/quote]

[quote name='Tra Le Sollecitudini #19']The employment of the piano is forbidden in church, as is also that of noisy or frivolous instruments such as drums, cymbals, bells and the like.[/quote]

Now, if the employment of the piano is forbidden, as are drums, cymbals, bells and the like, how can it fufill the mandate of Sacrosanctum Concilium #120? If there is to be an organic growth, the logical answer is that it cannot.

By common acception, the piano is considered to be a secular instrument. And that is forbidden for use in the Church because it cannot be rendered apt, precisely because it is a secular istrument, much like the guitar or much like drums, cymbals, bells and the like.

Here is what the Church teaches about aptness;
[quote name='De Musica Sacra #60']The following principles for the use of musical instruments in the sacred liturgy are to be recalled:

a) Because of the nature, sanctity, and dignity of the sacred liturgy, the playing of any musical instrument should be as perfect as possible. It would be preferable to omit the use of instruments entirely (whether it be the organ only, or any other instrument), than to play them in a manner unbecoming their purpose. As a general rule it is better to do something well, however modest, than to attempt something more elaborate without the proper means.

b) The difference between sacred, and secular music must be taken into consideration. Some musical instruments, such as the classic organ, are naturally appropriate for sacred music; others, such as string instruments which are played with a bow, are easily adapted to liturgical use. But there are some instruments which, by common estimation, are so associated with secular music that they are not at all adaptable for sacred use.[/quote]

Looking to the last sentence of paragraph b; we see that some instruments are so associated with secular music that they are not at all adaptable for sacred use. The piano would fall into this category. How? Ask Barry Manilow, Lionel Ritchie, or Vanessa Carlton or any host of secular musicians. The piano is more recognizable through them than through the Church.

However, the more stable aspect of this is that Tra Le Sollectudini is the prohibitor of the piano and if Sacrosanctum Concilium is read and applied with tradition and Tradition in mind, then the piano cannot be considered apt nor can bells, drums and cymbals.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I wonder what the "liturgical music director" would say/do if I sent her that...

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' post='1005176' date='Jun 13 2006, 09:38 PM']
Now, if the employment of the piano is forbidden, as are drums, cymbals, bells and the like, how can it fufill the mandate of Sacrosanctum Concilium #120? If there is to be an organic growth, the logical answer is that it cannot.

By common acception, the piano is considered to be a secular instrument. And that is forbidden for use in the Church because it cannot be rendered apt, precisely because it is a secular istrument, much like the guitar or much like drums, cymbals, bells and the like.

Here is what the Church teaches about aptness;
Looking to the last sentence of paragraph b; we see that some instruments are so associated with secular music that they are not at all adaptable for sacred use. The piano would fall into this category. How? Ask Barry Manilow, Lionel Ritchie, or Vanessa Carlton or any host of secular musicians. The piano is more recognizable through them than through the Church.

However, the more stable aspect of this is that Tra Le Sollectudini is the prohibitor of the piano and if Sacrosanctum Concilium is read and applied with tradition and Tradition in mind, then the piano cannot be considered apt nor can bells, drums and cymbals.
[/quote]


I knew I read that... somewhere.

Thanks.

So you're asying that even if the piano keyboard sounds like an organ, it cannot be used because a piano cannot in any way be made apt?

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='1005219' date='Jun 13 2006, 10:57 PM']
I knew I read that... somewhere.

Thanks.

So you're asying that even if the piano keyboard sounds like an organ, it cannot be used because a piano cannot in any way be made apt?
[/quote]

Following logically, the progression of Church teaching and tradition, yes.

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1005183' date='Jun 13 2006, 10:41 PM']
I wonder what the "liturgical music director" would say/do if I sent her that...
[/quote]

If he is orthodox, he will agree, if he is heterodox, he will disagree. I am using "he" in the generic sense...most "liturgical music directors" are "shes."

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='1004408' date='Jun 13 2006, 12:38 AM']
I know it says organs and no pianos but what if you have a piano keyboard that sounds like an organ?

[url="http://music.yamaha.com/products/category.html;jsessionid=ADFABE0A4711D26688DDDEDB74C40423?groupId=18"]Clavinova[/url]
Is it the sound of the piano that we don't want (since it's a percusion instrument) or is the piano itself?

Would they be acceptable? It seems like they would be more acceptable than a piano.

Just wondering.
[/quote]

The clavinova is not acceptable merely because it is like a piano, but rather because the sound of the instrument is synthesized. That is also forbidden.

indescribable
Posted

Cam do you know of any dioceses/ regions that adhere to this strictly? Its just that until I ventured upon the debate board, I've never heard of this traditional stance on music. I dont' want to debate, but just be informed.

missionseeker
Posted

i thought that might be true.
I hate it when there's a perfectly good organ sitting there and they use guitars ...


*shivers*

phatcatholic
Posted

it seems to me that if you have a keyboard that sounds like an organ, u could use it, as long as you are always using it to make organ sounds. i mean, isn't it the sound of the instrument that is important?

missionseeker
Posted

This is a little off topic, but one time I was at a church and I went in the bathroom and the footpedals for the organ were standing against the wall.

apearantly, synthesized instruments are forbidden as well.

phatcatholic
Posted

btw, where does it say that synthesized or amplified instruments are forbidden?

Posted

[quote name='indescribable' post='1005307' date='Jun 13 2006, 11:35 PM']
Cam do you know of any dioceses/ regions that adhere to this strictly? Its just that until I ventured upon the debate board, I've never heard of this traditional stance on music. I dont' want to debate, but just be informed.
[/quote]

I don't know of any that adhere to this strictly. However, just because this is not adhered to doesn't mean that it is a logically and practically correct view.

One of the most disturbing things about the last 40 years is the sorely lacking amount of proper catechesis. I think that just as one must be catechized in theology, then one must also be catechized in the proper form and function of the liturgy.

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1005322' date='Jun 13 2006, 11:54 PM']
btw, where does it say that synthesized or amplified instruments are forbidden?
[/quote]

It is in the encyclical, De Musica Sacra. It says:

[quote name='De Musica Sacra #60c']Finally, only instruments which are personally played by a performer are to be used in the sacred liturgy, not those which are played mechanically or automatically.[/quote]

A synthesizer falls into this category.

There is a provision for a temporary (that being the key, [b]TEMPORARY[/b]) use of an electronic organ if even a small pipe organ is not available. However, this is simply tolerated and not to be the norm. It is even prescribed that explicit permission from the local Ordinary be given to even use this....

[quote name='De Musica Sacra #64']As a substitute, the electronic organ may be tolerated temporarily for liturgical functions, if the means for obtaining even a small pipe organ are not available. In each case, however, the explicit permission of the local Ordinary is required. He, on his part, should consult the diocesan commission on sacred music, and others trained in this field, who can make suggestions for rendering such an instrument more suitable for sacred use.[/quote]

The encyclical goes on to say:
[quote name='De Musica Sacra #71']The use of automatic instruments and machines, such as the automatic organ, phonograph, radio, tape or wire recorders, and other similar machines, is absolutely forbidden in liturgical functions and private devotions, whether they are held inside or outside the church, even if these machines be used only to transmit sermons or sacred music, or to substitute for the singing of the choir or faithful, or even just to support it.[/quote]

It is clear that mechanical amplification of instrumentation is not acceptable.

indescribable
Posted

does "private devotions" mean one's own prayer time?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...