Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

A Catholic blog I visit regularly recently posted a link to [url="http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2006/005/1.36.html"]this article from Christianity Today,[/url] written by the pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in NYC.

I found it interesting because before I became Catholic I was a member of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in Indianapolis, modeled directly after the NYC church and following many of the same ideals and philosophies. It was (and is) a very "Catholic" Protestant church ... many striking similarities to a Catholic Mass, but still very Protestant theologically. But this guy makes some very interesting points about being a Christian in an urban setting. In the interest of openness and honesty, although I live in an urban setting, I don't attend an urban parish at the moment for a variety of reasons. But I still think there's a lot of value in what this guy has to say about the need for Christians to live, work, and worship in cities.

[quote]The relationship of Christians to culture is the singular current crisis point for the church. Evangelicals are deeply divided over how to interact with a social order that is growing increasingly post-Christian. Some advise a reemphasis on tradition and on "letting the church be the church," rejecting any direct attempt to influence society as a whole. Others are hostile to culture, but hopeful that they can change it through aggressive action, often of a political sort. Still others believe that "you change culture one heart at a time." Finally, many are attracted to the new culture and want to reengineer the church to modify its adversarial relationship with culture. Many in the "one heart at a time" party play down doctrine and stress experience, while some in the reengineering group are changing distinctives of evangelical doctrine in the name of cultural engagement. That is fueling much theological controversy, but even people who agree on the need for change disagree over what to do to our doctrine to reach the culture.

None of the strategies listed above should be abandoned. We need Christian tradition, Christians in politics, and effective evangelism. And the church has always contextualized itself into its surrounding culture. There are harmful excesses in every approach, however. I think that is because many have turned their specialty into a single magic bullet that will solve the whole problem. I doubt such a magic bullet exists, but just bundling them all together is not sufficient either.

Instead, we need a new and different strategy.

My first strategic point is simple: More Christians should live long-term in cities. Historians point out that by A.D. 300, the urban populations of the Roman Empire were largely Christian, while the countryside was pagan. (Indeed, the word pagan originally meant someone from the countryside—its use as a synonym for a non-Christian dates from this era.) The same was true during the first millennium A.D. in Europe—the cities were Christian, but the broad population across the countryside was pagan. The lesson from both eras is that when cities are Christian, even if the majority of the population is pagan, society is headed on a Christian trajectory. Why? As the city goes, so goes the culture. Cultural trends tend to be generated in the city and flow outward to the rest of society.

People who live in large urban cultural centers, occupying jobs in the arts, business, academia, publishing, the helping professions, and the media, tend to have a disproportionate impact on how things are done in our culture. Having lived and ministered in New York City for 17 years, I am continually astonished at how the people I live with and know affect what everyone else in the country sees on the screen, in print, in art, and in business.

I am not talking about the "elite-elites"—the rich and famous—but about the "grassroots-elites." It is not so much the top executives that make MTV what it is, but the scores of young, hip creatives just out of college who take jobs at all levels of the organization. The people who live in cities in the greatest numbers tend to see their values expressed in the culture.

Do I mean that all Christians must live in cities? No. We need Christians and churches everywhere there are people! But I have taken up the call of the late James Montgomery Boice, an urban pastor (at Philadelphia's Tenth Presbyterian Church) who knew that evangelical Christians have been particularly unwilling to live in cities. In his book Two Cities: Two Loves, he argued that evangelicals should live in cities in at least the same percentage as the general population. If we do not, we should not expect much influence in society.

Once in cities, Christians should be a dynamic counterculture. It is not enough for Christians to simply live as individuals in the city. They must live as a particular kind of community. Jesus told his disciples that they were "a city on a hill" that showed God's glory to the world (Matt. 5:14-16). Christians are called to be an alternate city within every earthly city, an alternate human culture within every human culture, to show how sex, money, and power can be used in nondestructive ways.

...
It will not be enough for Christians to form a culture that runs counter to the values of the broader culture. Christians should be a community radically committed to the good of the city as a whole. We must move out to sacrificially serve the good of the whole human community, especially the poor. Revelation 21-22 makes it clear that the ultimate purpose of redemption is not to escape the material world, but to renew it. God's purpose is not only saving individuals, but also inaugurating a new world based on justice, peace, and love, not power, strife, and selfishness.

So Christians work for the peace, security, justice, and prosperity of their city and their neighbors, loving them in word and in deed, whether they believe what we do or not. In Jeremiah 29:7, Israel's exiles were called not just to live in the city, but also to love it and work for its shalom—its economic, social, and spiritual flourishing. The citizens of God's city are the best possible citizens of their earthly cities.

This is the only kind of cultural engagement that will not corrupt us and conform us to the world's pattern of life. If Christians go to urban centers simply to acquire power, they will never achieve cultural influence and change that is deep, lasting, and embraced by the broader society. We must live in the city to serve all the peoples in it, not just our own tribe. We must lose our power to find our (true) power. Christianity will not be attractive enough to win influence except through sacrificial service to all people, regardless of their beliefs.
...
There is another important component to being a Christian counterculture for the common good. Christians should be a people who integrate their faith with their work. Culture is a set of shared practices, attitudes, values, and beliefs, which are rooted in common understandings of the "big questions"—where life comes from, what life means, who we are, and what is important enough to spend our time doing it in the years allotted to us. No one can live or do their work without some answers to such questions, and every set of answers shapes culture.

Most fields of work today are dominated by a very different set of answers from those of Christianity. But when many Christians enter a vocational field, they either seal off their faith and work like everyone else around them, or they spout Bible verses to their coworkers. We do not know very well how to persuade people of Christianity's answers by showing them the faith-based, worldview roots of everyone's work. We do not know how to equip our people to think out the implications of the gospel for art, business, government, journalism, entertainment, and scholarship. Developing humane, creative, and excellent business environments out of our understanding of the gospel can be part of this work. The embodiment of joy, hope, and truth in the arts is also part of this work. If Christians live in major cultural centers in great numbers, doing their work in an excellent but distinctive manner, that alone will produce a different kind of culture than the one in which we live now.[/quote]

Posted

I agree completely, I think the same can be said for secular colleges too. So many Chrisitans think they have to go to a Christian college, when they can make such an impact at a public university. It isn't [i]that[/i] scary, I managed to do it.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

AS followers of Christ we are to ENGAGE the world, not hide from it.
Lights do not burn well under a bushel...

Posted

An incredible article. I enjoyed reading it. I think the author makes a good point in describing that it is our cities that influence the nation as a whole.

Furthermore Christians can re-invigorate life within cities. Currently cities are utopias for liberal and modern thought. I can see it myself in the city I live in.

Posted

[quote name='Kristen' post='1004794' date='Jun 13 2006, 01:12 PM']
I agree completely, I think the same can be said for secular colleges too. So many Chrisitans think they have to go to a Christian college, when they can make such an impact at a public university. It isn't [i]that[/i] scary, I managed to do it.
[/quote]

And then there are those Christian students who are fighting hard to bring the Lord back into their so-called Christian colleges. Like Oxford/Cambridge, the University of Toronto (where I go) is comprised of several colleges, most of them Christian -- St. Michael's (Catholic), Regis (Catholic), Trinity (Anglican), Wycliffe (Anglican), Victoria (United), Emmanuel (United), Knox (Presbyterian). The problem is, of course, that while all of these colleges started out eons ago as thoroughly Christian in vision and conduct, today most of them are virtually no different than any of the secular colleges on campus. The liberals have taken over.

I spent my first year at one of the secular colleges, but I'm transferring to St. Michael's for next year. I, along with a few other theologically orthodox Catholic students, plan on taking that place by storm.

Posted

Not to inject race, but Catholics in America tend to be...white, and at least working class. Cities are littered with ghettos, and that means non-white, poor people. The Churches that are able to reach out effectively tend to be black Protestant Churches that are populated by black Christians who come from that environment. Unless you come from that kind of environment, you're probably going to be less willing to enter into it.

Posted

Yes, but in many cities there are black Catholic Churches. There is one in mine. And our cathedral is very mulit-cultural; I see people from every different culture when I visit there. Right now I attend a parish in the suburbs which is extremely "mixed" - black (both African AND African-American), Hispanic, Asian, and White.

Furthermore our Archbishop is black.

Posted (edited)

Yah, they do exist. I know we have a black choir in my Archdiocese. But they're relatively few and far between, whereas you can go into just about any ghetto and find a Protestant Church that is populated by the black community.

Also, because black Catholics are relatively rare, black Catholic Churches tend to serve that particular need. They're similar to Eastern Churches in America, in that they serve the needs of a particular minority, and do not have a great social presence. Black Protestant Churches usually don't serve a minority; they serve the entire community where they serve, because black Protestants aren't a rarity in those areas.

Hispanic Catholic Churches probably have more potential socially, at least right now, because Hispanic Catholics are pretty numerous in this country.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

Era's right. That's true of the black Catholic churches here.

Posted

umm catholics in america also tend to be umm... hispanic! and korean and philipino. lots of them are living also in inner cities. maybe boston is a "white and black" but both washington dc and la where i've grown up in/lived in, as well as harrisburg nad philly, which i've spent time in, have a huge mix of all races in the inner city (albeit, less on teh white side, i will admit) so catholic churches can indeed meet and greet this need to serve the inner city and here in LA, actually do.

of course, doing it orthodoxically welll... it helps when you have a good shepherd :rolleyes:

Posted

Sometimes I think it is the minorities - Hispanics, Africans, and Asians - that will help the church remain orthodox.

Posted

the immigrant ones who haven't been americanized into their catholicism?

absatotalutely :D: look at the vocations in the NOT western world!

Posted

[quote]umm catholics in america also tend to be umm... hispanic! and korean and philipino.[/quote]

Yes, they do. That's why I said that the Hispanic core in the Church has the best opportunity right now for reaching out. Actually, at the parish I was baptized at, there are three different communities; English, Spanish, and Asian. There's also a lot of Brazilians around here too, so they have a few Brazilian communities as well.

But, there's still a different dynamic there from black communities. Hispanic communities are made up of a lot of immigrants. Black Americans are not immigrants, they're usually born here. Their language is English, their culture is American. That's why we see less of a black Catholic presence. With immigrant communities, you have Catholics coming here and building. But black Americans are stuck with the Catholic presence that already exists. Protestant Churches have a long, organic history in ghetto areas, so that is where black Americans in those areas are going to gravitate. Hence, getting back to the article, we need Catholics in the ghettos, but because Catholics in America tend to be white, they're not inclined to buy a house in the ghetto and move their family there. I guess the best answer would be single Catholics willing to do that, rather than living in the swanky parts of a big city.

Posted

i'm just trying to point out to you that Catholics in America do NOT tend to be white, that hispanics are there in large (and ever growing)numbers. in addition, there are growing non-immigrant hispanic communities that are starting to meet this need in a big way.

now, you could make the argument that hispanics and black communities don't always get along well, as is sadly the case more often than not in los angeles, in which case you're back to square one :idontknow:

Posted

[quote]I guess the best answer would be single Catholics willing to do that, rather than living in the swanky parts of a big city.[/quote]

Ah, but this is where a Catholic presense is needed - the swanky parts of a city might need a Catholic presense to remind the wealthy that they can continue to help the poor.

Furthermore, some really nice neighborhoods are where homosexuals live - in Atlanta there are two distinct neighborhoods, one where the men live and the other the women. Here's another instance where there needs to be a strong Catholic presense.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='kateri05' post='1005974' date='Jun 14 2006, 11:18 PM']
i'm just trying to point out to you that Catholics in America do NOT tend to be white, that hispanics are there in large (and ever growing)numbers. in addition, there are growing non-immigrant hispanic communities that are starting to meet this need in a big way.
[/quote]

Ok, let me rephrase. In the context of this article, about Catholics who live in "non-urban" areas, I would say they do tend to be white. I couldn't find a statistical analysis of race in the Catholic Church of America, but I think it would bear that out.

I'm not saying that's necessarily a bad thing. We can't choose where we come from. But I do think that is a factor here. Although, it's really not unique to the Catholic Church in America. I would say non-urban Americans in general tend to be white.

Edited by Era Might
LouisvilleFan
Posted

I was actually surprised to learn how many African-American Catholics are here in Louisville, although I'm sure the vast majority of blacks here are Protestant. I belong to a parish in a mostly white inner-city neighborhood and probably 30-40% of the parishinors are African-American. One guy entered the Church with me this past Easter Vigil and his brother converted about 40 years ago.

Of course, another part of the answer is encouraging more inner-city Catholic churches to take a page out of their Protestant neighbors and get more involved in the local social issues. Definitely easier said than done, but I'd reply with one of those inspirational high school graduation quotes like "a journey of a thousand miles starts with a single step and taking a restroom break." Or something like that :)

Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1004650' date='Jun 13 2006, 10:23 AM']
A Catholic blog I visit regularly recently posted a link to [url="http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2006/005/1.36.html"]this article from Christianity Today,[/url] written by the pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in NYC.

I found it interesting because before I became Catholic I was a member of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in Indianapolis, modeled directly after the NYC church and following many of the same ideals and philosophies. It was (and is) a very "Catholic" Protestant church ... many striking similarities to a Catholic Mass, but still very Protestant theologically. But this guy makes some very interesting points about being a Christian in an urban setting. In the interest of openness and honesty, although I live in an urban setting, I don't attend an urban parish at the moment for a variety of reasons. But I still think there's a lot of value in what this guy has to say about the need for Christians to live, work, and worship in cities.
[/quote]
Interesting article, with some good points.
It reflects ongoing debates in local Catholic circles about whether it is better for strong Catholics to focus on going out and being influential in the secular (usually urban) world, or whether they should focus on building their own Catholic communities in a culture somewhat seperated from the outside culture.

For instance, should Catholics move to the big city, and strive to be influencial in business, media, etc., or should they live in the country and homeschool their kids in a community of like-minded Catholic families?

I tend to think it isn't so much an either/or thing, but that different people are called to different paths.

A few points with the article:
1) The fact that the early Church tended to be focused more in urban centers was less part of a Christian strategy favoring urban over rural living than it was due to the fact that at the time, most roads and sea-routes connected urban areas. (And of course, more people could be reached in urban areas). In the ancient world, travel into rural areas was often very difficult and hazardous, involving travel through dangerous and trackless wilderness, and for this reason, "rural" areas were slower to be evangelized.

2) The author ignores the vitally important element of the growth of monasticism during this time. In the early Church, during the height of the decadence of the Roman Empire, many devout Christians deliberately fled the cities to live as hermits or communities of monks in the wilderness, praying for the rest of the Church. While moderns tend to regard monastic living as a useless "retreat" from the outside culture, monasticism was vital to building and preserving the Faith and Christian civilization through dark times.

Basically, I think that probably more Catholics should try to make an impact on the secular culture, but that the importance of building a Catholic culture from within (particularly for those raising families) cannot be neglected.

[quote name='Kristen' post='1004794' date='Jun 13 2006, 01:12 PM']
I agree completely, I think the same can be said for secular colleges too. So many Chrisitans think they have to go to a Christian college, when they can make such an impact at a public university. It isn't [i]that[/i] scary, I managed to do it.
[/quote]
I think good Catholic education is important too. Not everyone has to go to a solid Catholic school, but they definitely fulfill a need, and those who attend such schools should not be disparaged.
If Catholics are not solidly grounded in their own Faith, they will not be able to effectively evangelize the outside world. A good Catholic education should prepare students for evangelization. Many graduates of orthodox Catholic colleges, such as the one I intended are involved in campus ministry programs such as FOCUS, or in other missionary work.

It seems too many kids, who are not already very well grounded in their faith, tend to lose the Faith after going away to college in a secularized setting.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...