Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

missionseeker
Posted

no.

missionseeker
Posted

will he lgive the Catechism any -whatever?- if he won't do Creeds or is he too free church for that? Like will he let you use that without giving you a bunch of flac?

If that's the case then you should say something like

Dr. Jefferson,
I give you a fair chance to explain and your faith to me. You have called me un-Christian, Satanist and simpleminded, yet when I try to defend my Faith and my God (who, by the way is the same as yours) you say that none of it is valid. Just because you do not beleive something, you should not throw it out with no glance in a debate. If I cannot defend my Faith by explaining what I beleive, and why I beleive it using the texts that I think best help me explain it, then we are never going to trully "settle this". All I ask is to be able to use my creed, catechism, and the words of many men smarter than I who devoted their entire lives teaching and preaching the Faith of the Church. I have listened to you and ask that you listen to (or read what) I say with the same respect. My creed is backed by Scripture, my catechism is backed by Scripture, and the words of others are filled with Scripture quotes but you won't listen to the words of a Catholic.

i don't know- I know that sometimes with Fundis i get into an arguement with you just have to hold up your hand and say "Whoa wait aminute- I listened to you- now listen to me" Everything goes a lot better after that.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

Just some random responses to this guy's original post:
[quote]No sir, we have been over this 1000 times. I ONLY claim that the Bible is TRUE and does NOT need private translation from people or organizations whatsoever. It was written so that even a little child can understand it. It is religions like yours with their ridiculous "high priest's" that claim that a normal person, contrary to Christ's own words, cannot possibly understand Scripture for themselves. They do this to excercise power and authority over the average man and to play God. It makes me sick.[/quote]
I guess my first comment would be, how could Our Lord comment on Scriptures that didn't even exist until decades after His Ascension?

I suppose that someone could find a quote from Our Lord on the clarity of Scriptures (i.e. understandable by a little chld), but then there's the passage in the Acts of the Apostles about the Ethiopian eunuch ([url="http://www.usccb.org/nab/bible/acts/acts8.htm#v27"]Acts 8:27-37[/url]). The Ethiopean did not understand the Scriptures (OT). Phillip explained the meaning of the text. Should we pass judgment on Phillip and say that he contradicted "Christ's own words" to "exercise power and authority" over the Ethiopean? Does Phillip's actions sicken him in the same way that the Catholic Church does?

Other thoughts: what Church under the sun does not attempt to restrict interpretation of the Scriptures in some way? For example, how many fundamentalists would welcome Mormon or Jehovah's Witness theology from their pulpits?

Also, when I read the Acts of the Apostles and many NT epistles, it becomes clear that the Apostolic Church derived its authority directly from Our Lord. They constantly exercised "power and authority," just as the Catholic Church does today. As has already been said, the New Testament was born from the Church, not the other way around.

[quote]We have been over this as well, and while I never mentioned the eucharist in this thread, I will say that it is certainly NOT based on Scripture at all, nor is it based on the apostolic fathers which I do NOT consider an authority anyhow, but merely a sort of commentary. However, for you to hold up the "patristic writings" as a beacon of hope is quite hypocritical for you and I both know that I could quote from the "fathers" things that you do not agree with and do not adhere to!!!!!!!![/quote]Isn't it natural to believe that we can gain further insight into the teachings of Our Lord by studying the writings of the Apostles' disciples (i.e. the Apostolic Fathers)?

As for the comment about disagreements among the Church Fathers:
1) There is no citation of an example disagreement.
2) There is no citation of a Church Father whose writings/theology remotely supports the novelties of fundamentalist theology.
Wouldn't such a citation bolster his argument?
[quote]Sure...and the Bible also teaches that Joseph Smith was a true prophet and the virgin Mary ascended to heaven on a 3 headed cow....NONSENSE! There is NOTHING in the Scriptures or the apostolic fathers that even remotely promotes papal authority, let alone papal infallibility or temporal power.......NOTHING![/quote]
Here is a link to "NOTHING":
[url="http://www.catholic.com/library/church_papacy.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/library/church_papacy.asp[/url]

Regarding temporal power: I always saw the church in the Acts of the Apostles as one which wielded temporal power. In fact, many people gave all of their belongings to the church when they joined the community. This pattern of behavior surely gave the church leaders temporal power. This temporal power helped the Church spread the Gospel.
[quote]To accuse me of heresy for simply believing what God's word says is to accuse the word of God itself of being heretical! That dear sir is true heresy!! [/quote]
Even the devil quoted the Scriptures when he tempted Our Lord. Anyone can quote Scripture. I am surprised to hear someone claim that it is heretical to challenge another person who merely quotes Scripture. Scriptures can be quoted to support either orthodox or heretical interpretations.
[quote]The real question is what makes "the church" better then Jesus Christ Himself or His perfect word?[/quote]The Catholic Church derives its authority from its Founder, Our Lord. We Christians all accept this fact implicitly; because we trusted the Church to infallibly proclaim the Canon of the New Testament, long after Our Lord's Ascension into heaven. From what other authority can we accept the contents of the New Testament?
[quote][quote]let alone the other 40,000 protestant denominations?[/quote]
I am NOT a Protestant, so this little wise-crack means nothing to me and you already know that. [/quote]
Many protestant denominations have started out as "non-denominational" or "inter-denominational." Generally speaking, their founders didn't want to start new sects.

Regarding the term protestant, people categorize Christians into (1) Catholic, (2) Orthodox, and (3) Protestant. Any Christians who don't fall into the first two baskets, will usually fit into #3.

PS: What's all the talk of the "super-unit"? Is this the nerdy way to refer to the Church? Is it so horrible that we Catholics took Our Lord's words to heart when He prayed "that they (i.e. believers) may all be one, as you, Father, are in me and I in you, that they also may be in us, that the world may believe that you sent me." It is a shameful scandal that the world must see a divided Christianity. As Our Lord says, the world may more readily believe that it was the Father who sent Him, when there is a unity of believers--both in theology and organization.

Posted

awesome response, thank you very much

here is some of the arguments I have had with this guy before

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=43852&hl=Dr\"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...852&hl=Dr\[/url].

Posted

Oh Billy, he replied...

First off, much of what he is originally angry about is that he is cruel towards islam believers. So I cited the catechism when I was asked what the church thought about Islams

[quote]Quote:
The Church's relationship with the Muslims. "The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims; these profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind's judge on the last day."
(LG 16; cf. NA 3.)(LG=Lumen gentium, NA= Nostra aetate)[/quote]

Then Dr. Jefferson started

[quote]You AMAZE me!

You claim to understand church history and then you quote this revisionist nonsense!

You are no different then the Jehovah's Witness who conveniently FORGOT that their religion prophesied the end of the world incorrectly or the Mormon who conveniently FORGOT that Brigham Young taught a doctrine called, "Blood Atonement".

You are NOT a "Chriastian" and your not even a real historical Catholic! You are a sort of pseudo-Catholic with an extreme humanist slant.

If you think that HISTORICAL Catholicism always felt this way about Islam, you are mistaken!

WHAT do you think the Catholics thought about Islam when they were torturing and slaugtering Muslims?

Islamic belief hasn't changed, but the Vatican's "wording" sure has, as the church finally realized they couldn;t CONQUER the Muslims with the sword, so they just decided to try and conquer them with deceit and flattery!

If you really think that "Allah", a "god" that had no Son, was never incarnated and who had multiple wives (read the original satanic verses of the Quaran) is the SAME God as the Jehovah God of the Bible, then I can finally see why you are so deluded and off course and there isn;t much more for us to talk about you. You are far gone!
If YOU really have more in common with someone who DENIES the Triune God, virgin birth, crucifixion and resurrection then you should be ASHAMED OF YOURSELF and you are not even fit to call yourself a "Catholic", much less a "Christian".

By all means, convert to Islam sir, for you would do less harm to the true body of Christ that way. [/quote]

Then he continued after I left some comments to him that I have from previous posters on this thread..

I am going to quote both his responses and the quote he is taking from me, I will color my quote different and hopefully it will be less confusing.(**phatty, edit if it doesnt work)

-----
[quote]Dear "RevProdeji",

This is in response to BOTH of your replies:

[color="#333399"]Dr. J, I have never crawled away from a discussion between us. I have had finals, military duty(*well documented on the mod board, and wolves board) as well as the fact that I am planning a wedding and have a horrible work schedule last fiscal quarter. The only reason I have ever left our convo is because of the repeativtive and pointless "arguments" you make. [/color]

Sir, you have shrunk away MANY times, not only in your lack to reply whatsoever, but in your cute way of ONLY replying to what you can answer and not touching on issues where you know you are flat wrong. I on the other hand reply to EVERYTRHING don't I? As I have nothing to hide, cover-up, or run away from.

In regards to your up-coming wedding....congratulations, IF she doesn't have a living husband. If she does, I counsel you to read Romans 7: 2 and stop before you start!
[color="#333399"]
Your constant misguided prejudice towards a catholicism that only exists in your mind is obsurd. I have had discussions with fundi's that have a similar anti-catholicism as you have, and often when they understand catholicism for what it really is than there is no issue.[/color]

I see. That is to say, when you have LIED to them about Catholicism's theology just as a Jehovah Witness does about theirs and COVERED-UP Catholicism's history just as a Mormon does then you are able to DECEIVE them into thinking the Catholic cult is just another branch of "Christianity"......well, I'm sorry sir, but you aren't talking with someone who doesn;t know how to read, believe and obey a Bible. Your tricks may work on pompous geniuses who would rather trust a man over God, but they don't work on a true Biblical Christian like me.

He that covereth his sins shall not prosper: but whoso confesseth and forsaketh them shall have mercy. (Proverbs 28: 13)

[color="#333399"]Let me help for a second, the root of our faith is in the creed, the same creed that all catholics say in mass[/color]

Ah yes, the famous creed, let us examine it shall we! This will show us just what a hypocrite you are won't it?

[color="#330099"]WE beleive in one God,
the Father, the Almighty,
maker of heaven and earth,
of all that is, seen and unseen.
We believe in one Lord, Jesus Christ,
the only Son of God,[/color]

It appears that your "God" has a Son, yet the Muslims don't believe this sir, yet you say they worship the same God? Can you spell "L-I-A-R"?

[color="#333399"]eternally begotten of the Father,
He was always
God from God, Light from Light,
true God from true God,[/color]

Ah, so JESUS CHRIST of Nazareth is your GOD is He? The WHY would you claim that you worship the SAME "God" as Islam, when they do NOT believe that Jesus Christ was "true God" but a mere mortal man?

Your own words prove you to be a liar and a deceiver, one who would rather tell lies to lead people to your corrupt religion then have the guts to stand on the truth of God's word and let the chips fall as they may. That sir is pathetic!

[color="#333399"]begotten, not made,
He was not created like we are.
of one Being with the Father.
Through him all things were made.[/color]

Yet again, the Muslims do NOT believe this at all, yet YOU worship "Allah" aye? Again, why you don't you do the Lord a favor and just become a full fledged Muslim as you would do less damage to true believer's that way? IF you truly believe the word of God, then STOP lying and trying to deceive Muslims by telling them that you worship the same God they do. Have you no shame? Have you no strength of conviction? the Islamic "God" had no Son and did no such thing. In fact, they don;t even believe that Jesus Christ was crucified, let alone that he rose from the dead. Again, have you no shame, have you no convictions that aren't for sale?

[color="#333399"]We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of life,
who proceeds from the Father and the Son.
With the Father and the Son he is worshiped and glorified.
He has spoken through the Prophets.[/color]

Muslims certainly do NOT believe this. So which is it sir, do you worship the One true TRIUNE God of the Bible or the "god" of Islam who is NOT triune in nature and has no Son? Take a STAND for once in your life!

[color="#333399"]We believe in one holy catholic and apostolic Church.
We acknowledge one baptism for the forgiveness of sins.[/color]

I would take exception on this point and say that the catholic church does NOT believe in "one baptism" but TWO. For, if they believed in the one true baptism that washes sins away they would not sprinkle their infants as that is unBiblical, completely useless and entirely illogical. Jesus Christ Himself taught that while John the Baptist baptized with water, he would baptize with the Holy Ghost...that is the ONE true baptism, not your ridiculous sprinkling of water!!!!!

[color="#333399"]We look for the resurrection of the dead,
and the life of the world to come.
Amen.
The Holy Spirit is the third person of the Trinity. Three persons, one God- (with the tha Father & the Son...) [/color]

Amen!

Again, you are either a blatant LIAR for saying that you believe and worship the same God as Islam or you are just a spinless coward who doesn't have the strength to stand for the word of God, seeing as to do so would make you unpopular. WHICH IS IT?

[color="#333399"]One- the one Church that Christ established on earth[/color]

That would certainly NOT be the Babylonian/Judaic monstrousity that is the Roman catholic church however!

[color="#000099"]Catholic - little "c" Greek word for universal. This doesn't exclude non-Catholics. All Christians are a part of the universal Church.[/color]

Yes, I understand that.

However, WHY then did the "Roman Catholic" church find it neccessary to TORTURE and MURDER so many "Christians" simply because they were not "Roman Catholic". Again, revisionist history isn't true history padre!

[color="#333399"]Apostolic- from Christ to the Apostles, apostles to us.[/color]

What a joke!

I could point out many things in the apostolic writings that the "Roman catholic" cult does not agree with or practice. The Roman Catholic church is no more "apostolic" then are the Oneness Pentecostals of the Soutern USA with their Jesus-Only doctrine, but who call themselves apostolic!

[color="#333399"]What part of that do you find blasphemous, false, non-biblical ect. since that is catholics beleive.[/color]

You should be asking yourself that question, since you claim to worship the same God as all Muslims and "Allah" had no Son, was not triune in nature, etc.,.

Also, there are alot of toher doctrines and practices that Catholics "believe" aren't there? It is those doctrines and practices that prove them to be a satanic and unBiblical cult.

Even a Jehovah's Witness, Mormon, Armstrongism, etc., believer could post a little paragraph or two that would make Christians think they are legit, however it is the stuff they like to hide that reveals them to be satanic cults, not the stuff they openly show and you of all people know that!

[color="#333399"]Now, I listen to you, so please listen to me I give you a fair chance to explain and your faith to me. You have called me un-Christian, Satanist and simpleminded, yet when I try to defend my Faith and my God (who, by the way is the same as yours) you say that none of it is valid.[/color]

Firstly, I always "listen" to you and I respond to everything, unlike you, so don't falsely accuse me of ignoring your posts.

Secondly, I don't believe I have ever called you "simple-minded" as I am aware of your educational background. Blind, wolf, hypocrite, pathetic, yes, I have called you all those things as that is what I truly think of you, but never "simple minded".

Thirdly, IF your God is "Allah" then we do NOT have the same God!

[color="#333399"]Just because you do not beleive something, you should not throw it out with no glance in a debate.[/color]

Be serious! I NEVER do this! I examine and read everything I get my hands on. I have studied in-depth over 25 religions and love reading anti-Christian works as I like to refute the challenges and strengthen my faith. You on the other hand, ignore, cover-up and even flat out lie to get around certain issues.

[color="#333399"]My creed is backed by Scripture, my catechism is backed by Scripture, and the words of others are filled with Scripture quotes but you won't listen to the words of a Catholic.[/color]

WRONG! I will "listen" to a catholic all day long and I may even learn something about history, etc.,. However, I will not lose all logic and reason and agree that your catechism is "backed by Scripture"! Parts may be Biblical and those parts I would agree 100% with, but there are also parts that are entirely unBiblical and those I will NEVER agree with!

[color="#333399"]I guess my first comment would be, how could Our Lord comment on Scriptures that didn't even exist until decades after His Ascension?[/color]

Are you serious?

If you believe the word of God, then you would also believe that ALL Scripture was authored by God Himself. Jesus Christ didn;t have to "comment" on every verse of Scripture as it was written by God and automatically relevant and valid and worthy of being obeyed.

[color="#333399"]I suppose that someone could find a quote from Our Lord on the clarity of Scriptures (i.e. understandable by a little chld), but then there's the passage in the Acts of the Apostles about the Ethiopian eunuch (Acts 8:27-37). The Ethiopean did not understand the Scriptures (OT). Phillip explained the meaning of the text. Should we pass judgment on Phillip and say that he contradicted "Christ's own words" to "exercise power and authority" over the Ethiopean? Does Phillip's actions sicken him in the same way that the Catholic Church does?[/color]

Again, are you being serious? I ask that question in all sincerity as I can;t believe you are seriously asking this.

However to answer your question, God never said it is sinful to explain the Scriptures, He said it was sinful to subtract or add to them or to "privately interpret" them, all of which the Catholic church loves to do in both word and especially deed.

[color="#333399"]Other thoughts: what Church under the sun does not attempt to restrict interpretation of the Scriptures in some way? For example, how many fundamentalists would welcome Mormon or Jehovah's Witness theology from their pulpits?[/color]

The reason it would not be welcomed is because it is unBiblical!

I have no problem with the Catholic church barring agnostics or cultists from speaking blasphemy in their pulpits, just as I have no problem with Islamic Mullahs barring Western ideaology and television. However, I have a huge problem with the Catholic church sponsoring torture and murder of so-called "heretics".

[color="#333399"]Also, when I read the Acts of the Apostles and many NT epistles, it becomes clear that the Apostolic Church derived its authority directly from Our Lord. They constantly exercised "power and authority," just as the Catholic Church does today. As has already been said, the New Testament was born from the Church, not the other way around.[/color]

You are utterly mistaken.

While the apostolic churches certainly did exercise "authority" to a point, they did not do so to the unBiblical extent that the Catholic church has done. There were no apostolic crusades or inquisitions were there? NO!

[color="#333399"]Isn't it natural to believe that we can gain further insight into the teachings of Our Lord by studying the writings of the Apostles' disciples (i.e. the Apostolic Fathers)?[/color]

Of course. However, when one puts those works ahead of the Scriptures, there is a huge problem! Remember, those writings are NOT "Divine Scripture" but merely human works and may contain errors, etc.

[color="#333399"]As for the comment about disagreements among the Church Fathers:
1) There is no citation of an example disagreement.
2) There is no citation of a Church Father whose writings/theology remotely supports the novelties of fundamentalist theology.
Wouldn't such a citation bolster your argument?[/color]

Firstly, I didn't think there was a need to cite an example as you claim to be a "patristic scholar" and know as well as I do that there are some issues where the authors didn't always agree.

Secondly, NAME JUST ONE doctrine that I hold that the apostolic fathers didn't agree with, JUST ONE!

Please remember that when I say I am or have been called by others a "fundamentally, fundamental, fundamentalist", that is NOT because I am a rapture belieiving, abortion clinic bombing Southern Baptist, but ONLY because I read, believe and obey the Scriptures, no matter what.

I would agree with you 100% that many so-called "fundamentalists" or crack-pots, however they are no more fundamental then you are, what with their man-made doctrines and unBiblical practices.

[color="#333399"]Regarding temporal power: I always saw the church in the Acts of the Apostles as one which wielded temporal power. In fact, many people gave all of their belongings to the church when they joined the community. This pattern of behavior surely gave the church leaders temporal power. This temporal power helped the Church spread the Gospel.[/color]

WRONG! The ONE fellowship (all others operated rather differently) you speak of in the book of Acts did NOT demand, command or even teach "temporal power", it was merely a choice for the individual believers to live that way. Even Annanais and Saphira could have given nothing and been accepted, yet they were punished for lying, something you seem do rather freely.

The example of the simplistic and rather communistic apostlic church in the book of Acts is FAR DIFFERENT from the example of the Roman Catholic church's land grabs, wars, extreminations, ornate temples, vast financial holdings, etc, and you know it!

[color="#333399"]Even the devil quoted the Scriptures when he tempted Our Lord. Anyone can quote Scripture. I am surprised to hear someone claim that it is heretical to challenge another person who merely quotes Scripture. Scriptures can be quoted to support either orthodox or heretical interpretations.[/color]

I actually hardly ever quote Scripture on these boards as I know that isn;t well received. However, you might want to understand that the devil TWISTED Scripture, he did NOT quote it straight.

I, on the other hand, read, believe and OBEY the Bible, which you condemn. That is sad, however, it is just as the Lord said it would be.

[color="#333399"]The Catholic Church derives its authority from its Founder, Our Lord.[/color]

NONSENSE! Jesus Christ had NOTHING to do with the Roman Catholic church and its Babylonian religious system, NOTHING!

[color="#333399"]We Christians all accept this fact implicitly; because we trusted the Church to infallibly proclaim the Canon of the New Testament, long after Our Lord's Ascension into heaven. From what other authority can we accept the contents of the New Testament?[/color]

No, "we Christians" do NOT accept that as it is utter nonsense. Do yourself a favor and purchase a copy of David daniels, "Did the Catholic Church Give Us the Bible", it would do you good to actually know what your talking about and not just believe what you were taught in catechism.

[color="#333399"]Many protestant denominations have started out as "non-denominational" or "inter-denominational." Generally speaking, their founders didn't want to start new sects.[/color]

What does this have to do with anything?

I am NOT a founder of anything. I am merely ONE Christian individual who believes and obeys the Scriptures and would die for the truth!

[color="#333399"]Regarding the term protestant, people categorize Christians into (1) Catholic, (2) Orthodox, and (3) Protestant. Any Christians who don't fall into the first two baskets, will usually fit into #3.[/color]

That is not true and those who do so are quite ignorant. Simply consider Anabaptism which comprises the Amish, Mennonites and Hutterian's. They are most definitely NOT in any of the above three "categories

[color="#333399"]Is it so horrible that we Catholics took Our Lord's words to heart when He prayed "that they (i.e. believers) may all be one, as you, Father, are in me and I in you, that they also may be in us, that the world may believe that you sent me."[/color]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

Yes, you "Catholics" really took those words to heart, by TORTURING and BURNING those who didn't agree with your heretical beliefs!

[color="#333399"]It is a shameful scandal that the world must see a divided Christianity. As Our Lord says, the world may more readily believe that it was the Father who sent Him, when there is a unity of believers--both in theology and organization.[/color]

There IS and ALWAYS HAS BEEN a perfect UNITY of true Biblical Christians, ALWAYS!

That these true Biblical Christians won't apostasize from the faith and join the ranks of the cultist Catholic church is a credit to their strong stand for the truth, not a shameful thing!

You go on with you satanic ecumenical work and join all the Catholci, Orthodox, Protestants, Hindu's, Animists, etc., together under the banner of Rome.......I will stay on the side of the Lord Jesus Christ!

[color="#333399"]where the NT came from?[/color]

God

[color="#333399"]Where did the NT writings get their authority?[/color]

From GOD!

[color="#333399"]Where does he get his authority to interpret scripture?[/color]

I do NOT "interpret" it, I ONLY read, believe and OBEY it!

[color="#333399"]Why is his authority better than the other 1 billion christians in the world?[/color]

If you are referring to ME personally, I will say that ** I ** have NO authority and don;t claim to have any, unlike the man who sits in Rome that you follow!

If by WHAT I read, believe and obey (the word of God), I will say that it has ALL AUTHORITY as it was authored by GOD!

[color="#333399"]Ask him to explain revelations to you if a little child can easily understand it?[/color]

Revelations is EASY to understand in the grand scheme of things. In fact it looks to me like the Catholic church had a harder time with Matthew then Revelation!

[color="#333399"]Peter and Paul were members of the Church Christ founded- what church is he a member of and who founded it?[/color]

I am a member of the body of Christ that JESUS, Himself founded! If you want to be a member of a Babylonian religion that was founded long before the birth of Christ and claim that Peter founded it, so be it, but you only deceive yourself.

[color="#333399"]The Bible is so easy to understand - therefore everyone has their own spin to put on it?[/color]

YES! This is precisely because people do not believe it in the first place and then do not obey it in the second place.

For example, if someone who is a soldier and truly enjoys killing and would never quit the militart in a million years reads "love your enemies", "resist not evil", etc., he will put his own spin on it to mean that he can in fact kill his enemies in certain circumstances.

If a man falls in love with a woman who left her husband and seduced him, he will read Romans 7: 2 and "spin it" to mean whatever he wants, just so he can feel good about marrying the adulteress.

HOWEVER, if one will just READ, BELIEVE and OBEY what God's word actually says, he will please God and find true peace, joy and truth, no matter what life throws at him. This is something you know nothing about as you have never been born again.

[color="#333399"]John 6:54-55: "He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day. For My flesh is true food, and My blood is true drink."
I got that from bible.com,that verse gets the job done, especially for the purpoes of refuting a sola scriptura theory. Suffice to say that John 6 pretty much proves the existence of the Real Presence in the Eucharist. You claim that scripture should be understood from even a small child(*Campbell argument), while how else would you understand this?[/color]

Umm.....try reading the entire context as well as the other portions of Scripture that deal with the Lord's supper. Anyone can pull one verse out of context to support his ludicrous theory, which is what you are doing here.

It is COMPLETELY OBVIOUS that the Lord's supper is a symbol and NOT literal. Did Jesus Christ rip off a piece of his flesh and let Peter start gnawing on it? Did John slit Christ's neck and start drinking his blood? Does the entire self of Jesus Christ rest inside of a Catholic communion wafer? Can one eat their God?

Do some reseach sir and you will find out that the entire catholic system, especially the unBiblical "Eucharist" nonsense is BABYLONIAN and was around long before Christ was ever born. So were the nuns, monks, confessionals, mother and child, etc.,!

[color="#333399"]Matt 16:18: "I also say to you that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build My church; and the gates of Hades will not overpower it."[/color]

And upon THIS rock I will build my church. With even a basic understanding of English it is obvious that Christ was NOT building His church upon Peter but opon the testimony Peter gave (that Jesus Christ was the true Son of God).

To think that Jesus built His church and stated that the gates of hell (not hades) would not prevail against it and then to equate this with Peter, the apostle who denied Christ three times, did far less then Paul to spread the Gosepl and later choose to please men rather then stand for God's word in his debate with Paul concerning the Gentile believer's is RIDICULOUS!

You can have Peter or even Paul (although they wouldn;t accept you based on your doctrine).....I'll take Jesus!

[color="#333399"]Dr. J, why so much hate for the catholic church?[/color]

I have NO HATE for any individual person, NONE, however I do hate false teaching as Christ did and I do expose it as he commanded.

Believe me, I would NEVER resort to conversion by the sword or TORTURING and MURDERING Catholics the way they did true believers and even "heretics" throughout the centuries.

Yours is the religion of hate and blood-lust dear sir.

[color="#333399"]I have seen in moments that you are a good person, and a real believer in your faith. But the hate you display is counter to the message of Love that Christ taught his people.[/color]

Would you stop throwing the word "hate" around as if it had supreme weight. The reason I EXPOSE false religions as Christ commanded is because I have TRUE LOVE for all, not false, "feel-good", "emotional", love.

Just as Jesus and Paul truly LOVED those that they called "sons of hell", "children of the devil", etc., so to do I truly LOVE and pray for those who i call hypocrites, wolf, etc, like YOU!

I would rather have you DETEST me and reject your cult and be accepted by the Lord then love and respect me and end up in the lake of fire. That dear sir, is true love!

[color="#333399"]as the late Archbishop Fulton Sheen said, "It would be hard to find 100 people in the world who hate the Catholic Church, but there are many thousands who hate what they mistakenly believe is the Catholic religion
and if what they hate really were the Catholic religion, Catholics would hate it too"[/color]

I would just say, IF the average "Catholic" actually knew the history and teachings of the Catholic church they would hate it too......and I have seen this first hand![/quote]

Guys, I need some help. :unsure: I know what he says is not true, I just cant seem to refute him. This message board has alot of traffic and I can not just leave him un answered






phatty, I guess the blue I used does not look as different from the black. Could you edit it so there is a color difference?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...