Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I was just wondering if there are any other denominations that celebrate the Eucharist. (I think that Episcapilians(don't know how to spell it) do) If other denominations do, is it real or is the Catholic Church the only Church that can truly say that Christ is present?

Thanks and God Bless!!

:)

Posted

my dad is lutheran (part of the missouri synod) and i know that he has told me that his church believs that both Jesus and the bread are present, which is different than cahtolics who believe that it's all Jesus and no bread.

Posted

any lutherans out there, please correct me if i'm wrong, or if your church believes something different.

Circle_Master
Posted

lutherans believe in consubstantiation and not transubstantiation.

Posted

I believe the Methodist church also does it, because my friend talked about it one day, how they don't have communion every sunday, but like once a month. I don't think though they believe it is Jesus present. Likewise we as catholics can recieve it 365 times a year and more!

Posted

Yeah, I think that Evangelical Frees do it too. My friend was talking about it. i don't think they believe in communion w/ Christ's presence though. She said that they had recieved communion the week before, but she said it in a sarcastic way like it was silly that they even did it.

God Bless!! :)

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Many Protestant denomiations have a communion service from once a week to once or twice a year. They serve bread or crackers and wine/ grape juice. They do not have transubstantiation (changing the bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ), but a memorial service. Many do not consider it a big deal.

CAtholics consider Jesus in the Eucharist as the center of Catholic life.

Guest swamphox
Posted

here's one for you....

I heard of things like Padre Pio turning the bread into actual flesh and the blood in AB+

I'm certain that you're aware this doesn't happen every time.

How does the Catholic church defend the inconsistency of it not turning into something provably flesh or blood on a regular basis? and which also remains provably wine and bread on a regular basis ?

there's alot of faith involved in beliving that something tasting like mogandavid is actually blood and my faith only goes so far...it is much more believable to me (and less out-right creepy honestly) for me to believe that it is done as a:representation, b. a rememberance of what took place, and c. on large prayer/ritual as a whole that is sometimes answered in the form of actual provable blood/flesh

don't get me wrong, I was born catholic, raised catholic, my mom is still a eucharistic minister (therefor i'd rather not like to trouble her with this...things could become unpleasant) and I still attend mass on a much more regular basis than any of my peers

is this purely a faith issue on my part? or has the catholic church come up with a sound defernse on why substance x is said to have become substance Y even though substance X retains all the charectaristics of substance X and none of substance Y?

another more plausible explantion for me is that it becomes infused with the holy spirit while remaining bread and wine thereby "spiritually" becomin flesh and blood while still retaining the charechtarisitcs of bread and wine

anyhelp would be appreciated feel phree to email me

Posted

alright, the times like lanciano and the like where it takes on the physical charectaristics of flesh and blood is something done by Jesus to increase faith that that happens every time. However, most times He makes it to retain the physical charecteristics simply so that we may receive Him without being grossed out. ;)

alright, imagine you are right now looking at a piece of bread. what is that made up of? molocules right? what are the molecules made up of? atoms, right? what are the atoms made up of? ummm... wait a second, science has yet to get close to knowing that. this atoms are only in existence because God wants them to be in existence. and their substance can be whatever God wants it to be. If all the atoms in a piece of bread suddenly changed substance to become the actual Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of the Lord Jesus Christ, yet all these atoms still stayed in the same place, zoomed back out it still looks and acts like bread and wine. Science isn't advanced enough to detect the substance of the atoms that make it up, and it prolly never will be because that's one of the biggest secrets God's gonna keep from man.

So, the structure of the atoms, their bonds and all that other chemistry stuff that i never learned to well, stays the same. the atoms that were combined into molecules are still combined into molecules, but those atoms are no longer whatever elements make up bread and wine, they're the Body/Blood/Soul/Divinity of Jesus Christ, but they still are in the same form as they were when they were ordinary elements, so all physical senses can only see/taste/feel the structure those atoms are in. it's the substance that changes.

hope that helps ;) :cool:

Posted

Ain't it funny when the priest didn't believe in the ture presence of Jesus Christ in his full body, blood, soul, and divinity, that God preformed a miracle and bled. Then scientists claimed "It's a hoax" and then it turns out they did a blood test and it came back positive for human blood from the heart. What a great way God showed us his true miracle, all because of that priest that didn't believe what he was doing. What a wake up call to that priest. This really doesn't relate except for the Eucharist. So, lets thank God, for this miralce to all Catholics and more!

Posted

alright, the times like lanciano and the like where it takes on the physical charectaristics of flesh and blood is something done by Jesus to increase faith that that happens every time. However, most times He makes it to retain the physical charecteristics simply so that we may receive Him without being grossed out. ;)

alright, imagine you are right now looking at a piece of bread. what is that made up of? molocules right? what are the molecules made up of? atoms, right? what are the atoms made up of? ummm... wait a second, science has yet to get close to knowing that. this atoms are only in existence because God wants them to be in existence. and their substance can be whatever God wants it to be. If all the atoms in a piece of bread suddenly changed substance to become the actual Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of the Lord Jesus Christ, yet all these atoms still stayed in the same place, zoomed back out it still looks and acts like bread and wine. Science isn't advanced enough to detect the substance of the atoms that make it up, and it prolly never will be because that's one of the biggest secrets God's gonna keep from man.

So, the structure of the atoms, their bonds and all that other chemistry stuff that i never learned to well, stays the same. the atoms that were combined into molecules are still combined into molecules, but those atoms are no longer whatever elements make up bread and wine, they're the Body/Blood/Soul/Divinity of Jesus Christ, but they still are in the same form as they were when they were ordinary elements, so all physical senses can only see/taste/feel the structure those atoms are in. it's the substance that changes.

hope that helps ;):cool:

Aloysius, atoms are made up of protons, neutrons, and electrons.

Posted

i meant to go down to protons and neutrons and electrons. guess i skipped that step. what are protons', neutrons', and electrons' true substance.. then it goes there.

:ph34r: :wacko: just forgetful lil me.. don't pay any attention. :banana:

Posted

I heard of things like Padre Pio turning the bread into actual flesh and the blood

I read a book called "Relics" ( I don't remember the author, but if you wanna know just tell me and I'll find out ;) ) It had quite a few things about Eucharistic miracles. One time it happened & the blood dried up into 5 different pouch thingys. They were all different sizes & shapes, but they all weighed the same. When I read that I was like HA you unbelievers. It's so frustrating when so many Catholics don't believe in the Eucharist, especially when so many things like this happen.

photosynthesis
Posted

protons are made out of quarks, and electrons are made of leptons. I don't know what neutrons are made out of though. I probably have it all wrong...

but if Jesus can rise from the dead and make the blind see...if He, the King of Kings, could humble Himself to become one of us in the flesh, to die on the cross for our sins...

couldn't he also be present in the Eucharist? He's God...and with God, anything is possible.

you're right in saying that believing in the Real Presence is a leap of faith...and I guess that's what God wants from us. He wants us to live by faith, not by sight. It takes faith to look at Holy Communion and see Jesus, not the bread....and I'm sure the disciples at the Last Supper were just as weirded out when Jesus said "This is my body". But they took and ate of the bread, and Jesus rewarded them with faith.

Ask Jesus for faith, and he will give it to you...

Posted

protons are made out of quarks, and electrons are made of leptons. I don't know what neutrons are made out of though. I probably have it all wrong...

what is the substance of "quarks" and "leptons"?

the purpose of going down into the tiniest parts of the bread's existence is to show we truly could not explain what the substance of something is. if the substance of every single "quark" and "lepton" suddenly changed to be the substance of the Body Blood Soul and Divinity of Christ, these "quarks" and "leptons" would still retain the same structure related to other "quarks" and "leptons" and thus all physical charecteristics would remain the same. only God truly knows the substance of things ;) :cool:

photosynthesis
Posted

I said before that I don't really know what I'm talking about in regard to the composition of atoms, that's just something I remember from school. Quarks and leptons are the smallest parts of the atom...I think...they're smaller than protons and neutrons and voltrons and arbitrons and all of that stuff. and it's not really about the substance of the individual quarks and leptons, but how they're combined.

Is there a chemical formula for the body, blood soul and divinity of Christ? I don't know. I wouldn't think so, since you can't really force God into that small of a box. But scientists did do tests on some of the miraculous hosts and found that it was human heart tissue. what was bread had turned to flesh...I don't know how...I certainly don't know enough about protons and quarks to tell you.

Posted

im not sure i'm getting accross to you what i mean.

i'm not talking about the miracles that Physical science detects, but the ones that happen in our churches every day

i'm saying that the only reason we see/taste bread/wine is because all of these molecular structures stay in tact, but what the molecules are made of is a completely different substance. scientists have no idea what substance anything is. as far as they can tell at is complete smallest form it's protons, neutrons, and electrons, (ignoring your whole quarks thing, it's irrellivant, if you wanted to go deeper it would be aight.)

anyway, what is a proton? it's, well, energy or somethin right? now what is the essence of energy? well there's like + and -, but that's all they can know. but there is something distinctive in everything's substance, aside from the structure of the molecules and what not, that make it what it is. and down at the very smallest level is where that is most comprehensible, cuz we cannot comprehend what these small particals are made out of whereas our human minds comprehend bread made out of wheat or w/e. anyway, the protons, neutrons, and electrons in bread and wine have the substance of bread and wine. they are all in structures that make their physical attributes make them bread and wine, but they would not be bread and wine unless God willed that every aspect of them was bread and wine, down to the quarks. now, if God wills that every little proton neutron and electron were to change in substance, but not change in structure, it would retain this physical distinction as bread and wine, to the eye of science which is ignorant to the amazing complexity of God even sustaining something to be what it is structured to be, it is still bread and wine. but the entire substance has changed to become the Sacred Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Jesus Christ.

photosynthesis
Posted

so it's got the structure of bread + wine, and the substance of Jesus. gotcha. next time i won't talk about quarks and leptons (or voltrons or arbitrons, for that matter) after midnight for the sake of clarity.

Posted

:D lol good idea,,, quarks? i thought those were just funny antics :lol:

photosynthesis
Posted

well, i was being funny and stuff, but quarks and leptons do exist...i don't know much about them, but i do know that they're smaller than protons + neutrons + leptons. arbitron is an agency that compiles ratings for radio stations, and voltron is an old tv show about some robot.

i can't be counted on to make any sense after 1am.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...