Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

catechists need catechized...


Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Yes, I'm a theology major but I've been taking the certification classes for my diocese this summer and have come to the conclusion that the majority of people teaching... need a bit more theology. However, I'm concerned about some of the presenters...

First of all, we had a (non-habit-wearing-Vatican-Two-changed-a-lot-of-things) nun who claimed that, "Jesus made mistakes... took some wrong turns... and was vindicated by God and resurrected". She clarified (after some protestations) that she doesn't mean to say that Jesus sinned and denied that mistakes can be sin, and kept referring to Jesus' human knowledge and how His knowledge was imperfect so He made mistakes, etc. without being guilty of sin. This sounds odd to me. I agree that Jesus was had human knowledge and that He knew what was necessary for His age... but I don't know that I agree this implies that Jesus "made mistakes"... perhaps I'm being too rigid here, but this sounds dangerous to me.

And then today we had a woman in the class claiming that "contemplative prayer is a gift we're all given in baptism and it's what we need to be unlocking in our children today!!!!" and didn't back down after being asked where this was from/why she would say that contemplation is a baptismal gift. She also rejects the idea that Satan is the serpent in the account of the Fall, and chastised the instructor and the class for "assuming" so.

We've also been told to teach that the Creation account is a "myth"-- but this with a qualified definition-- not of being something false, but of something that analogously teaches certain truths of the faith. I can agree with that-- Creation does teach us certain truths of the faith... but "myth" seems, again, like a dangerous word to use.


There's more but that's all for now.. I'm tired.

Charms717RM1
Posted

Yeah...some of that sounds kinda whacky. Now I'm sure that contemplative prayer has been beneficial for many people, but i seriosly doubt if many kids have the attention span to get anything out of it. Lol, at least my kindergarten VBS class wouldn't. They'd contemplate for 3 seconds and then go back to their coloring books :P:

Posted

wait.... did you say you're taking the Archdiocese of Los ANgeles Master Catechsist certification classes???

oh.

you didn't.

funny how the content sounds exactly the same WRONG stuff <_<

:club: you'd THINK that you would have to be qualified to teach theology on the diocesean level. you'd THINK :madrant:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Sounds like the sister-types that I know as well. They are all teaching "Jesus didn't know he was jesus til he died" line nowadays. They got this from Father Brown type popular [ but heretical] reading, not from any real catholic teaching. Heresy -pure and simple.

Posted
:idontknow: Never heard of such nonsense in all my life.No wonder Catholics don't know their faith and wind up joining protestant churches. They are not learning the faith,and church leaders aren't reaching out to people like they should,so we keep loosing them.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...