cmotherofpirl Posted June 15, 2006 Posted June 15, 2006 Many U.S. parishes lay led, despite Vatican reaffirmation of priests’ role By Gail Besse 6/14/2006 National Catholic Register OSHKOSH, Wis. (National Catholic Register) – Sister Judy Miller works long hours as parish director of St. Mary’s in Oshkosh. She is one of nearly 600 full-time “parish life coordinators” in the country running day-to-day operations in parishes without a resident priest. In one day, the Sister of St. Joseph of Carondelet may assist at a funeral, meet a new parishioner, counsel someone about an annulment and sit down with the nursing-home board. After dinner there may be a confirmation to attend. “We function as a pastor except in matters of the sacraments,” she said of her role. Her greatest satisfaction is “empowering the people not to take a back seat.” The number of people appointed to this role is apparently increasing at a greater rate than the number of parishes without a resident priest is increasing, according to figures compiled by CARA (the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate) at Georgetown University. The Vatican has been concerned about the trend for years. The Second Vatican Council stressed that lay people have an important mission of their own – in the world. A 1997 Vatican instruction on lay ministry was a strong reaffirmation that it was ordained ministers’ role to run parishes. The document had a rare pedigree. Called “Instruction on Certain Questions Regarding the Collaboration of the Non-Ordained Faithful in the Sacred Ministry of Priests,” it was signed by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger and the heads of almost every other Vatican congregation. It was then approved by Pope John Paul II. Its message: don’t confuse priests and lay people, even when priests are lacking. The Vatican instruction emphasized “the need for a continuing, zealous and well-organized pastoral promotion of vocations” as the long-term solution to a priest shortage, and warned that “any other solution to problems deriving from a shortage of sacred ministers can only lead to precarious consequences.” But some parishes started the practice of using lay leaders in the 1980s. Almost half these parishes are in the Midwest; most others are in the South and West. Parish directors have been used in the dioceses of Richmond, Chicago, Milwaukee, Indianapolis, Cleveland, Seattle and Saginaw, Mich., among others. The Northeast has accounted for only a small percentage, but the trend is on the rise. This month, the Diocese of Pittsburgh was scheduling “listening sessions” for people interested in becoming parish-life coordinators, spokesman Robert Lockwood said. Research figures show that from 1995 to 2005, the number of parishes without a resident priest went up about 30 percent – from 2,160 to 3,250. The figures also show that from 1993 to 2004, the number of parishes entrusted to someone other than a priest more than doubled – from 268 to 566. The Vatican document stressed that such solutions addressing the priest shortage “cannot be other than transitory and must be linked to a series of pastoral programs that give priority to the promotion of vocations.” It quoted Pope John Paul’s warning that a “functionalistic conception of holy orders” could actually “encourage a reduction in vocations.” “We cannot increase the communion and unity of the church by ‘clericalizing’ the lay faithful or by ‘laicizing’ priests,” he said in a 1994 address, “The Participation of the Lay Faithful in the Priestly Ministry,” which provided much of the basis of the 1997 Vatican instruction. He also said that problems caused by the shortage of ordained ministers can be alleviated only by praying for vocations and “only secondarily or temporarily by having lay people in some way supply for them.” But bishops have responded in varying ways to the shortage of priests, according to the CARA report, “Emerging Models of Pastoral Leadership: Parish Life Coordinators in the U.S.” Some bishops use large numbers of non-resident priests, while others more readily appoint deacons and lay people to these positions, the report concludes. Sister Judy Miller’s title in the Green Bay Diocese is parish director, but elsewhere the role has titles such as pastoral administrator, lay director, pastoral coordinator, lay administrator, parish-life director and parish-life collaborator. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops defines the job of a deacon, religious or lay person who is responsible for the pastoral care of a parish as “parish coordinator.” “We’ve identified 36 titles,” said senior researcher Mary Gauthier. “This makes for confusion.” “Even more confusing is that the job description varies among dioceses.” Interpreting code In the Kansas City-St. Joseph Diocese, Bishop Robert Finn has made the distinction between the laity and the clergy clear. Since his installation last year, he closed the diocese’s 27-year-old Center for Pastoral Life and Ministry. He increased staffing at the vocations office, established a separate pro-life office and beefed up the adult-education program. Bishop Finn could not be reached for comment, but his spokeswoman, Rebecca Summers, said that other priests may pastor those parishes without an administrator somewhat like they would a mission parish. The bishop spelled out his vision in the diocesan newspaper, The Catholic Key, last July. “We have to understand where the power of the laity is,” he said. “It’s in the family, the workplace, the marketplace. That’s where [the transformation of society] has to happen.” We need lay people in church leadership,” Bishop Finn said, “But only a very small percentage of lay people will be involved in that.... If we are not serious about those laity who do not work in the church, then we are missing the whole thing. We have to keep broadening our vision.” Canonical confusion Some of the confusion can be traced to how one sentence inserted into the 1983 Code of Canon Law has been implemented. Canon 517 says: “If, because of a lack of priests, the diocesan bishop has decided that participation in the exercise of the pastoral care of a parish is to be entrusted to a deacon, to another person who is not a priest, or to a community of persons, he is to appoint some priest who, provided with the powers and faculties of a pastor, is to direct the pastoral care.” “This departure from the norm was inserted primarily for use in mission countries,” said Sister of the Cross and Passion Elissa Rinere, who holds a doctorate in canon law and is coordinator of pastoral planning for the Diocese of Norwich, Conn. The Vatican’s 1997 instruction said that “because these are exceptional cases, before employing them, other possibilities should be availed of, such as using the services of retired priests still capable of such service, or entrusting several parishes to one priest or to a [group of priests].” And, it added, “in any event, the preference which this canon gives to deacons cannot be overlooked.” Pope Benedict XVI used strong words to remind Canadian bishops of church teaching May 11. While he thanked laypeople for their generosity in serving the church, he said Catholics must never lose sight of the central and irreplaceable role of the priest. “How can young men want to become priests if the role of the ordained ministry is not clearly defined and recognized?” he asked bishops from Quebec at the end of their ad limina visits to the Vatican to report on the status of their dioceses. The diaconate Meanwhile, the number of permanent deacons has increased from 11,371 in 1995 to 15,027 in 2005. Sister Elissa noted that the United States has more deacons now than the rest of the world combined. A lay person, with the bishop’s approval, can conduct prayer services and distribute the Eucharist that a priest has previously consecrated, while deacons have the further ability to preach homilies, she said. Canon law gives preference to the deacon as parish leader and, “Some bishops use deacons as the first line of replacement” in priestless parishes, she said. “And the fact that they are ordained has ecclesiastical significance.” Deacon John Bresnahan of Lynn, Mass., said, “What needles deacons in some dioceses is there’s a push to use lay administrators” rather than tap the diaconate. “One of the biggest arguments you hear for ordaining women is the shortage of priests,” he said. “Well, the number of deacons is up. Let’s look at this positively and use them.” - - - Catholic News Service contributed to this report.
kateri05 Posted June 15, 2006 Posted June 15, 2006 diocese of san berndadino is the poster child for this and los angeles is fast adopting the model even tho we dont techinically need to s othat we can "be ready" when the shortage hits how do i know this, you might ask? i had to sit thru the san bernadino diocese parish life coordinator lady and the sacramental priest assigned to her give a presentation about how great it was blah blah blah and the worst was the priest: being a sacraments machine basically really freed him to BE a priest and not worry about other parish issues. wait you mean freed you to pursue a writing career and not be a shepherd to your flock? sigh back to the trenches!
phatcatholic Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 i talked to a pastor of a parish in Louisville a while back, and he gave me the impression that alot of priests are tired of the administrative work. they don't want to do it. they just want to be able to give the sacraments, and counsel / pastor people. he also said that the these new parish administrator positions are paying 6-figures but no one wants to do it b/c it is such a hassle.
journeyman Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 Our parish is one of those "lay led" ones - we see the canonical pastor about once a year - the priest on Sunday is usually a retired diocesan priest - arranged and scheduled by the pastoral coordinator, who, as the article pointed out, handles the day to day pastoral needs of the flock - except sacraments - for which she has/had a hefty rolodex - also as noted, it is draining work, but compensation at six figures ? not in our parish - nor does our parish have a permanent deacon
morostheos Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 It's funny, as a Catholic campus minister I feel my job description is very much like what you were saying journeyman, at least when our priest was out of comission from his car accident in the fall. It is definitely a lot of work sometimes, and I often don't feel qualified for it. I think there are some administrative things lay people can help with, but ultimately everything should be the pastor's decision - he is the spiritual father for his parish, so in the same way that the father should be the head of the family so should the priest be in charge of his flock. Sure, delegating is a good thing, but there's certainly a balance where he has to make sure he's still in control. I'm thinking of emailing that article to the person in charge of "pastoral planning" for our diocese...
kateri05 Posted June 16, 2006 Posted June 16, 2006 the question really is: WHY are priests "tired" of it? does it have to do with formation? with spiritual preparedness and sustainablility? or does it have ot do with the nature of pastoral priesthood. i'm not really leaning towards the latter since its been like that since, um, forever. go for it Claire - send it to her (? one just assumes oh yea and around these parts, pastoral life coordinators or whatevertheheck you call them certianly do NOT make six figures. i'm thinking like $60k-$70k MAX MAX. 6figs... what crazy rich catholic diocese is THAT?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now